Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: David Murray on September 05, 2026, 09:15:01 AM
-
Hi everyone, I have two melodeons a Pokerwork and Lily. Due to my arthritis I can only really play the Lily - the close and stepped keyboard works for me. I would like to replace my pokerwork with something I can still play. I really like the Tommy - more voices, stepped keyboard, small, but it is outside of my budget - can anyone recommend an alternative for me to look at? I would be most grateful.
-
I'm a fan of the Saltarelle l'Elfique (https://saltarelle.com/en/accordeons/lelfique) same voices as the Tommy but with a thirds stop as well, and I prefer the Saltarelle sound.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3YANsS8tCAs
-
Another model that might work for you is the Dino Baffetti black pearl II. It’s only 19 button on the treble side so considerably lighter than the 3 voice, 21 button model.
-
Thank you for both suggestions - I will check them out.
-
Arthritis? Well, you cannot cure it, but definitely you can treat it. And yes, I speak from personal experience.
Maybe, rather than changing the box, you could consider changing therapy...
-
Maybe, rather than changing the box, you could consider changing therapy...
Or do both - changing one does not prevent changing the other.
Ideally, changing box would prevent arthritis ! (:)
-
I have had my arthritis for nearly 20 years now - progressively getting worse although biologic injections are helping. I started as a concertina player - which is why when I could not bend my fingers much I started with a Lily - the concertina like sound appealed to me. I was given a Pokerwork which I enjoyed for a while. Really want to continue my melodeon journey for as long as possible and as I am reaching retirement will finally have more time to practice. Appreciate all the replies.
-
Maybe a nice Preciosa?
-
What about a Liilliput as a possibility ? Light and buttons close together - and lovely Right hand harmonies
-
If you have access to a good accordion tech then maybe you could look into simply changing the flat keyboard to a stepped one. It could solve your problem and save a nice amount of money. Just a thought. ;)
-
How about a fettled Hero button accordion in the key of D?
-
I think some of the French makers have models similar in size to things like the Tommy, like Tania Rutkowski (https://www.tr-accordeons.com/les-modeles/les-diatoniques/accordeon-diatonique-2-rangs-8-basses.html). Not sure how much cheaper they'd work out but if you fancy a holiday to Le Son Continu you'd be able to try out a few different smaller options as I remember there being a number of makers offering them when I last went.
Edit: though looking closer that's not a stepped keyboard on Tania's model, albeit the keys are raised above the board unlike things like the Pokerwork.