Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Reedman on January 24, 2010, 06:48:29 PM
-
Does anyone know if these accordions are any good? Which one would be better to buy?
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=320477052599&ssPageName=STRK:MESELX:IT#ht_500wt_1182
http://cgi.ebay.com/Hohner-melodeon_W0QQitemZ270519013246QQcmdZViewItemQQptZKeyboards_MIDI?hash=item3efc308f7e#ht_500wt_1182
Thanks friends
-
Hmm - a Hohner 1 row versus a Serenelli 2 row? Got two very different beasts there in all sorts of ways. Fact is they don't really compare. So it depends what you want really. If I were new to the melodeon I'd be tempted by the 2 row as a 1 row is NOT easier to play. However there's a size/weight differential which may be an issue. The hohner looks smarter and MAY need less doing to it to get it up an running as a playable box. The box from Ireland certainly needs a bit doing to it - though from the description nothing too major (if that's totally accurate).Personally I'm a bit of a Hohner nut, and since I quite fancy a 1 row in G major at the moment I know which one I'd be interested in if I lived on the other side of the pond. However, I do think that the G/C tuning is just such a great tuning!
I've been no help have I? But just a question really, I'd be interested in knowing which button it is that's 'slightly out of tune' on the Hohner? Is it a bass note or chord or is it on the treble side and is it on the push or the pull?
The grill on the box from Ireland also looks a bit bashed about as well doesn't it?
Might be worth asking the question. Before you decide to have a punt!
Regards
AL
-
... But just a question really, I'd be interested in knowing which button it is that's 'slightly out of tune' on the Hohner? Is it a bass note or chord or is it on the treble side and is it on the push or the pull?
Both these boxes could be around 50 years old, so unless there is evidence of maintenance or tuning in the recent past (eg invoices for work carried out) I think it would be safe to assume that each of them will need work to get them playing really well. Having said that it is possible that they might be ok.
Buying secondhand instruments off ebay is a complete lottery.
-
Buying secondhand instruments off ebay is a complete lottery.
Just bought a Club off Ebay to practice tuning on and recieved a Clarise Cliffe vase, now thats a lottery
-
Just bought a Club off Ebay to practice tuning on and recieved a Clarise Cliffe vase, now thats a lottery
Sounds more like a raffle, Lester. ;D :
Aren't they worth quite a bit, those vases?
Take abit of tuning though...
Baz
-
Take abit of tuning though...
Baz
Nonsense! You just add water till you get the note you want! ;D ;D
-
I'd buy the Hohner if it was a 4 stop...As I like G
If I were interested, I'd ask the seller "how" he knows it is in "G"
I think the Serenellini would be an interesting project box and I think $300 US would be about right
I would also like to know the make and quality level of the reeds
It sounds like the seller knows something about boxes so may be able to answer the question
-
I think the Serenellini would be an interesting project box . . .
Note that the box advertised is a Serenelli, not a Serenellini. I understand Serenelli used to be a good Italian make, and the advertised one is likely to be Italian; whereas nowadays "Serenelli" is a badge used on Chinese boxes. I believe the current manufacturer Serenellini is an entirely different maker, in business since 1978.
-
Thanks for all the discussion. I had heard that Serenelli is a good old Italian make so might go for that. A friend of mine has one he bought for $550 and its great. A little like this one but different colour. Anyway thanks for the advice and lets hope I get it! ;D
-
Reedman,
If you are specifically interested in a box like the Serenelli (a lightweight, 12-bass, 2-row, 2-voice, flat-keyboard accordion), they are somewhat uncommon. The Hohner Vienna-style 4-bass 1-rows are also good little boxes (especially with a little modification) but show up every week.
As Theo mentioned above (and melodeon implied by calling the Serenelli a "project"), you might want to figure into your budget the overhaul that an older box will likely need. That will cost some time and hassle factor as well as the money, and you will have to make some decisions about what work to do and who can do it for you. But if you want a box like that, I think you would find it expensive to order a new one!
PG
-
Buying secondhand instruments off ebay is a complete lottery.
Just bought a Club off Ebay to practice tuning on and recieved a Clarise Cliffe vase, now thats a lottery
New package reported at Chez Bailey so hopefully my melodeon has arrived :||:
-
Read it wrong but my posted opinion stands...