Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: rileycat on May 11, 2026, 01:03:57 PM

Title: Turner prototype
Post by: rileycat on May 11, 2026, 01:03:57 PM
Has anyone here tried the prototype Turner melodeon from Squeezebox Marketplace folks.  Just interested to hear about a 'new' maker brand.
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: Andy Next Tune on May 11, 2026, 03:26:24 PM
There's nothing on his website that I could see.
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: rileycat on May 11, 2026, 04:32:45 PM
Apparently there were 2 instruments at Upton for folks to try for feedback purposes, and Rees Wesson has a vid. on his website.
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: Helena Handcart on May 11, 2026, 06:16:27 PM
Apparently there were 2 instruments at Upton for folks to try for feedback purposes, and Rees Wesson has a vid. on his website.

No doubt they will also be on the stall at Chippenham.
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: rees on May 11, 2026, 07:45:48 PM
Apparently there were 2 instruments at Upton for folks to try for feedback purposes, and Rees Wesson has a vid. on his website.


It's not on my website, it's on Facebook.

https://www.facebook.com/reel/1657888905526758 (https://www.facebook.com/reel/1657888905526758)
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: Anahata on May 12, 2026, 10:30:38 AM
This is another incarnation of Oakwood, isn't it? I looked at the Squeezebox Marketplace web site and found a picture of the same John Turner who ran The Music Room, once the main retail outlet for Oakwood. The instrument looks similar, and the comments about it being loud and a perfect morris box are like the description of the Dino Baffetti/Oakwood Binci box.

I'll be watching with interest...
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: rees on May 12, 2026, 12:09:29 PM
This is another incarnation of Oakwood, isn't it? I looked at the Squeezebox Marketplace web site and found a picture of the same John Turner who ran The Music Room, once the main retail outlet for Oakwood. The instrument looks similar, and the comments about it being loud and a perfect morris box are like the description of the Dino Baffetti/Oakwood Binci box.

I'll be watching with interest...

Yes, the same John Turner.
The box is a copy of the Oakwood, made in Italy.
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 12, 2026, 03:37:43 PM
Does this prototype signify the DB Binci ( that followed the DB Oakwood special ) ceased production?
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: rees on May 12, 2026, 03:43:36 PM
Does this prototype signify the DB Binci ( that followed the DB Oakwood special ) ceased production?

I doubt it as the new Turner model is not made by Dino Baffetti.
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 12, 2026, 04:02:41 PM
Thanks Rees. Sorry, am a bit rusty on who made what in that neck of the woods.
Is there any details about where it's made, i.e. in house or by a continental factory?
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: rees on May 12, 2026, 04:11:33 PM
Thanks Rees. Sorry, am a bit rusty on who made what in that neck of the woods.
Is there any details about where it's made, i.e. in house or by a continental factory?

All I know is that it's made in Italy. Mr Turner is not revealing where.
Here's another Facebook link.
https://www.facebook.com/reel/1722617055571835 (https://www.facebook.com/reel/1722617055571835)
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: rees on May 12, 2026, 04:13:29 PM
This from John Turner:

"They are not yet on sale. The one you see it’s a sample we managed to get to show to people. They are certainly turning heads, keep an eye on the website for announcements."
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: squeezy on May 13, 2026, 12:47:04 AM
Hmmm ... from that video they definitely have the Oakwood grille pattern.  Interesting for many reasons!!!  I don't like the idea of makers deliberately confusing the consumer as to who have made the instruments they are buying with methods like this ... I understand how complicated the relationship between John Turner (squeezebox marketplace) and Martyn Banks (Oakwood) is, but I don't think it's necessary for their conflicts to be used to complicate buying musical instruments for the consumer.

The box sounds nice in the video though.

Edit: If the Turner prototype box is good enough then it would sell well based on its playing qualities and aesthetics without copying the Oakwood grille ... I can't see any good reason for doing that other than either to confuse the buyer or for personal reasons ... neither of which are valid.
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: rees on May 13, 2026, 01:18:46 AM
Well said John.
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 13, 2026, 07:44:49 AM
Thanks John.
I'd noticed the grill and yes, 'confused' sums it up.
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: Helena Handcart on May 14, 2026, 10:29:04 AM
I must admit, at first glance I thought it looked so much like an Oakwood that Martyn must be involved - unlikely though that is. Equally, the last batches of Oakwoods that Martyn made have a very different design and grille pattern - I am lucky enough to have number 1 of 10 2-voice models and it is a joy.

I'll be interested to see, and try, the new model but agree with previous posters that making a thing which is not an Oakwood look too much like an Oakwood is not a good thing for multiple reasons.
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: Mark Rogers on May 23, 2026, 05:16:34 PM
Tried them today at Chippenham. Gorgeous. I could see the Tipo a Mano being better for Morris than the handmade reeds.  Much nicer playing than my Binchi II, lighter, prettier and good volume.

Obviously not an Oakwood thanks to the large raised ‘Turner’ on the front.
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: nigelr on May 24, 2026, 07:52:22 PM
Likewise, I tried one at Chippenham today.  Loud, punchy and light. Certainly a good box.

The two big minuses for me were (a) the bass reed layout means there isn't a third stop option and (b) the eye-watering price tag.

Not enough to coax me away from my DB Oakwood Super 2.
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: CAB on May 25, 2026, 10:23:46 AM
I too tried both the TAM and hand-made reed options at Chippenham yesterday.  Both impressed me.  I was reminded of the power and projection of my Wheatstone model 22 EC with its shallow reed pans and they confirmed the Turner has the same characteristic for similar reasons.

The action is very fast, apparently owing to using metal in place of wood.  What struck me was the ease with which I could do the trick of hitting a button three times in quick succession with consecutive fingers, which is always a bit hit and miss on my existing boxes but proved very reliable on the Turner because the action returns so quickly after each strike.  I suggested they should think about a BC model for the Irish market, where that rapidity would go down very well.

I confirm both of Nigel's minuses.  You'd have to either have one without left-hand thirds or tape 'em off.  No room for a stop mechanism, apparently.  And yes, they won't come cheap!  I was told the difference between TAM and hand-made might be around £200 or so, not much difference in the context of around 4000.
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: Ross Dubois on May 25, 2026, 08:07:39 PM
...The action is very fast, apparently owing to using metal in place of wood.  What struck me was the ease with which I could do the trick of hitting a button three times in quick succession with consecutive fingers, which is always a bit hit and miss on my existing boxes but proved very reliable on the Turner because the action returns so quickly after each strike.  I suggested they should think about a BC model for the Irish market, where that rapidity would go down very well.

I confirm both of Nigel's minuses.  You'd have to either have one without left-hand thirds or tape 'em off.  No room for a stop mechanism, apparently.  And yes, they won't come cheap!  I was told the difference between TAM and hand-made might be around £200 or so, not much difference in the context of around 4000.

I also mentioned to Mr. Turner that a compact box like that in B/C or C#/D would be quite nice and he argued that because there are only 19 buttons it would probably not happen, as he believes most semitone players wouldn't like the missing notes. I'd argue that, there are still a great many tunes I can play with 19 buttons and the old D/C# boxes were often 19 buttons and you can really get a lot out of those.

Also, regarding treble mechanism, I reckon that speed increase is also just overall down to design and spring tension as I've played a good many traditional wood action stepped keyboards with great speed. Sharon Shannon comes to mind as someone who whips around on a tommy just fine in that respect, and there's also some prodigious Italian organetto players that are just wildly fast. But if you're saying that it's just a super quick action in general, id also buy that for a dollar.

Speaking of dollars, without knowing the provenance of the instrument, I'm not sure I'd be super keen to spend £4,000 quid. I get protecting your perception of value and overhead, but for that much money I really want to know who's made my instrument
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: squeezy on May 25, 2026, 11:27:52 PM
I didn't get a chance to play on it at Chippenham ... but I'm very glad to see that there's Turner lettering on it to remove any doubt as to whether it's an Oakwood or not.

As for knowing exactly who made it ... that wouldn't bother me when getting a box if the box clearly performed the way I wanted it to.  At this early stage I would be wary of ordering one to be made for me on the back of seeing a prototype ... squeezeboxes are complicated things and even the most accurate of factories are capable of putting out two seemingly identical boxes with playing characteristics that can feel very different in your hands.

That being said ... the video of Rees playing it sounds absolutely stunning ... and very like the sound of an Oakwood model 2 which is a fantastic sound for Morris or ceilidh ... all of the reviews here seem to confirm that this prototype plays like a model 2 as well.

Hats off to John Turner for taking the risk to get something like this made for our (very niche) market.  I hope they're a success.
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: Rick St. John on May 26, 2026, 11:31:21 AM
I had a go on one of these at Chippenham. (I couldn't compare it with the other on because that one had a non-adjustable bass strap that was way to small for my hand). It was a pleasure to play - very responsive, with a good tone. If I was in the market for a morris box, this would be on my shortlist
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: Helena Handcart on May 26, 2026, 12:26:04 PM
I was also only really able to try the TAM version due to the teeny bass strap on the other mode.  A fast and punchy box certainly, but the lack of a thirds stop would be a disadvantage for me. I almost never play with thirds in but the thought of spending that amount of money and still needing to reach for a roll of masking tape doesn't appeal. That said if you were in the market for a seriously small and punchy morris box this one would certainly be worth a look.

I was looking purely out of curiosity in any case as I already have my personal ultimate morris box - one of the ten Oakwood 2-voice boxes made in 2017.
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: CAB on May 27, 2026, 12:12:16 AM
I also mentioned to Mr. Turner that a compact box like that in B/C or C#/D would be quite nice and he argued that because there are only 19 buttons it would probably not happen, as he believes most semitone players wouldn't like the missing notes. I'd argue that, there are still a great many tunes I can play with 19 buttons and the old D/C# boxes were often 19 buttons and you can really get a lot out of those.

Funnily enough, he asked me just that question - if I thought the range would be enough.  Maybe you got him thinking about it!
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: Rog on May 28, 2026, 08:42:32 AM
On the grille design…it might have been:
maker ‘you have a grille design? It cost you more for a different one from this here Oakwood you sent me’.
Answer: (checks wallet) … let's go with that grille…
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: rileycat on May 28, 2026, 05:06:21 PM
Could be John's original grill design for Oakwood, perhaps?
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: Helena Handcart on May 28, 2026, 05:22:48 PM
On the grille design…it might have been:
maker ‘you have a grille design? It cost you more for a different one from this here Oakwood you sent me’.
Answer: (checks wallet) … let's go with that grille…

The Oakwood grille design was based on a champagne flute owned by John's mother-in-law*.

* I think, may have been another close family member.
Title: Re: Turner prototype
Post by: Gena Crisman on September 14, 2026, 11:51:31 AM
Squeezebox marketplace had a stall at Swanage folk festival, somewhat unexpectedly. Had a go on a good number of things, including this.

Descriptions are accurate. Probably important to try playing it in a non festival environment given how very fiesty it presented itself as, but the big thing you'll notice regardless of where you play it would be the action. Neither box I played had accidentals, which made me sad. I... Really need to make myself a repertoire of tunes that don't rely on the nuanced parts that change all the time. And then write that list down so I can remember what they are when I need them!

I've had a the opportunity to play an oakwood model 2 in the past and I recall they have a very fast action with a wooden keyboard. To me mostly my takeaway was less about the speed per se and more like getting into a very luxurious bed or eating those really nice chocolates that you like - very smooth and you can just do what you want in complete comfort. But there again I usually play a box using a very similar metal action, with a similar keyboard thickness, so, do take note of that thickness. Couple of my friends have a Dino super 3 and a very nice loffet box of some kind, that I've played recently and their wooden keyboards are really thin! Too thin for me, for sure, but important to some.

Also had a chat, and played other instruments. Turns out Salterelle do some nice compact 2.5 and 3 rows that compete with Castas offering of the Benny or... Afaik, nothing else, in that space? I only learned to the stall because a friend bought an accordion, and told me about it, and when I went to visit, I saw two of my other local friends trying and I believe they also both bought instruments. So hopefully fruitful for everyone!

They asked me to demo a 2nd hand box for someone across the pond, as well as asked to record me playing a bit in general, which I did agree to. I'm never really sure how to feel about that lol. I tried playing my melodeon afterwards and couldn't get anything complicated to come out after doing 2 full days of morris and the 2 evening English sessions, so I expect my attention to detail was probably a little shot. It's nice to see a premium box purveyor at Swanage, though.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal