Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Gromit on April 21, 2026, 06:58:28 PM
-
Does anyone use a mute on their box. I want to reduce the volume while practising so as not to annoy neighbours (I live in a flat) I'm thinking of making something to clip onto the grill but concerned it might restrict airflow to the bellows. Any thoughts?
-
I tried doing this with a piece of wood inserted behind the grill, but honestly... it didn't make much of a difference in volume. Slightly, noticeable, but far from what I would call a mute. You might try adding some foam in there, but I doubt it would change much. The most effective solution I have found is to just... play quieter. Try adding just enough pressure to make the reeds speak, no more. You can many boxes (pokerworks included) fairly quiet. Emphasis on fairly. It's still... it's still an accordion though.
Now, you could buy acoustic panels and put them in a room in the middle of your flat as your 'practice space', but that seems a bit extreme to me.
-
I stretched a patch of soft leather all over the grille of mine once as an experiment. Some concertinas have this inside the end grilles. It muted the sound impressively, but it didn't actually sound very nice and the basses were still loud.
There's not much danger of restricting airflow, as long as you don't actually glue it down all round the edges. But in my experience it's not worth it anyway.
-
I've a habit of being awake in the small hours, and sometimes get bored enough to do a bit of practice. I sit on the bed and pull the duvet over the box, which does muffle it. I don't know whether it'd be enough for a flat dweller, but it might be worth trying.
-
Miguel Gramontain (a young, and very innovative maker in the Pyrenees) does a variable mute..
Here's Aurelien Claranbaux testing it out. https://youtu.be/-3o2Kpg-XRQ
I used to play under a duvet too! And it's very good for your technique;
You can't see your hands. You have to just play … 👍
You can also use a melodeon as a clock, at night 😉
-
Thanks folks, your comments have given me food for thought. The variable mute looks interesting.
-
It won't be cheap! But Miguel is a very competent maker, albeit mostly of wood framed CBA's.
He's also a very competent musician, supporting his lady partner, who sings beautifully.
-
It won't be cheap!
Thanks but I'm a retired woodworker so I'm thinking of making something my self out of wood.
-
Another thought: when I started relearning whistle three years ago, I asked my neighbours whether it was bothering them. They're retired and at home a lot, so I didn't have the option of practising while they were out at work.
They said they'd only ever heard me playing once, and that was because one of them happened to be in the bathroom – they'd never heard it in their other rooms. Bumped onto one of them a few weeks after I got the box (which seems really loud to me), and they'd no idea I'd even started learning.
So it is worth talking to the neighbours if you're on good terms. There could be less noise transference than you think.
-
I'm sure they can hear me because I can hear them playing piano. I also play wooden flute that can be even louder but I can't mute that.
-
My initial neighbour's son wrt this semi-detached used to practice his trumpet, right next to the desk where my PC sat! But not at night.
The next one's sons had a penchant for teenage parties if their dad was away at his girlfriends. They finished about 03:30.
-
I'm sure they can hear me because I can hear them playing piano. I also play wooden flute that can be even louder but I can't mute that.
But does it bother them? Are there times of day when it's more likely to? I'd have asked my neighbours this if they'd said could hear it.
I don't play for hours, so it's not very different to people mowing lawns outside or hoovering in the next room. People can often tolerate a bit of noise as long as the time, volume and duration aren't unreasonable – and talking to them shows you're trying to be considerate.
-
I rehearse a five piece Zydeco band, drums, bass, everything in my workshop behind the house.
The neighbours keep asking when the band is coming back as they want more music!
P.S. they are mostly pensioners.
-
I'd agree with the suggestion you ask your neighbours. You may be surprised at the answers you get.
As things warm up here in Maine I play on the back steps quite a bit. A lot of folks in the neighburhood say they enjoy it. Sometimes the local kids drop in for a dance, and every now and again my English friend comes over with a cold six-pack. A couple of years ago someone from a few blocks away posted on one of those local gossip websites asking "does anybody know where the accordion player lives"? Every single one of my neighbours refused to answer the question. The two reasons they gave were:
- We're not going to tell you because you might stop the music
- If you can't find an outdoor accordion player on your own, why would we help you?
-
To me the demonstrated Variable Mute semed to have more effect on tone than actual volume.
-
To me the demonstrated Variable Mute semed to have more effect on tone that actual volume.
I think you're right.
-
I put 3 layers of linen under the felt on an AD Laura as an experiment. It certainly softened the overall volume and killed overtones, making it "seem" quieter.
BUT it made the box loose its vibrancy overall and who wants that.
Best to just play softly; good practice and the TAM let you practice your technique, such as it is!
-
...the TAM let you practice your technique, such as it is!
What's the TAM and are you criticising my technique? (:)
-
As things warm up here in Maine I play on the back steps quite a bit. A lot of folks in the neighburhood say they enjoy it.
I can't find a local pub anywhere near San Luis Obispo, California, that hosts a weekly cèilidh; box players are few are far between here.
But if pipes are your poison we have several; one of whom lives about a mile from my house. It's hilly terrain, but if the wind is right I can hear him very clearly, usually in the evening when I hear him. I enjoy do enjoy it, but wonder about neighbors nearer to him. Of course our dBs are but a whisper held to pipes.
-
Grommit, I was referring to the tipo a mano reeds of course and *my* technique!
One thing about air flow BTW is that I got the idea from microbot about linen.
It does not seem to affect air flow hardly at all at least not to my neanderthal-level technique
-
In re "just play quieter":
You can amplify what you're hearing by setting up reflective surfaces to redirect sound to your ears. Solid music stands are good for this, making it easier to hear yourself and gifting the reduction in overall SPL to your neighbors. Angle and height of the shelf are adjustable to your needs.
-
You can amplify one end (relative to the other) by simply turning your body side-on to your audience. The sound coming out of a melodeon is very directional!
Corollary: never sit to-the-left of another melodeon player in a session 😉
-
You can amplify one end (relative to the other) by simply turning your body side-on to your audience. The sound coming out of a melodeon is very directional!
Corollary: never sit to-the-left of another melodeon player in a session 😉
The topic is how to project less, not more...
-
The topic is how to project less, not more...
You could do that by turning to your right, left-hand towards the audience and playing a fairly lean bass line. I accept that it wouldn't sound very nice if one likes to play a heavy dumb cha-cha. But if you watch the professionals they need you all have a light handed technique anyway? And quite commonly can emphasise one end, or the other depending on where they're going.
Are we coming to the conclusion that mechanical methods (other than playing under the duvet!) aren't the best solution?
-
Chris...
Go back to the OP to orient your replies to the particular situation...which has NOTHING to do with public performance
-
A sheet of 4mm felt under the grille is all you need, but my experience with several TAMs was that they
- tend to be loud;
- tend to have poor dynamics, esp very poor for playing piano, as they just jump to mf as soon as you move the bellows.
So getting a box with good quality AM reeds and playing them softly is also an option. And a good sets of AMs will likely scream louder than TAMs is you start playing at full power.
Another alternative is to get a prewar Hohner with "Hohner Germany" reeds. They are very good quality but not nearly as loud as post-war Italian ones.