Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: BJG on March 12, 2026, 03:09:53 PM
-
I'm interested in gathering opinions on the spec for a potential MIDI melodeon practice instrument.
The Streb is the gold standard in this arena, and I've been the proud owner of a couple of these. What I'm imagining is more of a budget silent-practice / travel device. It might be a kit.
I've been experimenting with DIY MIDI controllers for a few years, and recently started collaborating with the inventor of the "Digi-Gurdy" MIDI hurdy-gurdy on a new practice device for that.
https://youtu.be/hMmTkBvm75g
This isn't a replacement for a hurdy-gurdy; it's a silent practice device for a hurdy-gurdy, which is a different proposition.
Any thoughts/ideas welcome. (:)
-
You might want to look at this: https://www.soinutxuri.com/p/main.html?m=1
Scroll down for images and videos.
He's based in the Spanish Basque Country.
The keys are fully customisable, there is however no bellow pressure control.
A switch is activated under the left hand palm to detect pushing and pulling, but it's all or nothing, no pressure control whatsoever (at least last time I checked about 6 months ago).
He's now been working on an actual box sized one, but I do not know if bellow pressure has been added. I really feel like it's something that's missing on the flat model.
-
I have one of these ... I bought it when starting out thinking it might be very helpful ... but haven't made much use of it.
The keyboard is essentially a small/thin portable QWERTY keyboard on its side with a thin bit of veneer covering over the unused keys. It's a pretty light and flimsy affair with just a clicker-switch for bellows based on the space bar ... so very different in feel/function from a box. I might be more useful now I have some (moderate) skills, but it stays in its box. Something like the Squeeze Easy system (now defunct?) in a defunctioned box would be a whole lot better for a beginner at least?
-
Things I love about the Streb:
- Internal speakers and batteries
- Pitch shift
- Customisable keyboard layouts
- Bellows pressure sensitive (and some really good pressure curves rather than a straight linear thing)
Things I'd like a Streb to have
- 18/24 bass end potential
- Better sound samples
- Quieter keyboard
Re: spanish thing; many years ago I wrote an iPad melodeon app that relied on pressing an area to simulate bellows push. It was pretty unconvincing to be honest. I think you need proper bellows, and a good response curve to be a credible e-melodeon.
-
Don't forget the Roland FR18 if looking at this kind of thing. It is light, three-row 18 bass, any number of keyboard layouts you want, with plenty of sounds. The problems I found with it are that the box sounds are not very realistic, the action, though variable, is not sufficiently adjustable, and the feel just isn't right. I've heard some players overcome these problems pretty well. I feel it could have been truly great, with a little more development, but Roland decided to pull the plug on the project.
-
I have yet to try this one, but the french brand Cavagnolo also made a diatonic midi accordion: https://cavagnolo.com/digit-air-diato/
The brand spent time and effort designing midi CBAs, so I guess for the midi part, it should be good, with many melodeon samples and the ability to design your own layout. But the price tag is on the high side of the Force :D
-
I've been curious about blow accordions (image attached for those unfamiliar) for a little while now, and I wondered about a the feasibility of a midi instrument that uses a mouthpiece for the pressure sensor, rather than bellows. It could be smaller, and potentially cheaper, as well of course being the spark that ignites the blow accordion renaissance I've been waiting for
(EDIT: To clarify, the image isn't my collection, just a good illustration of what a blow accordion looks like)
-
What a lovely looking collection, and I'll bet they all work? Well done!
-
With you Chris. The Roland FR18 was diabolically complicated but a good value (getting expensive now). For their market at least here in the States the various piano and chromatic versions were sensibly marketed.
For the FR18 I felt they didn't have any idea of what they were doing: should they go after Tex-Mex, Euro, French or what? In fact it ended up a novelty box that at one time they nearly could not give away.
You could get one on US Ebay nearly new along with a nice Roland battery amp for $800 USD both with OEM Roland cases. Mon Deu.
-
I had a Streb for a while, and occasionally miss it.
I would like something small and portable, that feels like a melodeon - say a Giordy, perhaps with a couple more buttons, or maybe a Lilly at a pinch, or Liliput size even.
Perfectly happy for headphones, with an audio feed for a stereo as a nice-to-have.
I nearly always used the Streb with headphones, it was handy for silent practice, but a bit big to carry around on the off-chance that I might get some practice time, or in a tent at a festival.
But it would need to sound at least reasonably like a melodeon :D
-
I purchased the Squeeze Easy Midi Melodeon from Roy Hendrie.
It is a converted Hohner Club with several button configurations programmed.
https://www.jollyrogeraccordions.co.uk/product/midi-melodeon-system/
I will be listing it for sale soon at a very reasonable price.
I purchased it mainly for silent practice but now find that I no longer need that function.