Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Tunes => Topic started by: Michael Eskin on November 03, 2026, 11:45:52 PM

Title: 3 polkas and 2 slides I learned from Dónal Murphy at the O'Flaherty retreat
Post by: Michael Eskin on November 03, 2026, 11:45:52 PM
Three polkas and two slides I learned from Dónal Murphy at the O'Flaherty retreat:

https://michaeleskin.com/tools/abc-irish-box-fingering-player.html?def=eJy1U-9r2zAQ_a6_4mCUfBmolsIIggbkxDalDVvbwQqjHzTp3HpJ7GJnY4P743dy0uVnYftQCDn73unp7t3zvUnEZzNz3QrbDj41i7mDd4m4NokciZlRcihu-Hl4kahzcWWm4uxsdjm9hOe2eWzdElTykvmGbgUfhjA6j_976W7VVvUjlMtyuZt-_rHokCvJTHPILdkAwcsgCQOkBaUWrCxkLjNJYluhemBC2RSmyhCfzvg9pwwBPQVkAvApRSKUpQRUJE5WJGBV_BniUOQZPQhxf0oO9aocNjTt2yhixyn4QOgAx4E8959KLymkUKQkjlCWi8fRWT_LkKIqG_AVhq_0kBg4qmEeOzQ9zEQnbmG9MnWo1OCvVPp1qd5KpxwyNoMGRyU3yhvHOCZ7JPUyZefYdUEOdr8igegjFRXjB6d60coxQukINXiuohKBx6Z0CCQ8qxFNNIHsBJFb-6in3MoDWbVArOHj4LZq2uDqQSduDXSLKiBrBIlira45crgxoOXoItFRLbDL6le0top7s9DHzBJu3gsNuSrY2Ad4Asg9B8-tau6kiD3tZnidvTf0OstjqvCfpD4ckur1wCoOfMXr6qAp4Qrb9reYGJhVc4Q736xW7-HuybVNHUNdNzW_r_AnwpfKz5_c8p-Vcd_5qyPjuXvuMld9p7SOHlLNW2CH78FQxilUNMVGmrSfYifjkaVx7CPFFlC8X00bisiot5greyxetT26hyrs4ZezR92UtHcz6_cHXbyCxg&tuning=bc
Title: Re: 3 polkas and 2 slides I learned from Dónal Murphy at the O'Flaherty retreat
Post by: CAB on November 04, 2026, 12:10:00 AM
The first polka looks a lot like La Russe:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SyVtA9ftJ5U (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SyVtA9ftJ5U)
Title: Re: 3 polkas and 2 slides I learned from Dónal Murphy at the O'Flaherty retreat
Post by: Michael Eskin on November 04, 2026, 12:20:10 AM
Definitely the same tune! 

Dónal just generically referred to the set of three tunes as the "Masters Set". 

He wrote the last tune for his son to commemorate his getting his Masters degree.

I often don't have actual names for individual polkas like I'd have for other styles of tunes.
Title: Re: 3 polkas and 2 slides I learned from Dónal Murphy at the O'Flaherty retreat
Post by: Roger Hare on November 04, 2026, 05:20:35 AM
To my tin ear, that 2nd polka sounds a bit like either Cronin's Kitchen or John with the
Light Brown Hair
? Both are in Bill Black's Irish Traditional Tune Library - the 1st from
Ceol Rince na hEireann', Vol. 2, the 2nd from the the Roche Collection, Vol. 2?

The 1st is also listed as 'unknown', so I dunno where the title Cronin's Kitchen came
from...

I always have some difficulty deciding if two tunes are 'the same'... :(
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal