Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: codger on October 28, 2026, 02:12:41 AM
-
Hi, Just had the felts and leathers replaced on my 2 row 2000 cairdin. The buttons are slightly higher now than original which, initially, I thought would be ok but I have noticed that there is a considerable difference between the two rows which effects the smooth cross row action I was used to. Do makers use a different (thicker) felt and leather on the outside row to achieve the smooth action that I am used to??? Any help/suggestions would be appreciated. Thanks
-
I recommend you talk to the technician who did the work for you. Speaking as an experienced repairer I always want to know if my client is not completely happy with my work so I have the opportunity to put things right. Any competent repairer should feel the same.
-
Normally the felt/leather thickness is the same for all rows. Consistent button height is achieved through action adjustment. Readjusting button height as/if necessary is part of the process when replacing felt/leathers.
See this video by Lester Bailey on refacing treble pallets on a Hohner. At about 13:00, he says ''Now the tricky bit'' (!) and readjusts the buttons. The exact method may be different on another brand of melodeon but the principle remains the same.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g7nVDIXF3qc&list=PLDoaFL1pYKYqVmiUYp7PPU7JJYsYo34f1&index=2&t=994s (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g7nVDIXF3qc&list=PLDoaFL1pYKYqVmiUYp7PPU7JJYsYo34f1&index=2&t=994s)
-
Thanks for the replies. Without going into all the intricacies of the situation, however, my question still remains the same.
Do makers use a different (thicker) felt and leather on the outside row to achieve the smooth action???
As in, not having to bend metal levers to achieve the desired action by using different thickness of felt/leather pads on the outside row.
-
I’ve never seen different thicknesses of pallet facing between two rows of the same instrument.
What have seen is different thicknesses of felt in the back of the keyboard. This is a common methods to adjust how far down the buttons travel. It doesn’t alter the height of the button before its pressed.
-
"As in, not having to bend metal levers to achieve the desired action by using different thickness of felt/leather pads on the outside row."
It would seem that the metal (or wooden) levers are manufactured to allow the same (or perhaps the correct) lift on each row with the same thickness of of pallet facing on all of the pallets. The only reason that the levers are further 'adjusted', would be to change the button height after fitting a thicker/thinner pallet facing, or to suit the preferences of a particular player.
-
The buttons are slightly higher now than original
This is what worries me, I would take it back and get it corrected.
I have a Salterelle Bouebe BC, the button height and shape is just right. I tried a Castagnari Dinn 11 and found it difficult to play, buttons too high, couldn't slide when needed and the buttons had square edges compared to the Salterelle.
-
There are usually adjustments made to the levers to get the correct button height when the instrument is being built - you can usually see the 'crimping' marks along the top (or bottom) of the aluminum lever arms on the length that goes from the axle to the button. I have likewise made similar adjustments to the lever arms when I wish to lower (or sometimes raise) the button height. However, if a repair person is changing the pallet leather/felt, they would generally replace with material the same thickness as what was there before to avoid having to reset button height (unless you're replacing the overly-thin material that Hohner often used). If your button height is now different since having the pallets re-faced, the person who did the work did not do or finish the job properly.
In answer to your question, different thicknesses of felt/leather facings would not be used between different rows, no. The metal levers are adjusted as required during the building process to get the buttons sitting at the same height.
-
The refacing job is made a lot easier if the same felt thickness as original is fitted, otherwise the buttons need levelling (which it sounds like did not happen in the case of the OP). On the case of old Pokerworks, they were fitted with skins but no felt sandwich, and I normally just replace that, rather than mess around with thicker felt/leather. If you add thickness to the facing it basically screws the geometry and you are into key levelling. This can get quite tricky on a PA..so i work on the basis that if a single skin on the facing was good enough when it was manufactured..then it's good enough as a replacement.