Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: anotherboxplayer on January 06, 2010, 09:11:00 PM
-
What are the differences between the small hohner preciosa and lilliput? I never know which i am looking at!
-
The Liliput is small, the Preciosa is even smaller! They are marked with the name, though it does tend to wear off, especially from Liliputs.
-
Theo, didn't you say the Liliput has conventional treble reed blocks? I looked in the Preciosa and the treble reeds are laid flat with a third bank layered over he first two (the air flow being through holes between the main two blocks).
Do they have a different sound? Cajun makers always claim that flat mounted reeds have more attack...
Yes, I will confirm by phone - I want my preciosa rebuilt please! More important than spending money on luxury items - food, taxes, etc. C/F or D/G, hmmm?
Rob.
-
Yes the Liliput has conventional reedblocks, the Preciosa has the treble reeds laid flat, and yes it makes a big difference to the sound. The sound has a different character, and there is possibly more volume if you play hard, and more immediate. I try to avoid attack, punch, bite, in describing the sound of musical instruments! They sound more like a fight :o than making music. 8)
-
I try to avoid attack, punch, bite, in describing the sound of musical instruments! They sound more like a fight :o than making music. 8)
You must have heard me playing! Wow, Theo's in Geordieland and I'm in Blazingsmoke - no wonder Rees says I play too loud.
Rob.
-
thanks rob and theo - just what i needed to know! now to find a preciosa!!
-
to me the basses on a Preciosa are the sweetest on any box I've played. I think there is a reason but i've forgotten what it is
-
Here are photos of my two boxes. Both have been breathed on by Theo.
The Liliput is still in CF club, and has a lovely mellow sound. The club layout is proving useful for cross row playing in C.
The Preciosa is a stunning instrument - in DG (4th button start) - and suprisingly loud.
Peter
-
Here are photos of my two boxes. Both have been breathed on by Theo.
The Liliput is still in CF club, and has a lovely mellow sound. The club layout is proving useful for cross row playing in C.
The Preciosa is a stunning instrument - in DG (4th button start) - and suprisingly loud.
Peter
These are both Lilliputs.
-
These are both Lilliputs.
That is a very bold statement, what are your grounds for saying that?
-
These are both Lilliputs.
That is a very bold statement, what are your grounds for saying that?
My apologies, bad eyes. I didn't enlarge the photo.
-
The Liliput is small, the Preciosa is even smaller! They are marked with the name, though it does tend to wear off, especially from Liliputs.
If there are no bellows straps it's a Preciosa, these have an internal bellows lock so you can fit them into an even more ludicrously small case (or rucksack) without the straps catching and coming undone. Very popular with Hitler Youth who loved to go a-wandering along the mountain track, so I've been told :-)
Ian
P.S. I think some later Preciosas did have straps, maybe the bellows lock was a pain to get/keep working. It certainly causes some confusion with people who don't know about this when they pick one up and try to play it...
-
The Liliput is still in CF club ...
The Preciosa is a stunning instrument - in DG
You must be very happy with these accordions. Since I saw Bill Farmer's video when playing his Liliput in C/F, this is the accordion (a restored and overhauled one, of course) I'm after, too.
It would be interesting to know how many Liliput owners are here.
What about a Liliput Fan Club?
Who owns the most Liliputs (Preciosa included)? Peter has two. Who has three?
Miki
-
I have just the one, a Lilliput in CF, Club of course. :||:
-
It would be interesting to know how many Liliput owners are here.
What about a Liliput Fan Club?
Who owns the most Liliputs (Preciosa included)? Peter has two. Who has three?
Liliputs and Preciosas seem to be also quite popular on german ebay
I have never seen one to be sold for less than €100
-
If there are no bellows straps it's a Preciosa, these have an internal bellows lock ... Ian
P.S. I think some later Preciosas did have straps, maybe the bellows lock was a pain to get/keep working. It certainly causes some confusion with people who don't know about this when they pick one up and try to play it...
My Preciosa is a different style from the one in Peter's photos (see TOTM vid), and it does have bellows straps - slim one's made of a metal-link material.
Diane
-
Very popular with Hitler Youth who loved to go a-wandering along the mountain track, so I've been told :-)
Ian
[/quote]
Tomorrow Belongs to Me...
-
It would be interesting to know how many Liliput owners are here
I bought a Bb/Eb from Mike Wild a year or so ago. Its a lovely key, rich and mellow. It goes on holiday with me when the 3 row 18 bass won't fit in the car. Needs a bit of a Theo makeover now, but of all the Hohner Clubs I've played or owned it is the best by far. I want one in G/C, A/D, C/F and D/G.........
Interesting how modern makers (Castagnari, Loffet etc) have gone down the single voice line for mini melodeons. Is there anyone building anything like a Lilliput these days?
-
I have a C/F Lilliput that is 'de-clubbed' on the treble side. It is surprisingly easy to adapt to the different button spacing. It was in very good condition. Just needed tuning and a few valves replaced. I think the fact that it was originally sold with a nice little case helped to keep away the ravages of time to some degree.
-
I have a Lilliput which Theo declubbed and converted to D/G 4th button a couple of years ago. Brilliant box and tends to be the first one I pick up.
