Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Sandy on January 11, 2010, 07:29:34 PM
-
Just wondering where the emphasis comes (if any) with the basses when playing a hornpipe. Is it a short or long oom or pah sort of thing ??? I've worked on trying to get a 'crisp' right hand but don't feel comfortable with the Bass punctuation . :|||:
Cheers
Sandy
(:)
-
Hi Sandy
there's an example being much admired right now over on this current thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3286.msg39756.html#msg39756).
Thank you, that is brill 8)
cheers
Sandy
(:)
-
Just wondering where the emphasis comes (if any) with the basses when playing a hornpipe. Is it a short or long oom or pah sort of thing ??? I've worked on trying to get a 'crisp' right hand but don't feel comfortable with the Bass punctuation . :|||:
Cheers
Sandy
(:)
[/quot
short um & long pa! The dancers land on the UM as they are unable to hover & the emphasis on the PA provides the lift to get them up again!. also a hornpipe needs a very steady bass rhythm even though the teble end may seem to be going somewhat speedily.
george
-
Sandy, you have it correct in thinking about the emphasis ie perhaps more helpful than thinking about things in terms of 'oom' and 'pah' (which, as a basic underlying - but not necessarily sounded - rhythm in much of English traditional dance music, has come to be viewed perhaps rather derogatively on here... Many times there is an 'oom', but without an obvious 'pah' - so it's not all stilted and boring, but there is variety within that underlying idiom...).
Whilst I admit to being rubbish at translating written notation into rhythm -I play what I hear - I would have thought that the emphasis ie the longer, or more stressed note in tunes such as 'Sweeps' or 'Gypsy's Hornpipe' (one of my favourites for that 'steady rhythm, provides not played too fast, but with swing!) is on the first beat of the bar, rather than on the second?
Diane
-
Sandy, you have it correct in thinking about the emphasis ie perhaps more helpful than thinking about things in terms of 'oom' and 'pah' (which, as a basic underlying - but not necessarily sounded - rhythm in much of English traditional dance music, has come to be viewed perhaps rather derogatively on here... Many times there is an 'oom', but without an obvious 'pah' - so it's not all stilted and boring, but there is variety within that underlying idiom...).
Whilst I admit to being rubbish at translating written notation into rhythm -I play what I hear - I would have thought that the emphasis ie the longer, or more stressed note in tunes such as 'Sweeps' or 'Gypsy's Hornpipe' (one of my favourites for that 'steady rhythm, provides not played too fast, but with swing!) is on the first beat of the bar, rather than on the second?
Diane
Thank you Diane, I sort of feel an emphasis on the first beat with the odd punched bass just before the end of a phrase. (Sorry I am thinking off my head rather than finding an example). Now feel I am happy anchoring the tune with Bass noted steady rhythm but should I punch the trailing chord or let it sustain a bit ? ???
cheers
Sandy
(:)
-
Just wondering where the emphasis comes (if any) with the basses when playing a hornpipe. Is it a short or long oom or pah sort of thing ??? I've worked on trying to get a 'crisp' right hand but don't feel comfortable with the Bass punctuation . :|||:
Cheers
Sandy
(:)
[/quot
short um & long pa! The dancers land on the UM as they are unable to hover & the emphasis on the PA provides the lift to get them up again!. also a hornpipe needs a very steady bass rhythm even though the teble end may seem to be going somewhat speedily.
george
Thank you George.
I have rarely played for dance so it's difficult for me to interpret in that way. I am def seeing the steady bass rhythm though now.
Cheers
Sandy
(:)
-
Am I so wrong? To me the beaury of this hornpipe was the steadyness of its melody line, played agaist a very fluid left end ???.
Anhata's doing all sorts. He plays, playing swing, push ryhthm, dum(join-chord), chunks, gaps, bass runs .... so surely the opposite of "steady bass rhythm".
And quite exempary in going that.
-
Am I so wrong? To me the beaury of this hornpipe was the steadyness of its melody line, played agaist a very fluid left end ???.
Anhata's doing all sorts. He plays, playing swing, push ryhthm, dum(join-chord), chunks, gaps, bass runs .... so surely the opposite of "steady bass rhythm".
And quite exempary in going that.
I must say that's an amazing example. I still feel an underlying bass emphasis/ pattern which is keeping it steady. (just wouldn't know how to define it) I shall experiment and listen to Anhata a few more times. Maybe I need to stop thinking again, just listen and play. :-\ :|||:
Cheers
Sandy
(:)