Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: mselic on October 07, 2026, 05:20:41 PM

Title: Curved/warped aluminum soundboard
Post by: mselic on October 07, 2026, 05:20:41 PM
I have in the shop a client's old 4v Paolo.  The aluminum soundboard has a substantial curve/warp to it, something I've commonly seen in wooden soundboards but not aluminum.  The pallets are leaking air and could be refaced, however I'm wondering if doing this may actually exacerbate the problem since the old pallets have 'taken up the slack' somewhat by matching the curve of the fondo to some degree.  You can see from the photo of one of the original pallets that the outer edges of the felt are thicker and the centre more compressed. The plastic pallets themselves actually have a bit of a curve to them, and I'm uncertain if that's occurred over time or if it's by design (since the underside of the plastic pallets have a small area where the rubber 'arm' from above pokes through ever so slightly).  One option might be to brush the felt on either end of the pallets, either on the old material or on new material if it gets replaced, to help 'take up the slack' even more.  These lever arms are also of the type with the rubber arm which shifts slightly to help the pallet sit as flat as possible on the soundboard.

I'm open to suggestions...
Title: Re: Curved/warped aluminum soundboard
Post by: Theo on October 07, 2026, 05:54:29 PM
That is a serious warp. I would also be concerned about air leaking under the reed blocks. 
Title: Re: Curved/warped aluminum soundboard
Post by: robotmay on October 07, 2026, 08:16:05 PM
Wow, did someone use it as a step stool? That's a pretty dramatic curve. I would imagine you'd be risking damaging the cabinet if you try and push it back into flatness. You could possibly apply a thin piece of wood over the top of the holes after sanding its back side to fit the curve and have the palettes strike that, but that seems like a lot of work and you'd have to get all the holes perfectly aligned. If it was my own box I'd probably try and straighten it out but I'd be apprehensive with a customer one.
Title: Re: Curved/warped aluminum soundboard
Post by: Theo on October 07, 2026, 10:16:12 PM
Or possibly even get a new fond with registers from Carini and graft it in. I’ve just done a fondo graft so I know it’s possible, but does require careful planning.
Title: Re: Curved/warped aluminum soundboard
Post by: -Y- on October 07, 2026, 10:45:13 PM
Is the fondo warped behind each row of pallets? Maybe the area that covers each set of 4 holes is 'flat' enough?
You could try changing the felt on two pallets (one for each row) and testing with other holes closed with tape to check whether or not you can have a good enough air tightness?
Title: Re: Curved/warped aluminum soundboard
Post by: Fionn on October 08, 2026, 12:54:38 PM
Is it possible it was a manufacturing fault, and it's always been like that?

Aluminium could warp if it was screwed down too hard or if a wooden casing shrank substantially, but neither of those seem to be the problem. And even with the curve, it still seems to fit snugly into the casing rather than being fractionally short.

If it was always like that, maybe the leaks are more due to normal ageing factors than the strange shape.

Title: Re: Curved/warped aluminum soundboard
Post by: mselic on October 08, 2026, 04:29:13 PM
Is the fondo warped behind each row of pallets? Maybe the area that covers each set of 4 holes is 'flat' enough?
You could try changing the felt on two pallets (one for each row) and testing with other holes closed with tape to check whether or not you can have a good enough air tightness?

Surprisingly, the pallets seem to sit in such a way that all 4 holes are covered, at least as far as the eye can see (with a couple of exceptions, which were the pallets that someone else had attempted to resurface but which they had done poorly).  However, it does look like there are areas of the pallets (usually front or back, or both) that have less compression than where the pallet arm sits, which I suspect is at least in part due to the warping of the soundboard.  It is from these areas that there tends to be leakage.  Strengthening button tensions would help mitigate some of that, but it already takes 120g of pressure to begin to lower the button, and the client likes the feel and action of the keyboard as it currently is.  A colleague in Ireland with plenty of experience overhauling Paolos has suggested I remove the pallets and 'brush' the felt to give it a bit more volume in the front/back areas to help pick up some of that slack.  The client has agreed that would be the best next step, given that I strongly suspect replacing all the pallet facings will not make much of a difference, and in some cases may even make things worse.  This instrument has had a rough life, but it does play and sound beautifully apart from the air loss.
Title: Re: Curved/warped aluminum soundboard
Post by: Theo on October 08, 2026, 04:56:03 PM
I’ve occasionally seen long 4v pallets where there is a little packing  under the felt at either end of the pallet.  This approach might allow you to get a better seal at the ends of the leaking pallets.  You could test this out by using a scalpel to make a cut in the existing felt and insert a suitable piece of packing material eg, paper, card or veneer.
Title: Re: Curved/warped aluminum soundboard
Post by: mselic on October 08, 2026, 07:41:19 PM
I’ve occasionally seen long 4v pallets where there is a little packing  under the felt at either end of the pallet.  This approach might allow you to get a better seal at the ends of the leaking pallets.  You could test this out by using a scalpel to make a cut in the existing felt and insert a suitable piece of packing material eg, paper, card or veneer.

Theo, a trial run of this on a few pallets has yielded promising results. Brushing up the felt on the old facings did nothing. I think we may be onto something here…
Title: Re: Curved/warped aluminum soundboard
Post by: folkloristmark on October 09, 2026, 11:57:38 AM
I have this if you want it gratis from france
Title: Re: Curved/warped aluminum soundboard
Post by: pgroff on October 10, 2026, 11:02:14 PM
I remember seeing this caused (reversibly) by reedblocks that were clamped too tightly. If the warp persists when you remove the reedblocks, then full speed ahead with one of the other solutions already recommended
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal