Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Quebecois on February 21, 2008, 12:06:25 PM

Title: Position of the hand playing the treble notes
Post by: Quebecois on February 21, 2008, 12:06:25 PM
Just curious to know the people's playing technique!
Title: Re: Position of the hand playing the treble notes
Post by: BruceHenderson on February 21, 2008, 01:22:00 PM
Just curious to know the people's playing technique!

   I voted "other" because I use a thumb-strap on my one-rows, I place my thumb on the side of the buttonboard (no thumb-strap) when playing my two-row, and I use my entire hand -- including playing buttons with my thumb -- when playing my three-row.
BH, NC USA
Title: Re: Position of the hand playing the treble notes
Post by: Lin Leighton on February 21, 2008, 02:20:04 PM
I voted "other" because i put my thumb not on the edge but on the flat bit behind the edge, dont know what its called, but my hand then makes a shape like the letter U.  I tried putting it on the edge but it just didnt work for me.
Lin
Title: Re: Position of the hand playing the treble notes
Post by: Pushpull on February 21, 2008, 02:53:55 PM
Like Lyn, I have my thumb behind the keyboard. I feel my fingers are more relaxed and mobile that way. I do use the thumb strap on my Tommy and 1 row but not on the Pokerwork (broke and didn't get replaced), so the jury's out a bit on the thumb strap. I have 2 straps on the 2 rows and 1 on the 1 row so that's inconsistent too!!

Roy.
Title: Re: Position of the hand playing the treble notes
Post by: Malcolm Austen on February 21, 2008, 03:59:34 PM
I voted other, I am with Lin on this one most of the time I put my thumb behind the key board but for some tunes of parts of tunes it gets up on to the edge. I use one strap on all my melodeons this may have some influence on how I hold them.
Title: Re: Position of the hand playing the treble notes
Post by: Clive Williams on February 21, 2008, 04:30:22 PM
I voted other, I am with Lin on this one most of the time I put my thumb behind the key board but for some tunes of parts of tunes it gets up on to the edge. I use one strap on all my melodeons this may have some influence on how I hold them.

I've added a 'behind the fingerboard' option to the poll - those of you who play like that and have already voted  should be able to change your vote if you wish!

I kind of vary between thumb behind the fingerboard and thumb on the edge myself, more often than not I'm lazy and stick the thumb behind the fingerboard... hmmm, as in my profile pic, I notice. Ah well, life's too short to have perfect technique, eh?

I always play with one strap - never really got on with two straps, and even playing a heavy box standing up, I find it a lot more comfortable to lengthen the strap and stick it over my head 'the wrong way' - this has the effect of locking the treble end in place absolutely solidly, and there's no danger of the strap sliding off the shoulder.

Cheers,

Clive
Title: Re: Position of the hand playing the treble notes
Post by: sCANdanADIAN on February 21, 2008, 05:14:01 PM
 Last spring I freed my thumb from the edge of the keyboard and started to use it to play accidentals,then low notes,then for forming chords,now i use my thumb wherever it's convenient.This was after 15 yrs of playing with my thumb on the edge,I'm never going back.

I hadn't actually watched  this instructional clip until a week ago but Vojko's other video's were my main inspiration to use my thumb. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4FUDMTgkaqw&feature=related

Chris
Title: Re: Position of the hand playing the treble notes
Post by: Quebecois on February 21, 2008, 06:04:38 PM
I am of the "floating hand" kind too, the thumb is indeed useful for those accidentals placed before the low notes.  Also, with five fingers available, why use only 4? Piano and chromatic accordion players use their thumb.

Whatever gets the job done is the best, I suppose!

 
Title: Re: Position of the hand playing the treble notes
Post by: Lin Leighton on February 22, 2008, 02:40:19 PM
well it seems to be a little bit of cross threading here, but since others have mentioned straps, my vote on that one is, I use 1 strap sitting down, 2 straps standing up, and a back strap too when out processing with Morris
Lin
Title: Re: Position of the hand playing the treble notes
Post by: BruceHenderson on February 22, 2008, 03:03:04 PM
__.  Also, there is a difference to the hand placement depending on number of rows.  On my one-rows, I have been working on getting comfortable with playing with the flats of my fingers (as recommended by R. Ouellet and others). This puts the knuckles of my left hand about an inch away from the outer edge of the button board and pretty much on a plane with the front surface of the button board.  With the two row (D/G), I can play the D row that way (to some extent, anyway) but I'm more comfortable playing the G row with some arch to my fingers and touching the buttons with the tips of my fingers (hard to explain but kinda like the part of your finger you touch the buttons on a phone with) -- this results in my entire hand being brought forward (i.e. away from my body) and the knuckle joints are significantly above the plane of the button board.  The three-row (A/D/G) is different again, in that my fingers come towards the buttons even more vertically (if you consider away from the body "up").  With the facility to use my thumb to catch some notes, especially on the outer rows and closer to my chin, that means that my hand is moved even further away from my body; but the oddball part of it is that if I'm just playing a simple tune in G (not a lot of movement up and down the scale, little cross-rowing), I'll often just slip the edge of the button board into the crook of my thumb with my thump lying flat on the back and my fingers arching over two outer rows.

__.  Inconsistent, and probably not the "best" technique but it works for an old, grey-haired, thowed out, retired guy who drives slow.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal