Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Arnold on March 26, 2026, 08:15:08 AM

Title: Reed swap for Joe Burke BC layout
Post by: Arnold on March 26, 2026, 08:15:08 AM
Hi, I’m starting to get to grips with the BC layout and I’m quite liking it, good for major keys C, G, D, apart from the basses which I am intending to switch to Joe Burke but with full major chords and E minor… I am therefore looking to swap out my bisonoric G/D and C/G bass/chord reedplates for G/G and D/D. I suspect it’s an early Chinese made box and has ‘T’ reeds. I’m looking for similar, since I want a consistent response. This would be a straight swap but I would pay to send the blocks off and have them fitted since wax fumes irritate my airways… Please PM so I might have options. Cheers!
Title: Re: Reed swap for Joe Burke BC layout
Post by: Arnold on March 27, 2026, 05:25:38 PM
Nothing has come up yet, so I’m looking into other sources… I’ve searched the Hohner CShop but I’m finding it confusing… Would it be worth sourcing them through a retailer of Hohner accordions eg Hobgoblin?..
Title: Re: Reed swap for Joe Burke BC layout
Post by: tirpous on March 27, 2026, 06:51:04 PM
Very likely your existing chord reeds could be reused with rearranging and retuning.
Title: Re: Reed swap for Joe Burke BC layout
Post by: Arnold on March 27, 2026, 09:24:23 PM
To tune the bass reeds would mean a change of up to a fifth so I’m not sure that’s an option?..
Title: Re: Reed swap for Joe Burke BC layout
Post by: tirpous on March 27, 2026, 09:55:15 PM
Note I said existing -chord- reeds. Maybe you only need the bass reeds, in other words.
Title: Re: Reed swap for Joe Burke BC layout
Post by: Arnold on March 28, 2026, 12:11:51 AM
Yes, I would take just the bass reeds and tune the chord reeds if that was all on offer, but it would still be 4 chord reeds to tune by up to a whole tone, so better to swap them out if possible…
Title: Re: Reed swap for Joe Burke BC layout
Post by: mselic on March 28, 2026, 02:47:17 AM
I suspect it’s an early Chinese made box and has ‘T’ reeds. I’m looking for similar, since I want a consistent response.

You'd be surprised at how little difference it can actually make on the bass end when using a mix of different makes of reed.  I just recently 'made' a whole 4v bass set for a box that I have using a complete mish-mash of different makes and grades of reeds that I had on hand.  It's the best sounding bass of any of my accordions and I absolutely cannot tell any difference in tone or response from one bass or chord to another.  Sounds and plays fabulously!  I find that's not like the treble side at all, where differences between make and grade of reed can be more easily perceived. Just mentioning in case it helps you more easily obtain your desired reed layout.  Best of luck!
Title: Re: Reed swap for Joe Burke BC layout
Post by: Rog on March 28, 2026, 07:45:51 AM
I know this is in the selling section..but can I echo mselic's comment. I have converted a few melodeon basses, and done a couple of Joe Burke. I used PA reeds I think (though they may well have been Hohner) on the last one at least, and it sounded great. In my experience people get too hung up on the type of reeds etc. As a further aside it is actually non trivial…i.e. a lot of work because you have to reconfigure the entire bass and source a lot of reeds (i.e. costs more than tuppence h'apenny). But easily doable.
Title: Re: Reed swap for Joe Burke BC layout
Post by: Arnold on March 28, 2026, 08:37:23 AM
It’s the ‘Paulo Soprani’ layout, so it’s not too much work, being a straight swap of 8 reedplates (I’m keeping the thirds in which probably helps)… From the chord reedblocks, there are 4 reedplates that need switching. I need B3/B3, D4/D4 for the G/G chord pair, and F#3/F#3, A3/A3 for the D/D chord pair (I’ll need to confirm those octaves are correct). For the basses, 4 reedplates will need to be swapped out, but all other original reedplates stay in their place. I’m a bit unsure of the octaves looking at Hohner website, since I expected the lower D bass to be D2/D2, but the lowest reeds available on their website start at G1. I’ll try to figure it out by measuring the reedplates…
Title: Re: Reed swap for Joe Burke BC layout
Post by: Arnold on March 28, 2026, 09:49:46 PM
I think I have a solution using left hand reedplates from an old 1040G… D from G/D bass pair to be tuned up to G for G/G unisonoric bass and C/C bass pair tuned up a whole tone for D/D unisonoric bass… There’s the D4/D4 chord reedplate there too, leaving 3 chord reedplates to be retuned in whichever way is most efficient… I need to know what file would be best for this job and if maybe anyone has an old one to sell, having upgraded perhaps… I’m still open to swap though as I figured they are of more value to most people around here as bisonoric basses…
Title: Re: Reed swap for Joe Burke BC layout
Post by: Arnold on March 29, 2026, 06:40:56 PM
Well, I got myself into an unnecessary muddle there and needlessly retuned 4 perfectly good bisonoric reedplates  :|bl All the higher chord reeds are of course on the outside of the block and simply need weighing down to match the inside reeds. Thanks to Tirpous for providing this insight... They don’t even need removing from the block. It’s only for the G/G bass that this doesn’t work. Oh well, I’ll put it down to experience!.. Anyone got unisonoric G basses. Let me know!..
Title: Re: Reed swap for Joe Burke BC layout
Post by: Arnold on April 02, 2026, 07:23:03 PM
Unisonoric G/G bass reedplates (filed up from spare G/D plates) are now in the box in place of C/G bass reeds. G push bass reeds from G/D pair are weighed down to match pull D. Push chord reeds C and E are weighed down a semitone and tone respectively to match pull chord reeds B and D. Push chord reeds G and B are weighed down a semitone and tone respectively to match pull chord reeds F# and A.

It’s a big improvement. Simple accompaniment is now possible in major keys of C, G, D and even A (for those Scottish tunes that have no G# - I decided to keep the E major chord too). Further possibilities eg minor keys with thirdless chords, but I haven’t yet gone there…
Title: Re: Reed swap for Joe Burke BC layout
Post by: Rog on April 03, 2026, 07:42:35 AM
Well done. But as I said, it (can be) a non trivial change, esp if you chase your tail a bit..
Title: Re: Reed swap for Joe Burke BC layout
Post by: Arnold on April 03, 2026, 01:55:39 PM
Well done. But as I said, it (can be) a non trivial change, esp if you chase your tail a bit..

Thanks, adhd means I’m constantly chasing my tail!.. Sometimes all that’s needed is a little nudge in the right direction… Had I given it a little thought initially, I would have properly figured out, but I do tend to be a little gung ho!..
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal