Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Ross Dubois on September 21, 2026, 01:27:38 AM

Title: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: Ross Dubois on September 21, 2026, 01:27:38 AM
I love small boxes. I've had many concertinas and small accordions and though they lack the specific timbre potential of their bigger counterparts, they have their own specific thing that I generally love.

I've had a very small L'Artigiana C#/D and a Castagnari Roma but sold them on so they aren't pictured here.
I prefer boxes under 28cm from side to side, but generally aim for something around 26cm or 25cm or smaller. For the sake of the thread, id say those boundaries work (anything under the standard 28cm maybe). My globe and hohners are 28cm so not quite small boxes 

Anyway, in this photo I have the following:

-Herbert Svoboda 2 voice Melodeon in D. Has a stop for switching to one or two voices

-Castagnari Tommy B/C 3 voice from the late 80s (I believe) so it's a 23cm version.

-Castagnari Melodeon 70th anniversary from 1984 (or 87, can't quite tell). Bizarrely rare, castagnari told me this is the predecessor to the standard Melodeon model. It's a beautiful box with a copper badge.

-Hohner Mignon I got for my son, who is currently a toddler but I want to start him early. Id like to get a preciosa at some point as well.

My Kensington Concertina is not pictured as it was in the bedroom and I didn't want to disturb my sleeping toddler.

What small boxes do you folks have?

(https://i.ibb.co/4n5ptHVn/IMG-20260920-195736.jpg) (https://ibb.co/bM8XmkKM)
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: Clive Williams on September 21, 2026, 08:56:23 AM
I have a bunch of 7 button Hero chinese melodeons in C, which I got to encourage my kiddo's into the world of melodeons. Boys being boys of course, they rebelled - the youngest plays the sax and oboe, and the eldest has just taken up with a C-system Hohner Lucia CBA (must be one of the smallest functional CBAs you can get) which I got to learn 'some day' - he learned it instantly, and plays it all the time.
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: Ross Dubois on September 21, 2026, 02:45:25 PM
I am envious of the Lucia owners. Those are so cool, and I've seen some folks convert them to DG boxes. There's another model like that from Hohner too, but I can't quite recall the name

And yeah, I fully expect my son to maybe not be into accordion since I play it all the time. We also make ocarinas for a living so he has spent the first 21 months of his life blowing into those and will likely be burned out on them by the time he wants to actually play music, haha
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: Rick St. John on September 21, 2026, 03:48:53 PM
When I used to travel a lot for work, I looked for a small 1V D/G that would fit in hand luggage. I looked for a B.Loffet Touptit or an Excelsior Mini but both were discontinued. In the end I got a Saltarelle Epsilon which fitted the bill wonderfully
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: Fionn on September 21, 2026, 09:44:23 PM
I once saw a fella at an Irish session playing a tiny little Cairdín, which sounded great. I came away thinking I'd be tempted if I ever saw one going secondhand.
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: Ross Dubois on September 22, 2026, 02:54:28 AM
I once saw a fella at an Irish session playing a tiny little Cairdín, which sounded great. I came away thinking I'd be tempted if I ever saw one going secondhand.

The Cairdin mini is a great box, powerful but very clear, if that makes any sense. I know a guy that's selling one in Ireland if that's of interest. It's a 2 voice C#/D

I like the 3 voice mini deluxe most, but they rarely come up second hand.
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: Theo on September 22, 2026, 10:39:24 AM
A friend of mine has a C#D Cairdin mini that he likes so much that he has made a copy in BC.
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: Fionn on September 22, 2026, 12:27:10 PM
Quote from: Ross Dubois link=topic=32620.msg372022#msg372022
The Cairdin mini is a great box, powerful but very clear, if that makes any sense. I know a guy that's selling one in Ireland if that's of interest. It's a 2 voice C#/D.

Be glad of a DM with the details if you don't mind! I suspect it'll be beyond my budget, but it's worth asking at least.
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: Gena Crisman on September 22, 2026, 03:07:30 PM
There's another model like that from Hohner too, but I can't quite recall the name

One suspects the Hohner Cornelia. eg the one John Spiers has: https://youtu.be/yXbvhw5EGO4

Small boxes are spicy in a way bigger instruments just aren't. I rarely have interest in playing big instruments just because they don't feel like they're fun to play. It kinda just is there, or, it isn't, and you know almost right away when working on a tune. It's kinda silly really, and hard to gauge, too, since 'compact' can mean very different things to different people. But just gotta get hands on sometimes and see if an instrument suits!
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: penn on September 23, 2026, 10:54:05 AM
Yes I always come back to small boxes. Here’s a shout for the Benny. It’s 25” across the front (but the keyboard sticks out bit - Ross - does that spoil your definition?)
I’ve had it for 2 or 3 years and I’ve really bonded with it in the past year since I’ve been travelling a lot. It has a very lively sound, I love the key spacing and quick action, it has every note I want, plenty of alternatives in both directions, and I feel I can chuck it around and pump it along the row when I want to do that. Why would I need any other box?
It’s the only box I play these days, (aside from the Lily for morris days out, there no escaping MAD).
Gren
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: hickory-wind on September 23, 2026, 02:04:24 PM
Here is a small Paddy Clancy 2 voice in DG.
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: hickory-wind on September 23, 2026, 02:05:08 PM
Another small Paddy Clancy, this time 3 voice in DG.
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: hickory-wind on September 23, 2026, 02:06:32 PM
John Whelan's Cairdin mini in BC. 5 switches, 3 voice if I recall.
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: hickory-wind on September 23, 2026, 02:11:11 PM
Peter Hyde (Australia) small 2 voice in BC.
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: hickory-wind on September 23, 2026, 02:15:09 PM
Ann (Ma) McNulty's Superior in D.
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: hickory-wind on September 23, 2026, 02:18:47 PM
Ma McNulty's Baldoni Bartoli 6 voice in D.
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: hickory-wind on September 23, 2026, 02:23:02 PM
Pre 1950 Paolo Soprani 3 voice in BbEb

https://youtu.be/8pfgKRzwkBI?si=t4C_e5hMW0Z1Pl_1 (https://youtu.be/8pfgKRzwkBI?si=t4C_e5hMW0Z1Pl_1)
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: hickory-wind on September 23, 2026, 02:30:06 PM
My favorite model of Hohner's Preciosa in BbEb. It had a lovely suede covered case.
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: squeezy on September 23, 2026, 06:28:16 PM
There's another model like that from Hohner too, but I can't quite recall the name

One suspects the Hohner Cornelia. eg the one John Spiers has: https://youtu.be/yXbvhw5EGO4



Possibly ... the Hohner Cornelia I is basically a 3 voice version of the Hohner Lucia.

Alternatively the instrument in question could be the Hohner Pirol, the smaller 24 stradella bass cousin of the Lucia in the tiny continental chromatic accordion family.  There are pictures and comparison of size to a pre-Erica on this old thread https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=17901.0
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: Winston Smith on September 23, 2026, 06:29:36 PM
"Ann (Ma) McNulty's Superior in D."

Nice! What's the extra button, please?
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: Anahata on September 23, 2026, 07:27:12 PM
My Oakwood Model 3 (I think) from about 1995.
21 button treble, another one with a keyboard wider than the main case (24cm / 22cm), amazingly loud for its size and a perfect morris or ceilidh box.
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: hickory-wind on September 24, 2026, 01:56:57 AM
"Ann (Ma) McNulty's Superior in D."

Nice! What's the extra button, please?

Looks like it's extended at the lower range (forth button start instead of third) after studying this video of Colm Gannon expertly playing it.

https://youtu.be/wZmkHejGsoU?si=jR3cbJzXUvFoHsVn (https://youtu.be/wZmkHejGsoU?si=jR3cbJzXUvFoHsVn)
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: mselic on September 25, 2026, 03:43:58 PM
My main box these days is a compact, custom 2v Dancemaster (Michael Usui) C#/D with Ciccarelli Bombate A-Mano reeds.  The casework was made for him in Italy and then he did the rest.  The reeds are outstanding and the response of them, and the overall playability of the box, is unmatched by anything else I've tried to date.  24cm length x 15 cm wide and 30cm tall (it stands tall but the other dimensions are compact in comparison).  I've never seen another example of this casework, although if you go to Michael's (likely inactive) Dancemaster facebook page, you'll see the same box as the profile picture.  I've had this box in sessions alongside Castagnaris, Cairdins and Gaillards, and I felt none compared to this one (IMHO).  I feel very lucky indeed to have acquired it!

I used to own a Cairdin Mini in C#/D as well.  In fact, it now belongs to a fella in Ireland who's selling it (along with much of his other collection) and I wouldn't be surprised if it's the same one Ross mentioned.  The Cairdin was nice but I found the narrow bass end, with button side angled inwards, rather awkward to hold.  It also needed a lot of work to correct what I felt were some substantial design flaws, some of which I had written about on the forum.  It had Antonelli A-Mano reeds, but I found that the box still took more effort to play (and be heard in a session) than I liked.

One thing that I've noticed with more compact boxes - you have less air to work with!  If you're using a lot of sustained bass notes, you'll run out of room quicker than with a box that's Corso or Nuage sized.  Playing technique obviously comes in to play here but it's one potential drawback of compact boxes.
Title: Re: Small Accordion Appreciation Thread
Post by: mselic on September 25, 2026, 03:48:36 PM
I'll also add that, unlike many compact boxes, both my former Cairdin Mini and current Dancemaster have full bass configurations with Low bass reeds.  On the Cairdin Mini it was actually an issue since they're usually not made with low bass notes, and the inclusion of them in my case resulted in reed tongues bouncing off each other due to lack of clearance.  I later corrected the issue.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal