Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Ross Dubois on August 11, 2026, 06:50:28 PM

Title: Volume differences between castagnari Tommy's and Sharon?
Post by: Ross Dubois on August 11, 2026, 06:50:28 PM
I have a Tommy that's probably from the early 90s with antonelli reeds and it is a screamer. I love it very much, but it is extremely loud compared to any other box I've owned. It drowns out my three voice Paolo even.

You can modulate your playing well enough thanks to the versatility of the antonelli reeds, but even at its gentlest it's still a pretty loud and punchy box. It got me wondering if subsequent generations of Tommy's had different characteristics as I recall reading that the size of the box actually changed as well as antonelli merging with salpa to make Voci.

I was also wondering if the Sharon model plays differently volume wise then the Tommy,  even though it's like pretty much the same chassis size as the Tommy. I imagine the only real difference would be the keyboard.

So yeah, if anyone has any experience with Tommy's over the years and has also tried to Sharon, I'd like to hear what you think.

I'm a BC player predominantly (and one row boxes) and the Tommy has a stepped keyboard which for years I have played just fine, but it's had me wondering whether or not swapping to a Sharon would change a number of things or just the keyboard situation. It would be something to consider for me if the volume was a little bit quieter and it had a flat keyboard
Title: Re: Volume differences between castagnari Tommy's and Sharon?
Post by: mselic on August 12, 2026, 10:27:46 PM
A couple of things to consider:

-smaller boxes tend to pack more punch volume-wise than those with a larger casework, all other things being equal.

-AFAIK, the only difference between the current-day Tommy and Sharon is the flat keyboard on the Sharon.

-older Castagnari boxes used Antonelli reeds, while modern ones (such as the Sharon) use Voci Armoniche.  The former reed maker merged with the latter, but the two reeds they produced are different.
Title: Re: Volume differences between castagnari Tommy's and Sharon?
Post by: Ross Dubois on August 26, 2026, 10:33:28 AM
I have a small one row Melodeon that's smaller than the tommy and it's pretty quiet comparatively. Tipo a mano reeds, a unique flat mount emulating reedblock as well, but half as loud as the Tommy.

So is it a matter of size or something else? Does a metal s soundboard on a small box matter?

But regarding the Shannon and Tommy it makes sense they'd be pretty similar. Maybe worth asking about the saltarelle Aether instead
Title: Re: Volume differences between castagnari Tommy's and Sharon?
Post by: Paul Bryan on September 02, 2026, 06:26:34 PM
hi the set up of the boxes is the important thing pallet lift will be a big factor in volume  also the old tommy has a reverse action to help the pallets lift more parallel new tommys have a direct action  button height will also affect the volume im guessing the sharon has direct action as its cheaper and quicker to produce   reed set up and brand could also make a difference and age of reeds played for many years will also make a diffrence  so a lot of factors  to think about
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal