Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: triplet on January 20, 2010, 02:47:08 PM
-
What do you think: are plastic reeds faster than leather ones? Does it affect the tone? ???
-
This discussion (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1920.0.html) may help you
-
and this post (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2004.msg20204.html#msg20204)
It may be worth doing your own search. The search tool on this forum works reasonably well I find.
-
and this post (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2004.msg20204.html#msg20204)
It may be worth doing your own search. The search tool on this forum works reasonably well I find.
tum tee tum - I just searched for "reasonably well" and same again without quotes and got each time in red
Your search query didn't return any matches.
Maybe it's the way I tell them but this happens most of the time... :o
-
tum tee tum - I just searched for "reasonably well" and same again without quotes and got each time in red
Your search query didn't return any matches.
Maybe it's the way I tell them but this happens most of the time... :o
A well you have been caught out by the famous frivolous search filter :D ;D
search for "plastic valves" with or without quotes gives plenty of hits.
-
Many of my older accordions have leather valves that have curled. Therefor they don't seal reliably.
My newer boxes have plastic valves that don't curl.
-
here is a recent suggestion (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3072.msg36336.html#msg36336) for more effective searching of the forum
Yup - I must admit I use google to find things on The Guardian newspaper site when I want to find something I have read in the paper version. The Grauniad has updated its search engine a number of times over the last 12 months and it remains appalling, failing even to find its own headlines for the day or day before - hence the google route...!
I must be less frivolous in future or doG will strike me down!! >:E
-
Observations
One self poclaimed "accordion engineer" says plastic only
One very famous manufacturer of high quality melodeons uses leather
Some makers use a combination
My aged (and RIP) Italian born maker/repairman/tuner used leather only and always from the throat of the animal.. (his words)
I personally prefer leather .. but this assumes proper storage and an occasional maintenance, recurling and replacement.
There are other materials I find suitable...
-
There are other materials I find suitable...
Such as?
-
secret cosmic security clearance required.
-
It's someting like whale skin or panda tongue, isn't it?...or human leather...
-
I used a piece of heavy paper to "temporarily" replace a missing plastic valve in an East German piano accordion. I forgot that I had done this 30 years ago. It is still working fine.
-
NAUGA hide
-
pre-CD computer disc material also works quite well.
-
This has been a question in my mind for a while as well....plastic or leather. In my 50's "goldbrand" Pokerwork, the original plastic valves are, for the most part, intact and flat. Not bad for 40+ years of service. A couple have shed due to failed adhesive. Plastic seems to be the more reliable valve for the long haul.
I've seen some boxes with a combo of plastic on the small reeds, leather with boosters on the larger. Personally, I think that the plastic reeds do add a subtle sound to the box, a sort of 'schlak' sound, as the note is released and the valve closes, possibly a momentary high-frequency oscillation somewhere in there. Perhaps it's just my well worn eardrums...... :-X
-
Personally, I think that the plastic reeds do add a subtle sound to the box, a sort of 'schlak' sound, as the note is released and the valve closes, possibly a momentary high-frequency oscillation somewhere in there. Perhaps it's just my well worn eardrums...... :-X
I notice that too, but not on the mid to high range. That is why leather is still best for the low reeds, it is less noisy.
-
Has there been any confirmation about when synthetic valves first started appearing on Hohner melodeons?
How much "lift" off the valve is acceptable for a leather - should it lie completely flat?