Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Lew Morris on August 01, 2026, 08:15:54 PM
-
Right hand:
No problems
Left hand:
4/4 no problem
2/4 " "
6/8 " "
3/4 just can't hook up to save my life.
Nothing fancy; variable tempo would be nice, a syncopation feature would be a grand. Prefer new vs. used.
-
We've talked about this before. The investor advice for Waltz time is "anything except dum chacha"
l my own main insight about 3/4 time Was that playing nothing at all for one of the beats is also a rhythm event. Let's call that "Z"= zero. we are talking about a beat on the left and in which you play "silence". Cha … would be hitching the cord button
From that concept you can do all sorts of things | Dum cha silence |? It really doesn't matter.… my advice would be too just play left hand for a week or so and get that really fluent. Something you don't think need to think about and then reintroduce the right hand against it. There's a bit of practice involved but once you've got it sorted it'll be with you forever. Try …
| dum Z Z | … or | dum cha Z| or | dum Z cha |
You can also bring the cord in to join a previous base beat - or vice versa
|Dum Z both | or | Dum…hold join | or even | dum join silence |?
Everything works. I learned this by playing left-hand only in all sorts of different rhythms including silences, and joins, until I could play but anything at Will. Then you bring in your right hand melody against that. It really enriches the interpretation of the tune. Don't worry about it.
Everything works. The key to the whole thing, is realising that playing {nothing} is as much a {rhythm event} as playing a base, or a chords/bass
-
Conversely, when I started out I just couldn't crack the left hand for reels, polkas and jigs but waltzes just clicked for me.
-
Try playing only the downbeat bass note for a while for ¾ time. Also lay the melody over the comp instead of adding LH to the RH.
-
Then you bring in your right hand melody against that
Also lay the melody over the comp instead of adding LH to the RH.
This where the need for the neural implant comes into play ... :P
As much as I dislike the whole "AI" thing it has allowed me to find related videos, and it was able to locate several discussions (two of which were from MelNet), that I could not find using the MelNet Search function.
Exercises from Gavin Atkinson
https://youtu.be/zrfxhFpc7sY?si=fgL_D8bvbXoKuH8t
A technique termed "ghosting" by Lucy Riddett (basically learning to disassociate the right and left hand
https://youtu.be/NszFNLU2JiA?si=HLqKgiIm_RZ16tQT
And this one, which coincidently includes "silent" beats. By Jeffery Forbes
https://youtu.be/4Bycy2NyUbg?si=eIfSKrk6WQf3HQdY
I've been trying to disassemble this process; instinctively starting with just the downbeat alone. I've made some progress. Most daunting thusfar are tunes like; Mazurka d'Auvergn, and Planxty Fanny Power. I will definitely use all of your suggestions.
I posted this as a humorous aside, but certainly appreciate the feedback.
Lo, the plight learning in a vacuum; I can't imagine the bad habits I've developed...
-
You can work on this without the box:
Tap 1-2-3, 1-2-3, 1-2-3 with your LH and the rhythm of the melody with your RH.
-
Be aware that there are multiple ternary rhythms that aren't waltzes
Auvergnat Bourrée | One Two three | - the so called "heartbeat" rhythm
Irish Jigs not my scene …
Polska's are complicated, and depend on the dance, and where you are in Scandinavia. Dick is our group expert
https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=32468.msg371128#msg371128
-
I too remember struggling with 3/4 waltzes, but after a while it clicked
I cannot give you anything more insightful than 'keep bashing away, it will happen!'
Also as said, don't be a slave to um pah-ing.
There might be a case for perhaps bass only, a bass and chord together, a little bass run to mimic the melody or even a silent left hand for a phrase.
Um pahs are not compulsory!
Good luck 👍
-
Be aware that there are multiple ternary rhythms that aren't waltzes
Yup, including Fanny Power. Closest meter is probably 6/8, but the more important thing is that it's not a dance. Approaching Carolan tunes as if they're waltzes or weird slow-motion jigs or polkas means ignoring some of what makes them tick. They'll never feel quite right.
Playing speed can be brisk or slow, varied or constant, it depends on the individual tune and how you interpret it. As they were composed for the harp, it might be an idea to start by listening to a range of harpers playing them? Although most of the surviving tunes are played as instrumentals these days, a good proportion were originally composed as songs.
-
I think if a new player is still having difficulty with "um-pa-pa", it's a little early to be worried about playing more varied and interesting bass patterns.
I had some trouble with 3/4 at first, too. Just keep at it, and it'll feel more and more natural. Can you listen to a tune in 3/4 and tap out the beat with your foot or your hand on a table? Then, can you play the tune, melody only, in time with emphasis on each downbeat? In other words, is this just a problem putting the two hands together, or is the 3/4 rhythm itself giving difficulty?
-
Fair comment Jesse, yes at first keep it simple to 'get through the door' of the 3/4 rhythm before exploring other options.
Isn't it strange that several here, including me, struggle with this rhythm at first. I wonder why?
-
Isn't it strange that several here, including me, struggle with this rhythm at first. I wonder why?
I think it is possibly because the basic "oom-pah", which works for most rhythms, is a simple alternation between the finger playing the root and the finger playing the chord. "Oom-pah-pah" introduces a completely different, and more complex, pattern.
Learning to play involves building up neural pathways - "muscle memory". This new pattern is fighting with the neural pathway you had built up learning "oom-pah". You have to establish a new neural pathway, which can only be done by repetition. Take your time, it is more important to be accurate than fast or you risk embedding mistakes. Stop before you get tired, for the same reason. Once you have it nailed it will then be easier to bring it up to the desired speed.
These basic patterns can be fairly boring musically and many advanced players do more complex things with the left hand, but to be able to do that they have to have nailed the core patterns first. You can only start to leave things out if you know what to leave out. But for some tunes a basic unadorned accompaniment is exactly right. It is one of the contradictions of this instrument that once a beginner has finally mastered "oom-pah" the next step is to start unlearning it, or at least knowing when not to use it.
As with most things when it comes to learning music, the answer is practice.
-
In a 2005 weekend workshop (Kinnersley Castle), Steph Milleret's tip to me was "anything, except om pah pah"
It stood the test of time. Some of the best, and frankly simplest advice that I have ever been given
-
In a 2005 weekend workshop (Kinnersley Castle), Steph Milleret's tip to me was "anything, except om pah pah"
It stood the test of time. Some of the best, and frankly simplest advice that I have ever been given
These basic patterns can be fairly boring musically and many advanced players do more complex things with the left hand, but to be able to do that they have to have nailed the core patterns first. You can only start to leave things out if you know what to leave out. But for some tunes a basic unadorned accompaniment is exactly right. It is one of the contradictions of this instrument that once a beginner has finally mastered "oom-pah" the next step is to start unlearning it, or at least knowing when not to use it.
As with most things when it comes to learning music, the answer is practice.
I'm with Howard on this. Walk before you run, kind of... (:)
-
Good point about the extra 'pah' Howard, hadn't thought of it like that.
To my mind, the whole 'um -pah' thing with the bass and chord is to establish the fact that both hands are doing something different. Therefore as said you need to build that pathway and 'um - pah' is the way to do it.
Yes by all means do other things when the neural link is established but... at the beginning you need to establish that left and right hand link.
-
I think if a new player is still having difficulty with "um-pa-pa", it's a little early to be worried about playing more varied and interesting bass patterns.
I agree with this - don't run before you can walk.
Synchronising "um-pa-pa" in the LH with melody in the RH is a basic skill worth learning if you can't do it yet, but once you can, you move on and spend the rest of your 3/4 playing life looking for opportunities to avoid it. And I still do it, but I'll try hard to avoid doing it for more than about 4 bars in a row, or it starts feeling relentless.
Milleret's advice is succinct and memorable, but needs to be understood in context.
-
I think if a new player is still having difficulty with "um-pa-pa", it's a little early to be worried about playing more varied and interesting bass patterns.
I agree with this - don't run before you can walk.
Synchronising "um-pa-pa" in the LH with melody in the RH is a basic skill worth learning if you can't do it yet, but once you can, you move on and spend the rest of your 3/4 playing life looking for opportunities to avoid it. And I still do it, but I'll try hard to avoid doing it for more than about 4 bars in a row, or it starts feeling relentless.
Milleret's advice is succinct and memorable, but needs to be understood in context.
I would amend this to include simply playing the down beat regardless of the time signsture. Oom only, no pas.
-
I would amend this to include simply playing the down beat regardless of the time signsture. Oom only, no pas.
I'm not clear what you mean by this. If you are advising the OP not to bother with "pas", I disagree. Ignoring the "pas" may solve the immediate problem but won't help them develop the left hand coordination they need to become a fluent player.
If it is an interpretation of "anything but oom-pah" then it raises the question whether the emphasis should be on the down beat or the off beat.
Whilst I firmly agree with the idea of "anything but oompah", learning oom-pah for all time signatures is a stage players need to go through. Only when they have a solid basis to underpin their playing will they then be able to find ways to avoid it.
-
Milleret's advice is succinct and memorable, but needs to be understood in context.
Steph's degree is in maths (ditto Pignol. They were in the same class at Grenoble university).
About 30 years ago he made a really deep study of rhythms. And poly-rhythms. He can tap out 3/4 with one hand and 5/8 with the other. That's extremely clever, but has … limited application in folk music. But they are both good dancers and the usual "the rhythm should inform the feet" is an important part of their music.
We see the same with la Chavanée, and the better Irish bands. That's to say that most folk music is dance music.
-
I would amend this to include simply playing the down beat regardless of the time signsture. Oom only, no pas.
I'm not clear what you mean by this. If you are advising the OP not to bother with "pas", I disagree. Ignoring the "pas" may solve the immediate problem but won't help them develop the left hand coordination they need to become a fluent player.
If it is an interpretation of "anything but oom-pah" then it raises the question whether the emphasis should be on the down beat or the off beat.
Whilst I firmly agree with the idea of "anything but oompah", learning oom-pah for all time signatures is a stage players need to go through. Only when they have a solid basis to underpin their playing will they then be able to find ways to avoid it.
Start with the oom, bring in the pa. I'm a two-finger LH player. I use my middle finger for the oom ..
-
I'm a big fan of um-pah-pah.
It makes a good solid base for right hand rhythmic interplay.
Try playing a good solid 1 2 3 / 1 2 3 repeating left hand pattern then drop left hand chords on 2 3+ / 1 2+ / 2 3+ / 1 2+ 3.
The result is funky, quirky and definitely not an overbearing waltz pattern.
As an interesting anecdote I'll throw in an experience from some 15 - 20 years ago when I was teaching. I showed my pupil a simple waltz using a straight um-pah-pah pattern. My pupil, though not an accordeon player, was a good singer and very musically aware. She asked me to repeat the four bar pattern. She queried my left hand. Though I was convinced that I was playing a solid 1-2-3 um-pah-pah pattern she heard a much more subtle rhythmic emphasis. We recorded my playing. On listening it was clear that there were distinct changes in emphasis throughout that gave the effect of a far more complex pattern. This was probably further influenced through subtle changes in note length, anticipation and delay.
Don't give up on um-pah-pah. Played mechanically it's a great trick when you want to evoke the nostalgia of the steam driven fairground. Played with the subtlety and musicality of an experienced jazz drummer the effect can be mesmerising, enticing and magical.
-
The rhythmic beat is found in both hands and the bellows. Plenty of hooks on which to hang your coat...
-
Your suggestions are much appreciated folks. Between LH technique work, and my newly arrived A/D, I have a lot to work on.
Apologies for my delayed response, it wasn't a matter of disinterest; we had a family loss on August 8 and things are just now starting to resemble normal.
Cheers.