Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Andrew Culwell on January 18, 2010, 05:29:27 AM
-
I've heard mention of varnishing the interior of an accordion to facilitate brighter tone. Is this true? What do they mean when they say "brighter" My assumption would be that the varnish keep sound from being absorbed as the interior wood is porous, varnish would work as sealer and create a louder higher tone? Is this a correct hypothesis or am I reaching?
-
[scientist alert]
I think it's a reasonable hypotheses, but to know if it is 'correct' you require some experiments to test the hypothesis!
[/scientist alert]
What is true and easily verified is that varnished reedblocks are the norm on high quality piano accordions.
-
Also on the high dollar Hohner diatonics.
-
Also on the high dollar Hohner diatonics.
Yes, the Overture and Morino, I'd forgotten about those.
On the other hand Castagnairi and Saltarelle reedblocks are not usually varnished.
-
I suppose it's a matter of aerodynamics. The brighter surface will let the air flow more easily through the blocks, as well as projecting the sound waves better. I generally think that it suits non-dry tuned power-boxes best to have varnished reed blocks, and to have as small chambers as the reed will allow. A friend of mine had an old paolo with non-varnished blocks, and there was a clear difference after the blocks got a coat of shellac.
-
I suppose it's a matter of aerodynamics. The brighter surface will let the air flow more easily through the blocks, as well as projecting the sound waves better. I generally think that it suits non-dry tuned power-boxes best to have varnished reed blocks, and to have as small chambers as the reed will allow. A friend of mine had an old paolo with non-varnished blocks, and there was a clear difference after the blocks got a coat of shellac.
A coat of varnish on wood does reduce the absorption of sound at high frequencies, but as Theo says, whether this makes any noticeable difference to the sound isn't proven -- polishing an aircraft makes it faster, but this doesn't mean that polishing a bicycle does the same.
Even the paolo/shellac story isn't proof, people often hear what they expect to hear -- like "the more expensive cable definitely sounds better" after being told that's what they were listening to, which was a shame because it wasn't :-)
Ian
-
I could probably dig out some values from my acoustics stuff and try to hash some calcs, but I don't have them with me. I'd be surprised if the amount of absorption of varnished wood is significantly less than unvarnished wood over that small a cross sectional area.
-
I guess I was confused as to what was being varnished here. Are we speaking of varnishing the reed blocks that the reeds are mounted in or are we speaking of varnishing the interior of accordion itself? I guess my assumption and this may be ignorant was that the interior walls of the accordion would be varnished to produce a stronger brighter sound. Correct me please if I'm way off mark.
-
It's both. On expensive instruments the reedblocks and the interior surfaces of the instrument are usually varnished.
-
This would have an affect on the reflection/transmission of sound at the interface. But not much. The reflection of sound energy at an interface is proportional to the square of the difference in accoustic impedance Z. Air has a high impedance (poor conductor) - solids are much better conductors with low impedance (think horses hooves via ground, or railway line noise).
So at your block {Reflection} = constant X (high-low)2
... giving a naturally high refection rate. (Low refection means absorption)
Surface texture also changes things. A smooth surface acts as a mirror. Wood grain may scatter - but again not much. The grain size is small comapared to sound wavelength. Laquer layer thickness will matter too. Here in ultrasound dept (I kid you not) probes are coated with layers a quarter wavelength thick to increase energy transmission. These effects are all frequency/wavelength dependent, as is the accoustic impedance in any given medium for that matter
So some harmonics would be strengthened relative to others. There was sophistry along these line with respect to the Stradivarius violins, but AFAIR the selective thinning of their wood was the key, reinforcing panel vibration modes.
My guess is that laquering one's bellows card might have the most effect. But as ever, science doen't get you too far in melodeonism. It's try it and see. Anyone had a go?
Thus endeth the lesson ;)
http://www.ndt-ed.org/EducationResources/CommunityCollege/Ultrasonics/Physics/reflectiontransmission.htm
-
My brand new Mélodie gives off a whiff of varnish when I play, and it definitely comes from the pallet holes. So I suspect they varnish the reed blocks. The accordion has a very bright sound, so I, too, wonder whether there's a connection. The same on my one-row Petosa, and I've read somewhere on this forum that they indeed do varnish them...
-
My last year's Gaillard has no whif of varnish whatsoever, and AFAIR has all natural wood inside. It has a very soft tone. (And no, I'm not gonna risk it)! :Ph
-
polishing an aircraft makes it faster, but this doesn't mean that polishing a bicycle does the same.
That's why cyclists shave their legs instead ;D
-
polishing an aircraft makes it faster, but this doesn't mean that polishing a bicycle does the same.
That's why cyclists shave their legs instead ;D
[pedant alert]
Cyclist derive no benifit from shaving their legs as far as aerodynamics and speed are concerned, they do it to aid stiching/plasters when they come off and damage their legs
[end pedant]
-
This would have an affect on the reflection/transmission of sound at the interface. But not much. The reflection of sound energy at an interface is proportional to the square of the difference in accoustic impedance Z. Air has a high impedance (poor conductor) - solids are much better conductors with low impedance (think horses hooves via ground, or railway line noise).
So at your block {Reflection} = constant X (high-low)2
... giving a naturally high refection rate. (Low refection means absorption)
Surface texture also changes things. A smooth surface acts as a mirror. Wood grain may scatter - but again not much. The grain size is small comapared to sound wavelength. Laquer layer thickness will matter too. Here in ultrasound dept (I kid you not) probes are coated with layers a quarter wavelength thick to increase energy transmission. These effects are all frequency/wavelength dependent, as is the accoustic impedance in any given medium for that matter
So some harmonics would be strengthened relative to others. There was sophistry along these line with respect to the Stradivarius violins, but AFAIR the selective thinning of their wood was the key, reinforcing panel vibration modes.
My guess is that laquering one's bellows card might have the most effect. But as ever, science doen't get you too far in melodeonism. It's try it and see. Anyone had a go?
Thus endeth the lesson ;)
http://www.ndt-ed.org/EducationResources/CommunityCollege/Ultrasonics/Physics/reflectiontransmission.htm
All true -- the question is, will any effect be significant? It's well known that wood panelling affects the reverberation time and tonal quality of a room and that both these are altered by varnishing. But then reverberation is very sensitive to absorption because the sound is reflected many times, a melodeon probably isn't because the sound pretty much escapes immediately.
Same as the "soundboard material" argument -- just because it has a huge effect on the sound of a violin doesn't mean it has any significant effect on the sound of a melodeon. Hence my comment about airplanes and bicycles :-)
And as usual the "I tried this and it definitely sounded better" argument is not valid if you knew what "this" was, due to the fact that people tend to hear (or see, or feel, or taste) what they expect to hear (observer bias). It also doesn't matter *how* many people believe it, this still doesn't make it true (or untrue) -- lots of people believe strange and incredible things about audio cables, but not once have these been shown to be true in a double blind test.
Note that I'm not saying it *doesn't* have any effect, just that acoustics says that any effect will be small or insignificant, and that as far as I know nobody has proved it in a valid manner which can distinguish fact from opinion.
Ian
-
Given what we all learned at school about vibrating strings there is an obvious resonance effect when you elongate the bellows. Their folds should act as a repetitive resonator to lock certain harmonics .... [futher dull stuff deleted to protect the innocent]
... but has anyone here actually noticed the box's tone change as you pull (or push) and hold a long note? ;)
-
... but has anyone here actually noticed the box's tone change as you pull (or push) and hold a long note? ;)
Acoustically, no, but if you put a microphone inside the bellows, attached to the reed-block (zydeco style) there is a kind of phasing effect to the amplified sound as the bellows is elongated.
-
As a matter of "sound" - no.
Tuning is another matter. If there 2 or more reeds going together, and one or more are "weak" in construction or setup - or even tuned too close, they can pull in together after a second or even more, especially when playing very low volume. Thus, changing the sound after a while...
-
Given what we all learned at school about vibrating strings there is an obvious resonance effect when you elongate the bellows. Their folds should act as a repetitive resonator to lock certain harmonics .... [futher dull stuff deleted to protect the innocent]
... but has anyone here actually noticed the box's tone change as you pull (or push) and hold a long note? ;)
I've tried it, and the answer is "no".
You wouldn't expect it to be a significant effect anyway, acoustic cavity resonances are strong inside rigid boxes with flat walls -- in a melodeon the ends are covered with reed blocks so are hardly flat, and the sides are relatively soft (acoustically speaking) bellows so sound energy will leak out instead of being reflected back inside and building up a high-Q resonance.
Same issue as the violin vs. melodeon soundboard question (or polishing a plane vs. a bicycle, or skin effect in audio cables) -- something which looks at first glance like it could make a big difference doesn't when you look into the details of the physics/acoustics :-)
Ian