Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Owen Woods on January 31, 2010, 01:03:20 PM
-
About a week ago I won an auction for what looked to be an interesting box. Poorly described (spelt "accordion" wrong) and pickup only, so unsurprisingly few went for it. I picked it up yesterday, which took nearly 5 hours longer than I would have hoped, due to lots of things going wrong, but I now have a new box.
It is (as I thought from the pictures) a Casali Verona, BCC#. This is exciting, because I have wanted a box with 12*4 stradella bass for quite some time. It is not in perfect condition, not by any means, but for �52 I don't think I could have done much better.
Damage report: No bellows straps, no case, needs new bass strap and new shoulder straps. None of that is a particular problem, although taking it back on the train from Colchester and then walking the 20 minutes through Cambridge to my house with it strapped to my chest was interesting :P Needs a retune, obviously, although it isn't sounding catastrophic on the bass end. Treble side bellows gasket is leaking all over the pace, as is the treble bottom bellows strap bracket (what's left of it). Fingerboard and grille are slightly bent, which I think is what is making the treble mechanism clicking a little. Plus the bass mechanism is a little sluggish. I will take it to pieces today and see what's what. I'm hoping that quite a lot of it I will be able to do myself, it's just the tuning which I will have to pass on to Theo or Rees or someone. Might bring the reedblocks to M&M in March and save myself some postage.
I am half tempted to convert it to C#DG, as although I am learning BCC# (I have a trichord), I would really like to mess around with the bass now, using a fingering that I can more easily get to grips with. The C# could just be directly transplanted, a fair few reedplates from the C row could be used in in the G and possibly with some judicious retuning the D row could be constructed out of some of the B row. Unfortunately I think that it would most likely be so expensive that I would have to sell my Trichord (which also needs tuning) in order to finance it, which would mean giving up on BCC#. So I would have to chose between two systems without properly trying them out.
Opinions/Advice?
-
I've only known 2 or 3 people who have tried c#/d/g and all of them have gone back to d/g or on to c#/d. It strikes me that c#/d/g is not a happy combination in practice. In theory I agree it looks great, but I think the learning effort would be more fruitful invested in one system or the other rather than the mongrel child.
-
I've only known 2 or 3 people who have tried c#/d/g and all of them have gone back to d/g or on to c#/d. It strikes me that c#/d/g is not a happy combination in practice. In theory I agree it looks great, but I think the learning effort would be more fruitful invested in one system or the other rather than the mongrel child.
What about me? Though to be candid I play it essentially as a D/G - with lots of flattened notes relative to the D row and I've filed the duplicated F# and C notes to more useful things.
-
I've only known 2 or 3 people who have tried c#/d/g and all of them have gone back to d/g or on to c#/d. It strikes me that c#/d/g is not a happy combination in practice. In theory I agree it looks great, but I think the learning effort would be more fruitful invested in one system or the other rather than the mongrel child.
What about me? Though to be candid I play it essentially as a D/G - with lots of flattened notes relative to the D row and I've filed the duplicated F# and C notes to more useful things.
In a way Chris I think your experience reinforces what I was trying to say. Which was to advise Ukebert to stick with a "standard" system and learn one of them first before deciding to spend large sums of money in an experimental conversion.
-
When I started I thought C#/D/G looked like a good idea too. But now I think it's a case of over-hybridization. On most 3-row boxes you'd end up with too short a G row and too long a C# row - and a D row that ought to be longer, too.
-
When I started I thought C#/D/G looked like a good idea too. But now I think it's a case of over-hybridization. On most 3-row boxes you'd end up with too short a G row and too long a C# row - and a D row that ought to be longer, too.
There's a physical issue with the reed blocks, but paradoxically I saw the long C# row as an advantage (the rows run 11,10,9) as it was non D/G notes I was after.
I took more than a year to get used to it and to decide it was right to file those reeds, and wrong to club it. 'Having invested the time' my F#/G/C was commissioned 'same system' (Gaillard was not happy). As we never seem to get up to the top end on D/G - the shorter rows didn't irritate. Gaillard 's 3-row is (10,11/10) so not a problem on that one either. But I seem to have achieved this optimisation more by luck than judgement.
Note I only play it as a C#D when doing a Bb or F blues (or actually playing in C#). But there are some fascinating scales that live mostly on the G and C# rows!
-
but for £52 I don't think I could have done much better.
Jammy. 8)
I am half tempted to convert it to C#DG...
I'd say no. As a C#/D/G user with experience of size/weight issues, you'd end up with something too heavy. :Ph
Stick with B/C/C#. As nature intended. ;D
And at least when/if you need to sell, you haven't wasted time/money fixing up something that's too obscure to shift...
(If you want a cheap C#/D/G, look for an A/D/G Corona - or DDR lookalike - and get the outer row block tweaked...)
I've only known 2 or 3 people who have tried c#/d/g and all of them have gone back to d/g or on to c#/d. It strikes me that c#/d/g is not a happy combination in practice. In theory I agree it looks great, but I think the learning effort would be more fruitful invested in one system or the other rather than the mongrel child.
Conversely, I've known several people who have tried C#/D/G, and stuck with it. And use d/g or c#/d as well.
Simon Knight (RIP) or Neil Browning (http://www.neilandmeg.com/simonsbox.shtml) are another couple of bods who spring to mind...
As far as I'm concerned, it works perfectly well in theory and practice. And saves having to cart a carload of boxes around... ::)
Happy to be another mongrel child... 8)
Woof woof woof... Grrrrrrrr.... ;D
Ed J
-
Eejay,
I have also tried and liked C#/D/G. The main complaint I have (when going cheap with a Hohner club body as a starting point) is that I want more than 8 bass buttons, to get the basses I want in the right directions to coordinate with all the right hand fingering options.
I have to ask if the Simon Knight (RIP) you mentioned is the brother of Patrick and Andrew. If so I learned a couple of my first English tunes from him when I was living in Bangor, Wales in the mid-1980s. I was a guitar and piano player just learning about boxes back then but I remember the tunes and his early advice very well. I think he was playing both D/G and B/C instruments at that time, so very interesting if he also played C#/D/G.
PG
-
There's a picture of Simon Knight on http://www.neilandmeg.com/simonsbox.shtml and the larger original(?) here (http://www.neilandmeg.com/gallery.shtml) Dunno about Simon (doesn't look too like his brothers) but you've met him and I've not. btw are Neil and Meg the same Brownings that used to do a music and jester act in the early 90's?
.. and an opportunity to thank Ed for introducing me to C#DG - it's worked for me.
-
I have also tried and liked C#/D/G. The main complaint I have (when going cheap with a Hohner club body as a starting point) is that I want more than 8 bass buttons...
That's why I suggested the Corona (Compadre or DDR clone) as a starting point, for 12 bass.
Though I do find that 18 bass is mighty useful... ;)
I have to ask if the Simon Knight (RIP) you mentioned is the brother of Patrick and Andrew. If so I learned a couple of my first English tunes from him when I was living in Bangor, Wales in the mid-1980s.
There's some more on Simon here (http://www.setdancingnews.net/news/onews13.lp#Simon)... and here (http://www.setdancingnews.net/news/onews16.lp#Priddy)... seems to be the same fellow.
And I'm fairly sure Bangor's where Neil B lives... I recall he is/was involved with Eryri Morris... (http://www.eryri-morris.org.uk/)
.. and an opportunity to thank Ed for introducing me to C#DG - it's worked for me.
Case in point... ;D
Ed J
-
In a way Chris I think your experience reinforces what I was trying to say. Which was to advise Ukebert to stick with a "standard" system and learn one of them first before deciding to spend large sums of money in an experimental conversion.
Well I have already learned D/G and to be frank, although it would be nice to play in every key under the sun, it isn't really necessary for what I want to play. I need to play in C, G, D, A, E, B and relative minors. By looking at the fingering charts, which I accept isn't the best way of finding out, it looks like those keys would be possible, with a little practice, on both BCC# and C#DG, although the latter would take me a lot less time to figure out and has the advantage that I can start to play it in sessions and for dance almost immediately, which is a lot of what I love about folk music. With a BCC# it will take me proportionally longer to learn just because I will have to reach a certain standard before I can play with others.
When I started I thought C#/D/G looked like a good idea too. But now I think it's a case of over-hybridization. On most 3-row boxes you'd end up with too short a G row and too long a C# row - and a D row that ought to be longer, too.
This is 11/12/11 8) My Saltarelle is 11/12.
I'd say no. As a C#/D/G user with experience of size/weight issues, you'd end up with something too heavy. :Ph
Stick with B/C/C#. As nature intended. ;D
And at least when/if you need to sell, you haven't wasted time/money fixing up something that's too obscure to shift...
(If you want a cheap C#/D/G, look for an A/D/G Corona - or DDR lookalike - and get the outer row block tweaked...)
That's interesting. Why would it be too heavy for C#DG but not for BCC#, because of the bellows jiggling? Thing is that I'm really a cross row player anyway, so at least in G and D, waggle isn't a problem. With a push C# and G#, A shouldn't be a problem either, E would be OK with a little care. As for C and B, C might be tricky, as it would go pull/push/pull/push/pull/push/pull/push, which is almost exactly the opposite from normal. I haven't really thought about B yet. Or F, but both look plausible.
And if I want to sell it then I think that I've done a bad job on this decision. I would love this bass so much that I am keen to make a mistake, not get along with it and then sell it, giving up the advantages of the bass end. Hence why I am asking melnet's opinion :P There will be plenty of time to think about it anyway. In the meantime, if anyone wants to lend me a C#D or a C#DG... ;)
I have also tried and liked C#/D/G. The main complaint I have (when going cheap with a Hohner club body as a starting point) is that I want more than 8 bass buttons, to get the basses I want in the right directions to coordinate with all the right hand fingering options.
This has 48 bass :P
-
Another option, Ukebert, would be a D/G with a full third row of accidentals. One reason I went for this system was because I was already familar with a D/G box and didn't want to learn a new system, but I did want to play in the keys you mentioned (and F as well!) This was the best decision I ever made because I still have my D and G rows, since most of the tunes I play are in those keys, but I also can play with relative ease in the other keys I want simply by using the accidentals on the third row - and I have the added bonus of reversals for the C, C#, D and E notes.
-
To a B/C/C# player you have what many of us consider the perfect instrument (4x12 stradella bass - ooooh!). Please don't mess with it - try the original tuning and if you don't like it after a bit, sell it on. T.
-
To a B/C/C# player you have what many of us consider the perfect instrument (4x12 stradella bass - ooooh!). Please don't mess with it - try the original tuning and if you don't like it after a bit, sell it on. T.
Even though I did defend C#/D/G as a useful system, I actually have a lot of sympathy with the above point of view also. Good quality instruments, especially if they are not common and especially if there is a community of players actually needing that type of instrument, deserve special respect and a second thought before modifying them. IMO.
PG
-
To a B/C/C# player you have what many of us consider the perfect instrument (4x12 stradella bass - ooooh!). Please don't mess with it - try the original tuning and if you don't like it after a bit, sell it on. T.
Even though I did defend C#/D/G as a useful system, I actually have a lot of sympathy with the above point of view also. Good quality instruments, especially if they are not common and especially if there is a community of players actually needing that type of instrument, deserve special respect and a second thought before modifying them. IMO.
PG
Aye and that is one of the major cons of modifying it I admit :|bl
-
Another option, Ukebert, would be a D/G with a full third row of accidentals. One reason I went for this system was because I was already familar with a D/G box and didn't want to learn a new system, but I did want to play in the keys you mentioned (and F as well!) This was the best decision I ever made because I still have my D and G rows, since most of the tunes I play are in those keys, but I also can play with relative ease in the other keys I want simply by using the accidentals on the third row - and I have the added bonus of reversals for the C, C#, D and E notes.
I did the same, using a key layout I got from Emmanuel Pariselle many years ago.
-
See to me an extra row of odds and sods seems a little inelegant. Plus I think that it would be easier to get the hang of if it were in a "logical" order.
-
Seems to me an extra row of odds and sods seems a little inelegant. Plus I think that it would be easier to get the hang of if it were in a "logical" order.
I don't agree. If we play in any key other than the standard keys of a diatonic box (e.g. D & G on a D/G box), we need to cross rows - and many of us cross rows in the principal keys as well. So one needs to learn the pattern of buttons for each non-standard key. (I do it by playing scales and arpeggios.) The patterns for keys that use notes from a third row of accidentals aren't inelegant, illogical or difficult to learn: they are just different from the patterns for the standard keys.
-
Seems to me an extra row of odds and sods seems a little inelegant. Plus I think that it would be easier to get the hang of if it were in a "logical" order.
I don't agree. If we play in any key other than the standard keys of a diatonic box (e.g. D & G on a D/G box), we need to cross rows - and many of us cross rows in the principal keys as well. So one needs to learn the pattern of buttons for each non-standard key. (I do it by playing scales and arpeggios.) The patterns for keys that use notes from a third row of accidentals aren't inelegant, illogical or difficult to learn: they are just different from the patterns for the standard keys.
Actually I take that back, if I did design a row of odds and sods it probably would be easy to learn. But I am OCD enough to really acre about stuff like this and it would bother me to have a row which didn't form some sort of nice pattern.
-
Actually I take that back, if I did design a row of odds and sods it probably would be easy to learn. But I am OCD enough to really acre about stuff like this and it would bother me to have a row which didn't form some sort of nice pattern.
Just because a row is accidentals it does not have to be random. A basic pattern can repeat up the octaves, same as a main row with the pull notes shifting up one for each octave higher. The difference is that you can choose which sharps/flats/reversals you find useful, rather than just accepting everything shifted by a semitone. Of course if your main purpose is to use the C# row for 'Irish' ornamentation then a semitone shift is the way to go, but then you probably would not want the G row!
I see you are not OCD enough to worry about spelling, so there is hope! ;D ;D
-
Actually I take that back, if I did design a row of odds and sods it probably would be easy to learn. But I am OCD enough to really acre about stuff like this and it would bother me to have a row which didn't form some sort of nice pattern.
Just because a row is accidentals it does not have to be random. A basic pattern can repeat up the octaves, same as a main row with the pull notes shifting up one for each octave higher.
As Theo knows, I have such a box - D/G with a full row of 9 accidentals set out just this way ie 4 + 4 + 1, up the octaves. Possibly going spare, as really too large for me to manage....
-
After playing it today (and taking bits of it apart to see how it worked) I have come to two conclusions. Firstly it needs a good fettle, I can see a number of small things wrong with it that add up to a bigger job than I can manage with the little time that I have. Secondly I have fallen head over heels in love with it :|bl It is a lot bigger than any box that I currently have, yet it feels small, compact and light.
I also played some BCC# for the first time in a few weeks and surprised myself by how much better I had become. If I can get this box (need to get my girlfriend to name it) retuned and fettled then it won't be long before I can play in sessions, which of course will make my playing better and better.
So I think that I shall keep it as BCC#, at least for now. I will probably have to sell my Trichord in order to finance this one. Rather unfortunate, since my Trichord needs a retune as well... I was going to get Theo to do it but ran out of money in a big way last term. Hopefully I'll still have some left by M&M and can hand it in there.