Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Derik Palmer on August 28, 2026, 11:20:11 PM

Title: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Derik Palmer on August 28, 2026, 11:20:11 PM
Hello. I'm new. Well, I'm new here and new to the melodeon. In the rest of the world I'm distinctly secondhand, look well used but not quite worn out, feel in need of a service and hope that any replacement parts needed are readily available. I've played various stringed instruments for many years but have always had a yen to play a melodeon and recently arrived at the realisation that if I don't scratch the itch now then at some point it will be never. So - here I am! And having read up on where to start and looked around at what's available I've taken the plunge and bought myself a secondhand but apparently in very nice condition Dino Buffetti D/G. Its a Cascade III, everything seems to work OK. Secondhand, signs of wear but still functioning well enough - we seem to be a good match!

I've discovered a lot of YouTube posts and had a look at the list of tutors on this board. I live close to Brighton on the south coast of England and there's one tutor listed there but with no contact details so I'll probably rely on some internet courses for now. One thing that has already struck me; in the bluegrass and old-time genre there are loads of day and weekend camps and festivals, all of which have instructional workshops at their core; guitar/mandolin/fiddle players are pretty well catered for from complete beginner level to the guys who just make the rest of us jealous. But I'm struggling to see any sign of something similar in the melodeon/concertina world? Do you guys have a strict oath of secrecy about such things, or is getting up close and personal just not done?

Fear not - more silly questions to follow...
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Fionn on August 29, 2026, 12:57:22 AM
Try learning Irish on C#/D!  Never even met anyone else who plays it, let alone teaches face to face. ::)

There will be options out there though. Not all tutors advertise, as they may get enough work without it. Best way to find people is do what you've done: ask. Assuming you want to play English folk, there might be a folk club, pub session or Morris side where you could find local contacts.

The next best thing would be one-to-one lessons over Zoom/Teams/etc. They're still tailored to you as an individual, and it doesn't matter if the tutor lives at the other end of the country.

As for get-togethers, there are usually classes and workshops associated with the summer festivals. The season's pretty much over now, but there's always next year. By that time you'll hopefully have progressed, which in turn might give you more options.

Good luck!
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 29, 2026, 07:50:43 AM
There have been starter workshops at the major festivals, there would be ones this weekend at Shrewsbury. Sadly with the festival season almost finished that reduces options for now.

Ed Rennie and Helena Handcart both of this parish are heavily involved in these sessions, hopefully they will pop up here, though I suspect they are currently at Shrewsbury so it might take a day or two.

Also check out workshops run by Acorn Instruments. I think they're running one in Wolvercote near Oxford in November, details will be on their websites.

In short, there are workshops to get you going. Good luck!
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 29, 2026, 07:55:46 AM
I forgot... Helena works with Ed Rennie here...
https://spinningpathmusic.co.uk/squeezebox-from-scratch/

Take a look!
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Gromit on August 29, 2026, 08:29:25 AM
Lewis Folk Club near you have various workshops throughout the year - http://www.lewessaturdayfolkclub.org/LAFC/prog2025.html
There's a couple coming up in the next few months.

24 Oct Cohen Braithwaite-Kilcoyne English Melodeon but looks like it's for advanced players though.
14 Nov Tim Edey Melodeon no details of level at the moment.

There are some sessions in your area https://thesession.org/sessions/search?day=&q=Brighton - Sussex https://thesession.org/sessions/search?day=&q=Sussex
Probably a mix of English and Irish, I'd go along to the English ones and chat to DG players.
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: heartshaped1 on August 29, 2026, 08:51:38 AM
Hi Derik and welcome!

Bellows and Buttons might be the kind of thing you’re after? - There are two weekends a year, one at Wolvercote in Oxfordshire and one in Settle in Yorkshire. Helena (as mentioned above) teaches absolute beginners, I teach beginners, then there are a range of higher workshops taught by some of the greats above that.

Details here! https://bellowsandbuttons.co.uk/index.cfm

Good luck and keep posting, there’s no such thing as a stupid question!

Vicky
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Squeaky Pete on August 29, 2026, 09:23:01 AM
Hi Derik
I'm in Lewes and help run one session nearby. There's at least one per week in and aound Lewes, mostly English based. Some Irish in Brighton too I gather.
I go to some of the Lewes workshops.
Do get in touch if you want some further details.
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: WestOz on August 30, 2026, 08:50:37 AM
Hi Derik, and welcome
To get you started, you might have a look at  https://www.daddylongles.com/dgmelodeon
Some free tuition, and some you can pay for.
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 30, 2026, 10:02:59 AM
As Vicky says, there is no such thing as a stupid question.
Another free option is... here!
Just ask away...
We all started at some point.
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Theo on August 30, 2026, 11:23:02 AM
Another option is a tutor book.  There are several good ones available.  Even if you end up having lessons a book is a good place to start so you are prepared to get the most out of lessons.  It is pretty straightforward learn the layout of notes, basses and chords, and the location of the air button from a book,  and you could try some of the first steps of playing too.

And spend as much time as possible listening to music that you like and might want to play. That way you will have a good idea of what you want to learn.
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Steve C. on August 30, 2026, 03:22:31 PM
Seconding to Theo. 
Not just tutor books but Youtube in general is a revelation.
There are MANY youtubes (by members of this group especially) that are essentially tutors and did I say FREE.  And not only excellent in sound but in  production values. And inspirational.
BUT you can play them over and over and over and over again until you get it.
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 30, 2026, 03:40:22 PM
At the absolute 'Ground Zero' beginning for me, I bought a tutor book which I found very helpful.
It got me going and taught me my first couple of tunes.
It bridged the gap between knowing nothing to jumping to start to learn tunes that I already knew from my previous instrument.

I already knew the type and the actual tunes I wanted to play from my concertina days so had an advantage.
As Theo says, listen to music, whether live at a session, Youtube or recorded. It helps get tunes into your head and also points you in a direction of what you like and where you might go musically - English, Irish, Continental etc
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Lew Morris on August 31, 2026, 05:13:35 AM
Quote
At the absolute 'Ground Zero' beginning for me, I bought a tutor book which I found very helpful.

Title? I need all the help I can get.  ;)
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 31, 2026, 07:55:14 AM
I started with Dave Mallison's 'The D/G Melodeon Absolute Beginners Book'
Here.... https://www.mallyproductions.com/mallybooks

That was back in 2010. I think there was only a couple of books available then.
Ed Rennie of this parish has a tutor book I think. Might be worth messaging him to find out.

It might be worth starting a new thread and asking for opinions on tutor books currently available.
The only problem being we all learn in very different ways. What works for one might not suit another person, but Dave's book got me off the mark.

( 2010... blimey. Doesn't time fly when you're enjoying yourself?  :|||: )
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: melod-ian on August 31, 2026, 10:12:54 AM
To add to the Sussex session options:
There’s The Crabtree, Shoreham-by-sea 3rd Monday of the month and The Cricketers, Broadwater, Worthing last Tuesday of the month. Both general English tunes based.
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: rees on August 31, 2026, 10:31:38 AM
Another vote for Dave Mallison's 'The D/G Melodeon Absolute Beginners Book'
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Steve C. on August 31, 2026, 01:23:08 PM
+1 for Mally.
It gives you that early confidence of "hey, I can play" that is really helpful.
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: malcolmbebb on August 31, 2026, 05:04:08 PM
Some years ago (too many) a group of beginner melodeon players got together for a workshop. Many of us had not even seen another melodeon player at that point.
There was an issue in that the major events didn't cater for absolute beginner players, which we all were. So, after some chat on here, the first Melodeon Playgroup took place.
Well, it's still going and still has its key emphasis on beginners and absolute beginners - but they kept getting better and kept coming back, so now extends to Improvers and Advanced players.
It takes place in early February in Evesham, Worcs - a little bit away in time and distance from you, of course - but might be of interest to you. It's one day, but we usually make a cracking weekend of it.
Helena, of this parish and the subject of numerous honourable mentions in this thread, started there and is woven into it - and will be teaching there next year.
I'll put a link here and below (https://www.melodeonplaygroup.org/). There is a catch, however.
Bookings are rumoured to open very shortly and it fills up very quickly.
https://www.melodeonplaygroup.org/ (https://www.melodeonplaygroup.org/)
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Helena Handcart on August 31, 2026, 07:00:25 PM
Ed Rennie and Helena Handcart both of this parish are heavily involved in these sessions, hopefully they will pop up here, though I suspect they are currently at Shrewsbury so it might take a day or two.

Yep, we were at Shrews again this year, what a fabulous festival. Another two Absolute Beginner taster sessions done, full house (and more) both days. All loan instruments in use, and it's a good thing I personally know all the traders because I was able to blag some extra instruments from them (thank you Acorn Instruments, Squeezebox Marketplace and PJ Music for your generosity).

Shrewsbury marks the end of our festival workshops for this season but you can find us on Facebook (https://www.facebook.com/SqueezeboxFromScratch) to see what's coming up in future.

As others have mentioned, there are really four main D/G events in the calendar each year, the two Bellows and Buttons (https://www.bellowsandbuttons.co.uk/) weekends in November and April, Melodeon Playgroup (https://www.melodeonplaygroup.org/) in February and the Halsway D/G weekend. Halsway don't really cater for entry-level players though, but it's worth keep in mind for future reference.

As previously noted, Melodeon Playgroup tends to sell out very quickly - and very often to the mailing list members before public bookings are opened publicly. If you think you might want to go next year do join the mailing list.

As for tutor books, they can be a great resource but are a very personal thing. I absolutely did not get on with the Mally book, found the tab unnecessarily complex to read and the tone of the thing didn't work for me. Fortunately  I found Ed's book which unlocked the whole thing for me, much more intuitive tab system to get you started. I also got on well with the split-screen video included - much easier to understand what was going on and follow it than just a CD/audio files.

As for stupid questions, there may not be any, but I am still working on testing that theory.



Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 31, 2026, 07:29:01 PM
Hurrah Helena's back!
Good to hear the festival went well, you both are doing a stirling job spreading the Good Word!

Yes as said, tutor books are such a personal choice, the current theory supported here by 3 people liking Mally and one not getting on with it.
I don't think Ed's book was around when I first started, but I can't remember exactly...
If you wished to peruse it, is it available online, or how to buy a copy?

Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Derik Palmer on August 31, 2026, 10:03:55 PM
Thank you all for your replies! I had to wait for some days for my registration to this forum to be approved but your responses have been worth the wait.

I'm aware of the sessions at Lewes Folk Club which are very local to me, and did attend one some years ago when I was contemplating buying an anglo concertina - it never happened because whilst I was indulging in my favourite hobby of prevaricating, someone else bought it from under my nose. But it was very obvious that despite the description of being for all levels of ability, all of the other attendees had a very good idea of what they were doing and had I been an active participant I should have been a hindrance to everybody else. Despite being made to feel welcome I wouldn't want to be responsible for holding others back in a situation like that.

Festivals can be a bit problematic because I'm a carer for my wife and I need to arrange cover in order to go. My son is very good at coming down to give me a break, but he has his own life to live and I'm hesitant to ask more than I need; but having said that the November event at Wolvercote sounds to be ideal for me and I'll make arrangements to be there, so many thanks for bringing it to my attention. I'm finding there are so many little corners of the internet where suppliers lurk and events are arranged, but there doesn't seem to be a central point of focus which brings them all together - maybe something this forum either does already or could do - if it does then I haven't yet found that particular corner either.

Oh yes - I've also ordered the Mallinson book.
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 31, 2026, 10:45:24 PM
Hi Derik,
I'm glad some of this has been of use to you.
I remember going to sessions and being very aware everyone was competent... and I wasn't. We have all been there!
Whether you can play or not, sessions are worthwhile as you will hear all sorts of tunes being played. Listening is a good thing to do. You'll get a feel for certain types of tunes, styles of playing, and also the things that you might not be so enamoured with. It can give you an idea of what you'd like to play.

Also sessions are social affairs, you get to know people and chat. In my sessions there are people who simply come along for a pint and a listen, and as a player you get to know them, have a chat between tunes, it makes for a very sociable evening.

Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Fionn on September 01, 2026, 12:16:24 AM
But it was very obvious that despite the description of being for all levels of ability, all of the other attendees had a very good idea of what they were doing and had I been an active participant I should have been a hindrance to everybody else. Despite being made to feel welcome I wouldn't want to be responsible for holding others back in a situation like that.

You could say that about a couple of sessions I attend, but they do welcome beginners. Our sessions are sometimes fast-paced simply because there are no inexperienced players there. Another week the tempo's more moderate because there are. Yet another, everyone will be applauding a beginner for playing for the first time. The impression you get depends on which week you happen to turn up.

There are a couple of ways people start joining in. One is to get there early, and ask the first three or four arrivals if they'd help out by warming their fingers up on a couple of tunes at a gentle pace. Another is to accept the invitation if/when they're asked to start a tune; even if they play really slowly, the others don't feel they're being held up. It's a short time out of a whole evening and they've all been that beginner.

Newbies tend to lurk for a while before they're willing to get an instrument out of a bag. It's important to feel confident that eyes won't be rolled at them if they make mistakes, and to realise experienced players mess up as well. In any case, it isn't beginners that session players find really objectionable. It's bad manners, entitlement, showboating, people who noodle along to tunes they don't even know, people who think their shut-your-eyes-and-point chord selection is close enough for folk. Of course not every session is the right place for a beginner, but if it's advertised as all-ability, it probably is.

Maybe start going as a listener as often as possible. You'll not only get to know people, you'll also start to get a sense of their core repertoire. Those are the tunes to learn, and it's easier when the melody's already familiar because you've heard it several times. Ask for tune names and write them down; ask if you can use your phone to record how they play tunes you particularly like.

Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Disparate Dan on September 01, 2026, 07:18:43 AM
I too started with the Mally book, but very soon became disenchanted with it.  "Maggie's Melodeon" is the one I stuck with.
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 01, 2026, 07:44:41 AM
Fionn's experience mirrors mine.
My first tunes are often my regular ones. It helps me remind myself where the buttons are and reaquaints me with my box. Other regulars have a similar strategy so those 'early tunes' get played a lot and are very inclusive for those reasons.
Similarly we acknowledge everyone started at some point and encourage new members to play a tune at whatever level they are at.
Also, for future reference, we all have our personal repertoire so no-one knows every tune played, and you'll frequently observe me listening not playing cos i dont know thst one!
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Jesse Smith on September 02, 2026, 03:51:11 PM
When I started (about 8 years ago! :o ) I acquired the Dave Mallinson and found it very helpful for the first few months. I worked through the tunes in order about halfway through the book and by then I felt comfortable enough to start working on the occasional Tune of the Month here, etc. By that point the book starts to swing more towards Irish tunes rather than the English tunes I was (and am) chiefly enthusiastic about, so there were diminishing returns of a sort anyway.

If you can find the melodeon tutor DVDs that John Kirkpatrick did about 20 years ago, those are fantastic. They will probably overwhelm you at first but I found them very "aspirational" in that they showed me visually what was possible with the same instrument that I was learning.
Title: Re: Stupid questions incoming!
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 02, 2026, 04:32:34 PM
Likewise for me Jesse, as my interest is in English tunes too.
Mally's book got me working both hands together which is a huge leap I think.
I then bought Nick Barber's tune books and cd's too. They were tunes I was mostly familiar with, and a simple melody with chords above. My sight reading was basic so along with listening to the cd's I started to learn the tunes I recognised from my local sessions.

Whatever route you start with, tutor books, lessons etc. its worth knowing there are next steps to follow in whichever way you wish to go.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal