Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Tunes => ABC => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on October 13, 2026, 02:31:13 PM
-
Hi All,
I am trying to replicate a tune as per the tunebook.
It has two parallel tunes, one I presume is melody, the other a harmony line or counter melody.
I've discovered for the first time that:-
line one is given by using V: as in V:1
second line line V:2.
All good, it replicates it as per the tune book for the first line/harmony, but then on the second pair of lines I run into trouble.
The second two lines are this
[V:1]zgeg|zafa|zfdf|zgeg|zc'ge|zafd|zefd|ccc2:|
[V:2]ezz|fzz|dzz|ezz|czz|dzz|c2eG|EEE2:|
The V:2 is complete, but the last bit of the V:1 line ( fd|ccc2:| ) ends up below the V:2 line.
I've tried the V: without square brackets and the text below it, and as here, in brackets with the text beside it but both present this incomplete first line.
It seems that if I try and ignore this and go onto the third set of paired lines they too now are out of sync and it's becoming an unusable mess.
Any ideas peeps?
thanks for looking.
-
This doesn't make much sense.
V:1 has four notes in each bar.
V:2 has only three notes in each bar except for the final two bars, which have four.
The rendering that you describe is correct according to what you have written, but lacks musical coherence.
Perhaps if you post a scan of the lines you are transcribing we can find a way forward.
-
This is most likely what was intended:
X:0
M:2/4
L:1/8
K:C
[V:1]zgeg|zafa|zfdf|zgeg|zc'ge|zafd|zefd|ccc2:|
[V:2]ezz2|fzz2|dzz2|ezz2|czz2|dzz2|c2eG|EEE2:|
(1) I had to put in some headers to make my ABC renderer work. Your note values may be different.
(2) I made a z into a z2 in each bar to make the lengths add up i.e. exactly 4 quavers per bar
In general, when you create multiple parts in ABC like this, the sum of note and rest values must exactly match in every bar.
Paste the abc ABC into http://maryanahata.co.uk/abcviewer to see it rendered the same way I'm seeing it
-
Ah.... thanks Anahata.
Yes your tweak renders it as it should be.
I did read in my abc guide that the two lines should be equal but was't sure what that meant exactly. It's my first use of two voices using V: so it's a bit of an adventure for me.
I have noted that whilst transcribing some tunes from the book, the note lengths within the bar hasn't always been correct.
This is another example of it where my accurately notated from the book 'ezz' doesn't make sense and add up to the note lengths, as Mike says!
Thanks!
Every day is a learning day... (:)