Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: melodeon on January 30, 2010, 12:20:41 AM

Title: Erica
Post by: melodeon on January 30, 2010, 12:20:41 AM
I found a virtually unplayed  early 80's Erica for sale.
It is red.. my least favorite color..
Key of C/F  also not my favorite..
The owner got it new in Germany in 1982 and appears to have played it a couple hours ,no more.
He is not an accordeon player

He looked on the internet at new prices so he wants $900 US

I explained to him  popularity of the various key systems and the years and so on...

I suggested  $4-600  would be fair considering Red and C/F

Were it Black and G/C  or Bb/Eb or A/D  I might offer $700 ish

I do have a set of G/C reeds but that would leave me with a RED  box.

Any thoughts... ?

Or anyone else interested in spending $900 for a red  C/F  Erica.

I want to be fair with him.. but do not want to overpay

I am willing to pass.

The last Erica style box I bought was a very fine  Corso in C/F and I paid  $35.35  ( thirty five dollars and thirty five cents)

There is a mint Pokerwork available for $600  also in C/F  also German and unplayed. More to my liking.



Title: Re: Erica
Post by: burnt nial on January 30, 2010, 01:52:08 AM
I try to keep track of Ericas and Double Rays on ebay and various accordion dealers. If it is really in perfect shape it might make $700 on ebay and $800 at a dealer's. I see red Ericas all the time in C/F going anywhere from $400 to $600.
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Andrew Culwell on January 30, 2010, 02:11:47 AM
Another player of Double Rays and Erica's here, I think he is way overboard with the price.  Pass on this one, another nice Erica will come along and be much more reasonable.  Or this guy will have to post his Erica again after it doesn't sell.  Either way if your patient you will get a better deal.
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Lars on January 30, 2010, 08:40:20 AM
If you need a C/F Erica, let me know.

Around here in Denmark, there's most of the time a handfull for sale, good to mint condition, for 100-150 euros. Nobody likes 'em around here in that tuning!
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: theSmoiler on January 30, 2010, 04:58:45 PM

I do have a set of G/C reeds but that would leave me with a RED  box.


What's wrong with red melodeons.... :'( :|||:
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: LDbosca on January 30, 2010, 06:12:06 PM

I do have a set of G/C reeds but that would leave me with a RED  box.


What's wrong with red melodeons.... :'( :|||:

They're ugly.

Now let the arguments begin!!! ;)
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: ladydetemps on January 30, 2010, 06:26:00 PM
Red melodeons are cool. You just need red shoes to match.
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Andrew Culwell on January 30, 2010, 08:32:43 PM

I do have a set of G/C reeds but that would leave me with a RED  box.


What's wrong with red melodeons.... :'( :|||:
Seems like red melodeons don't get any respect around here with the musical furniture crowd  <ducks tomatoes>  They seem to personify all that is evil and kitschy in the accordion world.  Me I just keep making my red hot-rod more souped up, as a matter of fact the reed upgrade is in the offing, hello Binci TAM, <chortles with glee at the dismayed expressions>  Of course I have my eyes on one of those sweet sounding walnut furnishings myself, however I don't think I'll ever quit playing or toting my bright red Double Ray to sessions.
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Andy Simpson on January 30, 2010, 08:49:36 PM

 Me I just keep making my red hot-rod more souped up, as a matter of fact the reed upgrade is in the offing, hello Binci TAM, <chortles with glee at the dismayed expressions>  

*cough*Ferrari engine in a 2CV*cough*  ;D
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Andrew Culwell on January 30, 2010, 08:55:36 PM

 Me I just keep making my red hot-rod more souped up, as a matter of fact the reed upgrade is in the offing, hello Binci TAM, <chortles with glee at the dismayed expressions>  

*cough*Ferrari engine in a 2CV*cough*  ;D

As I recall plenty of Ferrari's are red!  As for the engineering in the box itself I'll probably have that Double Ray when I'm 70 and it will be as playable as any Casta on the block and maybe sound as good to my ears!
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Tyker on January 30, 2010, 09:53:07 PM
I found a virtually unplayed  early 80's Erica for sale.
It is red.. my least favorite color..
Key of C/F  also not my favorite..




You are  just a colourist !
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: theSmoiler on January 31, 2010, 12:06:26 AM

I do have a set of G/C reeds but that would leave me with a RED  box.


What's wrong with red melodeons.... :'( :|||:

They're ugly.

Now let the arguments begin!!! ;)

Not if they are a hand-made, one-off in wood from a well-respected English manufacturer - they are gorgeous!
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: melodeon on January 31, 2010, 01:52:47 AM
Having worked on and driven Ferraris  and 2CV's ,  I prefer 2CV's
Ferraris remind me of my ex.. fast around corners and not particularly reliable

I love red.. just not Hohner Red.. it flat sucks , gag o matic, ugly, hideous, garrish, cheap looking, lipstick on a prig...clown barf is prettier....

I will  except the new XTREME series Coronas... That red is different

When I first heard about the Erica ,  I had the price of $300 fixed in my head as fair for a RED  C/F... even a mint one.
When he told me $900 I was shocked into silence (rare condition)  It took me a moment to regroup and brought to mind all my former
corporate talky talky man skills to address the issue of the price being way  high for what he had.  I fear he was prepped by an acordeon playing friend(generous but misguided and misinformed)   One not an accordeon player ,and the other a Tex Mex style 3 row player  where red is god and G with CF
makes another CF desirable.  The owner then went to the internet.. and the rest is recent history.
I don't think he realizes that accordeons depreciate , and just as with cars.. condition is important but so is the right model and right engine and right color in determining value.... The only thing going for this accordeon is the condition.   All else "subtracts" from its value.   A black G/C with a wood rather than plastic keyboard would make it worth more.. but this is not the case. The least desireable color and key system.  And not old enough to be
"the right vintage" .


Thanks for all the replies.

Title: Re: Erica
Post by: waltzman on January 31, 2010, 02:01:49 AM
Having worked on and driven Ferraris  and 2CV's ,  I prefer 2CV's
Ferraris remind me of my ex.. fast around corners and not particularly reliable

I love red.. just not Hohner Red.. it flat sucks , gag o matic, ugly, hideous, garrish, cheap looking, lipstick on a prig...clown barf is prettier....

I will  except the new XTREME series Coronas... That red is different

The swiss Hohner red celluloid is also different.... very nice in my opinion.
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: melodeon on January 31, 2010, 02:08:21 AM
And so was the garnet or "cabernet" red on the "pre" Coronas.  Very nice.. but standard run of the mill Erica red..not so nice.

Erica The Red.....   did he not invade Ireland  or was it   ... ?
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Andrew Culwell on January 31, 2010, 04:03:05 AM
Having worked on and driven Ferraris  and 2CV's ,  I prefer 2CV's
Ferraris remind me of my ex.. fast around corners and not particularly reliable

I love red.. just not Hohner Red.. it flat sucks , gag o matic, ugly, hideous, garrish, cheap looking, lipstick on a prig...clown barf is prettier....

I will  except the new XTREME series Coronas... That red is different

When I first heard about the Erica ,  I had the price of $300 fixed in my head as fair for a RED  C/F... even a mint one.
When he told me $900 I was shocked into silence (rare condition)  It took me a moment to regroup and brought to mind all my former
corporate talky talky man skills to address the issue of the price being way  high for what he had.  I fear he was prepped by an acordeon playing friend(generous but misguided and misinformed)   One not an accordeon player ,and the other a Tex Mex style 3 row player  where red is god and G with CF
makes another CF desirable.  The owner then went to the internet.. and the rest is recent history.
I don't think he realizes that accordeons depreciate , and just as with cars.. condition is important but so is the right model and right engine and right color in determining value.... The only thing going for this accordeon is the condition.   All else "subtracts" from its value.   A black G/C with a wood rather than plastic keyboard would make it worth more.. but this is not the case. The least desireable color and key system.  And not old enough to be
"the right vintage" .


Thanks for all the replies.


All this talk about red but what really matters is what's  under the hood! 
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: strad on January 31, 2010, 12:26:30 PM
My Paolo's red and it's great, so there!

Nigel
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Owen Woods on January 31, 2010, 12:41:15 PM

I do have a set of G/C reeds but that would leave me with a RED  box.


What's wrong with red melodeons.... :'( :|||:

They're ugly.

Now let the arguments begin!!! ;)

Not if they are a hand-made, one-off in wood from a well-respected English manufacturer - they are gorgeous!

Were you at Sidmouth? There was a red, wooden (very nice) box from a well-respected English manufacturer there...

Anyway, I don't think that red boxes are the most attractive in the world, although I have nothing particularly against red. And the gorgeous red of the Lilliput is of course an exception :P
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: nfldbox on January 31, 2010, 05:09:22 PM
This is no doubt too obvious to say but, always being willing to try the obvious: regardless of the many very good boxes in red celluloid isn't this the most common finish on the cheap Chinese boxes? Which could lead to some prejudice against it. When I bought my first box, used from O'Brien's in St. John's, there were a couple of Hohners and all the rest were Chinese with Italian names. And your choice of colour was red, red, red or red. Thus the prejudice against red. If one has a fine red box and is a bit proud of it, one would be tempted to have a big sign saying "REGARDLESS OF THE COLOUR THIS IS A ......."
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: forrest on January 31, 2010, 05:25:15 PM
Having worked on and driven Ferraris  and 2CV's ,  I prefer 2CV's
Ferraris remind me of my ex.. fast around corners and not particularly reliable

I love red.. just not Hohner Red.. it flat sucks , gag o matic, ugly, hideous, garrish, cheap looking, lipstick on a prig...clown barf is prettier....

I will  except the new XTREME series Coronas... That red is different

When I first heard about the Erica ,  I had the price of $300 fixed in my head as fair for a RED  C/F... even a mint one.
When he told me $900 I was shocked into silence (rare condition)  It took me a moment to regroup and brought to mind all my former
corporate talky talky man skills to address the issue of the price being way  high for what he had.  I fear he was prepped by an acordeon playing friend(generous but misguided and misinformed)   One not an accordeon player ,and the other a Tex Mex style 3 row player  where red is god and G with CF
makes another CF desirable.  The owner then went to the internet.. and the rest is recent history.
I don't think he realizes that accordeons depreciate , and just as with cars.. condition is important but so is the right model and right engine and right color in determining value.... The only thing going for this accordeon is the condition.   All else "subtracts" from its value.   A black G/C with a wood rather than plastic keyboard would make it worth more.. but this is not the case. The least desireable color and key system.  And not old enough to be
"the right vintage" .


Thanks for all the replies.






 In light of the above comments, I would advise you to let it go................ 8)
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Bob Ellis on January 31, 2010, 05:34:58 PM
What's wrong with red melodeons.... :'( :|||:

They're ugly.


Not if they are a hand-made, one-off in wood from a well-respected English manufacturer - they are gorgeous!

I have thought about stealing your gorgeous red Oakwood.  >:E  The only thing stopping me is the knowledge that it would never sound as good in my hands as it does in yours.  :'(
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Andrew Culwell on January 31, 2010, 05:54:28 PM
This is no doubt too obvious to say but, always being willing to try the obvious: regardless of the many very good boxes in red celluloid isn't this the most common finish on the cheap Chinese boxes? Which could lead to some prejudice against it. When I bought my first box, used from O'Brien's in St. John's, there were a couple of Hohners and all the rest were Chinese with Italian names. And your choice of colour was red, red, red or red. Thus the prejudice against red. If one has a fine red box and is a bit proud of it, one would be tempted to have a big sign saying "REGARDLESS OF THE COLOUR THIS IS A ......."
How's the saying go?  "imitation is the highest form of flattery"  Nuff said!   This thread I think has been highjacked so I'm off to play my red Hohner, you will never get me to feel blue about red!
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Rob2Hook on February 01, 2010, 12:34:47 PM
What's wrong with red melodeons.... :'( :|||:

Well, this one's not an Oakwood...
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: LDbosca on February 01, 2010, 01:12:22 PM
You're really going to put Binci TAM reeds in it? That's incredible.
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Gandy on February 01, 2010, 02:22:31 PM
You're really going to put Binci TAM reeds in it? That's incredible.
How much would that cost?   Roughly, for a 2 voice 21 key box.
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: LDbosca on February 01, 2010, 02:32:39 PM
Put it this way, you're half way to buying a good accordion buying those reeds and having them put in. The dancemaster site has prices for reed replacements: http://www.irishdancemaster.com/reeds.html
It's in dollars but it gives you an idea.
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: ladydetemps on February 01, 2010, 02:37:33 PM
What's wrong with red melodeons.... :'( :|||:

They're ugly.


Not if they are a hand-made, one-off in wood from a well-respected English manufacturer - they are gorgeous!

I have thought about stealing your gorgeous red Oakwood.  >:E  The only thing stopping me is the knowledge that it would never sound as good in my hands as it does in yours.  :'(
Wanted to run off with it myself. lol!
http://3276.e-printphoto.co.uk/suffolk/index.cfm?z=z&y=y&p_id=12724430&c_id=87684&action=view
You know if you ever consider getting rid of it Diane...let me know. ;)
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Andrew Culwell on February 01, 2010, 02:56:09 PM
You're really going to put Binci TAM reeds in it? That's incredible.
It's really fascinating the kind of reactions I've gotten to replacing the reeds with high end reeds particularly on this forum.  They range from, "what's wrong with the Hohner reeds, you'll ruin the Hohner sound"  to "Putting  Binci TAM reeds in a Hohner is like putting a diamond necklace on a pig"  
I see it this way:  If you love Hohners and your a Hohner purist your going to hate the idea.  If your an italian box snob then your going to hate the idea.  It really is about what I want out of my box.  I listen to Martin Quinn a fine player and I believe he plays a hohner with high end reeds in it.  I love the sound he gets from his box and to that end that is where I'm heading.  In my opinion and my current tuner and technician agrees with me, the Hohner can be just as fine a  box with some re-engineering and high end reeds.  The color and the look of the box don't mean squat!  Of course I'm a relatively new player and approach this maybe from a less orthodox position.  If your a italian box playing fundamentalist then you will always spurn the Hohner and that's okay.  In terms of the design of the box I'm of the opinion that it's the reeds that make a huge difference in the sound.  Yes the acoustic chamber or whatever you choose to call it has an impact on the box overall sound.  I'm of the opinion that the Hohners are engineered in the Hohner way no less quality but different in that aspect.  IMHO.  Some may disagree, they have every right to there opinion, but that is all it is.  Altogether the upgrade will put my cost at about 2000.00 for the DR, in my opinion not a bad investment in a box that I intend to keep for my lifetime.
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: LDbosca on February 01, 2010, 03:06:43 PM
You're really going to put Binci TAM reeds in it? That's incredible.
It's really fascinating the kind of reactions that gets on this forum.  They range from, "what's wrong with the Hohner reeds, you'll ruin the Hohner sound"  to "Putting  Binci TAM reeds in a Hohner is like putting a diamond necklace on a pig" 
I see it this way:  If you love Hohners and your a Hohner purist your going to hate the idea.  If your an italian box snob then your going to hate the idea.  It really is about what I want out of my box.  I listen to Martin Quinn a fine player and I believe he plays a hohner with high end reeds in it.  I love the sound he gets from his box and to that end that is where I'm heading.  In my opinion and my current tuner and technician agrees with me, the Hohner can be just as fine a  box with some re-engineering and high end reeds.  The color and the look of the box don't mean squat!  Of course I'm a relatively new player and approach this maybe from a less orthodox position.  If your a italian box playing fundamentalist then you will always spurn the Hohner and that's okay.  In terms of the design of the box I'm of the opinion that it's the reeds that make a huge difference in the sound.  Yes the acoustic chamber or whatever you choose to call it has an impact on the box overall sound.  I'm of the opinion that the Hohners are engineered in the Hohner way no less quality but different in that aspect.  IMHO.  Some may disagree, they have every right to there opinion, but that is all it is.  Altogether the upgrade will put my cost at about 2000.00 for the DR, in my opinion not a bad investment in a box that I intend to keep for my lifetime.

It just strikes me as a bit funny that someone who admits to being new to the instrument would be so certain that this is a good idea. I would have thought that strong opinions on instrument type would be developed through extensive experience. I know that I didn't have the playing experience to judge an instrument well until I had been playing for at least 5 years. My playing also had to reach a certain level of sensitivity before I could judge the responsiveness of any particular instrument/reed combination.

Have you contacted Martin Quinn to see what configuration he has? It could just be dry tuned Hohner reeds, give him a shout if you're really determined to get his sound.

At the end of the day it's your money and if you're really sure that this is the best reed/instrument/value for what you get combination then by all means do it.
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Gandy on February 01, 2010, 03:32:16 PM
I wish I had a chance to see the end result.  Personally I like the idea of an upgraded Hohner, although its probably irrational.   I see that you used to have a Corso with upgraded reeds.  Other than the reeds, what else did you do to upgrade it, for example did you lighten the mechanism or pallets, or replace the pallet leather?
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Andrew Culwell on February 01, 2010, 03:53:04 PM
Actually this isn't a project that I've undertaken without any input from more experienced boxplayers.   My rational for spending the kind of money is this.  I have already put 1300.00 into the Double Ray with a keyboard replacement and adjustment and find the action and performance to be superb, as does my mentor and teacher who himself plays a Casta.  He also feels that the accordion sounds great since Michael at Dancemaster adjusted the tremolo on the stock Hohner reeds.  I could turn around and sell my DR getting perhaps 800.00 for it if that, but I have an attachment to it as it has been quite a good box. 

That said it was Michael at Dancemaster who initiated the idea of putting the Binci's in.  His estimation of the box was that it was a great lightweight box with an upgraded keyboard with great action and response.  So my options were sell the DR and get a fraction of what I put into it, keep it and buy a high end italian box, that might not meet my needs and that I would have to buy without playing as there are no retail sellers of those boxes within driving distance so I'd be getting an unknown quantity.  The upgrade will cost 800.00 and that puts my investment at 2000.00 on a box I already love and am accustomed to playing.  I've had no less than 3 other advanced players ask me to play the box and they have been impressed with it's performance and playability, they play Casta's and Cairdins themselves and seem to think the idea of putting Binci's in the Hohner to be interesting and possibly worthwhile. 

The Corso had Cagnoni import reeds placed in it and was converted from C/F to B/C and the reason it didn't work out was that I really prefer the weight and performance of the Double Ray and had a hard time adjusting to playing the heavier, more clumsy Corso.  Plus it only allowed me to play in three voice mode. So it's on it's way to a player in Ireland who was extremely pleased to get it.  So while I would probably love to have a Castagnari or Saltarelle and will eventually get one I don't see the Reed upgrade as illogical in the least. 
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: LDbosca on February 01, 2010, 04:45:29 PM
Glad you've thought about it so much, I hope it turns out like you want it to. :||:
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Alison Scott on February 01, 2010, 05:20:23 PM

I do have a set of G/C reeds but that would leave me with a RED  box.


What's wrong with red melodeons.... :'( :|||:

Oh, I love my red Liliput (as seen on Ashokan Farewell on YouTube). In fact, the only comment I got on the video was about the exceptional beauty of the box rather than the tune or my playing.
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Andrew Culwell on February 01, 2010, 06:41:50 PM
Believe me I agree with the above statements with regard to the kind of red celluloid that is used now as opposed to what was used on those beautiful Ruby Lilliputs that Hohner made years ago.  That said I'm not so fussy that I need to strip off the current less satisfying red celluloid.
Title: Re: Erica
Post by: Andrew Culwell on February 02, 2010, 06:31:47 PM
So I put the question to Martin Quinn through email and he was kind enough to give me an answer about his box.  This is what he said:  

"My hohner has a lot of different features ,reedblocks made by briggs,old paolo soprani reeds, new bellows, handmade fingerboard,

I don't work with binci reeds i use voce armoniche or cagnoni TAM reeds, both of these are excellent in quality but binci are good if you can get them.
they give you a cleaner sound nice tone.

Now I'm not going to be able to get Reed blocks designed by Briggs but I am having the Binci TAM put in and already have the new keyboard.  The Bellows might come later as I need them, If I could get old Paolo reeds I wouldn't hesitate to use them.  Martin is a technician so I'm sure he did most of this stuff himself, except for the reed blocks.  good enough for Martin is good enough for me. (now if I could only play as well as he!)

--Drew
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal