Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: strad on January 09, 2010, 12:25:01 PM
-
What are peoples thoughts on the morality of MAD? I can understand having boxes in different keys but surely acquiring e.g a load of Paolo Sopranis all in the same key is removing the availability of those boxes from those who might want to get a decent box as they become more proficient in their playing?
Heading back to my kennel
Nigel
-
For me, the real sin is buying things just to look at them, not only taking a perfectly good instrument out of circulation and out of the hands of someone who's going to play it properly but also pushing prices out of the reach of most musicians and setting the scene for people buying instruments as investments, inflating the price further still.
I think it's sad that so many fine musical instruments are being hoarded away to satisfy somebody's need to have something for the sake of it. When I heard about that Strad in the Ashmolean that the donor specified could not be played under any circumstances it actually made me angry.
-
Hmmm...interesting thought this. Not a question of 'morality' really. I mean it's not like Melodeons are like air or water or food, so no there's moral conflict concerning their acquisition in general terms.
The greater problem from my perspective is the answer to the question 'why'. If the basis of MAD is simply driven by greed then that is, in my opinion, immoral - indeed, it's a deadly sin. On the other hand a collector of old grey Paolo's could be such because of the pleasure each unique instrument brings to the collector. In which case it's not greed that drives MAD and therefore far less likely to be immoral. If it's to show off - to be ostentatious about one's collection - then in my book that's simply immoral. If its a collection driven by the desire to research, understand and share knowledge, about a particular kind of instrument then I would say that is a praiseworthy endeavour.
Having said the above I have to say that I don't know any collectors for whom I would term their collection 'immoral'. Most collections are borne out of a desire to appreciate the finer nuances of their subject and real passion and love for a particular thing. None of which I would consider to immoral.
However, I do wish boxes were not so expensive.
AL
-
I've been slightly ashamed of my 6 for a while, (although my little Lilli will never be sold, while I'm still drawing breath). I made a sea change move into 3-row playing over the past 5 years and it took nearly 3 of those to get delivery from Gaillard. My now rarely played C/F is on sale here and had a couple of offers. I plan to sell my interim G/C next now BG has art last delivered. My concertina went to a good home in 2004.
So yes, it is probably wrong to hoard instrumnents you don't play. This was IMHO particulary true of my antique Wheatstone concertina.
-
Being a recent "victim" of MAD and having a virulent case that led to 5 boxes in a years time I figure I should comment. While many of these boxes may be bought out of "covetousness or great desire to have a thing no matter what", there is some morality in one restoring the box and eventually passing it on to another player. I'd have to say that every box I've bought so far needed at least some small amount of restoring and I'm in that process. I now have placed my Primatona on Ebay last night simply because I only rarely play it. Of course the night before I purchased another nice old box to restore and that's why I am selling the Primatona. Yes I may never learn to play that Bb Eb Lilliput that I bought a few weeks ago but if I don't I'll eventually let it go.
My feelings would be that if your not restoring it or playing it or exhibiting it for others to see and learn from then yes maybe there is a bit of selfishness involved. If your accumulating rooms full of Melodeons and Accordions simply because you can, then maybe that's more a mental illness than a immoral act.
With me it's the fascination that I've just recently found with the mechanism and the sounds and sheer wonder of the little things! Of course I wouldn't mind if some of the gentleman on this forum would flood the market with some of those wonderful old Paolo's and Walters so I could snap one up for a pittance...I can dream!
-
It might be amoral but the average MAD sufferer does not, I suspect, give a damn about some unfortunate who may be denied becoming a MAD victim!
...think of it as helping society keep the number of Maddies at tolerable levels.... until a cure can be found :P
The non-proliferation of Paolo Sopranis is an associated side benefit ;D
Remember, a melodeon is not just for Xmas :-*
-
I don't object to people owning quite a few instruments or even having nice ones they rarely play but genuinely appreciate. It's people who deliberately "collect" examples of nice instruments and at best play them once a year or take them out to show them off to another collector before carefully putting it back that misuse the instruments and drive prices up. The highly desireable instruments that garner such attention usually do so because they are superb to play and listen to and buying them just so you can say you have one, never playing it and sticking it in a glass case is just wrong. A sales rep from a musical instrument distributor whose father is a fairly well known electric guitar player once told us about how many lovely old acoustic guitars his dad had, (3 figures), and then went on to say how he only actually played a couple and the rest were all in storage. Sad.
...and don't get me started on those w*****s who commission the best makers to use all their skills to craft a fine instrument from the finest materials available for the express purpose of never playing it and sticking it in a glass case. >:(
-
I get MAD when I see an unfamiliar acronym that is not defined anywhere in the text.
I work with a computer nerd that I call "alphabet boy."
Enough with the alphabet soup already!
-
When I heard about that Strad in the Ashmolean that the donor specified could not be played under any circumstances it actually made me angry.
Fair enough in some ways, but what is special about the "Messiah" Stradivari, is that it has more or less NEVER been played. It passed through various people's hands, but has always been kept in "as new" condition.
There are plenty of Strads working hard for their living, and there are a good few, that may well sound crap, that live in strong-boxes for that reason. Although it's a pity in some ways, it seems reasonable that this one instrument (assuming it is genuine!) should be kept in as new condition.
Article here
http://www.fritz-reuter.com/articles/guardian/messiah/lordofthestrings-messiahstrad.htm
(It has, of course, had the "Vuillaume" update to modern neck angle and bass bar etc.)
-
I know far more about the guitar equivalent than I do about the melodeon variety. I don't have much time for collectors - there are people who collect 60's British electric guitars because they are rare - they are rare because they are so unremittingly poor that most were skipped years ago. Interesting old electrics are now no longer available to working musicians and custom shop offerings tend to be rip offs comprising other peoples bad choices.
As far as I am concerned the value of any instrument is in how well it plays for the gig it is intended. It strikes me that there is no melodeon equivalence of the "Gordon Smith" (look it up). The Hohners are the Fenders and the Costallotis are the Gibsons. My current contibution to MAD is one Delicia Popular III and one Hohner Club IIIB - I suppose I can't comment really.
-
Someone suggested Wicky-Wacky-pedia.
I should not have to do research because others are too lazy to spell out something the first time it is mentioned.
-
Someone suggested Wicky-Wacky-pedia.
I should not have to do research because others are too lazy to spell out something the first time it is mentioned.
Dave,
I think you have unfortunately fallen victim of the 'long-standing chums' factor on this forum. The term MAD - Melodeon Acquisition Disorder - was first coined on this forum several years ago in its early days, and the merits (or otherwise) of accumulating several melodeons for various reasons was discussed at length then and on various occasions since. A high proportion of people here will know what MAD stands for and perhaps (wrongly as it turns out) assume that everyone else knows too.
If you look back through past threads you will find many references to MAD. It is not an official term, merely a bit of light-hearted fun, the impact of which comes from the acronym itself and which would be rather spoiled if it had to be spelled out in full every time. Enjoy the forum but don't take everything too seriously.
-
I get MAD when I see an unfamiliar acronym that is not defined anywhere in the text. I work with a computer nerd that I call "alphabet boy." Enough with the alphabet soup already!
Medics are much worse. The words are long and everyone abbreviates. Slightly dangerously they sometimes use the same letters for different things (different specialties) and decoding these on Xray forms can be challenging. I do concur that this group is particularly initial prone and the speed at which TOTMs have been reduced to these startled me. In particular AF always triggers the wrong thoughts in me as it is a standard one professionally. So I'd encourage more use of the forum's ACRONYM tag. Am I the only person using it? Syntax is as below.
[ acronym="take out the spaces to make it work" ]TOTSTMIW[ /acronym ]
Theo - could it perhaps be on the "Post Reply" toolbar? Far more useful than "glow" "shadow" and "travelling M" ???
TR2T - I'd say buying lots of new accordions simply provides work for makers and is morally neutral, economically good. Buying lots of second hand ones pushes up prices, bad for impecunious students wanting their first instrument, but good for the likes of Theo and Rees, also for the economy. Buying antique ones (eg my concerina) and then not playing them is IMHO far more dubious
-
The term MAD - Melodeon Acquisition Disorder - was first coined on this forum several years ago in its early days
The term is also used for other instruments.
Some particularly appropriate versions relate to saxaphones (SAD) and banjos (BAD)!
-
Chris - as a fellow medic I know what you mean, but if I didn’t use acronisms (or initialisms) and had to write everything out in full I would never get home to play one of my three melodeons ;)
Out of interest, what is AF an abbreviation for when talking about melodeons (or have I totally missed the point here?)
Re the original point of the thread, I don't have a moral objection to 'collectors', but I don't understand the drive either(In the same way that I will never understand petrol heads or the pathological sports fans...)
If you want a melodeon in every key so you can play them all as and when necessary that's fine. If they are going to sit on a shelf and not fulfill their original purpose then that’s sad.
In my case I have two D/Gs and a CGF. The 2 1/2 row D/G is quite recent and I now dont play the older 2 row D/G any more. I know I should sell it on to a new good home but I never seem to get round to it - is this a new phenomenon? maybe we should call it 'melodeon inertia' (M.I ???) Anyone else suffer with this affliction?
Matt
-
Out of interest, what is AF an abbreviation for when talking about melodeons (or have I totally missed the point here?)
Ashokan Farewell the current ToTM* following on from LiDL** and StP***
*Tune of The Month
**L'Inconnu de Limoise
***Speed the Plough
-
The 2 1/2 row D/G is quite recent and I now don't play the older 2 row D/G any more. I know I should sell it on to a new good home but I never seem to get round to it - is this a new phenomenon? maybe we should call it 'melodeon inertia' (M.I ???) Anyone else suffer with this affliction?
Always worth having a spare (or four) just in case!
Also sentimental value means I have kept the G 1 row 4 stop I started with (if just a reminder to tell anyone thinking a one row is a good starter instrument that they are wrong) and my first decent melodeon (Castagnari Tommy) although I rarely if ever play it any more.
-
Since my Loffet 3 row came along, I've been wondering about my collection of Clubs. They are not getting played (except the Lillput) and one of them, a Club IV previously owned (or kept for spare parts?!) by Tony Hall is a very fine instrument indeed, beautfully restored by Theo. When the Loffet was away being tuned, it was the Lilliput that got played.
But somehow it seem a big effort to advertise or go through the ebay ritual.
For me its the same with guitars. I had a fine guitar built for me 30 years ago by the Cambridge luthier Robert Welford. I'ver flirted with others but always come back to the Welford. Its my guitar, just as the Loffet is rapdily becoming my accordion.
-
You'll find MAD GAD BAD FAD etc on lots of instrument discussion forums.
"Don't you just hate TLA's?"
::) ;D
(Three Letter Acronyms. Yes, two baited hooks for the pedants there!)
-
'melodeon inertia' (M.I ???) Anyone else suffer with this affliction?
Matt
The thing is that it's hard to part with boxes that you have played in the past, even if you no longer play them, partly because of emotional attachment and partly because you just might want to play them again in the future, and you just know that you will never be able to replace them.
I would say that if you've bought a costalotti and don't get on with it, then move it on, but there's no reason to part with the old pokerworks etc because their value is relatively low and they are probably worth more to you personally than the cash you would get if you sold them.
-
When I heard about that Strad in the Ashmolean that the donor specified could not be played under any circumstances it actually made me angry.
Fair enough in some ways, but what is special about the "Messiah" Stradivari, is that it has more or less NEVER been played. It passed through various people's hands, but has always been kept in "as new" condition.
There are plenty of Strads working hard for their living, and there are a good few, that may well sound crap, that live in strong-boxes for that reason. Although it's a pity in some ways, it seems reasonable that this one instrument (assuming it is genuine!) should be kept in as new condition.
Article here
http://www.fritz-reuter.com/articles/guardian/messiah/lordofthestrings-messiahstrad.htm
(It has, of course, had the "Vuillaume" update to modern neck angle and bass bar etc.)
If it's not being played then it's not fulfilling its purpose as a musical instrument IMHO. Not playing it because it looks fairly new is like covering up a painting to stop the colours from fading or not displaying a sculpture in case it gets damaged. I don't think I'll ever understand the obsession some people have with owning something desireable for no other reason than to own it and religiously preventing any use of it. A few years ago I remember seeing a programme at Christmas called James May's Top Toys where he met a collector of model trains who proudly boasted of his trains, which he went to great lengths to find and spent a great deal on, still in the original boxes, wrapped up in paper, never having been on a track or even removed from the box and never will be...why?.
I don't think there's anything wrong with MAD as manifested in most of us but there is when it goes too far and the reason for acquiring them is simply to acquire them or for the prestige and financial value. Similar to the difference between admiring the object of unrequited love from afar and admiring the object of unrequited love from their back garden through a pair of binoculars...
-
For those of us with MAD how many of your collection do you regularly play, for instance I regularly play my 1 Row, my Erica and my Salterelle l'Elfique?
-
FINALLY, a definition of MAD... "Melodeon Acquisition Disorder".
I see no immorality in buying orphan melodeons and fixing them up to enjoy.
Otherwise, someone else might buy them for decoration and hang them over a fireplace, creating a pool of beeswax on the mantle. That indeed is an accordion crime.
-
"Deficiency" is substituted for "Disorder" elsewhere on his forum.
"Melodeon Abbreviation Degeneration" is perhaps a better definition.
-
I do feel guilt. Not about my banjos--unplayed but basically worthless--but about my concertina and my bassoon. Both are quite lovely instruments but they have far too much emotional value for me to get rid of them. I am about to get rid of a very large book collection, which seriously saddens me, but my office is moving and it is ridiculous to move that many books that I shall never read again. The library and various grad students and a few colleagues will benefit.
-
I'm absolutely gobsmacked - a melodeon has become a collectors item !!!!!!???
Try telling that to other instrument players in your local session, they'll think you've been on the :|glug
-
I'm absolutely gobsmacked - a melodeon has become a collectors item !!!!!!???
Try telling that to other instrument players in your local session, they'll think you've been on the :|glug
To each his own they say! "Gobsmacked" And I thought us southerners in America had some quaint colloquialism's Got to use that one on a daily basis! Love it!
-
"Deficiency" is substituted for "Disorder" elsewhere on his forum.
Doesn't Melodeon Aquisition Deficiency apply to people who aren't buying enough melodeons?
For those of us with MAD how many of your collection do you regularly play, for instance I regularly play my 1 Row, my Erica and my Salterelle l'Elfique?
I've got 6, which probably qualifies me as a sufferer, especially as that will (hopefully) soon be 7.
I never play my D/G pokerwork (my first box), but don't want to get rid of it, and in fact it is currently getting some TLC from Mr Rowbotham of this parish to give it a new lease of life. I don't play my A/D Erica either, but then that was an eBay bargain bought some years ago for a particular purpose, and in fact A/D is such a nice pitch I might get that one refurbished too.
-
For those of us with MAD how many of your collection do you regularly play, for instance I regularly play my 1 Row, my Erica and my Salterelle l'Elfique?
I've owned 18 different boxes ... currently have 11 (wife thinks i only have 8! ;D ) Typically i am playing 4 of them... and play pretty much at least 1 of them every day where possible...
I'm not obsessed ..lol! :|||: :|||: :|||: :|||: :|||:
DTN
-
Why all this talk of guilt?
Obviously I can't play all my boxes at the same time. I have them scattered around the house. At least one is nearby whenever I get the urge to squeeze out a tune.
I have other hobbies as well. What annoys me is people who buy items simply to make a quick profit.
I spent quite a bit of time helping someone repair a radio which I thought they had purchased for their own enjoyment. I asked the person how the radio was working. The answer: "I sold it on e-bay."
They made a substantial profit thanks to my work. I am more careful about wasting my time helping others who are in a hobby just for e-bay-flippin' financial gain.
-
For those of us with MAD how many of your collection do you regularly play, for instance I regularly play my 1 Row, my Erica and my Salterelle l'Elfique?
I play my Corso, my Double Ray and occasionally tinker with the Lilliput, the others: a G/C prewar Erica and a Prewar C/F Club are in convalescence.
-
I think responses to ostentatious displays of MAD, are akin to the way we feel when confronted with any 'vulgar' display of wealth.
If you come from a mindset where it's considered OK to flaunt your material wealth, you'll probably be fairly relaxed about the idea of people acquiring more melodeons than they can possibly hope to play on a regular basis.
On the other hand, if you come from a culture that has difficulty in understanding why a doctor takes home less than a futures trader, whose only function in life might be to gamble, with other people's money, that the price of oil/sugar/wheat/whatever can be forced higher, to the detriment of the rest of society, then I guess you'll feel less than comfortable with the idea of the over-resourced letting their MAD run amok, forcing the price of decent melodeons higher for the rest of us.
I think, for me, it's a question of degree. If I could afford a pristine, top-end 'costalotti', I'd still need something cheaper as well, because I regularly take my instruments afloat, into a pretty hostile environment. I wouldn't dream of playing a 'costalotti' whilst under sail in the Humber Estuary in December, but the Pokerwork seems to have survived its most recent outdoor excursion unscathed.
I wouldn't take a Jeffries Anglo concertina afloat, or camping, but I'm happy to take my Rochelle, or occasionally my Norman C/G Anglo when I go sailing or camping.
I suppose we can all justify our acquisitions in our own ways. For me, it works most comfortably as '1 for best, and 1 for everyday'. Anything else is outrageous MAD which ought to be a certifiable, and punishable by having all of your melodeons seized, and redistributed to the deserving masses (i.e. me).
Simple really.....
-
Since I first got afflicted by all this I have bought and sold dozens of boxes. That was driven by simply wanting to try everything at once. Being an Essex boy I made a few quid on some and lost a bit on others but overall It has given me enormous pleasure for little money without causing anyone else any pain.
Latterly I decided it was old Hohners that really did it for me, not just as musical instruments but as objects which have a story to tell, or at least to speculate about.
Right now I only have a DG Presswood and a DG Preciosa. What surprises me in this thread is that nobody has talked about the sounds different boxes produce, whatever level of ability, or is that stating the obvious. Am I the only one here who sort of gets bored with the sound of one box and thus enjoys playing the same tunes on a different one, albeit in the same key? And some tunes just sound better on a particular box.
Right now I also have a Liliput being retuned to DG and starting off dry tuned, now that really will be different to my other boxes.
-
You'll find MAD GAD BAD FAD etc on lots of instrument discussion forums.
...and also the more generic GAS (Gear Acquisition Syndrome), which is the standard term on basschat.co.uk where I also hang out.
-
Earbrass - big thanks for reminding me about Dr Dream, a much-loved soundtrack from my youth. Musically about as far from the melodeon world as it is possible to get, I suppose.
You're welcome. I suspect "making life easy but making it worse" might reflect the attitude of many melodeonists to the piano accordion. ;D
-
I think the OP is complaining about a situation which doesn't exist. There's no problem with the supply of melodeons. Anyone wanting a better melodeon can simply go to a shop and buy one. To suggest that players are being held back from progressing because they can't obtain a suitable instrument is nonsense.
-
I think the OP is complaining about a situation which doesn't exist. There's no problem with the supply of melodeons. Anyone wanting a better melodeon can simply go to a shop and buy one. To suggest that players are being held back from progressing because they can't obtain a suitable instrument is nonsense.
I was going to say the same thing. There are people who will pay a lot of money for boxes with rarity value like some old Paolos, Oakwoods, etc, but that is inevitable, and as far as I know there is no evidence that these people are not buying them to play (or sell on, albeit at a profit, to someone else to play).
It's still possible for a cash-strapped buyer to pick up a decent box for £200 - £400 if they look around.....how much cheaper than that can we expect them to be? The value of most second-hand melodeons is based on what it would cost to buy one new, and this in turn is based on the cost of manufacture plus foreign exchange rates etc, not on supply and demand.
-
How about ASS?
Acronym Silly Squeezers.
-
I have two, play them both. If I had more, it's also a question of room. I am always trying to lighten up, minalimism can be a great thing, more room and less clutter to enjoy what you do have and use.
-
I only have two (one I'm trying to get rid of because I just want one for best and one that's for taking camping etc. rather than two nice ones.) melodeons and two concertinas. I am limited by space and funds. I tend to stick to 'window shopping'.
-
OK - medical opinion time.
- Two melodeons does not IMO constitute "MAD".
- Three could be prodromal symptoms, but OK if you are selling on.
- Four or more, is time to see the psychiatrist.
(I'd further confide that I've been seeing a psychatrist for some 16 months - that's another story).
-
The term MAD - Melodeon Acquisition Disorder - was first coined on this forum several years ago in its early days
The term is also used for other instruments.
Some particularly appropriate versions relate to saxaphones (SAD) and banjos (BAD)!
Actually on saxophone forums GAS is used rather than SAD.
I feel very strongly that instruments should be played and that it is wrong to deprive others of the joy of playing them. There are occasions when an instrument needs to be behind glass for it's own protection and so can't be played. Fair enough. Even instruments in musical instrument museums should be played regularly imo.
-
It is SAD that most of the instruments that I encounter have been abused over the years.
I am sure that most of you know the results of excessive heat and dampness.
None of my instruments are stored in the attic or the cellar.
The ones that were stored in damp dungeons by previous owners are airing out on the second floor of my house.
As much as I enjoy the results of my efforts, it is a pleasure to find a box that was cared for.
-
To bring in a slightly different viewpoint. My kids are now grown, but when daughers were 5 and 3 we scoured junk shops and purposefully set up a group of musical instuments in my study. By a couple of years we had about 30. Most were junk, but still played (a new brass mouthpiece at £32 cost more than the euphonium and trombone combined). We had bagpipes accordion, concertina, banjo, guitar, brass, clarinette, a rather dubious fiddle, later joined by a gurdy, a cello and grandad's old piano. A harmonium was quite literally 'found' ;) and just fitted in the front door porch. (Guess what sheet music we put on it). Melodeon count in those days was three.
The collection is dissipated now, but my kids were never pused into formal instrument lessons. But what they picked up they coud have a go on. They got lessons when they asked for them. All three play or sing into adult life (ie on stages). I feel it's one bit of parenting we managed to get right.
Sounds like you did get it right :P I've been considering doing the same in the unlikely event that I would be so blessed as to have an opportunity.
-
Sounds like you did get it right :P I've been considering doing the same in the unlikely event that I would be so blessed as to have an opportunity.
Mixed blessing mate - although you love those little ones dearly .. the World's religions have got it wrong. There's no life after birth :|glug
-
the World's religions have got it wrong. There's no life after birth :|glug
crashed and burnt on the morbid shelf of the moral maze - I'll top myself now should I :'(
-
the World's religions have got it wrong. There's no life after birth
Beg to respectfully differ...such philosophoical cynicism was in ancient Greece a quasi-religion all of it's own making - and it seems to me that not much has changed. Life is, of course, pretty much what the individual makes it. I'm experiencing a lot of life at the moment, and I was born 47 years ago. And even you Chris, are experiencing life (again, it's what you make of it). Last week in our homeless hostel in Coventry we suffered two deaths - one a member of staff (also age 47) from 'natural causes' and one a resident who committed suicide by leaping from the top floor of the building. I guess when you see life so tragically snuffed out by needless death, that 'life' becomes even more precious. Also as a father of four beautiful & brilliant children (not that I'm biased at all) I can thoroughly recommend taking a chance on life!
;D
Regards, AL.
-
You never know what true happiness is until your first child is born - and then it's too late!