Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: xgx on January 21, 2010, 01:35:20 PM

Title: chicken or egg
Post by: xgx on January 21, 2010, 01:35:20 PM
...which came first?

When playing for dancer it's been suggested that one should play to their feet ...

Ask a dancer what s/he follows and the reply's 'I follow the music....'



So, who's following whom?
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: joe on January 21, 2010, 01:56:24 PM
.....both! (In my cotswold experience)

The musician starts the dance with a bar or two of the music, which sets the pace / rhythm. Get that completely wrong and chances are the dance will be completely wrong!

Once started, it is very much up to the dancers. As a musician, I always follow one of the dancers, who I know will keep a steady rhythm. Morris is not a one-speed one-rhythm affair so it is important to change to the dancers and the omves, especially with jig dancing (where the musician can start at one pace and as soon as the dance starts the pace instantly changes to suit the dancer).

From a Dancer's perspective, the music isnt as important as you would think, in fact we can dance really well to no music! But a great musician and a great tune combination makes the dance even better. Its all a bit subjective really.
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: TomB-R on January 21, 2010, 04:01:25 PM
Both! Virtuous loop/feedback-system, when it's going well!

In some styles (step clog anyone?) one of the musician's jobs is to put the brakes on when necessary!
(However wonderful the side you play for!)
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: Theo on January 21, 2010, 04:27:09 PM
Dancers are musicians too, playing mainly with their feet.  Musicians and dancers should play together as a harmonious ensemble.
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: Mike Gott on January 22, 2010, 07:55:02 AM
.....both! ....

...I'll go with that too. I play for North West and the same interraction applies. Having said that, out lot are quite capable of starting to dance at a completely different speed to what we're playing at. I despair sometimes........

I suppose that having been a dancer myself in the past helps me as a musician, in that you have a feel for the dancer's perspective as well as the musician's.

Mike
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 22, 2010, 09:11:50 AM
Dancers are musicians too, playing mainly with their feet.  Musicians and dancers should play together as a harmonious ensemble.

I agree with this fundamentally. If you're playing for a team should you try to lead them, force the pace, drag, or oversyncopate - There will always be tension. So 'together' is surely the thing.  If you don't some dancers will tend to their own pace, others follow the music strictly.  Karma will be disrupted. The force will be disturbed. Whatever.

Playing for couples in european style .. they will all be slightly different and a musician must direct the pace and rhythm rather more. But I still personally take my cue from a 'good' couple..

PS: Yes Mike, having danced yourself is so useful
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: xgx on January 22, 2010, 10:36:55 AM
I think I have it now, thanks...

The musician follows the dancers who follow the musician who follows the dancers who dance to the music played by the musician ...

Yeah, right ;D :P

Now, who the hell does the drummer follow?
a. the musician
b. the dancer(s)

which of course begs the question, Who the hell are the dancers following, the beat of the drum, or the musician?

Meantime, who's the musician following?

Answers on the back of a £20 note please (address via pm)

NB
It offends the laws of physics for three people to follow each other simultaneously.
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: Bill the Farmer on January 22, 2010, 10:51:24 AM
It's quite simple, really. The dancers follow the musicians because the music tells them what to do, so they say.  :M
The musicians watch the dancers closely to get a clue as to which bit to play next.  :||:
The drummer if off in a little world of his own, and is ignored as much as possible by both the dancers and the musicians.
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: xgx on January 22, 2010, 10:58:33 AM
Bill ... perfect... well, it seems to work for our side ;)
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: Theo on January 22, 2010, 11:50:59 AM

which of course begs the question, Who the hell are the dancers following, the beat of the drum, or the musician?

Meantime, who's the musician following?

Wrong question.   Its not about leading and following, its being together.
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 22, 2010, 01:09:52 PM
Yes there are two convolved threads here.

  1) The silly one (fun nevertheless,  but nevertheless silly)  
  2) The fact that so much music or dancing is about sensitivity to the people you do it with

Observe the synchrony of these melodeonists from resident Iconoclass LdT  :||: and  :|||:  Happiness :D
 
      Whereas this bobbing morris dancer and boozer are well out of rhythm  :M. and :|glug   Misery  ::)


PS: Owen - see 1st line my reply (#5 above)
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: OwenG on January 22, 2010, 01:13:13 PM
Quote
Whereas this bobbing morris dancer   and boozer are well out of rhythm. :M and :|glug  Misery   ::)

I thought that was syncopation  ;D
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: george garside on January 22, 2010, 01:25:41 PM
.....both! ....

 . Having said that, out lot are quite capable of starting to dance at a completely different speed to what we're playing at. I despair sometimes........

I 
Mike

I once tested this theory by changing into a waltz half way through a north west daance - the buggers carried on without even noticing!

george
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: george garside on January 22, 2010, 01:33:39 PM

 

Wrong question.   Its not about leading and following, its being together.

Totally agree with Theo.  The late Will Atkinson, mouthie player extroardinary  & Shand MOrino player  once told me that 'every tune has a natural speed' and that if you hit that speed everything becomes easy.  That was  a very useful handy hint .  Don't force the pace or try to slow dancers down (or speed them up)  Find that natural speed and everything 'floats' the dancers dance right & playing & keeping time  just flows. I call it 'floatation speed'  Shand was a past master at it.

george 
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: jonm on January 22, 2010, 01:58:18 PM
There are odd occasions where it can help to "lead" the dancers. For example, half way through a (Cotswold) Headington chorus may come a half hey (change ends) followed by cross-backs (fancy stepping in place). Most sides take too long over the hey and finish up doing the cross-backs as a shuffle into place. If you speed up the music just a tidge as they start the half-hey, then return to normal speed as they finish, the dancers will tend to put extra effort into getting round and be in place for the cross-back steps in "normal" time. This is very subtle, only a few BPM I guess, and I only realised I was doing it when the dancers pointed it out.

Playing for Cotswold is never metronomic, the speed and rhythm ebb and flow with the dance(rs).

Off to play for a jigs instructional weekend.... :M :||:
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: xgx on January 22, 2010, 02:06:36 PM
...
When playing for dancer it's been suggested that one should play to their feet ...


In the light of the contributions, which 'silly' person advocated that....?  :-*

It wasn't the wrong question... it served the purpose of testing errant advice.

(Half hey with crossbacks excepted ;))

Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: Owen Woods on January 22, 2010, 04:06:22 PM
I once tested this theory by changing into a waltz half way through a north west daance - the buggers carried on without even noticing!

george

We contemplated playing Princess Royal in 7/8 the other night to see what would happen but we didn't do that dance in the end :P
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: Andy Next Tune on January 22, 2010, 08:13:55 PM
I'm sure Simon Care at Witney made some comments (among many others  (:)) along the line of...
-Ceilidhs/barn dances - dancers take their lead from the music
-Morris (cotswold) - musicians should take their lead from the dancers (normally No1 in set), and 'lift' the dancers.

Timing of this thread is great - morris AGM on monday and I've got music onto the agenda for exactly this reason 'cos not everyone gets it! See other thread on morris music I'm about to kick-off - comments need.

Andy

Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: Guy on January 22, 2010, 11:52:38 PM

I thought that was syncopation  ;D

Syncopation, as every Morris musician knows, is an unsteady movement from bar to bar.... :|glug
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: george garside on January 23, 2010, 10:30:02 AM
I'm sure Simon Care at Witney made some comments (among many others  (:)) along the line of...
-Ceilidhs/barn dances - dancers take their lead from the music
-Morris (cotswold) - musicians should take their lead from the dancers (normally No1 in set), and 'lift' the dancers.

Timing of this thread is great - morris AGM on monday and I've got music onto the agenda for exactly this reason 'cos not everyone gets it! See other thread on morris music I'm about to kick-off - comments need.

Andy




disagree with the ceilidh/barn dance bit!   The muisic should also lift the dancers at ceilidhs & bandances & for that matter any other form of dancing.  The music is not requiredd to make them land  -they can't hover!  - gravity brings them down  & the band shoves them back up!

george 



Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: IanD on January 23, 2010, 12:28:31 PM
I'm sure Simon Care at Witney made some comments (among many others  (:)) along the line of...
-Ceilidhs/barn dances - dancers take their lead from the music
-Morris (cotswold) - musicians should take their lead from the dancers (normally No1 in set), and 'lift' the dancers.

Timing of this thread is great - morris AGM on monday and I've got music onto the agenda for exactly this reason 'cos not everyone gets it! See other thread on morris music I'm about to kick-off - comments need.

Andy




disagree with the ceilidh/barn dance bit!   The muisic should also lift the dancers at ceilidhs & bandances & for that matter any other form of dancing.  The music is not requiredd to make them land  -they can't hover!  - gravity brings them down  & the band shoves them back up!

george 


Playing with "lift" is something that's difficult to describe and even harder to do for some people -- I'm trying to teach the concept to a couple of novice box players now on the principle that if you learn how to do it from the very beginning it comes naturally, but it's very difficult to "bolt-on" after you've learned how to play.

Both ceilidh and morris dance playing have strong similarities -- the music can drive the dancers along and lift and inspire them, but only if it's at the right speed and the tune has the right "feel".

When playing for ceilidhs we don't just think "oh, a 32 bar jig will do", it's a case of what type of tune will fit that dance (marchy, bouncy, lollopy, where the gaps are, single/double jig...) and what the right speed for the dance and the dancers is -- which varies from audience to audience, and is chosen by watching the dancers and seeing if the music seems too fast for them (rushed dancing), too slow (leaden dancing), or just right (like baby bear's porridge :-)

With morris you've generally got one less degree of freedom (choice of tune -- but ask Smiffs why Serpentiner *is* the best tune in the world for Bampton Sidestep), but also an added one with slows and corner figures (following what individual dancers or pairs of them are doing). I know how everyone in the team dances and what the "best" speed to play for them is in corners, but even this varies depending on how fresh/tired/emotional they are -- and this is done by watching the dancers closely, which is why I'm often looking at their feet.

But you can take the "following the dancers exactly" too far in my opinion -- Mr Jorrocks was the classic example, huge gaps and fits and starts in the music to follow *exactly* what the dancers were doing (massive jumps etc), resulting in something that didn't sound like music, and some people would say didn't look like dancing. It was said that when the government was trying to ban raves based on people dancing to the music ("a succession of beats characterised by a regular heavy musical emphasis" or something similar), they would have been the only morris team in the country who would have escaped the ban.

A really good musician helps to shape the style and dancing of the team -- together with the foreman teaching them how to dance, and the squire telling them what to dance -- to produce the best dance performance on the day, with dancers and musician(s) working together.

Ian
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 23, 2010, 12:58:53 PM
But you can take the "following the dancers exactly" too far in my opinion -- Mr Jorrocks was the classic example, huge gaps and fits and starts in the music to follow *exactly* what the dancers were doing (massive jumps etc), resulting in something that didn't sound like music, and some people would say didn't look like dancing. It was said that when the government was trying to ban raves based on people dancing to the music ("a succession of beats characterised by a regular heavy musical emphasis" or something similar), they would have been the only morris team in the country who would have escaped the ban.
Oh, oh, oh.....
Sorry Ian. I have to disagree with you here. I loved watching Mr Jorrocks. And their musicians and music were superb; the gaps between the notes somehow changed the earth's gravitational field so that those gert hefty chaps could spend longer in the air than the average dancer.

Just my personal opinion of course and I'm sure we won't fall out over it.  ;)
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: IanD on January 23, 2010, 01:56:42 PM
But you can take the "following the dancers exactly" too far in my opinion -- Mr Jorrocks was the classic example, huge gaps and fits and starts in the music to follow *exactly* what the dancers were doing (massive jumps etc), resulting in something that didn't sound like music, and some people would say didn't look like dancing. It was said that when the government was trying to ban raves based on people dancing to the music ("a succession of beats characterised by a regular heavy musical emphasis" or something similar), they would have been the only morris team in the country who would have escaped the ban.
Oh, oh, oh.....
Sorry Ian. I have to disagree with you here. I loved watching Mr Jorrocks. And their musicians and music were superb; the gaps between the notes somehow changed the earth's gravitational field so that those gert hefty chaps could spend longer in the air than the average dancer.

Just my personal opinion of course and I'm sure we won't fall out over it.  ;)


Mr Jorrocks -- the Marmite of morris teams :-)

Ian

P.S. I was also *impressed* what they did, dancing and music -- but I just didn't *like* it as Morris dancing...
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: IanD on January 23, 2010, 02:06:47 PM
Mr Jorrocks -- the Marmite of morris teams
For non-UK readers, Marmite is a by-product of beer.

...whose advertising theme is basically "love it or hate it, nobody's indifferent to it"...

Ian
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: Theo on January 23, 2010, 02:09:10 PM
Quote
...whose advertising theme is basically "love it or hate it, nobody's indifferent to it".. (http://www.marmite.com/).

Ian

Link added
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: GbH on January 23, 2010, 02:22:24 PM
Intrigued at what was being referring to, I did a quick YouTube search.  Is this it -  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j3hGtH8dQAw (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j3hGtH8dQAw)?



Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 23, 2010, 04:01:06 PM
Intrigued at what was being referring to, I did a quick YouTube search.  Is this it -  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j3hGtH8dQAw (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j3hGtH8dQAw)?
Yes, that's them. Outside their own Bell and Jorrocks pub in Kent by the looks of it.
Great solo jig from Andrew Jones and Tim Bull musician here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KzGzSVY098o
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: Owen Woods on January 23, 2010, 04:54:34 PM
Hmm, I have to say that doesn't fit with my idea of music or dancing either...

...whose advertising theme is basically "love it or hate it, nobody's indifferent to it"...

Ian

Interestingly I am genuinely indifferent to marmite :P
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: waltzman on January 23, 2010, 06:12:03 PM
Intrigued at what was being referring to, I did a quick YouTube search.  Is this it -  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j3hGtH8dQAw (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j3hGtH8dQAw)?
Yes, that's them. Outside their own Bell and Jorrocks pub in Kent by the looks of it.
Great solo jig from Andrew Jones and Tim Bull musician here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KzGzSVY098o

I guess I can understand the 'gravity defying' effect of hanging the music like that but it just grates on my ear.  I would consider breaking time more a musical novelty or trick rather than anything you would want to do frequently.  Having said that, I should add that I know nothing about morris dancing.
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: Accordion Dave on January 23, 2010, 09:56:03 PM
Perhaps I missed it, but I did not see any reference to recorded music at a dance.

It would seem from some of the arguements above that some dancers would find it impossible to dance with a recording.

If this were universally true disco dance halls would be completely unsucessful.
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 24, 2010, 09:49:52 AM
Perhaps I missed it, but I did not see any reference to recorded music at a dance.  It would seem from some of the arguements above that some dancers would find it impossible to dance with a recording.  If this were universally true disco dance halls would be completely unsucessful.

Sounds a real  oxymoron .. but is disco dancing actually "dance? It's some time since I was forced into it, but most seemed to consist of the girlies vagely twitching to strict (often computer generated) 4/4 rhythm around a pile of handbags.  So rather more to do with partner pickup than dance.

When I last looked (about 15 years ago) the most recent 3/4 or 6/8 pop hit was Day Trip to Bangor! Is that still the case?
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: Theo on January 24, 2010, 11:32:20 AM
  So rather more to do with partner pickup than dance.

I thought that was what all social dance was about? :o
Title: Re: chicken or egg
Post by: Accordion Dave on January 24, 2010, 10:16:19 PM
One person's dancing is another person's drunken stumbling. What some people consider "music" is just "noise" to others.

A good disc jockey can "read the crowd" and adjust the music and tempo.

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal