Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: paulyworly on February 17, 2008, 11:50:36 PM

Title: The Midi Concept
Post by: paulyworly on February 17, 2008, 11:50:36 PM
Hi

There have been a few threads on here about the the use of Midi, especially regarding the Streb.  Obviously this opens up a World of options for players including sounding like other instruments, playing through headphones etc etc.

Midi has been retro-fitted to PAs for years but has anyone ever come across a button box that has both reeds and Midi in the same instrument ?

Do you think it's possible to retrofit Midi to a standard acoustic button box or would that concept have to be designed from scratch into a brand new instrument ??

Just wondered....

Cheers

PaulyWorly
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: Bill Young on February 18, 2008, 08:54:12 AM
Midi has been retro-fitted to PAs for years but has anyone ever come across a button box that has both reeds and Midi in the same instrument ?

Do you think it's possible to retrofit Midi to a standard acoustic button box or would that concept have to be designed from scratch into a brand new instrument ??

There are quite a number of BCC# boxes that have had MIDI retro-fitted: Shand Marino, Hohner Gaelic, Fantini, Guerrini, Paolo Soprani. It should boil down to whether there's enough room in the box for the circuitry "gubbins".
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: Quebecois on February 19, 2008, 02:19:09 PM
The available space is the main issue, as said previously. There are a few systems available, including LIMEX and Roland:
www.johnsaccordionservice.com

I would see a MIDI-only melodeon as a nice option for sliently practicing, but nothing replaces the sounds and feel of reeds. I can't imagine playing a melodeon that sounds like a trumpet or a grand piano!
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: Stiamh on February 19, 2008, 03:19:34 PM
... has anyone ever come across a button box that has both reeds and Midi in the same instrument?

According to an email just sent out to his mailing list, Peter Hyde is now working on the idea of building boxes with both reeds and midi. He's a member here, so you could contact him through the forum for more information.
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: risto on February 21, 2008, 06:41:54 PM

... has anyone ever come across a button box that has both reeds and Midi in the same instrument?

Anyone found suitable midi gear for a DIY midi accordion?
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: Hasse on February 21, 2008, 07:04:33 PM

Anyone found suitable midi gear for a DIY midi accordion?

Well, I don't really know anything about this Swedish company (Bono Electronic) or its products, http://home.swipnet.se/bonotron/acc_uk.htm , but they apparently have some midi stuff for melodeons called: AM-4-D.
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: dahlberg on December 30, 2010, 02:05:05 PM
a friend of mine got a melodeon fitted with a bonotron system. Its quite ok but he chosed not to add bellow sensor,wich is a little boring. Bonotron is also very expensive.
Me and some others are working on a reedless midi melodeon based on Arduino. Instead of taking an existing melodeon i will build the box from scratch. I post a new thread on the forum when it comes to cutting.
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: graememackay on December 31, 2010, 04:40:39 PM
I use midi everyday and am looking now at replacing it with Limex.  I don't think there's anything on the market remotely close to the technology that Limex are using.  They have eliminated the need to use Sound modules, incorporated the option of an integrated microphone system and offer a wireless option too.  The bellow sensors detect direction as well as pressure which is ideal for diatonic boxes and all their sounds are sampled rather than general midi sounds.  Prety much everything is optional extras so every midi fit can be tailored to suit the player.

They do make completly wireless accordions, both piano & button, mainly Steriche Harmonikas as they are an Austrian company.  I'm led to believe 90% of midi'd accordions in Germany use Limex.  Good stuff!

My main reason for choosing their stuff is to reduce my luggage while travelling.  Only one cable and power supply to run all the mics and midi.  At the moment I carry about 10kg worth of mics, sound module and cables.  When flying thats a lot of weight.
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: HallelujahAl on December 31, 2010, 06:30:13 PM
Recently got myself a little Roland Fr-1 PA - and frankly I've been blown away by what it's capable of. Goodness knows what its big brother the Fr-7X is capable of. As Graeme says, the sound is sampled, which means that I have a variety of real accordions on board one small, lightweight, little beastie. Shame they only make PA & CBA versions and not diatonic button box as well. However, I'm sure that Roland could quite easily do it based on what they are currently producing.
This little box is fast becoming my number one box - it's even beginning to take over from my 3 row Hohner Vallenato in F/Bb/Eb as the transpose function on the accordion enables me to play along with my brass ensemble (and any other combo for that matter) very easily indeed. In fact sometimes I cheat and use the transpose function to enable me to play everything in C  :-[
AL
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: TomB-R on January 03, 2011, 09:33:55 PM
....... In fact sometimes I cheat and use the transpose function to enable me to play everything in C  :-[
AL

Well Irving Berlin did it...... :D
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: segi on January 03, 2011, 11:50:37 PM
Just to tell you guys, that I did build a box using a small micro processor and a pressur sensor for the bellows,
and it does work well indeed, What I did is used a on old frontalini completely remove the keyboard and reeds and put some keyboard switches  in, I just scan the keyboard and send midi signal (wirelessely using xbee modules)  I am using linuxsampler to produce the accordion sounds, which I have recorded using a real accordion.  and it does work extremely well
I also have a small keypad to change keys etc...
good luck with your project
The hardest part is to find the proper switch for the buttons...
.
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: jjw on January 04, 2011, 12:44:01 AM

Would you like to post more details of what you did, Segi?  Photos even?  Sounds an interesting project.

best wishes,
  Jerry
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: segi on January 04, 2011, 04:13:58 AM

Would you like to post more details of what you did, Segi?  Photos even?  Sounds an interesting project.

best wishes,
  Jerry

 Here are some photos, will try to make a small mp3 sample tomorrow
regards!
Serge
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: segi on January 04, 2011, 04:16:25 AM

Would you like to post more details of what you did, Segi?  Photos even?  Sounds an interesting project.

best wishes,
  Jerry

 Here are some photos, will try to make a small mp3 sample tomorrow
regards!
Serge

Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: segi on January 04, 2011, 05:47:04 AM

here is a small sample for the midi accordion using linuxsampler as a sampler
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: old geezer on January 04, 2011, 09:33:33 AM
congratulations, with this project, Segi.
oh; and a warm welcome to the forum

The hardest part is to find the proper switch for the buttons...
I was thinking along the lines of leaving the original buttons, levers and pallets, and fitting micro switches to the 'sound board'
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: segi on January 04, 2011, 11:04:07 AM
congratulations, with this project, Segi.
oh; and a warm welcome to the forum

The hardest part is to find the proper switch for the buttons...
I was thinking along the lines of leaving the original buttons, levers and pallets, and fitting micro switches to the 'sound board'
thanks!
yes that can be done also, I have actually done that In my first prototype. 
It is more a mechanical problem, I am sure that they are boxes out there were it can easily be done.  In the first prototype, I had a midi sound module hookup to the small computer board, but I was not pleased with the midi sound generated...
using a software sampler really does improve the quality.
  after a while, i have decided to remove the levers and put switches instead, since this was on old box, the pallets were quite noisy..... also decided to add another row..

regards!
Segi!
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: John Vernon on January 04, 2011, 11:59:40 AM
Hi all you MIDI nuts.
I have built several midi systems  :- Bass English concertina,Hayden Duet concertina,Hohner D/G,PauloSoprani BCC#,3 or 4 CBAs
Several points arise
1. Switches. I have used gold contacts, Infra-red optos and Magnetic Hall-effect sensors.
Many early accordion MIDi systems used gold contacts, they are relatively easy to adjust, but the contact is not all that reliable.
Optos may be affected by sunlight ceeping in and dust, but I have had no problems in 16 years
Magnetic Hall Effect is a little more tricky where space is limited, because one magnet may affect the adjacent sensor, but again I have had no problems in 16 years.
2. Wireless ! I see that the XBee modules have a delay of ~5ms. I thought that this was too much and have stuck to a wired system. I must look at the possible delays in the other wireless MIDI boxes ( Mid-air, Kenton, CME WIDI,... ).
Is this delay an issue SEGI ?
3. Having a instrument which talks MIDI is only the start! Something to produce sound is also required. synthesiser modules are available, but many of the sounds are not that good and getting dynamic range, attack, decay, bellows pressure response etc. etc... just how you want it, is difficult or impossible. I use an EMU Proteus2000 synth - now obsolete- for bass and piano sounds, this has the ability to tweak and adjust almost everything, however it took me three weeks of frustration before I understood how to get "almost" what I wanted out of it.
I have not tried to produce accordion sounds. I kept the reeds for that. However Segi's use of linux sampler looks interesting if you can accept using a computer - not the best things for reliability on the road!

Finally, if you really want to build your own, be prepared for a long haul and plenty of frustration.
John

Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: Owen Woods on January 04, 2011, 12:07:13 PM
This is all very interesting, thanks very much for sharing you two (:)
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: segi on January 04, 2011, 01:32:17 PM
Hi all you MIDI nuts.
I have built several midi systems  :- Bass English concertina,Hayden Duet concertina,Hohner D/G,PauloSoprani BCC#,3 or 4 CBAs
Several points arise
2. Wireless ! I see that the XBee modules have a delay of ~5ms. I thought that this was too much and have stuck to a wired system. I must look at the possible delays in the other wireless MIDI boxes ( Mid-air, Kenton, CME WIDI,... ).
Is this delay an issue SEGI ?

Good day John,
  I do think that 5 ms is quit fast, so I do not think it is an issue for the xbee module,   
 If you look the response (on an oscilloscope) of a read from the time you depress the buttons to the time the sounds come out, it is longer then we think. especially for the low tones.... The base actually comes out faster on my midi-sampler-accordion than a regular accordion

but as you mention,  if you need a reliable sampler better to go with a hardware sampler.   Note that i did this thing mainly for personal use (so that i would not wake up my children when playing)..  I am far away from a production model and I have no intention in doing so,  I just want to share what I did in case people are interested in such things...  I actually did this around 5 years ago,  it took me a summer to get it to work....
I do agree with all your comments...
regards!
Segi
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: Alan Morley on January 05, 2011, 02:05:34 PM
I might upset some Streb users, but I don't like the sound....

They are lovely if you use them to re-produce the sound of other reed instruments, and the key change potential is very useful.

Problem is - for a midi sound to sound right - a guitar must be played like a guitar, a violin must be played like a violin - or it dosen't work..

Might as well  buy a small keyboard...

Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: nemethmik on January 05, 2011, 03:01:02 PM
Recently got myself a little Roland Fr-1 PA - and frankly I've been blown away by what it's capable of.
I got exited reding Al's commet about Roland FR1. Howevere, when I was watching the sample videos on YouTube I was not blown away by the sound of the FR1. Can you give me a link to good quality sound example of the FR1?
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: summerstars on January 05, 2011, 03:03:12 PM
I might upset some Streb users, but I don't like the sound....

Might as well  buy a small keyboard...


But I can't play keyboard (some would say I can't play melodeon either)
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: dahlberg on January 06, 2011, 12:18:29 PM
I will use computer switches,it will not have the same feeling as real buttons but it dosent matter,my goal is the same Segi,to play in the evening whitout wake up the rest of the family.
Stagi:Wich kind of pressure sensor did you use?
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: segi on January 06, 2011, 01:20:28 PM
I will use computer switches,it will not have the same feeling as real buttons but it dosent matter,my goal is the same Segi,to play in the evening whitout wake up the rest of the family.
Stagi:Wich kind of pressure sensor did you use?

Dahlberg,
I am presently at work, I will check this evening to give you the exact part number that I have used
I remember that the first pressure sensor that I bought had too much range..

the one that I am currently using is quit good for the range,  note that bigger bellows means less pressure
but I do not think that would be a big factor if you use the same range that I am currently using

note also that I am using  a table to convert from linear readings to logarithmic output to emulate more closely the accordion

The switches are critical for this I have tried many of them and was not satisfied... I will check that part number also,  (I am quite satisfied with the one that I am currently using), it feels almost the same
Good luck with your project, and do not be afraid to ask questions!
regards!
Segi
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: rmenhinick on January 06, 2011, 04:59:34 PM

... has anyone ever come across a button box that has both reeds and Midi in the same instrument?

Anyone found suitable midi gear for a DIY midi accordion?

This looks promising http://shop.lividinstruments.com/builder.html it is a programmable USB/MIDI controller which supports 16 buttons directly or up to 64 in a simple diode matrix, and comes with supporting software to assign MIDI messages etc. and all for around £200 delivered. They even do buttons which you can put LEDs in so you can light up the keys when you are learning a new tune .. how cool would that be ;D?? (Yeah OK, not cool at all ??? but novel in a Melodeon!!)
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: dahlberg on January 06, 2011, 07:18:05 PM
risto:naaah,arduino is better,cheaper too

stagi:thanx a lot. (:)

as soon as i have all parts i start a building thread so all can take part.

back to topic:Another very good thing about midi is that you can do score sheets very fast,instead of putting out notes one by one you can simply just play,and mayb correct the worst mistakes. Easier also to do add second voices and try out diferent lines.
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: segi on January 06, 2011, 09:00:59 PM

Good day,
for pressure, I am using 5 inch H20 differential

Pressure Sensors, Transducers ±0.18 PSI, ±5" H20 PSI 0.25 ~ 4.25V All Sensors Corporation
5 INCH-D-4V 
DIgi-Key 442-1014-ND.
 
That is the minimum that you can used 1 inch H2O was not enough for my accordion
note that you can probably find something cheaper than that..  I actually bought that in 2006 for 99$ US and they are still pretty expansive today


For the switches I have used Cherry switches...without the keycaps... I just glued some plastic snap buttons that I have found at a local hardware store...


Cherry MX key switch pcb mount CH-160-ND  (DIGIKEY) linear feel


hope this is usefull for you!
regards!
Segi


Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: Squeeze Easy on April 14, 2012, 10:54:22 PM
For anyone interested in trying the LIMEX MIDI SYSTEM for diatonic accordions, a Shand Morino(Diatonic) is available to try at

John Douglas Accordions
Dumfries
www.johndouglasmusic.com             
            01387 256479           

Limex Demo Monday 23rd April 7pm start
Woodland House Hotel, Dumfries
Title: Re: The Midi Concept
Post by: Peter Stormy Hyde on October 03, 2012, 07:53:42 AM
... has anyone ever come across a button box that has both reeds and Midi in the same instrument?

According to an email just sent out to his mailing list, Peter Hyde is now working on the idea of building boxes with both reeds and midi. He's a member here, so you could contact him through the forum for more information.
You were right and I did get there.
The big problem to overcome with a box (diatonic not semi chromatic) that plays both MIDI and reeds at the same time is to be able to take full advantage of the MIDI that can play in any keys, is to be able to cut out all reeds and keep the box playing and feeling like  a real melodeon.

I did achieve this by having a stop on the top of both sides that when pulled it cut out all reeds but then opened another small hole to let a small amount of air through, this is truly the "Air Accordion" and can be played in bed with ear phones while your partner sleeps on. 

Size of box is 280mm x 150mm so it is within a reasonable size and is designed so a MIDI can be retro fitted to it.

The hardest part was getting the stop to cut out all reeds on the bass side whilst opening another hole for the MIDI.
 
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal