Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: chris hall on June 25, 2026, 04:35:47 PM
-
ive noticed in winter my melodeons can feel a little harder to play. slightly less responsive. harder work. less agile. ive also noticed in summer the opposite is true. today its 34 degrees and wow. im hitting licks on my acadian one row that i never thought possible. so whats going on. is it just that i feel like im in louisiana or is there something else at work? could the reeds expand slightly and become more responsive as the gap between the reed and plate narrows? could the reed itself just be less stiff in the heat. or could my old arthritic fingers just come to life in the summer. or is the sweat on my fingers acting as a lubricant . Or does my brain work faster in the heat? or does humidity give the notes extra vibrancy. Or is it all in my head? any metallurgists or physicists or doctors or psychologists or meteorologists got any answers. ive discussed this in the past with my students who have observed the same phenomenon so maybe its not just me? incidentally i once did a gig outside in freezing fog and it was like wading through treacle. whats going off?
-
Interesting...
This is definitely the first positive aspect of the global warming I've heard about! 8)
-
… could the reeds expand slightly and become more responsive as the gap between the reed and plate narrows?
I can debunk that one. Aluminium expands faster than steel, so if anything the clearance between reed and plate will increase with rising temperatures
-
Humidity changes seasonally. Low humidity : wood shrinks, air has less mass.
Higher humidity: wood expands, air has more mass. Both these spectral changes affect instrument response. It's not temperature per se. It's climate. Perhaps this is why I prefer to sing in the shower...
-
… could the reeds expand slightly and become more responsive as the gap between the reed and plate narrows?
I can debunk that one. Aluminium expands faster than steel, so if anything the clearance between reed and plate will increase with rising temperatures
good point. in which case?
-
Humidity changes seasonally. Low humidity : wood shrinks, air has less mass.
Higher humidity: wood expands, air has more mass. Both these spectral changes affect instrument response. It's not temperature per se. It's climate. Perhaps this is why I prefer to sing in the shower...
isnt singing or playing melodeon in the shower more to do with refections off the tiles. ie reverb. in which case?
-
Hot or cold, I'm still trying figure out why the bellows on my 1-row Hohner 114
feel are much stiffer than the bellows on my Hohner 2-row 2815. So stiff that I have to play it with the valve partially depressed.
The 2815 has two more bellows plaits/folds but that doesn't seem like it would be enough to make the difference.
Air flow restriction is the only thing that I can think of; the air valve breather hole on the 114 is about 20mm, I do not know the diameter of the hole on the 2815.
I bought the 114 in 1994.
-
the bellows on my 1-row Hohner 114 feel are much stiffer than the bellows on my Hohner 2-row 2815. So stiff that I have to play it with the valve partially depressed.
Try this, always worked for me (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iigObdMdK6I)
-
Try this, always worked for me
Thanks Lester.
I tried your technique in the past. BUT I missed the "crackling...good noise" part. I just went through the four sides and got some "good", albeit alarming crackles. It seems somewhat easlier on the pull. I'm probably guilty of not playing with the bellows at full extension since the stiffness made it uncomfortable. I'll run through this stretching drill until it loosens up more.
I've alway stored this instrument with the bellows straps secured. Would storing it 'un-stapped' help out with the stiffness issue?
EDIT
Barrowed from another discussion
I don't think my 2815 bellows will stretch this far
https://youtu.be/ce2e69B8Fy0?si=VvO2RG8TvgC-dn3_
-
Late to this thread, but could it be that your fingers are more fluid in warm weather, rather than the melodeon playing differently?
-
could well be. I'll put "little hotties" on my way to next winter gig inside gloves!
-
Hot or cold, I'm still trying figure out why the bellows on my 1-row Hohner 114 feel are much stiffer than the bellows on my Hohner 2-row 2815. So stiff that I have to play it with the valve partially depressed.
The 2815 has two more bellows plaits/folds but that doesn't seem like it would be enough to make the difference.
Air flow restriction is the only thing that I can think of; the air valve breather hole on the 114 is about 20mm, I do not know the diameter of the hole on the 2815.
I bought the 114 in 1994.
I find that often what people feel is an issue with stiff bellows is actually more related to reed response and other factors affecting how a keyboard feels and plays. Yes, new bellows can take some time to break-in, but even new bellows shouldn't make the box feel like it's a lot more work to play that it would otherwise be. You also can't compare a 2815 to a 114; one is a 2-voice (MM) instrument with light button tension and the other a 4-voice (LMMH) with a much heavier and stiffer button action. The response of L reeds alone in a Hohner can make the box feel noticeably harder to play. We are not comparing like-with-like here to be able to claim bellows are the issue. Your HA114 could most certainly be set up to play much more easily with the existing bellows; I dare say the bellows themselves are not the issue.
-
Chris, one thing that I've noticed with Cajun-style boxes (as well as other accordions with wooden key levers) is that changing humidity levels can affect how freely the key levers move. As wood expands it can cause the wooden levers to rub up against the adjacent wood which can cause them to not move quite as freely or easily. It can also happen around the axle rod (since it runs through a wooden key) causing some sluggishness as it pivots. This can be *very* subtle or it can be enough that it becomes obvious a lever isn't moving as easily as the others. Even when it's subtle, though, it can affect how a box feels when it's being played. It happened with me with several one-rows that I used to own, and I've seen the issue in clients' accordions as well.
Some Quebec cajun-box builders switched to using veneer-topped delrin for making the key levers to avoid this, and others have experimented with using a metal conduit in the wooden levers for the axle to pass through.
-
Late to this thread, but could it be that your fingers are more fluid in warm weather, rather than the melodeon playing differently?
I was about to suggest this as well. Back when I used to commute by bicycle year-round, I would definitely notice this about my knees as winter turned to spring!