Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: GbH on January 28, 2010, 06:38:29 PM

Title: Apple iPad
Post by: GbH on January 28, 2010, 06:38:29 PM
As I'm sure many of you will have already heard, Apple finally announced the release of their much-anticipated 'tablet computer' - the iPad - yesterday.  If you've not seen it, there's lots of info at http://gizmodo.com/5458292/apple-ipad-everything-you-need-to-know (http://gizmodo.com/5458292/apple-ipad-everything-you-need-to-know).  Some people are already, perhaps understandably, dismissing it as just "an iPhone that won't fit in your pocket" whereas others are getting predictably excited, perhaps just because it's new and shiny.   Personally, I'll reserve judgement until I see one.  However, from a melodeon playing point of view, two intriguing possibilities spring to mind straight away.

Firstly, it seems very possible that this device will be MUCH more suitable for hosting a melodeon simulation app.  Although Michael Eskin has proven that a concertina sim can work on an iPhone, I'm not so sure that a melodeon sim would be so effective on the smaller platform.  However, on the new device there would be no such problem, with enough screen space to include plenty of buttons for both the treble and bass ends.  Of course, even if this worked well, I doubt it would be considered worthy of being a Streb replacement as such.  However, as something to practice on in a quiet environment or when travelling, it could be much better than nothing.

Secondly, it would seem possible that the new device could function very well as a great ABC viewing tool.  Trying to view a score on an iPhone/Touch isn't particularly satisfactory and I wouldn't really consider using one as a replacement for printed music.  However, the iPad's screen is surely big enough to display a complete folk tune score large enough to be sight read.  I guess it would be fine for those people that can play from ABC directly, too.  So, yes, it seems that before too long, we could be carrying a device that would be able to call up and display pretty much whatever tune you want to see in an instant.  If nothing else, it would save carrying big piles of books and printouts to practice sessions.

Any thoughts?
Title: Re: Apple iPad
Post by: Quebecois on January 28, 2010, 06:40:51 PM
It can also display documents like an e-Book and play media files! Can come handy in that area, you could carry your library of audio files and score sheets.

But it seems there was already something called iPad here (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FTzhXMbOWHE).
Title: Re: Apple iPad
Post by: Eric Barker on January 28, 2010, 07:10:09 PM
It would be cool to have a melodeon function esp. if the push/pull sequence could be worked out on the same plane as a real melodeon.  (I think the anglo iphone has to be tilted up and down-could a melodeon go side-to-side?)  One could try all sorts of keyboards with basses.  But,  do you set up thumb straps?  One strap? Two? a harness?? Perhaps a clip to hold it on to your shirt.
Is it possible to have too much fun? 

Eric in Montana
Title: Re: Apple iPad
Post by: Quebecois on January 28, 2010, 09:11:47 PM
Is it possible to have too much fun? 
Absolutely NOT  :D
Title: Re: Apple iPad
Post by: Owen Woods on January 29, 2010, 01:07:00 AM
I think that an iPad could be really quite interesting, although it seems like they've missed a few tricks this time round. The potential for e-melodeons is exciting though (:)
Title: Re: Apple iPad
Post by: Bill the Farmer on January 30, 2010, 12:41:32 PM
I've looked into this, AFAICT you need to pay out at least $99 to be a iPhone/iPad developer, and I suspect the licence you have to agree to conflicts with the GNU General Public License, so you may not be able to give the app away free. And you need a Mac to develop on.

So, although I would love to have a go, I'm not going there unless the situation changes.
Title: Re: Apple iPad
Post by: boxlad on January 30, 2010, 12:46:22 PM
The i-pad looks promising however I wont be rushing out to buy it just yet. I'm certain that in a year or less there will be a second generation model with all the little issues that will arise solved and I'm sure a few upgrades also (webcametc). This is always the way with new tecnhology as happened with the i-phone.
Title: Re: Apple iPad
Post by: GbH on January 30, 2010, 01:38:55 PM
I've looked into this, AFAICT you need to pay out at least $99 to be a iPhone/iPad developer, and I suspect the licence you have to agree to conflicts with the GNU General Public License, so you may not be able to give the app away free. And you need a Mac to develop on.

So, although I would love to have a go, I'm not going there unless the situation changes.

Yes, you'd need a Mac and to sign up as a developer.  I don't know why there'd be a problem with giving the apps away, though - lots, perhaps most, of apps are freely available.  You would have to distribute them through Apple, though.

If you wanted to get in to mobile development, but didn't want to go down the Apple route, then you might consider developing for the Android system (i.e. the 'Google phone' and its many similar devices) instead.  I believe dev tools are freely available, well documented and based roughly around Java.  The downside would be that multi-touch doesn't seem to be standard on those devices as yet (which you'd probably want to use for an instrument emulation) and, perhaps more obviously, the user base isn't nearly as large.
Title: Re: Apple iPad
Post by: Howard Jones on January 30, 2010, 06:08:38 PM

Secondly, it would seem possible that the new device could function very well as a great ABC viewing tool. 
On another forum someone (Johnny Adams, I think) was extolling the virtues of one of the electronic book readers for displaying music.  Apparently it can display pdf files, which makes it a handy way of carrying round large quantities of music.
Title: Re: Apple iPad
Post by: mikesamwild on January 31, 2010, 05:59:07 PM
Just putting down a marker  for the m'Scroll
lI was watching a TV film on ancient Egypt and thought the papyrus scroll was a neat solution.  the concept could be further developed.

A cylinder as long as convenient or desired, and of a diameter determined by miniturisation,  could contain the hardware and software and a LED screen pulled out, like on a slide projector screen.  It could be held rigid by steel edges like extending measuring tape rules. This would give a nice square screen of suitable size.

All the work could be done with a stylus (like an etchasketch) with the gizmo recognising writing or allowing the apps symbols to be touched and activated, or maybe with voice recognition ,and there could be a touch keyboard too.  It would fit in my inside pocket with my tin whistle  and could be useful to play as a melodeon too. All the sound could come out of it or it could be lnked to those small stereo speakers.

When not in use the screen could be pulled out and act as a solar panel to charge it up.


Can I copyright a concept? or find a friendly geek to come into partnership???
Title: Re: Apple iPad
Post by: GbH on January 31, 2010, 06:21:18 PM
Just putting down a marker  for the m'Scroll
lI was watching a TV film on ancient Egypt and thought the papyrus scroll was a neat solution.  the concept could be further developed.

A cylinder as long as convenient or desired, and of a diameter determined by miniturisation,  could contain the hardware and software and a LED screen pulled out, like on a slide projector screen.  It could be held rigid by steel edges like extending measuring tape rules. This would give a nice square screen of suitable size.

All the work could be done with a stylus (like an etchasketch) with the gizmo recognising writing or allowing the apps symbols to be touched and activated, or maybe with voice recognition ,and there could be a touch keyboard too.  It would fit in my inside pocket with my tin whistle  and could be useful to play as a melodeon too. All the sound could come out of it or it could be lnked to those small stereo speakers.

When not in use the screen could be pulled out and act as a solar panel to charge it up.


Can I copyright a concept? or find a friendly geek to come into partnership???

Do you mean something like this? 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o-A8LMTVqAo (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o-A8LMTVqAo)

The e-paper idea has been around for a while now.  We got some early prototypes in our office quite a few years back, when it could only really be used to display a few black rectangles.  We still have these early sample sheets, which are now only fit for use as a particularly rubbish Christmas decoration.  Actually, that's pretty much all they were good for in the first place, but you can now at least see where the technology was headed.
Title: Re: Apple iPad
Post by: mikesamwild on February 01, 2010, 12:41:30 PM
That's  a nice clip.  what kept the screen rigid?
Title: Re: Apple iPad
Post by: Bill the Farmer on February 01, 2010, 03:59:18 PM
I've looked into this, AFAICT you need to pay out at least $99 to be a iPhone/iPad developer, and I suspect the licence you have to agree to conflicts with the GNU General Public License, so you may not be able to give the app away free. And you need a Mac to develop on.

So, although I would love to have a go, I'm not going there unless the situation changes.

Yes, you'd need a Mac and to sign up as a developer.  I don't know why there'd be a problem with giving the apps away, though - lots, perhaps most, of apps are freely available.  You would have to distribute them through Apple, though.

If you wanted to get in to mobile development, but didn't want to go down the Apple route, then you might consider developing for the Android system (i.e. the 'Google phone' and its many similar devices) instead.  I believe dev tools are freely available, well documented and based roughly around Java.  The downside would be that multi-touch doesn't seem to be standard on those devices as yet (which you'd probably want to use for an instrument emulation) and, perhaps more obviously, the user base isn't nearly as large.

I can sign up as an iPhone developer for free, but that doesn't get me the latest development kit needed for iPad development. I would imagine that will change. Ho Hum!
Title: Re: Apple iPad
Post by: Earbrass on February 01, 2010, 04:08:50 PM
On another forum someone (Johnny Adams, I think) was extolling the virtues of one of the electronic book readers for displaying music.  Apparently it can display pdf files, which makes it a handy way of carrying round large quantities of music.

A USB-connected foot-switch to turn the page would be handy.
Title: Re: Apple iPad
Post by: Accordion Dave on February 02, 2010, 01:56:56 PM
Here we go with the alphabet soup again.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal