Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Tune of the Month => Topic started by: Clive Williams on April 01, 2026, 09:17:48 AM
-
Hello again everyone; this month's winner (just) - Tom Tolley's. Here's Mel playing it:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K5ugPr5Gv-0 (first tune)
Also found under the names Tom Tulley's, Tom Tully's, Tom Tolly's, etc... you get the picture... and, apparently, also Tom Fowler's.
Here's a "close enough for now" version; https://abc.rectanglered.com/?t=8005&s=1 - I'm not sure I agree fully with the B music, but play it as you feel it, and if you have ABC you prefer, please post it.
Enjoy!
Clive
-
Tom Tolley's:
https://youtu.be/RPMNWPWJpKg
Best from Suffolk (cloudy)
Bill
-
Tom Tully's (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U7DuRN42lJE)
-
As a stop gap, here's a 16 year old video with Mary Humphreys on EC. This URL puts you halfway though the video where the relevant tune starts.
I get to actually play the tune 3rd time through.
https://youtu.be/WhOJuAkQNfM?t=118
This is a rare version of the tune as published by Andy Hornby with the "extra bars" in the B music removed to make it a conventional length. I think I'm right in saying those "extra bars" are part of the original ms. and he cut them out as a misguided editorial decision.
If you wish to rewind to the start of the video that's up to you.
A proper new version will follow.
-
Here goes, with a new version as promised, on my own this time: Tom Fowler's Hornpipe (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uyXNJb85zac) from the Winder ms.
-
Here goes, with a new version as promised...
Thank you. This is a great "beginner's tune", and I love your bass side interpretation.
I've been learning this tune, on my GC, since before it came up as a TOM nominee, but having problems putting together the left hand.
Just curious, can this tune be played on a one-row? On my 114c I run out of buttons, on either end. Playing solo, is there are work-around for situtations like this, or is it just a case of "can't get there from here"? Can't exactly skip the note and let someone else pick it up.
-
Just curious, can this tune be played on a one-row? On my 114c I run out of buttons, on one either end. Playing solo, is there are work-around for situations like this
Playing a one-row tends to be full of workarounds!
If you play it in the higher octave, you are missing one note near the beginning of the second half of the tune. On a C instrument, that would be D which you could replace with a B.
I'm less fluent in that higher octave of the melodeon and would find it a challenge to play it that way.
Some one row instruments have (assuming a C box again) a low pull A which would enable you to play it in the lower octave. There's a workaround if you don't have that low A, which is to play the one an octave higher. If your instrument if LMMH tuned the jump will be less obvious. I've used that hack successfully in the C music of Will Atkinson's Schottische (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CJuh6sj9KF0) where that A is a brief passing note and it works really well (and the 2nd time though the tune I play that section an octave higher).
I'm going to have to try this... don't know if a video will result!
-
... Will Atkinson's Schottische...
Oh my, another great tune to work on; my mum always said I was always putting the cart before the horse!
I found this version to start from, and I see that "A" you mentioned
X: 1
T: Willy Atkinson's Schottische
R: barndance
M: 4/4
L: 1/8
K: Cmaj
|:G>c|e2e2 e<(gg)e|f>ef>g a2b>a|g>c'b>ag>fe>d|c>de>c G2c>d|
e2e2 e<(gg)e|f>ef>g a2b>a|g>c'b>a g>fe>d|c2c2c2:|
|:g>e|f<d B2B2a>f|g<ec2c2c'2|b2d>e f2a2|g>ec>de2g>e|
f<d B2B2a>f|g<ec2c2c'2|b2d>e f>ga>b|c'2c'2c'2:|
|:G>c|e2e2e2d>c|B>AB>c d2 d>e|f2f2f2 e>d|c>Bc>d e>cG>c|
e2e2e2d>c|B>AB>c d2 d>e|f2f2f2e>d|c2c2c2:|
And my apologies for the topic drift.. . I'm going to my room now.
-
Here's my go - also based on Tom Fowler's from the Winder collection.
https://youtu.be/SsDZ4QCa07A
-
Played on my Bb/Eb Hohner Club Modell.
I heard someone playing it nice and slowly once and thought it sounded sweet.
https://youtube.com/shorts/av7INysjKcc?si=5ppOq0Bswez0wQcS
-
Hello all, nice to see a few versions coming along :-)
Here's mine, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ycMyB_HSUxQ played on the Preciosa in Bb/Eb, straight down the line. Noice.
-
I first heard this tune on the great 'Hardcore English' collection
Here's another Bb/Eb rendition, while enjoying hiking and sunshine in Tasmania:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YGxu3i0d5O0
-
I first heard this tune on the great 'Hardcore English' collection
Here's another Bb/Eb rendition, while enjoying hiking and sunshine in Tasmania:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YGxu3i0d5O0
A lovely spot for a tune. Maybe you could lug the Preciosa over to Wineglass Bay for the next recording :||:
-
Here’s mine https://youtu.be/NyUEYYZZn_g?si=PfzJnLS4ucG_0jXk (https://youtu.be/NyUEYYZZn_g?si=PfzJnLS4ucG_0jXk)
I’ve loved this tune from hearing Magnetic North on Barry Callaghan’s Hardcore English album, which in these days of having no CD player doesn’t get listened to enough.
Gren
-
Loving all the versions, and the varied keys! Here’s mine in plain ol’ G: https://youtu.be/kAxYqYPhrsE
-
Thank you everyone! On to the next tune, but as ever please feel free to stick late contributions onto the end of this thread :-)