Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: waltzman on January 01, 2010, 04:18:07 PM
-
The combination of putting felt on the pallets and limiting the button travel with a wooden bar as described by Theo has completely eliminated the clacking noise from the treble side of my Erica. The bass side, however, is another matter. I put a layer of felt on the bass pallets too but this was not sufficient. It still makes a substantial noise when the pallet strikes the wood as the button is released. I'm thinking of adding additional felt (maybe three layers) to quiet the bass side. Does anyone have any other suggestions?
Michael
-
Michael,
Did you solve the bass clack? I'm tackling a similar problem on a pokerwork.
-
Just leave it like that and call it a 'Ericlack'...
-
Yes and no. I've found ways of playing the basses that minimize the clack to the point where I've not tried to do anything else about it. What seemed to help the most on the treble side was limiting the button travel so that the pallets aren't slapping down from a great height. I haven't thought of an easy way to do this on the bass side.
-
It's possible to release the buttons (treble or bass) in such a way that the fingers slightly retard the return to the 'closed' position and reduce the slapping effect. Easy touch does it!
-
Just leave it like that and call it a 'Ericlack'...
H'mm....if it's a black one, remove the tremolo & it'll be an Eric Clackton Special..........
Merry Christmas all!
-
It's possible to release the buttons (treble or bass) in such a way that the fingers slightly retard the return to the 'closed' position and reduce the slapping effect. Easy touch does it!
Yes and no. I've found ways of playing the basses that minimize the clack to the point where I've not tried to do anything else about it. What seemed to help the most on the treble side was limiting the button travel so that the pallets aren't slapping down from a great height. I haven't thought of an easy way to do this on the bass side.
Limiting button travel, primarily to stop them "disappearing", does have the added bonus of reducing pallet noise. If overdone it will however also reduce any such "feel" from the buttons so that they seem more like a touchpad.
Because there no sensible way to limit button travel on the bass end, any silencing would have to be achieved by giving the pallets a softer landing, but do wonder whether additional layers of felt would give this.
I see that CGM are now listing 1/8" thick Foam for Hohner Pallets and wonder whether this would not provide a more resilent backing than extra felt.
-
I redid the bass pallets with the same 2mm felt and new leather that I used on the treble side but it did very little to help the noise. I wish I had used twice the thickness of felt. The foam might be a good option.
-
Would someone be so kind as to elaborate on who "CGM" are? Is there a similar US supplier?
-
CGM is Charlie Marshall.
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Welcome.html (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Welcome.html)
-
Don't know of any similar supplier in the U.S. (Since Sam Shublom has gone out of business), but there is FRM in Montreal.
Bob
-
Charlie Marshall will ship to the US. Call/e-mail him first for rates.
-
I redid the bass pallets with the same 2mm felt and new leather that I used on the treble side but it did very little to help the noise. I wish I had used twice the thickness of felt. The foam might be a good option.
On second thought, I'd be concerned about the durability of the foam. It would be much more likely to degrade over time than the felt.
-
Hohner used a foam in the 60s/70s on the Atlantic series piano boxes. If you find one now with the original pallet facings the foam has collapsed and turned to dust. Modern foams "might" be better, but felt has a proven track record, you do need to use the right sort of soft low density felt. I'm sure cgm will sell the right stuff.
-
I've dealt with Frank at FRM in Canada. He has a pretty good selection of supplies.
http://www.frment.com/
-
I've dealt with Frank at FRM in Canada. He has a pretty good selection of supplies. http://www.frment.com/
Thanks for the advice. By the way, I really enjoyed your site. Lovely boxes.
I particularly empathized with your Hohner 114's being subjected to experiments. My Hohner is shuddering at the prospect of even more exploratory surgery followed by clumsy efforts to stitch it back up. I've already discovered that one should not hammer the bellows pins back when they show way too much resistance. Who'd have thought that Swiss craftsman would have allowed slight asymmetries? Shameful. Next time I'll mark which end of the bellows is up.