Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Steve M48K on March 29, 2026, 07:42:51 PM
-
Not being able to find a cheap Hohner, I picked up an old Weltmeister DG melodeon to try.
It's the one that tries to look like a Pokerwork. But the construction is weird with curved metal corners that hold things together , rather than using screws.
Anyway, I've been inside trying to find things that I might be able to alter to make it better - new pallet leather/felt etc, but it all seems OK.
Is there anything I could do to make a Welty feel or sound better?
I had it serviced in Scotland and they put a quite wet tuning on it. I would prefer it a bit drier. The tone isn't that great though, so when I saw a set of DG reeds on Ebay I wondered if it was worth swapping them? They seem to be Czech reeds. Are they likely to be an improvement or should I stick with what I've got?
-
If the Weltmeister has made in GDR on the back it may not be worth persevering with. Later models, after German reunification are nice players but with a softer tone than Hohner.
If you add up the cost of a set of reeds and fitting and tuning(yes new reeds need tuning) then it’s unlikely to be worth it.
There is one eBay seller I’ve seen offering Czech reeds and if you are looking at the same source they are probably the basic machine made reed that won’t be any better than what you have.
Best stick with the Welty as it is. It should be good enough to get familiar with the system. When you reach the limit of it’s performance then trade it for something better.
-
A bit of crossover with the other thread here, but this from Theo, yes!..
-
Thanks for the replies.
Yes, I guess I'm stuck with it the way it is. Yes, it says GDR but doesn't actually have the Weltmeister name on it like some of the newer(?) ones.
It's playable but it feels like it should be better, somehow. I guess I'm just pondering repair possibilities as I repair other instruments, so for me, looking at repair options seems preferable to spending a lot of money. If there was a viable repair option it'd be something I'd like learning and getting experience of.
-
Messing with melodeon innards is very addictive, it often leads to a bad case of M.A.D.
-
I was in a similar position myself - I got a GDR Weltmeister cheap online for Christmas 2025, and got frustrated with its limitations. But it was enough to get me started, and decide it was worth spending some money on a really nice box, which has been worth every penny. This gave me the confidence to try and make a few improvements to the Welty - limiting the treble button travel to stop them disappearing down the holes, drilling out the air hole, bushing the bass buttons and replacing the felt/leather pads on the bass pallets. These all made a noticeable difference, but the best result I got was from replacing the bellows pins with new ones which fit much more snugly and made everything much more airtight - suddenly I was no longer running out of air! It's still a cheaply made instrument with a very primitive keyboard, so I wouldn't spend money replacing the reeds, but I'm quite happy with the improvements I've made. I found all the relevant info here at melodeon.net, by the way.
Nick
-
Interesting, thanks. I had thought of opening the air hole. It's seems a bit restricted.
There's a Welty for sale for £1200 in a certain folk music shop, which seem bizarre. Are any of them worth that?
-
"Are any of them worth that?"
Probably to someone, but maybe not to more folk. It depends upon what disposable cash you have, and how much it takes your fancy. Even if I had millions, I'd be hard pressed to pay more than £1000 for any melodeon, and I love them!
-
Nothing wrong with a weltie if it's in good nick, if you ask me, but apart from PA/CBA Supitas that can easily head towards £3k territory, I don't think that any old weltie is worth over £1k, unless it had £1k of work done on it.
FWIW, my very first squeezebox was a GDR-era weltie, and it had a nice timbre, even if everything else about it was pretty poor.
£1k will not buy you a lot of man-hours in this day & age, given UK labour charges & eye-watering taxes, so I have to disagree with Winston's previous comment, almost to the point that there's not a lot of melodions under £1k that are worth playing.
If I didn't have 3 kids to feed, I'd happily fork out £6k on a Tula hromka :-[.
-
If I didn't have 3 kids to feed, I'd happily fork out £6k on a Tula hromka :-[.
I wouldn't mind knowing which culture has a unisonoric button accordion in D, plus Fnat, Cnat and G#. Soon as I find out I'll be going there on holiday to scour the shops. ;D
-
Well, a hromka pitched in D has f and g# in the middle octave. That's quite a common key for them, but it's one of the highest-pitched hromkas you can get.
I've seen one or two on German ebay recently. I guess, you can swap out the A# for Cnat if you really wanted to go to town on it.
Beware of vintage ones - some might be tuned to the godawful A=427hz.
An extended range (5-smitone) hromka in D has a chromatic octave from the first A to the second A, but these are hard to find.
-
Well, a hromka pitched in D has f and g# in the middle octave. That's quite a common key for them, but it's one of the highest-pitched hromkas you can get.
I've seen one or two on German ebay recently. I guess, you can swap out the A# for Cnat if you really wanted to go to town on it.
Ah thank you, I didn't realise that.
Beware of vintage ones - some might be tuned to the godawful A=427hz.
I'm suitably warned! You get the same problem with old simple system flutes, but the discrepancy with modern tuning standards still isn't that wide.
-
AAAHAAAA, - so that's why I found a tuning fork at a flea market where A=427
-
AAAHAAAA, - so that's why I found a tuning fork at a flea market where A=427
:P
As far as I know, there was no official Soviet standard for A=427, but the majority of pre-1950s boxes are tuned to it.
Fionn, another option for you is to get an old 12-bass hohner (Or Weltmeister?), and swap the reeds to unisonorics from a PA to build a "compact" hromka layout for playing in only one home key (unlike 25x25 that's more geared towards 2 keys). You can ditch some dog-whistle notes on the treble end and get yourself the accidentals that you want, and you'll have bass I, IV, V for home key major & minor.
This is, essentially, a "kirillovka" melodeon with an altered bass layout.
See black notes on the attached C-maj layout & transpose to Dmaj.
-
Thanks for all the advice! I do know someone who has two or three old PAs in a store room. Busy with work on the house for the next few months, but after that I might start looking around for a cheap box to fiddle with over the winter. :D