Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Andy Next Tune on January 22, 2010, 08:22:50 PM

Title: Playing for Morris
Post by: Andy Next Tune on January 22, 2010, 08:22:50 PM
I'm stirring things up at our agm - it is that time of year - and would like some quick comments/feedback from other morris musicians as its my chosen topic for this year!

1. Musicians practice? Do you have them or just play at practices, pub afterwards etc? How do your musicians learn how to play well for dancing?
2. How do you bring new musicians up to speed and playing in public? In at deep end or ?
3. Cotswold question - how many musicians? As sides age, often the number of musicians grow as well! Do you let 'anyone' play who's able and not dancing? The morris big band. Or keep it to 1-2 musicians? Views?
4. Who is responsible for the music incl. quality? Is there anyone? (Equivalent to the foreman being responsible for the dances  (teaching/quality)?

If starting from scratch with your side, how would you like to organise the musical side of things?

Thanks, Andy
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Bill the Farmer on January 22, 2010, 09:02:47 PM
1. Musicians practice? Do you have them or just play at practices, pub afterwards etc? How do your musicians learn how to play well for dancing?

We don't have musician practice, we did for a few months some years ago, but that was to help beginners get going.

We don't let people play out in public unless they've played for at least a practice season. There are exceptions, like musicians from other sides, Lester, and Alan the bus driver from Brighton & Hove Buses, who plays a mean whistle when he takes us out on trips.

2. How do you bring new musicians up to speed and playing in public? In at deep end or ?

New musicians play for practice, lurking in the background, and when they're up for it, play out, similarly lurking in the background. Suddenly, one day, they find they're the music.

3. Cotswold question - how many musicians? As sides age, often the number of musicians grow as well! Do you let 'anyone' play who's able and not dancing? The morris big band. Or keep it to 1-2 musicians? Views?

We try not to have more than two or three melodeons, but that can be difficult as some people insist on playing. We have quite a large number of musicians in the side, but quite a few of them turn out sporadically, if that. We do the morris big band deliberately, for fun, with other sides occasionally. The chap mentioned below gets a bit upset if the band is too big.

4. Who is responsible for the music incl. quality? Is there anyone? (Equivalent to the foreman being responsible for the dances  (teaching/quality)?

That's a good question. We have a 'music squire', but she's more concerned with who can turn out than quality. We have a chap who teaches some of the finer points of the dancing, and is also a brilliant musician, who gives us tips.

If starting from scratch with your side, how would you like to organise the musical side of things?

That's a problem, quite a few of our musicians won't be organised, you have to make the best of what you can get. We don't make any special attempt to recruit musicians, we get a few people who turn up each year for practice for a few months, or even the whole practice season, but we don't see them again the next year.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: xgx on January 22, 2010, 09:19:17 PM
fwiw from my experience...

1. Musicians practice?  No, just play at practices.  
How do your musicians learn how to play well for dancing?  ;D we just play ;)

2. How do you bring new musicians up to speed and playing in public?  New musicians,  easier finding hens' teeth!!  

3. Cotswold question - how many musicians?   Just the one... Only ever danced with one 'traditional' cotswold side.

4. Who is responsible for the music incl. quality? Is there anyone?  No but if there was a problem we'd soon know about it I suspect ;)

If starting from scratch with your side, how would you like to organise the musical side of things?

Recordings and sheet music made available, regular 'musicians only' sessions, Squire/foreman to attend as and when...

Good luck Andy!!
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Lester on January 22, 2010, 10:31:28 PM
1. Musicians practice? Do you have them or just play at practices, pub afterwards etc? How do your musicians learn how to play well for dancing?
No practices other than playing at dance practice. The more experienced musicians are always free with advice for the newer musicians  ;D

Quote
2. How do you bring new musicians up to speed and playing in public? In at deep end or ?
Normally wait til they are the only musician available for a gig and then decide they have reached an acceptable level.

Quote
3. Cotswold question - how many musicians? As sides age, often the number of musicians grow as well! Do you let 'anyone' play who's able and not dancing? The morris big band. Or keep it to 1-2 musicians? Views?
Personal preference just one but, to quote someone "As sides age, often the number of musicians grow as well!" so mostly we have a band.

Quote
4. Who is responsible for the music incl. quality? Is there anyone? (Equivalent to the foreman being responsible for the dances  (teaching/quality)?
We have an acknowledged (rather than elected) music leader who is more than capable of leading the band when out dancing, this takes some doing with ~three melodeons, 1 accordion, 1 drummer and the leader on English Concertina!

Quote
If starting from scratch with your side, how would you like to organise the musical side of things?
Take anyone who was willing/able and mould them to do it MY WAY.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 23, 2010, 07:39:57 AM
You can view morris as primariy an art form or primariy a pub crawl (both are valid IMHO). Apologies if I rant or winge ...

The single worst thing morris musicians get up to is to continue playing when the dance has stopped. This particularly true of stick dances where generally the final clash with 'all in' or 'face up' us so abrupt and dramatic. OK - we can perhaps go one worse ... where one musician stops nicely at the line while another decides that what it really needs just now is a 'country dance chord' "Dadaaaa"  :-\   So relish that silence - let your dancers enjoy their moment.

You've probably guessed I'm from the 'Art Form for a Musician and 6 Fools' school.  However having a single musician in a side is an eggregious risk, and were I Squire I'd want at least one spare. Hmmmm - massed bands  ??? Sometimes larger than the dance group itself  ??? They  seem very 'in' at present. But do they add anything to the Morris? Your call.

however anything more than one person, and certainly 10+ surely needs a musicmeister to enforce at least some direction? I'd say more than three tremello melodeons is a perhaps dubious. And just what does that shakey egg contribute? Now if she'd switch to a drum that would help!

OK You have been put in charge: Have you the courage to drop to one or two instruments where the dance requres it? eg I've never heard Fieldtown Signposts sounding at all well to more than one instument.

I'd say musicians (if pleural) should meet occasionally off or pre practice to agree such parameters and at least discuss which of them will be in charge of say a set of slow capers, or the tune change in bonny green. Whether that's a leader, or a lead for certain dances is up to the group. Otherwise unless they are unusually gifted or sensitive (arguably not a universal trait in morris musicians) shambolism seems inevitable. Practice together? Well, you'll surely not be thanked for doing this during dance practice night!  

Should you choose a Lead Musician he is defo in charge of these aspects. I thnk the squire or dance leader should be the one who decide eg whether music is played coming on or off, and IME should offer more feedback generally as to style and pace.  

I'm an 'ex' nowadays - but did it for 20 years.  But these were the conclusions I came to. The three sides I was involved with had very sound dance leaders. Their ad hoc music was their weak link. Chris
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Pushpull on January 23, 2010, 08:33:58 AM
I tend towards the "one instrument for Cotswold" school.
OK You have been put in charge: Have you the courage to drop to one or two instruments where the dance requres it? eg I've never heard Fieldtown Signposts sounding at all well to more than one instument.
Agreed - ideally one without basses too.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Owen Woods on January 23, 2010, 10:27:07 AM
1. Musicians practice? Do you have them or just play at practices, pub afterwards etc? How do your musicians learn how to play well for dancing?

We don't have a musician's practice, no, we only play at dance practice. We learn by attrition (theoretically).

Quote
2. How do you bring new musicians up to speed and playing in public? In at deep end or ?

Well I was thrown into dancing, which I was expecting, as I was under the impression (and still am) that it is much more difficult to play for Morris if you have never danced it. As it happens I am dancing an awful lot more than I am playing, although I still hope to get my playing up and running properly in the future. I've shared a few shows with Ollie of this parish and playing on my own a fair few times in practice, but never played for a show on my own.

Quote
3. Cotswold question - how many musicians? As sides age, often the number of musicians grow as well! Do you let 'anyone' play who's able and not dancing? The morris big band. Or keep it to 1-2 musicians? Views?

Generally for practice, one, possibly two and for dancing out almost always one. We have four of us that turn up for practice, although rarely all at once. One is female, and so is allowed to play without dancing.

Quote
4. Who is responsible for the music incl. quality? Is there anyone? (Equivalent to the foreman being responsible for the dances  (teaching/quality)?

Our principal musician is the squire, so him.

OK You have been put in charge: Have you the courage to drop to one or two instruments where the dance requres it? eg I've never heard Fieldtown Signposts sounding at all well to more than one instument.

I agree. In fact I have never been able to work out a satisfactory bass part (I was thinking that using the chord buttons with the thirds out might work but haven't found a combination that matches the tune, which is one of my favourites) and would never dream of playing it with anything more than a single instrument on the melody.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: IanD on January 23, 2010, 12:45:49 PM
I tend towards the "one instrument for Cotswold" school.
OK You have been put in charge: Have you the courage to drop to one or two instruments where the dance requres it? eg I've never heard Fieldtown Signposts sounding at all well to more than one instument.
Agreed - ideally one without basses too.

Multiple musicians for Cotswold (actually, all dancing :-) have the problem that unless they play very "together" the gaps between the notes -- as important as the notes, maybe even more so if you're playing for dancing -- get filled in, which loses the crispness; also, where the speed has to vary a little (slows, capers etc) to follow the dancers it's difficult for them to keep together. Mushiness is the enemy of playing for morris.

Having said that, in a noisy environment more than one instrument gives more volume and makes it easier for the dancers (and audience) to hear, we often use more than one melodeon in these circumstances. But then most of the Smiffs musicians have learned from/with me and have a similar style (and attitude to following/leading the dancers, and speed) so hopefully this preserves some of the crispness.

There are tunes (like Adderbury Shooting) which -- at least, for the way we want the dance to look and sound -- benefit from multiple instruments, where the speed is pretty constant and the added depth/volume of a "melodeon orchestra" adds to the effect, and gives the opportunity to use harmony lines and counterpoint (ooh err missus).

Given sufficiently sympathetic musicians this even works for "gappy" tunes like Moresque (Longborough style) so long as the gaps are in the same place for all the musicians (who are watching the dancers, remember).

But for "high-profile" bookings like festival spots where there's little or no noise and we want to put on the best possible show, one musician (or at most two) is the norm, except for the few tunes which positively benefit from several.

Ian
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Theo on January 23, 2010, 02:03:06 PM
As one who neither plays for or dances Morris, but who likes to watch, I can say that all the really memorable Morris performances I've seen have had very few musicians.   

(and of those the the best of all have been with a single fiddle player!)  :|bl
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: ACE on January 23, 2010, 09:51:22 PM
Now if she'd switch to a drum that would help!


Drums have messed up loads of music and dances. Just getting a drum and thinking you can bang away in time, is  in most 'drummers' heads. A bad drummer can make all the life go out of the tune and make the dancers plod along instead of being lifted by a good tune. They are not needed to keep the musicians in time. Because if musicians cannot play for the dancers with out it they should not be playing at all.

A marching band marches to the drum, you cannot dance to the drum. Pipe and tabor players do not use the tabor to dictate the dance speed, more of a juggling trick than rythm.

Usually the drummer is a wannabe musician Not the right person to be beating out the time as most of them seem to do. But you try and convince them they are not really needed. You stand more chance of p#ssing in the queens handbag than getting them to go away.

It would be a good idea to have a musicians practice, but when you give the drummer the venue make sure it is in a different town to where you will be practicing
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: xgx on January 23, 2010, 10:27:23 PM
Drummer ...very difficult to ignore when 'he' is off the beat by 30msecs... and on one tune where every note gets a bang on the drum :'( :'( :'(

Every possibility has been explored... except my suggestion of having someone behind tapping out the beat with a brick ;D
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Falseknight on January 24, 2010, 12:44:17 AM
Never had any problems with drums (or drummers) - but I don't play for or dance Morris.  Many Morris sides i have seen have difficulty counting with their socks on.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 24, 2010, 09:56:52 AM
          (and of those the the best of all have been with a single fiddle player!)  :|bl


A brave thought, Theo, and really subtly expressed! Once I'd selected, CTRL-copied, opened my text editor and CTRL-pasted it in order to read this microdot of wisdom ... amazingly I found I almost agreed with you  :Ph

Drummer ...very difficult to ignore when 'he' is off the beat by 30msecs... and on one tune where every note gets a bang on the drum :'( :'( :'(

Agreed - good drummers are rare and our shakey egg lady is probably a long odds bet!  But I'd assert that Morris drum is perhaps the best example of off metronome drum one could envisage. Looking back,  I'd say the best Morris music I've heard over about 30 years of critical listening has been pipe and tabor with the drum dominating (whatever Theo might say)!  ;D
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 24, 2010, 10:50:58 AM
Drummer ...very difficult to ignore when 'he' is off the beat by 30msecs... and on one tune where every note gets a bang on the drum :'( :'( :'(

Every possibility has been explored... except my suggestion of having someone behind tapping out the beat with a brick ;D
Getting him to play the drum using a Stanley knife is usually quite effective.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 24, 2010, 10:52:52 AM
A brave thought, Theo, and really subtly expressed! Once I'd selected, CTRL-copied, opened my text editor and CTRL-pasted it in order to read this microdot of wisdom ...
Just hit the 'quote' button on the upper right. The compose window appears, with the quotable text in 'normal' size.  ;D
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: LJC on January 24, 2010, 11:11:01 AM
Ah, now you could be stirring a hornets nest with questions like this!

1. Musicians practice? No - only when playing for dancing during the practice season. Thankfully all our members now practice at home or are at a level where it doesn't really matter if they only practice morris tunes at practice.

2. How do you bring new musicians up to speed and playing in public? In at deep end or ?

I started at the deep end holding together quite a raggedy set, but after a few years and some gentle prodding in the right direction its beginning to come together. Everyone starting now is expected to come to practice and then stands to build up confidence and ability to play in public without having the spotlight thrust upon them.

3. Cotswold question - how many musicians? As sides age, often the number of musicians grow as well! Do you let 'anyone' play who's able and not dancing? The morris big band. Or keep it to 1-2 musicians? Views?

I prefer to play on my own or with one other person. It sounds cleaner and tighter, and allows for more spontaneous musicianship or variations. Others in the prefer to keep it large so that there is not a shortage of musos. This irritates me as there isn't a shortage!

4. Who is responsible for the music incl. quality? Is there anyone? (Equivalent to the foreman being responsible for the dances  (teaching/quality)?

I have been leading the music for the past few years anyway, but I'm now the side MD. The side has agreed on certain standards for dancing and playing to avoid people spoiling the show when they really cant keep up, but in an understanding and encouraging way. Since I'm leading I have been providing people with the dots for the way I play tunes and my chords to help cohesion. I've also made executive decisions on which version we're all going to play.

If starting from scratch with your side, how would you like to organise the musical side of things? Basically the same as now, but set the bar to the right level for players right from the start.

There is nothing wrong with drummers, but people need to realise that a drum is a really loud and dangerous instrument which requires practice! Picking it up to play through the once dance they don't like isn't effective or helpful! Sides with really good consistent drummers who play all the time can get some really good rhythms going, but this requires proper practice!
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: ganderbox on January 24, 2010, 11:12:08 AM
A brave thought, Theo, and really subtly expressed! Once I'd selected, CTRL-copied, opened my text editor and CTRL-pasted it in order to read this microdot of wisdom ...
Just hit the 'quote' button on the upper right. The compose window appears, with the quotable text in 'normal' size.  ;D

You beat me to it, Steve! That's what I just did.
And I do tend to agree with Theo. Certainly one of the most memorable performances I have seen was the Abbots Bromley Horn Dance in Thaxted, done to a solo fiddle. The sound as they approached was eerie and quite magical.
Then for something completely different there's Beltane Border who have a solo fiddle, amplified, with lots of drums....and the people wielding the drums can actually play them! Pagan Rock!   
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Theo on January 24, 2010, 11:42:31 AM
 I'd say the best Morris music I've heard over about 30 years of critical listening has been pipe and tabor with the drum dominating (whatever Theo might say)!  ;D

No argument with you there Chris!
I love to hear a really good drummer with almost any sort of music, unfortunately there are large numbers of people out there hitting things with sticks that are not really good drummers.  Recent examples I've heard of of fantastic drumming include the Ben Griffith, drummer with the Demon Barbers.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Owen Woods on January 24, 2010, 01:12:54 PM
Agreed - good drummers are rare and our shakey egg lady is probably a long odds bet!  But I'd assert that Morris drum is perhaps the best example of off metronome drum one could envisage. Looking back,  I'd say the best Morris music I've heard over about 30 years of critical listening has been pipe and tabor with the drum dominating (whatever Theo might say)!  ;D

I agree. I love the whistle and dub, fantastic sound.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Bob Ellis on January 24, 2010, 01:17:10 PM
Our Morris side is larger than average, possibly because we make a special effort to be welcoming and friendly and to avoid cliquiness. Since the side is large, it is hardly surprising that we also have a lot of musicians. When they are all there, I tend to think of them as Crook Light Orchestra! Restricting the number of musicians would have a damaging effect on our friendly and inclusive ethos - so we don't!

Music practices happen occasionally, but not on a regular basis. If we feel the need, we hold a practice - either to bring new musicians up to speed or to agree how we are going to play for new dances that have been added to our repertoire. I also produce a folder of tunes for the side and keep it up to date. Every musician receives a copy of this. As well as setting down the musical notation, it also includes the basses, so the melodeon players, our bass guitarist and anyone else playing a bass line do not play conflicting or dischordant basses. There is also a note of how many times the tune is to be played, where slows occur and any other relevant information.

When there are so many musicians, it is essential to have a leader, but there is nothing very authoritative or regimented about it. The leader is usually Jenny or me and our main task is to establish and maintain the tempo. We establish the tempo by playing a four-bar solo introduction. To maintain the tempo, Jenny bounces up and down as she plays her concertina; I do it by nodding my head and tapping my foot. The leader also reminds other musicians of anything unusual (e.g. double speed for the last chorus on most Adderbury stick dances or stop playing for the last chorus of Young Collins, Bledington).
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Gandy on January 24, 2010, 02:30:54 PM
Out of interest, how many are referring to Morris musician's who aren't also Morris dancers?
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Sandy on January 24, 2010, 04:26:56 PM
Would I be correct in thinking that, for more than one musician, the lead musician should focus on the strong dancer, and the other musicians should follow the foot of the lead musician. Or is there an appointed dancer for all musicians to play with?

Cheers

Sandy
 (:)
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Mike Higgins on January 24, 2010, 04:43:44 PM
I have only danced with one side, my local team, and have no practical experience of anything else so perhaps these views are not transferable to others.
In our dancing sides we have no members who are musicians only. We operate as two separate teams one all women, one all men and so each can play for the other when not dancing.
We have sometimes one, usually two, sometimes three melodeons playing at any one time when out. My own preference is for one only, so that it is easier to respond rapidly to the needs of the dancers. If the melodeons are very accustomed to playing together then two or three can work well if they really concentrate and pay attention to the leader and not forget the purpose of the whole thing and get carried away by playing the tune at breakneck speed.

As an old bloke I have noticed that the surface on which one dances, the occasion, the dance, the people in the dance and loads of other things make it very difficult to set the correct speed for the dancers each time at the start without loads of little adjustments. I have tried using a metronome to get to grips with speed but it is a hopeless task, there are too many variables. This is why I prefer to dance to one good melodeonist, or a pipe and a tambourine.

Finally, last summer I saw a morris side in which the band was enormous but with very few dancers, being outnumbered some three to one by the band. The band was very accomplished and enjoyable to listen to, but I'm not sure whether this was morris.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Ollie on January 24, 2010, 06:21:06 PM

And I do tend to agree with Theo. Certainly one of the most memorable performances I have seen was the Abbots Bromley Horn Dance in Thaxted, done to a solo fiddle. The sound as they approached was eerie and quite magical.   

Words often fail me when I try and describe the Horn Dance at Thaxted. Awe-inspiring.

I always think that only one person should play for Cotswold, as it is very difficult to have a band and to keep that felxibilty in the music to respond to what the dancers are doing. This is particularily true in dances with slows. Having said that, one of the sides I dance with does have two female melodeon players who often play together at practise and at dance outs. As they have been doing so for a number of years, they do keep that felxibility in the music. If your side has to have a massed band for whatever reason, NEVER have a massed band for a jig, single or double.

For me, the only drums that work in Cotswold are the drum of a pipe and tabor, and this can be a very effective tool in driving the dancers along and making them do the sticking in time! However, IMO, big drums and big bands are vital for North-West and Border. They can sometimes work in Molly, but with sword dancing, Long or Rapper, Cotswold rules apply.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Mike Higgins on January 24, 2010, 07:59:27 PM
Quote
IMO, big drums and big bands are vital for North-West and Border.

Having danced border for some 35 years I couldn't disagree more with the assertion that a big band is necessary for border.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Bob Ellis on January 24, 2010, 10:58:07 PM
I find it sad (and unintentionally insulting to others who do things differently) when people say that Morris music should always be this or should never be that. We should all be free to determine what works best in our particular situation without censorship or criticism from others. One of the interesting things about Morris dancing and the musicianship that accompanies it is that there are many different ways of interpreting it. Naturally, we all see some sides whose style appeals to us and others that we find less appealing, but that should not translate into blanket statements that certain things must be done in certain ways or that other things should never happen.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Bob Ellis on January 24, 2010, 11:18:57 PM
Would I be correct in thinking that, for more than one musician, the lead musician should focus on the strong dancer, and the other musicians should follow the foot of the lead musician. Or is there an appointed dancer for all musicians to play with?

Cheers

Sandy
 (:)

I am sure that many Morris musicians would agree with you, but I tend to adopt a more flexible approach.

When the dancers are all dancing together, I do tend to follow whoever is 'calling' the dance. I adjust the tempo, if necessary, by watching that dancer. I have known it happen for one dancer in a set to signal to the musicians that the tempo should be increased while another dancer is signalling for it to be slowed down! I ignore all such signals unless they come from the person calling the dance, who usually dances at No.1, but not always.

The main exception to this comes in corner dances, when I adjust the tempo during the corner sequences for each pair of dancers according to my observation of their dancing and my knowledge of the fitness, dancing style and ability of each pair.

At the same time, it is important to be aware of what the other musicians are doing. If I am the lead musician, I try to ensure that all the other musicians are following my lead and to signal to any who are not doing so. If someone else is the lead musician, I try to ensure that I am following their lead whilst also responding to the dancers.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Pushpull on January 25, 2010, 09:42:09 AM
I find it sad (and unintentionally insulting to others who do things differently) when people say that Morris music should always be this or should never be that. We should all be free to determine what works best in our particular situation without censorship or criticism from others.
At the same time we are all entitled to our views and the OP was asking us for our opinions.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: ganderbox on January 25, 2010, 09:52:11 AM
I find it sad (and unintentionally insulting to others who do things differently) when people say that Morris music should always be this or should never be that. We should all be free to determine what works best in our particular situation without censorship or criticism from others.
At the same time we are all entitled to our views and the OP was asking us for our opinions.

Yes, but Bob is right to point out that everybody's situation is different, and there really are no rules.
What is important is the dynamics of the side, as what works for one will not necessarily be right for another, and it would be a mistake to try to impose other people's ideas if they don't fit the circumstances.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 25, 2010, 10:13:11 AM
Yes, but Bob is right to point out that everybody's situation is different, and there really are no rules.

Agree wholeheartedly where organisation is concerned. But the drift of this is then that there is no such animal as bad Morris music?  Not my experience I'm afraid. Those massed bands at Ring meetings have already been alluded to in the thread, and I believe the Ring Leaders see that as a weakness (well, they certainly did in the 90's).  And we seem to agree that some morris music is quite superb  ??? relative to what, then?

Why this talk of imposition? A side has a perfect right to play badly, dance chaotically , get drunk, whatever. But that doesn't make it "good"  ::)

Perhaps we're taking that recent film rather too seriously.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: george garside on January 25, 2010, 10:32:01 AM
as Morris is usually performed as a display for the public the whole performance - music & dance- should   form an entity  that is  interesting both visually & audibly - when this is achieved the punters  identify with it, enjoy it, watch for longer & put more  brass in   tin and you get invited again - so everybody wins!

george ;D
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Bill the Farmer on January 25, 2010, 10:36:49 AM
I have known it happen for one dancer in a set to signal to the musicians that the tempo should be increased while another dancer is signalling for it to be slowed down! I ignore all such signals unless they come from the person calling the dance, who usually dances at No.1, but not always.

Funny you should say that...
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: ganderbox on January 25, 2010, 11:20:38 AM
Yes, but Bob is right to point out that everybody's situation is different, and there really are no rules.

Agree wholeheartedly where organisation is concerned. But the drift of this is then that there is no such animal as bad Morris music?.....
Why this talk of imposition? A side has a perfect right to play badly, dance chaotically , get drunk, whatever. But that doesn't make it "good"  ::)


Imposing rules won't make the music good if they aren't appropriate.
For example, four or five good musicians who work well together can make excellent music for Cotswold, but a group of musicians who don't work well together can be disastrous, at which point some control, (like how many people play, and who leads etc) will probably be needed. It might not be rules which are required , however, but diplomacy!
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Mike Gott on January 25, 2010, 01:24:59 PM
As a bandleader for a NW morris for over 20 years, I'm now firmly of the opinion that a few experienced and well rehearsed musicians who know what they're doing is always preferable to the casts of thousands who always try to join the band when there's a festival booking in the offing! Musicians with dancing experience are also good to have. And yes - you can have bad morris music. I've contributed to it myself in the past............

Mike
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Ollie on January 25, 2010, 10:16:39 PM
Yes, but Bob is right to point out that everybody's situation is different, and there really are no rules.

Agree wholeheartedly where organisation is concerned. But the drift of this is then that there is no such animal as bad Morris music?  Not my experience I'm afraid. Those massed bands at Ring meetings have already been alluded to in the thread, and I believe the Ring Leaders see that as a weakness (well, they certainly did in the 90's).  And we seem to agree that some morris music is quite superb  ??? relative to what, then?


There most certainly is. We used to have a musician for some years who could not only not play very well, but who would not adapt to the dancing. They dropped notes all over the place, lost the beat and would play at the speed they felt the should and would not be told otherwise. This made it very difficult to dance to and resulted in many a poor show. This is an example of bad Morris music. The first practise after this person left was a revelation and the dancing felt soo much easier.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Bob Ellis on January 26, 2010, 10:52:57 AM
I wasn't trying to suggest that there was no such thing as bad Morris music or that there shouldn't be any rules about it, merely that rules should not be imposed needlessly. I can think of only two rules that are neceesary: the first is that the music should adapt to the dancing (not the other way round) and the second is that if more than one musician is playing they should ensure that they are playing to the same tempo. :||: :|||: :||:

Issues about such things as whether Morris should be accompanied by one musician or by an ensemble or whether instruments such as drums or electrified instruments are suitable for Morris are merely matters of personal preference. As such, it is perfectly reasonable that they will be interpreted differently by different sides. Whether we like the music and dancing that results from a particular side's decisions is a matter for personal taste, but the Morris world would be a poorer place without the diversity that results from these different interpretations. Vive la difference!
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: waldoB on January 26, 2010, 11:59:45 AM
Regardless of the varying and lively opinions isn't great that Morris Music is the one exception to the onerous requirement of an Entertainment Licence. The broadening spectrum of Morris is bringing our national dance tradition to many that might otherwise not be interested. DB
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Jake Middleton (brinwins) on January 26, 2010, 12:40:45 PM
If one melodeon is good, that does not mean more is better
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Bob Ellis on January 26, 2010, 12:49:20 PM
If one melodeon is good, that does not mean more is better

...neither does it mean necessarily that more is worse.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Bill the Farmer on January 26, 2010, 12:58:05 PM
The most important thing about more than one melodeon is not to stand in a line, so you don't get what we call melodeon echo, like a ripple effect down the line. Also stand on the left of the whistle/flute player so (s)he gets the treble end and not the bass.

On the subject of the number of instruments for Cotswold, our local ring side, the Chancs regularly field an Anglo concertina, an Erica, and a PA, both for Northwest and Cotswold. And a drum for Northwest.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on January 26, 2010, 01:05:27 PM
Our (Ebor Morris) Wall of Sound varies very much with who's there, who's not dancing and who's just gone off to the pub. At out of season practices, it's whichever musicians can be bothered to turn out in the cold, wet and mud (usually two melodeons and my fiddle) and at our Dance-Outs it can be anybody who happens to have brought an instrument. Usually this works out OK, apart from one person who is a much better dancer than musician, unless he is dancing when it is vice versa.
We do tend to stand in a line, but the melodeons are in the middle and lead when we dance.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Mike Gott on January 26, 2010, 06:29:06 PM
The most important thing .....is not to stand in a line...

Earlier I mentioned having contributed to bad morris music. Well.....some years ago we had a large band strung out in long a single line at the side of the dancers - due to restricted space. About half way through the dance we began to get pained looks from the dancers - it transpired that one end of the band had dropped into a different tune to the other end...both of which were different to what the ones in the middle were playing....... :-[

Incidentally, as far as any "band" over the number of 1 are concerned, it's important that somebody is known to be the leader.

Mike

Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: IanD on January 27, 2010, 10:23:41 PM
I find it sad (and unintentionally insulting to others who do things differently) when people say that Morris music should always be this or should never be that. We should all be free to determine what works best in our particular situation without censorship or criticism from others. One of the interesting things about Morris dancing and the musicianship that accompanies it is that there are many different ways of interpreting it. Naturally, we all see some sides whose style appeals to us and others that we find less appealing, but that should not translate into blanket statements that certain things must be done in certain ways or that other things should never happen.

Same as with dancing -- style is one thing which is indeed a matter of interpretation and opinion, and not everyone will agree (Marmite :-)

Crap dancing or music at a public performance is however beyond the pale. If teams can't perform to a reasonable standard -- you know, dancing together in time to reasonably competent music -- they shouldn't be out in public reinforcing the already poor opinion that many people have of morris.

Ian
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Guy on January 27, 2010, 11:48:21 PM


Crap dancing or music at a public performance is however beyond the pale. If teams can't perform to a reasonable standard -- you know, dancing together in time to reasonably competent music -- they shouldn't be out in public reinforcing the already poor opinion that many people have of morris.

Ian

I'm not sure that I entirely agree. Whether it's Morris, playing, singing in a club...whatever, we've all got to start somewhere, and should encourage people to perform live. I'm sure we've all been part of performances at some time that looking back on it were not great, at best. I know I have, anyway!

But I do agree about standards-maybe it's something to do with attitudes to our performances. If people are looking to improve and practice to do that, then I think it's ok-it's when they're complacent about their performance, and think whatever they do is good enough....

Cheers,
Guy
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Mike Gott on January 28, 2010, 12:50:37 PM
....If teams can't perform to a reasonable standard -- you know, dancing together in time to reasonably competent music -- they shouldn't be out in public.....
Ian

Even in the light of my earlier admission, I'm with you on that, Ian. Sending dancers and musicians out in public before they're up to scratch doesn't do either of them any good. I'd rather not perform than go out knowing that I was about to unleash something substandard on an audience. Basically - don't get up and do something that you wouldn't be prepared to sit through yourself!



Mike
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Lester on January 28, 2010, 01:01:37 PM
....If teams can't perform to a reasonable standard -- you know, dancing together in time to reasonably competent music -- they shouldn't be out in public.....
Ian

Even in the light of my earlier admission, I'm with you on that, Ian. Sending dancers and musicians out in public before they're up to scratch doesn't do either of them any good. I'd rather not perform than go out knowing that I was about to unleash something substandard on an audience. Basically - don't get up and do something that you wouldn't be prepared to sit through yourself!

Mike

Whilst in principle I agree with Mike and Ian I play for a "special needs" morris side which has gathered together some good dancers and some less good and 1 or 2 poor dancers. Viewed from a purist morris point of view we are really not very good - not on correct leg - hands not in time - etc - but Joe Public seem to really enjoy what we do. We are always welcomed back at return events, we are regularly re-booked for pay events. We go about it in a cheerful manner, here is plenty of banter and gross mistakes are exposed for what they are and enjoyed as such.

So is it MORRIS maybe not, is it entertainment definitely - was MORRIS ever what was written down and anointed as being RIGHT probably not either.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Mike Gott on January 28, 2010, 03:42:35 PM
Whilst in principle I agree with Mike and Ian ...........

Good point, Lester. I think that failing to entertain is probably just as big a crime if not more so. It's something quite a lot of folks seem to fail to consider as part of their performance these days - too many people playing in public but just for their own satisfaction...

Mike
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: IanD on January 28, 2010, 06:43:16 PM
Whilst in principle I agree with Mike and Ian ...........

Good point, Lester. I think that failing to entertain is probably just as big a crime if not more so. It's something quite a lot of folks seem to fail to consider as part of their performance these days - too many people playing in public but just for their own satisfaction...

Mike


I didn't want to get into the subject of teams who *are* technically good but don't know how to involve and entertain the audience, that's another subject entirely...

There's room for everything from adequate teams who are great fun to great teams who are adequate fun -- of course, great teams who are great fun are the ideal, but not that common.

But with rare exceptions like the special needs team referred to afterwards, I've seen teams dancing out who are just a joke, so bad that even non-morris people can tell that they're rubbish rather than even barely acceptable. We're not talking about opinions about how a particular dance or tradition should be done here, just basic "can they dance together with each other and the music".

Yes everyone has to learn, that's what practices are for, to learn the dancing and the music to be able to go out and perform something at least passable -- I'm talking basic skills here, not top-flight standards. It's no different to the reason that you'd expect a busker playing in public to be able to play with reasonable competence, someone who's being playing the violin for a few months and can't even play in tune should not be inflicting horrible noises on the ears of the public.

Why should morris dancing -- and music -- be any different?

Ian
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: oggiesnr on January 29, 2010, 10:07:10 AM
I'm not worried about how many musicians play (as long as they're together) but I am concerned about being able to hear what's being played.

I've seen a couple of sides recently with solo musicians (one a fiddle player,the other team had a melodeon) where even from nearby I was struggling to hear the music.  The box-player had a pokerwork, plenty loud enough you would think but there was almost no bellows movement and almost no sound!

By the same token I've seen a couple of Border teams where the "drum corp" drowned out the melody instruments.

Steve
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: george garside on January 29, 2010, 10:42:26 AM
IN these days of declining interest in participating in morris  ( & for that matter in any other activity that requires commitment)  few sides  can guarantee putting up a team of top class dancers & highly skilled & practiced musicians at every turnout.  As a species we are gradually becoming older & have difficulty in recruiting new younger members so we do the best we can, despite creaking joints, knackered knees etc etc & most importantly most of us enjoy what we are doing.

 As far as musicians are concerned its often a question of doing the best you can with what youve got on the day & I also see it as important to 'accomodate' those who can no longer dance by welcoming them into the band with tambouine, shaky egg or whatever - it enables the continuing social cohesion , does no harm whatsoever & makes the band look bigger to the public & therefore adds to the spectacle if not greatly to the music.

At the end of the day  morris should be a 'fun' thing complete with happy smiling faces - whats the point in doing it if its serious to the point of misery & exclusion.

george
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Pushpull on January 29, 2010, 11:45:26 AM
Yes everyone has to learn, that's what practices are for, to learn the dancing and the music to be able to go out and perform something at least passable -- I'm talking basic skills here, not top-flight standards. It's no different to the reason that you'd expect a busker playing in public to be able to play with reasonable competence, someone who's being playing the violin for a few months and can't even play in tune should not be inflicting horrible noises on the ears of the public.

Why should morris dancing -- and music -- be any different?

Ian
I agree with Ian here and frankly I think it DOES matter what the public think morris dancing is. I've got nothing against people dressing up and running around shouting - just don't call it MORRIS. That, by association, means the rest of us are doing the same thing. Well we're not. Sorry for being grumpy (oh no I'm not).
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: xgx on January 29, 2010, 11:54:30 AM
...

At the end of the day  morris should be a 'fun' thing complete with happy smiling faces - what's the point in doing it if its serious to the point of misery & exclusion.


I'm sure I've read '...stern of countenance' somewhere, no mention of enjoyment as far as I can recall ;D

 :||: :M :|glug :Ph :|glug
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Mike Gott on January 29, 2010, 12:47:17 PM
You can have "fun" and smile and still do what you're doing well! In fact the grin factor from doing something well and knowing that you're doing something well is far greater than the cheap laugh value of doing something obviously rubbish in public. Some styles of morris are of course shambolic by nature, but there's no excuse for the music to be . I know that we're indulging in a hobby, that we're all amateurs - but that shouldn't be the excuse for turning out something shoddy.

Mike
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Owen Woods on January 29, 2010, 03:34:30 PM
I think that people are basically in agreement here. Most people think that Morris dancing done very badly should not be displayed, i.e. little sense of rhythm, boring dances, poor musicianship, hand movements not in time with one another etc. But there is a whole spectrum between the dreadful and the impeccable. Personally I would much rather see a side with drive and energy, but a little raggedy around the edges, than one which is technically very good in terms of stepping or hand movements, but is fairly staid, men not rising well or moving very much.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 30, 2010, 08:34:50 AM
Norbert Pignol believes that any 'Art' is as nothing unless you perform it. I'd guess this is very true of Morris, and not a mile off wrt melodeon or other music. We could argue the fine detail (and probably will..)   So one issue is at what stage you 'go out and do'. 

Another is whether you do anything about it when you know something is poor. There's always collateral damage in change, and a morris side has a strong sociological aspect - we've even used the word 'political'.

I'm slowly coming to a conclusion that the only way to get truly chrisp morris is to start with a bunch of fresh lads. Isn't there a Headington tune along those lines?
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: ganderbox on January 30, 2010, 10:02:26 AM


I'm slowly coming to a conclusion that the only way to get truly chrisp morris is to start with a bunch of fresh lads. Isn't there a Headington tune along those lines?

I think you're right there, Chrisp.

There are a few sides out there who have probably passed their "best before" date, and reached a point at which they simply aren't going to attract youngsters to join them. What we need is people with the initiative to go out and start a new morris revival, getting groups of young lads (or lasses, or both) to start new locally based sides, all learning together and thereby creating their own style.   
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: IanD on January 30, 2010, 11:39:32 AM
I think that people are basically in agreement here. Most people think that Morris dancing done very badly should not be displayed, i.e. little sense of rhythm, boring dances, poor musicianship, hand movements not in time with one another etc. But there is a whole spectrum between the dreadful and the impeccable. Personally I would much rather see a side with drive and energy, but a little raggedy around the edges, than one which is technically very good in terms of stepping or hand movements, but is fairly staid, men not rising well or moving very much.

So would I -- though even better would be to have drive and energy *and* technical excellence -- and knowing how to involve and entertain an audience as well would put the icing on the cake :-)

Though I wouldn't agree with the "men" bit -- I've seen a couple of women's Cotswold teams who can dance the socks off most men's teams...

Ian
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Owen Woods on January 30, 2010, 11:47:32 AM
Ian, I agree, I am all for mixed or female sides as long as they dance the Morris properly :P I have seen some fantastic mixed sides around.



I'm slowly coming to a conclusion that the only way to get truly chrisp morris is to start with a bunch of fresh lads. Isn't there a Headington tune along those lines?

I think you're right there, Chrisp.

There are a few sides out there who have probably passed their "best before" date, and reached a point at which they simply aren't going to attract youngsters to join them. What we need is people with the initiative to go out and start a new morris revival, getting groups of young lads (or lasses, or both) to start new locally based sides, all learning together and thereby creating their own style.   

The problems there comes with getting someone to teach them, as learning Morris out of the black book is a trifle difficult...
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: IanD on January 30, 2010, 11:51:22 AM


I'm slowly coming to a conclusion that the only way to get truly chrisp morris is to start with a bunch of fresh lads. Isn't there a Headington tune along those lines?

I think you're right there, Chrisp.

There are a few sides out there who have probably passed their "best before" date, and reached a point at which they simply aren't going to attract youngsters to join them. What we need is people with the initiative to go out and start a new morris revival, getting groups of young lads (or lasses, or both) to start new locally based sides, all learning together and thereby creating their own style.   

Or to join an existing team which has a strong style and knows how to dance and enjoy themselves and already has "youngsters" -- meaning people in their teens or twenties -- dancing with them. They do exist you know...

The problem with starting a new young side and learning together is that you can end up with teams who are very fit and athletic but don't understand what it takes to make morris look really good as a dance, and end up looking like a set of energetic but inexperienced jig dancers not a team.

The best foremen usually have considerable experience in both learning and teaching dancing, this is something that takes years to acquire. In a way it's like young musical virtuosos, many are technically excellent but don't yet have the real feel for the music needed to produce a really stunning performance.

Ian
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: IanD on January 30, 2010, 11:55:35 AM
...

At the end of the day  morris should be a 'fun' thing complete with happy smiling faces - what's the point in doing it if its serious to the point of misery & exclusion.


I'm sure I've read '...stern of countenance' somewhere, no mention of enjoyment as far as I can recall ;D

 :||: :M :|glug :Ph :|glug

They were probably worrying about being sacked for taking time off hard farm work to gallivant off doing morris ;-)

I agree that morris should be enjoyable both for the dancers and the audience, or there's no point -- but "fun" conjures up images of the hideous fake pasted-on grins that I've seen some dance teams put on...

Ian
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Mike Higgins on January 30, 2010, 12:20:51 PM
Quote
There are a few sides out there who have probably passed their "best before" date, and reached a point at which they simply aren't going to attract youngsters to join them.

There is some truth in this comment I suppose, but I have noticed that recruitment seems to go in waves. We can go for a few years with hardly any new dancers and during that time the dancing and playing becomes tighter and more accomplished as there is time to devote to refining the performance and not to teaching the basics of the dances and tunes.  We then seem to get an influx of new people and the energy increases dramatically, but lines, timing and music deteriorate.

I suppose we are a mix of wrinkly ancients and teenagers, the age group we can't hang on to are in their twenties. This is a very rural area and work is hard to find for young professionals, this is the sadness.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 02, 2010, 06:21:11 PM
This lot from another thread seem young enough ...   http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B3q0FmHb4FQ

And what cracking (and chrisp) music too. It's got everything - swung rhythm, drive, pulse, flattened 7th note (implied). Eminently danceable. In terms of this discussion I'd call this 'not bad'  :D
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Owen Woods on February 03, 2010, 01:10:27 AM
This lot from another thread seem young enough ...   http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B3q0FmHb4FQ

And what cracking (and chrisp) music too. It's got everything - swung rhythm, drive, pulse, flattened 7th note (implied). Eminently danceable. In terms of this discussion I'd call this 'not bad'  :D

Indeed. It is my favourite thing on YouTube at the moment. Cracking tune, cracking harmony, fantastic dancers.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Keithypete. on February 03, 2010, 01:22:48 AM
   I prefer to see a hanky in the hand not holding the stick for Oddington, good dancing though.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Owen Woods on February 03, 2010, 03:13:02 AM
   I prefer to see a hanky in the hand not holding the stick for Oddington, good dancing though.

Really? That's weird, I've never heard of that before (:)
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Lester on February 03, 2010, 08:25:09 AM
The hanky in the spare hand is a modern aberation. When Roy Dommett first reconstructed (made up :) ) Oddington he took it to Thames Valley Morris Men to try out and I was one of those men.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Keithypete. on February 03, 2010, 09:40:54 AM
The hanky in the spare hand is a modern aberation. When Roy Dommett first reconstructed (made up :) ) Oddington he took it to Thames Valley Morris Men to try out and I was one of those men.


To what extent is Oddington "...made-up..."?
   Traditional or not I still like the hanky in the other hand.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: baz parkes on February 03, 2010, 10:01:50 AM

To what extent is Oddington "...made-up..."?
   

I'm guessing in the same way that Jack Brown "re-constructed" Lichfield...

Baz

Ducking behind the parapet..
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Guy on February 03, 2010, 10:26:25 AM
And likewise I guess that a "band" (or at least more than one musician) appears to be acceptable...sounded brilliant to me, anyway...

Cheers,
Guy
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Lester on February 03, 2010, 11:37:10 AM
The hanky in the spare hand is a modern aberation. When Roy Dommett first reconstructed (made up :) ) Oddington he took it to Thames Valley Morris Men to try out and I was one of those men.


To what extent is Oddington "...made-up..."?
   Traditional or not I still like the hanky in the other hand.

Guess it comes down to how explicit the collector's notes were and thus how much "reconstruction" is required. If only C# and his chums had had video  ::)
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: IanD on February 03, 2010, 10:42:18 PM
This lot from another thread seem young enough ...   http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B3q0FmHb4FQ

And what cracking (and chrisp) music too. It's got everything - swung rhythm, drive, pulse, flattened 7th note (implied). Eminently danceable. In terms of this discussion I'd call this 'not bad'  :D

They might be young (and excellent) but they sure didn't learn to dance like that by reading a book :-)

(Dogrose are an energetic young offshoot from White Rose, who've been around even longer than we have :-)

Ia
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Ollie on February 04, 2010, 08:01:00 PM
Another question about playing for Morris, specifically box related. When playing for Cotswold, by yourself, should you keep the bass oom-pah and standard chords, or allow for interesting chords and non-oom-pah? I understand in order to compliment the dance, there are times when, for example in slows, you have to stray from oom-pah, but in ordinary figures, does it matter? I was playing for a practise before Christmas, and our Squire (who is also our main musician) said that some of the things I was doing with the basses were very unorthox. Thoughts?
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on February 04, 2010, 08:30:29 PM
Which bits of your output do your dancers listen to for their rhythm? If it's the bass, I'd be tempted to keep steady there and contrariwise if they listen to your emphases in the melody.  8)
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 04, 2010, 08:30:46 PM
I'm amazed he noticed - that wasn't my experience.

Do whatever you like with the basses in ordinary figures - so long as it doesn't become insensitive to the Dance. They may find it sligtly odd - but nothing is quite as odd as Morris - so don't lose too much sleep about that  :|glug

slows - spacial rules apply
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Bob Ellis on February 04, 2010, 09:08:40 PM
The rhythm is important to give the dancers the pulse of the music and to add 'lift' to their dancing. Therefore, in my opinion, it is important not to mess about with the bass rhythm and it is equally important to focus on the rhythm with the right hand.

However, one can get a bit bored playing the same tune over again (I certainly did when playing Bonnets So Blue ad nauseam last Monday night for the Upton Handkerchief Dance!), so I vary my choice of basses, but not the rhythm of them. Similarly, I add ornamentation to the right-hand melody, but I try to ensure that the ornamentation does not affect the basic pulse and rhythm on which the dancers rely.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Gandy on February 05, 2010, 08:29:57 AM
When playing for Cotswold, by yourself, should you keep the bass oom-pah and standard chords, or allow for interesting chords and non-oom-pah? I understand in order to compliment the dance, there are times when, for example in slows, you have to stray from oom-pah, but in ordinary figures, does it matter? I was playing for a practise before Christmas, and our Squire (who is also our main musician) said that some of the things I was doing with the basses were very unorthox. Thoughts?

I used to use bass notes as well - maybe a bass scale that either complemented or mimicked the melody.   In my opinion a Morris musician is not really driving the dancers, its more a duet between dancers and musician.  For example in some stick figures the dancers really drive the beat.

Try at a practice, and ask the dancers if it works for them.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Guy on February 05, 2010, 09:16:13 AM
Agreed - to mess about with the right hand could be instant death!

Actually, I'm not sure that I agree with this-as long as you're working with the dancers, I think you can play around with the right hand, as well as the left. I seem to remember John Kirkpatrick talking about variation and ornamentation, and playing the same tune over and over to see where it goes! Try it at practice and see what works...

Cheers,
Guy
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Rob2Hook on February 05, 2010, 11:05:32 AM
My favourite effect for Cotswold is to hear the box player lead the main beat with a short, sharp crescendo of both melody and bass, cutting short as the dancers feet hit the floor - something Ian D is particularly good at!  It gives tremendous emphasis and lift.

Rob.
P.S. I regret that no Cotswold side has ever asked me to play for them!
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Lester on February 05, 2010, 12:08:28 PM
P.S. I regret that no Cotswold side has ever asked me to play for them!

My secret is never to wait to be asked!   >:E
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 05, 2010, 07:19:18 PM
Agreed - to mess about with the right hand could be instant death!
Actually, I'm not sure that I agree with this-as long as you're working with the dancers, I think you can play around with the right hand, as well as the left. I seem to remember John Kirkpatrick talking about variation and ornamentation, and playing the same tune over and over to see where it goes! Try it at practice and see what works... Cheers,Guy

I guess I dont call ornaments and small variation 'messing about'  We were talking crossed rythms at the time I posted.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: IanD on February 06, 2010, 12:47:28 PM
My favourite effect for Cotswold is to hear the box player lead the main beat with a short, sharp crescendo of both melody and bass, cutting short as the dancers feet hit the floor - something Ian D is particularly good at!  It gives tremendous emphasis and lift.

Rob.
P.S. I regret that no Cotswold side has ever asked me to play for them!

Thanks Rob, the cheque's in the post :-)

Seriously, don't be afraid of leaving gaps in the music either -- often with a crescendo just beforehand -- especially for dances with big jumps in them, I often put big pauses in the basses at times like this (even if the right-hand melody carries on) as it does lift the dancers.

Making the basses follow the flow of the dance also helps -- instead of just playing oom-pah, substitute another oom for a pah (walking basses) at appropriate points, and punch in (oom+pah) to add emphasis next to the gaps.

For example this is something like I'd play Hammersmith Flyover ( | = bar line)

|   2 x double step    | jump         land        |         galley              | jump          land        |
| oom        oom oom | oom          oom oom | oom        oom         | oom           oom oom |
|        pah                 | pah           pah         |         pah         pah  | pah            pah         |

Hope that helps :-)

Ian

P.S. Ornamentation and variations is also fine *so long as it fits the dance*, I do it all the time -- in fact I can't play without doing it.

P.P.S. And sometimes even when it doesn't seem to, like "633 Squadron" rhythm in the chorus of Sweet Jenny Jones...
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Ollie on March 18, 2010, 10:48:21 PM
How's this for playing for the Morris - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXdgKi0TkxM  ;D ;D :M :M I want a go!!!
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 19, 2010, 06:15:19 AM
West Coast indeed! I thought that lead in on box was quite superb. It had their feet tapping, their audience's too, even I wanted to get up and dance!


I guess I still hold that Morris an art form for a musician and six fools :|glug  doc 3-row
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Andy Next Tune on March 19, 2010, 09:20:46 PM
West Coast indeed! I thought that lead in on box was quite superb. It had their feet tapping, their audience's too, even I wanted to get up and dance! ...........

Well played Squeezy!
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Owen Woods on March 20, 2010, 11:56:17 PM
West Coast indeed! I thought that lead in on box was quite superb. It had their feet tapping, their audience's too, even I wanted to get up and dance!

  • Then somehow those 'rhythm' instruments came in (guitar/fiddle?) - and lost that morrissy drive  :-\.  A case of 'too much' perhaps. I thought the middle section all felt a bit 'continuum'
  • Cor blimey - trumpet voluntaries! Defo not Cotswald traditional, but I liked them. Lifted the tune back, and didn't affect 'danciblility' at all IMHO.

I guess I still hold that Morris an art form for a musician and six fools :|glug  doc 3-row

I'd agree with this. I've always felt that Morris should be danced to one musician. I have to admit that the brass did add something though :P Squeezy's playing was typically top-notch.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: flipper on March 21, 2010, 01:37:43 AM
I feel that it is better to keep the melody going and leave the bass out if the bass is at all difficult to fit. I recently learned fieldtown, signposts and the bass is almost impossible and sounds great with just the melody. So yes less is more probably for some cotswold tunes.

Playing for Northwest is a different kettle of fish and requires a different type of tune which largely tend to be more band oriented and less lilting melody. So as long as everyone plays together a larger number of muscians is better.
 As for younger dancers, I danced myself when I was younger and only gave up when the need for a muscian was greater than a dancer, I have had 5 children 4 girls and a boy and all danced from a young age and 2 still do. At one time I had 4 daughters and my granddaughter all dancing for the same side. Sadly that side folded about 5 years ago when we moved and I now play for a local Northwest Side and we have several young members who dance a limited number of dances as they only practice during the school holidays. I also play for a local childrens side and we try to introduce the children to all styles of morris dancing including Maypole. The children we have at the moment age from about 4 years old to about 13 ( my youngest daughter having just left due to pressure of A level study) The children have thier own squire, forman and assistant forman and treasurer( with suitable assistance from grown ups) but when we dance out the forman calls the dance and chooses what dance they are going to do and who dances it. So far we have had no major arguments. The children are taught dances by members of local adult sides and we hope that when they are older they will go on to dance with one of the local sides. We have great fun and sometimes its not perfect but the public love it especially the maypole which we find we have people following us at festivals asking when the children are next going to do a maypole dance. The tradition won't die and we encourage the children to take up an instrument as well so that one day they will only need us for transport.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: flipper on March 21, 2010, 01:44:42 AM
A final thought is that having a number of muscians means that someone can carry on the tune when you have an elderly moment and can't remember if that was one or two A's (usually happens because you are playing a tune which lets face it you have played most weeks for the last 20 years or so and you spot someone in the crowd and find yourself thinking"thats old so and so I haven't seen hime since.....now when was it? )

Now tell me I am not the only one to have done this?
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Mike Higgins on March 21, 2010, 08:48:45 AM
Quote
A final thought is that having a number of muscians means that someone can carry on the tune when you have an elderly moment and can't remember if that was one or two A's

Happens all the time to me, although usually only when I am playing with someone else. It is worse if you start to chat with the other bloke and the tune and dance are straightforward.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Gandy on March 21, 2010, 10:26:23 AM
A final thought is that having a number of muscians means that someone can carry on the tune when you have an elderly moment and can't remember if that was one or two A's ....

In my experience these "moments" have been dealt with by the Morris Men jeering and singing the tune themselves, to lot of merriment from the crowd.  Adds to the entertainment as long as its not too often.   I don't think live performances are much harmed by the odd mistake, as long as the performers take them in their stride.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Anahata on March 21, 2010, 11:27:38 AM
Wow - just found this thread, lots of points to reply to...
Much sense from Ian Dedic, as I'd expect. I'm one of the box players he mentions, who have played alongside and learnt from him, and I've rarely concentrated so hard on listening to another player to make sure our styles matched, with some success I think.

I've danced to pipe and tabor, and found it a quite magical experience. It really is the best from the dancer's point of view, if it's played well.

That's also the clue to melodeon bass playing for morris: the basses are the drum and follow the rhythm of the steps and figures, hitting both bass and chord at strategic times for maximum impact, and leaving lots of gaps between the notes both sides of the box. I use  RH chords for rhythmic impact too.

Drums - the simple universal rule is that a drum is a musical instrument and need to be played by a musician who knows how to play it. Yes, we've all seen the bands where the drum and other percussion get picked up by random team members who aren't in the current dance...

The Bellowhead video - That style is better suited to North West of course, but it so happens that Eynsham is good choice to do that with too, as it's a tradition that suits rattling though the tune at a fixed tempo.

Practice? - At home for learning tunes if necessary, at dance practice for playing with the dance. Playing solo sometimes instead of following someone else's lead is also an instructive experience.

Losing count of A's and B's ? - I used to do that as beginner, but really an experienced morris musician should be (b) watching the dancers and (b) able to tell the difference between a figure and a chorus. Should be... OK, I've had the odd lapse of concentration from time to time...
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Owen Woods on March 21, 2010, 08:38:16 PM
I feel that it is better to keep the melody going and leave the bass out if the bass is at all difficult to fit. I recently learned fieldtown, signposts and the bass is almost impossible and sounds great with just the melody. So yes less is more probably for some cotswold tunes.

It's not just almost impossible, it is impossible as far as I am concerned. If only because if you use the bass it loses a massive part of what makes the dance special. I have, by dint of much thought, managed to work out a few chord options that don't sound horrific but would never use them to play to dance. That is a whittle and dub one I think.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Keithypete. on April 06, 2010, 12:03:43 PM
Can anyone point me towards a tune for Jug by the ear - Fieldtown, please?
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Little Eggy on May 04, 2023, 04:58:40 PM
I came across this very informative and interesting old thread because my wife suggested I consider playing for morris after watching that recent BBC 4 documentary.   Enormously helpful.  My local side is a Border Morris outfit.  In two posts there were comments to the effect that a larger group of musicians was OK for Border (but not necessarily for Cotswold or other traditions).  Why is this?
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: penn on May 04, 2023, 05:08:42 PM
Probably because Cotswold dancing is more intricate, and involves more changes of pace, making it easier for a single musician to keep in time with the dancers. On the other hand it’s nice to play in the middle of a border “orchestra” which is usually considerably louder and can often be heard outdoors.
Go for it Eggy!  (:)
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: george garside on May 04, 2023, 06:45:12 PM
I never got the hang of playing for cotswold probably because of the very dance specific tunes  none of which i was particulary keen on and which I think worked better with a single musician.  i enjoyed the 'band' feel of north west, clog stepping, border etc and also of playing fast rapper sword which definately worked best with a single musician.  Wnen playing ofr rapper as a single musician I rarely used the bass , instead trying to provide a similer feel/sound of a single fiddle. trying to concoct half decent bass at rapper speed  didnt  work and could detract from the proceedings
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: malcolmbebb on May 06, 2023, 07:23:22 PM
I came across this very informative and interesting old thread because my wife suggested I consider playing for morris after watching that recent BBC 4 documentary.   Enormously helpful.  My local side is a Border Morris outfit.  In two posts there were comments to the effect that a larger group of musicians was OK for Border (but not necessarily for Cotswold or other traditions).  Why is this?
In Border and NW dancers dance to the music.
In Cotswold the musicians play to the dancers. The more musicians, the muddier it gets.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: george garside on May 06, 2023, 08:58:16 PM
when playing for border or northwest  I always  played  to the feet of the best dancer in the  team or side or whatever.  This helped to keep the dancers in time with each other and  the band members in time with each othr and with the dancers feet. It also facilitated SLIGHT adjustments to the tempo or speed  if the dancers needed it to complete a manouvre in aa dignified way.

george
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on May 07, 2023, 07:11:00 AM
when playing for border or northwest  I always  played  to the feet of the best dancer in the  team or side or whatever.  This helped to keep the dancers in time with each other and  the band members in time with each othr and with the dancers feet. It also facilitated SLIGHT adjustments to the tempo or speed  if the dancers needed it to complete a manouvre in aa dignified way.

george

Totally agree George.
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: george garside on May 07, 2023, 05:32:55 PM
I came across this very informative and interesting old thread because my wife suggested I consider playing for morris after watching that recent BBC 4 documentary.   Enormously helpful.  My local side is a Border Morris outfit.  In two posts there were comments to the effect that a larger group of musicians was OK for Border (but not necessarily for Cotswold or other traditions).  Why is this?
In Border and NW dancers dance to the music.
In Cotswold the musicians play to the dancers. The more musicians, the muddier it gets.

for any sort of dancing be it old time , all ballroom,slow waltses , all brands of morris etc etc Istrongly advocate that a band, single musician or whatever play to the feet of the best dancer(s)  in order to get the rhythm  that s helps the dancers eg by providing 'lift' in the right places

This applies equaly to cotswold and is not the same thing  as "phrasing"" the music to best best  fit the seqence of a prticular part of a particular dance.
c
the basic ingredience of any type  dance music is RDT......RHYTHM...DYNAMICS  ....PHRASING  and preferably without exessive ornementation that can  have an adverse effect on the RDT!!!  in other words "keep it simple"
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: george garside on May 07, 2023, 11:35:04 PM
should read  RDP
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: IanD on June 24, 2023, 01:31:38 PM
I came across this very informative and interesting old thread because my wife suggested I consider playing for morris after watching that recent BBC 4 documentary.   Enormously helpful.  My local side is a Border Morris outfit.  In two posts there were comments to the effect that a larger group of musicians was OK for Border (but not necessarily for Cotswold or other traditions).  Why is this?
In Border and NW dancers dance to the music.
In Cotswold the musicians play to the dancers. The more musicians, the muddier it gets.

for any sort of dancing be it old time , all ballroom,slow waltses , all brands of morris etc etc Istrongly advocate that a band, single musician or whatever play to the feet of the best dancer(s)  in order to get the rhythm  that s helps the dancers eg by providing 'lift' in the right places

This applies equaly to cotswold and is not the same thing  as "phrasing"" the music to best best  fit the seqence of a prticular part of a particular dance.
c
the basic ingredience of any type  dance music is RDT......RHYTHM...DYNAMICS  ....PHRASING  and preferably without exessive ornementation that can  have an adverse effect on the RDT!!!  in other words "keep it simple"

Agree with everything you said, except perhaps "following the best dancer" -- that's fine if everone else can dance at the same speed as them, but if they're young and fit and jump high and not all the rest do that isn't always the case. I watch the whole team and try and pick the speed that looks best for the whole team, because nothing looks worse than a musician following one dancer and the rest of the team struggling...

Of course in an ideal world they'd all dance best at the same speed, but we live in the real world -- and I know how every member of the team dances, so the speed in corners will sometimes vary for each pair, and the speed in figures varies subtly in some traditions, stretching out the beat a bit for jumps and galleys.

I've been doing this for Smiffs for more than 40 years and it seems to work pretty well. But then all the other musicians have learned the style from me, and we do work hard to stay together -- including emphasis, and gaps in the music which are just as important as the notes -- and follow the dancers. We've been told things like "you sound like one melodeon but bigger" which I take as a compliment -- it's harder to make this work for Cotswold with multiple musicians but it can be done. And in some tunes/dances it gives you the opportunity to go off-piste a bit which a solo musician can't do -- but always having "fit the dance" and "lift the dancers" as the golden rules.

(and then there are occasions where you can break the rules like the "633 Squadron" chorus in Sweet Jenny Jones, but you have to choose these *very* carefully...)

In the end, it's all about watching the dancers... ;-)
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 24, 2023, 01:51:28 PM
Ian has nailed it for me... as you'd expect from him  :M
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 24, 2023, 04:39:57 PM

   He’s damn good. What happened to Ollie? 
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: IanD on July 01, 2023, 11:43:37 AM

   He’s damn good. What happened to Ollie?

He's a great musician who prefers to dance with Smiffs rather than play -- as it should be since he's the current squire... ;-)
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: baz parkes on July 01, 2023, 03:07:14 PM

   He’s damn good. What happened to Ollie?

He's a great musician who prefers to dance with Smiffs rather than play -- as it should be since he's the current squire... ;-)

Given he's currently cycling round Denmark, I take it he's excused :M duty? :|glug
Title: Re: Playing for Morris
Post by: IanD on July 01, 2023, 03:10:21 PM

   He’s damn good. What happened to Ollie?

He's a great musician who prefers to dance with Smiffs rather than play -- as it should be since he's the current squire... ;-)

Given he's currently cycling round Denmark, I take it he's excused :M duty? :|glug

Begrudgingly -- we're dancing out in Wimbledon on Tuesday and he'll still be in forn parts... :-(
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal