Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Hans Lemmen on April 10, 2026, 09:16:11 PM
-
It has been about two months since I bought my first box, a Hohner Pokerwork, and started to practice a few tunes that I liked on Youtube.
-These were tunes that sounded “special” to me in a way. Those were: Go enlist for a sailor , Tavern Terkisher and Eleanor Plunkett (and a polka) and some chords practicing. When I first heared them they all sounded intimidatingly difficult for a beginner . But I was also amazed how fast you can learn these. The basses are not totally fluent yet , as well as the general technique but that gets better every day.
It gives confidence to go try whatever I hear, even if it is a far shot. Like this one: https://youtu.be/SJMUn_QTEYI?is=w7t-b7bnxUTzsHVs
- Second is the observation that my old dog (who is almost deaf), discretely leaves the room when I start to play. Or he patiently waits for me to open the door. And since recently he already leaves when I pick up the box.
- I was also surprised how the brain deals with learning a tune. I had been wrestling with a few difficult parts for weeks. Next I had no time to play for almost one week but when I picked up the box again, I suddenly could fluently play those parts. My brian had been processing them in silence.
-
As I think I said to you earlier, Klesmer isn't the easiest thing to start on - because it involves that stretch over to the accidental button. But that's it's what you like … 👍 Enjoy!
I've never owned a dog, but our family cat used to attack my English concertina when I played it.
Animals have a much higher frequency range that humans. Hence "dog-whistles". I've always assumed that the aversion was due to some very high-pitched ultrasound harmonic from the reeds. I've not had a problems with melodeons before. Anyone else?
-
Great stuff! Learning tunes you want to play has got to be the best way to get that sense of reward and ongoing motivation, so keep doing what you’re doing.
I only have to unzip the case of my melodeon and my cat scarpers. I think the way the bellows expand and then the whole thing makes a big scary noise is what freaks her out. She’s my worst fan, even after my children.
You might want to check out the work of Dr Molly Gebrian. She is a neuroscientist and a musician who explains a lot of the science behind music learning. Your experience is a common one, and understanding why that happens helps me to learn faster. She has a number of videos on YouTube.
-
+1 on Molly Gebrain's "Learn Faster" book ... really thoughtful and useful advice with a serious evidence base ... the "sleep on it" principle works well for me too ...
I live with a cat who sometimes comes to listen to me play, curls up in/under a chair opposite ... but loathed my Dad's clarinet ... just opening the case led to the clattering of the cat flap! Fickle beasts ...
-
"Fickle beasts ..."
No, just good taste!
-
My cat used to jump on the piano stool beside me, ducking as a bellows end came his way!
If I really ignored him on occasions he'd jump on my shoulders and make me stop.
He just wanted a cuddle...
-
So what's the difference between diatonic and catatonic?
-
;D
A very good question!!!
-
So what's the difference between diatonic and catatonic?
Diatonic is what yer puts in yer Gin to stop you getting fat
Catatonic (Catnip) is what yer gives yer Cat to sedate it when you're playing
-
+1 on Molly Gebrain's "Learn Faster" book ... really thoughtful and useful advice with a serious evidence base ... the "sleep on it" principle works well for me too ...
I'll second that endorsement.
Learn Faster, Perform Better;A Musician's Guide to The Neuroscience of Practicing
Molly Gebrian
© Oxford University Press, 2024
New York, NY
ISBN: 9780197680070 (paperback)
Reference only; I have no affiliation with either the author, or Amazon
https://www.amazon.com/Learn-Faster-Perform-Better-Neuroscience/dp/0197680070
-
I watched some of her videos. Interesting, there is a lot that many people already do automatically.
But there was this most usefull advice that you should not repeat a whole sequence when you’ve made a mistake because it enforces repeating the mistake. Instead only restart at the mistake point itself and repeat correctly ten times.
I think there is a anology between training your dog puppy and training your brain: when you chose the wrong moment for the correction they both learn the opposite of what you want.
-
It’s TOMMY!!! Very happy with my purchase. It is a second hand DG but it looks like new. Being able to only switch on the low notes makes an end to the high-pitched squealing that my Hohner DG has.
-
I watched some of her videos. Interesting, there is a lot that many people already do automatically.
But there was this most usefull advice that you should not repeat a whole sequence when you’ve made a mistake because it enforces repeating the mistake. Instead only restart at the mistake point itself and repeat correctly ten times.
There's a little more to it than that. Often you have to go back and find the cause of the breakdown and find the way to succeed, then play through.
The nature of the diatonic box requires syncing bellows direction and fingering to the point where you gain muscle memory. Most of the breakdowns or loss of continuity I have enountered arise from an awkward RH fingering. Correction often requires re-positioning the RH to a point higher or lower on the keyboard by balancing the ins and outs, row-crossing, wrist angle and attention to the simple ergonomics of comparative finger length. You might look for certain physical targets which allow you to pivot to a more favorable hand position while maintaining continuous points of contact and avoiding "jumping" the hand up or down the keyboard and losing a comfortable progression of the fingers enumerating the tune.
Good luck.
-
Dick has expressed my thoughts exactly.
I've discovered that there are often several reasons that lead up to the point where I go wrong.
Perhaps being on the wrong finger to play the next phrase that trips me up?
I try different hand positions, fingering and bellows direction to let me play the phrase correctly, then I go back to the previous phrases and tweak that to allow me to get to that point and hand position where it works.
Sometimes it just takes a while to work out what's best approach...
-
Perhaps being on the wrong finger to play the next phrase that trips me up?
Definitely the cause of a lot of my beginner issues! Some patterns just fall into place, but there are a few where only one or two routes are feasible, specially playing along-the-row.
I have to spot the problem first, it's not always obvious. Then I revert to primary school music class: play just the last three notes, then the last four, then the last five, until the whole phrase and the run-up to it are fluent. It takes somewhat longer to cement it now than it did when I was nine... ::)
-
If only we'd all started at nine ;D
I've become more aware of hand shapes now I have a helper row. In one position the button I need might be difficult to hit then a change of position and it fall to the finger.
It just emphasises the point that when confronted with a new tune it is worth going through it many times, trying different hand positions and fingering patterns.
I keep going trying these out and after a while find I'm favouring one that will allow me to play the part.
-
If only we'd all started at nine ;D
Yup, and if only we hadn't forgotten to practise for the next 60 years! ::)
-
The learning process is fractal, thinks I.