Also recently bought a Preciosa from ebay germany, and now saving the pennies for its 70 year service!
Andy
-
Lilliput ... Brilliant box and tends to be the first one I pick up.
-
Lilliput ... Brilliant box and tends to be the first one I pick up.
A litter of Lilliputs!
-
Miklos - what a marvellous picture.
I have only recently realised that there are two "shapes" of Liliput - the very square one which seems most prevalent, and the more rounded one.
I note the one red instrument amongst many purple/grey - I recall many years ago seeing a green Liliput in Jimmy Shand Junior's collection. I tried to buy it but he said he was keeping it for the accordion museum he was planning to set up one day.
The Liliput only gets a one line mention in "the Hohner table" - built between 1935 and 1940. Anybody have any more details on the history of this wonderful instrument? How many made, what variants, etc?
-
Just in case some followers of this thread are not aware of the parallel "Whats special about them [Liliputs]" http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4357.0.html thread I thought it worth repeating here the message I just left there:
The sound samples on Mike Rowbotham's website http://www.michaelrowbotham.eclipse.co.uk/melodeons.html
really show up the different sound of the Liliput (bottom left instrument) and the Preciosa (bottom right).
-
My latest research into Liliputs has unearthed this really informative thread from the old melnet - http://melodeon.aimoo.com/General-queries-and-info/Hohner-Lilliput-1-600232.html (sorry if you are all already aware of all of this, but as a newcomer I am finding the melnets (new and old) an incredible source of information).
I was especially pleased to find a reference (Whomper, 17/6/05) to an online book all about the Club accordion system on this webpage - http://www.delaguerre.com/delaguerre/.
By the way, if searching for Liliput it is worth also searching for "Lilliput", a common mis-spelling of the Hohner name.
-
Miklos - what a marvellous picture.
I have only recently realised that there are two "shapes" of Liliput - the very square one which seems most prevalent, and the more rounded one.
here's 2 more; it appears that the circular grill is common to the rounded body.
does anyone know of a reed manufacture (source/supply) making reed blocks of the 14mm width, similar to those of Liliputs?
-
does anyone know of a reed manufacture (source/supply) making reed blocks of the 14mm width, similar to those of Liliputs?
I have asked the people at Cagnoni, who I buy reeds from, if they could make reeds with 14mm wide plates, they said no. The spacing between the reed tongues in these small plate reeds is the same as on standard with Hohner reed plates, so it is possible to reduce the width of Hohner reeds to fit in the smaller boxes. The reed tongues are also shorter for any given pitch, so its also sometimes necessary to reprofile the reed tongue of such replacements. I've filed down reedplates to make the occasional spare reed and it works, but its a laborious process.
-
[/quote]
here's 2 more; it appears that the circular grill is common to the rounded body.
does anyone know of a reed manufacture (source/supply) making reed blocks of the 14mm width, similar to those of Liliputs?
[/quote]
Definitely prefer the square shape. Anyone know if the quality or sound of the box changed with the changed shape?
-
Well, I'm getting excited now - Theo says my Preciosa is nearly ready! It's a red/mauve celluloid with a matching rounded grille. Not the prettiest by far, but when it's done I'll try to sort out some pics and maybe a soundbite.
Rob.
-
Well, I'm getting excited now - Theo says my Preciosa is nearly ready! It's a red/mauve celluloid with a matching rounded grille. Not the prettiest by far, but when it's done I'll try to sort out some pics and maybe a soundbite.
Rob.
I didn't realise that the preciosa came in red (:) Lucky devil anyway :P
-
Well, here's Theo beta testing at the Tap and Spile, Hexham. It's retuned to DG, but to soothe any Club purists, most wouldn't have attempted to rebuild it - half the bass reeds were missing and they were all attached with RTV sealant (ouch!). The bellows were completely shot and the tuning was beyond sufferance.
http://s780.photobucket.com/albums/yy87/rob2hook/?action=view¤t=Theo.jpg (http://s780.photobucket.com/albums/yy87/rob2hook/?action=view¤t=Theo.jpg)
Rob.
-
Ah, it's one of the later ones without the metal grill. Very nice (:) Oh, and nice boat as well ;)
-
Knew you'd like it, Ukebert. The box was a wreck from ebay.de a few years back - been sitting in a cupboard since. The boat is more local to you, built by a company that was registered in Tiptree! The original builders had worked mostly in Maldon.
Rob.
-
The Preciosa.
Well, Theo has done his magic and I've just "wasted" a whole afternoon playing it. Actually the LH strap is so tight I couldn't get it off! ;D Now it's been cleaned up, I realise it's imitation dark wood in colour (lighter streaks for the grain). It has a very distinctive tone that I guess you'll either love or hate, with loads of higher harmonics making it very bright and penetrating. The basses are unsurprisingly lightweight although loud and the chords are an octave above most boxes.
It happens I'll be out tonight with another Morris side, so first opportunity to show it off...
Rob.
-
Enjoy it!
The distinctive Preciosa sound really cuts through. Your sound will not be lost, even if you are surrounded by a myriad of other boxes in a morris band!
Andy