Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Peter Stormy Hyde on February 25, 2008, 09:25:25 AM

Title: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Peter Stormy Hyde on February 25, 2008, 09:25:25 AM
G'day Mates

In regards to the balsa wood reed blocks that has turned up in discussion on this news group, I have been using it for many years with fantastic results. I know this at first might sound a little silly but it is stable and does not interrupt or absorb the resonation set up in the cavity. At this point you need a timber that does not respond to frequencies as you want as much as you possible can to pass out off the accordion without any disruption by vibrating parts. My research has found in the last few years is that the timber of the accordion instrument needs to be inert, completely different to the guitar or violin type instruments, what we have in the accordion is closer to a speaker box. I have had a fantastic sounding piano accordion into my workshop for repairs that had Masonite (hardboard) sound boards, or should I say "dead boards."

If you are searching for good Balsa wood then look in the yellow pages under Balsa Wood, as it is used by architects and theater set makers (and surf board makers here in Aus')  and the darker harder stuff is cheaper as the trades want white balsa. You will find it far cheaper than the craft shop.

In my last batch of acoustic boxes I put it all to the test, and made a box that was made from 90% foam, and another flutina that had foam reed pans. Then testing with a frequency analyzer we found that we got a 33% increase in the lower partials and then it reduced to about 10-15% increase across the board in all the odd numbers with no increase in the evens. When I first played the 90 % foam box I thought I’d lost my top end as is sounded so very low.
And by the way it is very loud!

My mate who analyzes my instruments who is himself a top shelf instrument maker suggested it might be better to make accordions and concertinas from MDF! I do not have time to test that one, but it might be worth testing by someone.

Another plus about the foam that I’m using is that it has a memory, I have covered every surface with timber veneers, and I have been a little brutal with it to test out its survival probabilities, I have found that where a dent has been knocked into the instrument within a few days there will be no sign at all, as the foam pushes it back out again. This is not a cheap way of making an instrument as each surface has to be veneered, it is far cheaper time wise to use solid timber, but if someone needs a light instrument due to physical problems then this is the answer.


Although I made these box’s about 6 months ago this is the first time I have posted anywhere that I have done this, although my friend/customer base know about it, and a few have tested it. I will have it at the National Folk Festival and Port Fairy Folk Festivals here in Aus’ over the next month or so. 

Back to work, and Good Health Too You All.
Stormy
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Rob2Hook on February 25, 2008, 12:22:13 PM












(Speechless)
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Rob2Hook on February 25, 2008, 12:36:27 PM
No, actually I just wonder how incredibly different that must sound!  The choice of construction materials to affect tone is always interesting.  I have an old Castagnari Nik which can be piercing if played hard (something I'm often accused of).  The Dino Baffetti Black Pearl likewise and I believe both of these have aluminium "soundboards".  My Trilly has an incredibly thin tone when using just the dry tuned treble pair and an amazingly sound with the bass octave in - attack like a chisel in your ears - like a Cajun box.

The Hohner Pokerwork, on the other hand, with its long reeds has a much rounder tone (wooden board?) and even more so with the four-stop, tends to echo through the whole box. 

I'm guessing that with the resonance taken away, a foam box must be much more harmonica-like in tone?  What with that, the weight reduction (more muscle available to overblow it) and the self healing aspects you should be onto a winner.  Like a speaker cabinet...  I guess so (an alpine box is a bass reflex?), have you tried filling it with acoustic wool?
Could you put a soundbite on a website, please?
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: risto on February 25, 2008, 10:36:46 PM
Stormy's explanation makes sense also from another point of view:

An accordion reed produces a clear tone alone all by itself while a guitar string makes almost no noice if there is no soundboard resonating. (The reason for the difference being what?) Anyway, a resonating soundboard in an accordion should be very well "tuned" to give *nice* additional harmonics to the total harmonics and this would be a very difficult task for anyone. A none-resonating accordion costruction could leave the reeds sounding with their natural sound.

....or was that total rubbish?
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Peter Stormy Hyde on February 26, 2008, 10:42:13 AM
No, actually I just wonder how incredibly different that must sound!  The choice of construction materials to affect tone is always interesting.  I have an old Castagnari Nik which can be piercing if played hard (something I'm often accused of).  The Dino Baffetti Black Pearl likewise and I believe both of these have aluminium "soundboards".  My Trilly has an incredibly thin tone when using just the dry tuned treble pair and an amazingly sound with the bass octave in - attack like a chisel in your ears - like a Cajun box.

I have never used aluminum as sound boards, I have used mostly timber 3 ply that I make up using tonal timber as the filling in the sandwich, this could be a waste as it could be better used by the guitar makers.
Of course there is so many other things going on that I still have trouble making sense of it all, as one customer said he plays the accordion through his chest, but again that is an older box that has plenty of spruce in it, even as far as having spruce sandwiched between sheoak for the frames.

The Hohner Pokerwork, on the other hand, with its long reeds has a much rounder tone (wooden board?) and even more so with the four-stop, tends to echo through the whole box. 

I'm guessing that with the resonance taken away, a foam box must be much more harmonica-like in tone?


I have not thought of it that way but you are probably right, one of the noticable aspects of this the box it is very fast.

  What with that, the weight reduction (more muscle available to overblow it) and the self healing aspects you should be onto a winner.  Like a speaker cabinet...  I guess so (an alpine box is a bass reflex?), have you tried filling it with acoustic wool?

I have not tried the wool, but i will try it as soon as I can get some.

Could you put a soundbite on a website, please?

I will get a recording organised and I will post it up on youtube
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Alison Scott on February 26, 2008, 11:21:55 AM
G'day Mates

[loads of very interesting stuff snipped]

My mate who analyzes my instruments who is himself a top shelf instrument maker suggested it might be better to make accordions and concertinas from MDF! I do not have time to test that one, but it might be worth testing by someone.


Except of course that MDF is incredibly heavy, which probably argues against its use as an instrument frame. Maybe a foamcore/MDF ply?
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Peter Stormy Hyde on February 26, 2008, 11:22:56 AM
Stormy's explanation makes sense also from another point of view:

An accordion reed produces a clear tone alone all by itself while a guitar string makes almost no noice if there is no soundboard resonating. (The reason for the difference being what?) Anyway, a resonating soundboard in an accordion should be very well "tuned" to give *nice* additional harmonics to the total harmonics and this would be a very difficult task for anyone. A none-resonating accordion costruction could leave the reeds sounding with their natural sound.

....or was that total rubbish?
I would say you were right on track.
When I started restoring concertinas 32 years ago one of the very first things that had me very confused (and it took me nearly 30 years to buck the theories of tonal timbers) was that there is the sound board with about 15 spring loaded felt dampers pushing down on it and then a reed pan compressed down to the other side, it is impossible that it can be a sound board, try doing that to a guitar and it is obvious what would happen.

Our reed is our oscillator, and the air cavity within the reed block or pan is the resonator we can only amplify that sound or deaden it we cannot build on it. What I have learnt is that if anything moves in response to the reed or resonator we can then loose some of the sound, or get something a lot worse a "wolf".
Of course at the end of the day nothing is set in cement, there are so many combination of things that can cause changes, I'm a total none traditionalist, I will look at anything to improve my instruments, and I'm always willing to say that the theory (and i have had plenty over the years) I had last week was wrong.

But at this point of time "dead is best"
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Peter Stormy Hyde on February 26, 2008, 11:40:32 AM
G'day Mates

[loads of very interesting stuff snipped]

My mate who analyzes my instruments who is himself a top shelf instrument maker suggested it might be better to make accordions and concertinas from MDF! I do not have time to test that one, but it might be worth testing by someone.


Except of course that MDF is incredibly heavy, which probably argues against its use as an instrument frame. Maybe a foamcore/MDF ply?
You are right of course, its just that the day we first got the stunning results my mate (who is a pipe and flute maker) went into shock, as he had to reverse a lot of theories that he had about my work, he threw that one in to have a dig about the real wood I have collected over the years, I think he expected a fire sale!
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Quebecois on February 26, 2008, 12:32:55 PM
According to some studies the best material for speaker enclosures is concrete!!! 

But back to your experiments, what we need then is an inert reflector that does not resonate of vibrate?
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Pushpull on February 28, 2008, 02:04:26 PM
According to some studies the best material for speaker enclosures is concrete!!! 

But back to your experiments, what we need then is an inert reflector that does not resonate of vibrate?

A number of very fine speakers have been prodiced (and continue to be) with metal cabinets. The trick is to shape them so as to reduce standing waves and make sure they are adequately damped to get the resonant frequency of the cabinet nice and low. Having said that I do recall back in the 70s a house being advertised in Gramophone magazine. Strange to advertise a house in that mag? Well this one had reinforced concrete bass bins built into the basement.

So with respect to melodeons, I reckon it should be possible to make one out of say bitumen lined titanium (!!). If I remember correctly the Castagnari Casta had a metal soundboard.

Actually as an aside, I reckon what gives the Pokerwork its unique sound is it's lightweight "orange-box" construction. More heavily built (more expensive?) boxes never seem to have the same punch. It's rather like comparing a sturdily built "school" violin with a proper, much lighter, craftsman made instrument.

Roy.
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Quebecois on February 28, 2008, 02:17:44 PM
So, a non-resonating, porous and lightweight wood cabinet could then be made of balsa!
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Stiamh on February 28, 2008, 02:34:16 PM
All this reminds me of the claim by physicists that the material of which flutes are made is (hehe) immaterial - that only the bore dimensions matter, and a flute made of concrete (or plastic) will sound exactly the same as one of the same dimensions made of wood.

Musicians and instrument makers, however, know different.

Metal soundboards, btw, are used on many good-quality Italian accordions. Fans of the old Paolo Soprani boxes insist that the older ones with wooden soundboards have a warmer tone that the later ones with aluminum soundboards.
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Malcolm Austen on February 28, 2008, 03:49:14 PM
My bit of school boy physics, please feel free to shoot me down as I am just trying promote this discussion.
It may be that a loudspeaker enclosure is not the best way to think about what is going on as they are largely concerned with isolating one side of the speaker unit from the other as it is a thin diaphragm  oscillating , a google on loudspeaker design will get you much more than I can explain. The woodwind family etc. is mainly about resonance in pipes.
With free reed instruments what we have is a flow of air that is being chopped by the reed to produce a sound wave. 

So it would seem that you want a ridged reed frame attached securely attached to a ridged non sound absorbing reed block and a sound path to the outside world that is as free as possible from sound absorbing materials and resonating structures.

Stands back and ducks
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Theo on February 28, 2008, 05:00:38 PM
If I remember correctly the Castagnari Casta had a metal soundboard.

No, on the contrary one of its claims to fame was that it has a 'tonewood' soundboard.  The ones I've seen were cedar, I believe they also used spruce.
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Quebecois on February 28, 2008, 06:10:54 PM
No one has mentioned the fact that the only direct passage for the soundwave to reach the outside world is the tiny hole that opens to let the air actuate the reed! And it's partly blocked by the flapper!
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Pushpull on February 28, 2008, 06:12:49 PM
My bit of school boy physics, please feel free to shoot me down as I am just trying promote this discussion.
It may be that a loudspeaker enclosure is not the best way to think about what is going on as they are largely concerned with isolating one side of the speaker unit from the other as it is a thin diaphragm  oscillating , a google on loudspeaker design will get you much more than I can explain. The woodwind family etc. is mainly about resonance in pipes.
With free reed instruments what we have is a flow of air that is being chopped by the reed to produce a sound wave. 

So it would seem that you want a ridged reed frame attached securely attached to a ridged non sound absorbing reed block and a sound path to the outside world that is as free as possible from sound absorbing materials and resonating structures.

Stands back and ducks

My bit of school boy physics, please feel free to shoot me down as I am just trying promote this discussion.
It may be that a loudspeaker enclosure is not the best way to think about what is going on as they are largely concerned with isolating one side of the speaker unit from the other as it is a thin diaphragm  oscillating , a google on loudspeaker design will get you much more than I can explain. The woodwind family etc. is mainly about resonance in pipes.
With free reed instruments what we have is a flow of air that is being chopped by the reed to produce a sound wave. 

So it would seem that you want a ridged reed frame attached securely attached to a ridged non sound absorbing reed block and a sound path to the outside world that is as free as possible from sound absorbing materials and resonating structures.

Stands back and ducks

No you're absolutely right, speaker cabs and instruments are not the same beasts at all. I guess melodeons should have some resonance - as I said I'm sure the construction of the body has a great influence on the quality of sound. Then of course, free reeds, strings and woodwinds all have different requirements with respect to how the wood (or other) behaves.

Re. materials, a large number of woodwinds (even high quality ones) are made of plastics, resins or wood dust/resin mixes. Blind testing has demonstrated that it is impossible for even an experienced player to accurately and repeatedly say what material an instrument is made of. It's the quality of construction which counts.

A couple of examples: Hans Coolsma makes machined polyester recorders (machined in exactly the same way as a wooden recorder). They are very expensive and very good.
The great classical guitar maker (well THE great classical guitar maker), Torres, made a guitar with papier-mache back and sides to should how relatively unimportant these were. I haven't heard it but I believe it was pretty good (well it would be).

Roy.
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Pushpull on February 28, 2008, 06:13:52 PM
Sorry about the echo. You can see how important attention to detail is.
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: rees on February 28, 2008, 06:17:55 PM
I've been fascinated by the idea of a foam melodeon I so duly bought a can of expanding foam and sprayed the whole lot in through the air hole of my Castagnari.

I'm really not convinced that this is the way forward as I now can't get the melodeon in it's case!!!  ;)
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Pushpull on February 28, 2008, 06:19:29 PM
No one has mentioned the fact that the only direct passage for the soundwave to reach the outside world is the tiny hole that opens to let the air actuate the reed! And it's partly blocked by the flapper!
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Pushpull on February 28, 2008, 06:21:52 PM
No one has mentioned the fact that the only direct passage for the soundwave to reach the outside world is the tiny hole that opens to let the air actuate the reed! And it's partly blocked by the flapper!

I really must be more careful
I really must be more careful
I really must be more careful
I really must be more careful
I really must be more careful

What I was going to say is, that suggests a violin only produces sound through the toneholes. I would think the body of a melodeon is equally important. Hence the different sounds produced by different boxes with pretty much the same lumps of metal vibrating in them.

Roy.
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Pushpull on February 28, 2008, 06:31:49 PM
If I remember correctly the Castagnari Casta had a metal soundboard.

No, on the contrary one of its claims to fame was that it has a 'tonewood' soundboard.  The ones I've seen were cedar, I believe they also used spruce.

Ah well. It's not often I'm right but............
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Quebecois on February 28, 2008, 07:09:12 PM
What I was going to say is, that suggests a violin only produces sound through the toneholes. I would think the body of a melodeon is equally important. Hence the different sounds produced by different boxes with pretty much the same lumps of metal vibrating in them.
Roy.
Easily verified: compare the sound of a harmonica played by different players: the mouth cavity and hands act as a resonator and greatly effects the volume and tone.

 
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Malcolm Austen on February 29, 2008, 01:27:18 PM
Have a look at this (http://www.concertinaconnection.com/concertina%20reeds.htm) it is for concertinas but gives a very comprehensive introduction to what is going on.
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Larry Anthony on February 29, 2008, 02:45:28 PM
What I was going to say is, that suggests a violin only produces sound through the toneholes. I would think the body of a melodeon is equally important. Hence the different sounds produced by different boxes with pretty much the same lumps of metal vibrating in them.
Roy.
Easily verified: compare the sound of a harmonica played by different players: the mouth cavity and hands act as a resonator and greatly effects the volume and tone.

 


...and pitch.

Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Peter Stormy Hyde on March 02, 2008, 10:57:40 AM
What I was going to say is, that suggests a violin only produces sound through the toneholes. I would think the body of a melodeon is equally important. Hence the different sounds produced by different boxes with pretty much the same lumps of metal vibrating in them.
Roy.
Easily verified: compare the sound of a harmonica played by different players: the mouth cavity and hands act as a resonator and greatly effects the volume and tone.

 


...and pitch.


G'day this is going well!
I'm sorry that I'm not spending as much time as I should answering the questions here, as it is my festival time and I'm very busy, but I will see what I can do here now.

You are right about the harmonica, it is air within that is the resonator not your hands or mouth they only control the air! The air within the inside of the melodeon (outside of the reed block) is not a resonator, otherwise there would be a pitch change as you played the instrument.

Over the years I have built about 300 custom made (every aspect is custom designed) melodeons, and no 2 are the same they may be similar, but the timbers (real wood not ply) will vary from customer to customer. I have used everything from jarrah (used for making railway sleepers and street paver's in the UK) to spruce, and I have noticed that I get bigger variations from other factors other than the timber used if timbers are the same size. I think we need to look a little closer at some other important factors. The biggest one (outside reeds) is the pallet design, this is by far where I have noticed the biggest variations. What are they made from, how much felt is on them, how thick, what quality is the leather, are they rubber mounted or glued on with glue or wax, and how much lift? The leather on the face of a pallet can make a very big difference, ask any flute maker who uses vellum on their valves for that very reason.

I might be wrong in comparing the melodeon with speaker boxes, to be truthful I know nothing at all about them, but I did have a folk mate and fiddle player, who used to lecture on the subject of acoustics, and it was him who suggested they were the closer comparison, but then he did have a glass of Coopers Ale to his lips at the time.

Again; I'm no expert on the fiddle, but are the back and the front the resonators, and they have a sound post between them to keep them in phase? From this; it would suggest to me that if the timber in the melodeon was to resonate to much we would quite likely end up needing sound posts to keep all the parts in phase, I have never heard of one that was out of phase and would not play have you? A lot of research has gone into making stringed instruments as far as front and back is concerned, I have not seen the same type of research go into the accordion. Where are the "node  lines" (I think that is what they are called) in the accordion?  I would love to know.

Thanks to you all, it is a great discussion.
Stormy

Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: mber on March 20, 2008, 10:06:54 PM
I just bought MDF board here in States to make concertina handles.
It has a lable that reads:
"MDF contains a chemical, known to the State of California to  cause Cancer.
Use caution."

So be warned.
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: IanD on March 24, 2008, 01:08:32 PM
We had a big debate on the subject of melodeon soundboards on the squeezeboxes Usenet newsgroup a couple of years ago.

One conclusion was that -- like many other sound-related subjects -- lots of people have strong opinions which they can't back up in practice (the "expensive speaker leads sound better" syndrome). Just because a good-sounding instrument has a metal soundboard doesn't mean that the good sound is *because* of the metal soundboard.

Any comparison with guitar/violin soundboards is completely spurious. In these instruments the sound generator is a string which couples through to the air via the soundboard, and the properties of this do have a huge effect on the sound.

In a melodeon the sound is produced by the reed chopping up an airstream, and this sound then makes its way to the outside through the air, so anything that affects this will change the sound. The reed and reed plate (and the way they're mounted) affect the production of the sound in the first place, then this makes its way through the holes in the soundboard, past the pallets and out of the grille -- all of these change the frequency response and form resonant chambers, but the shape and size of these is what matters not the material (unless it's soft or flexible material like felt that can damp out high frequency sound)

The soundboard is fairly rigid to start off with, and is then clamped against several rigid reed blocks, so it's extremely unlikely that the material would affect the sound because it can't move to any significant extent, but the thickness and shape/sharpness of the air holes will make a differerence. If a metal soundboard is thinner and has bigger holes than a wooden one people may conclude (probably wrongly) that the metal gives a brighter sound -- but then my Oakwood has a thin laminate soundboard with big holes and that sounds bright as well.

The only way to prove this for sure would be to make two identical boxes with metal and wooden soundboards, both with the same thickness and size/shape of air holes. I'd bet good money that nobody could tell which was which...

Cheers

Ian
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Theo on March 24, 2008, 04:20:42 PM
The only way to prove this for sure would be to make two identical boxes with metal and wooden soundboards, both with the same thickness and size/shape of air holes. I'd bet good money that nobody could tell which was which...

Cheers

Ian

And even if there was a difference that still would be inconclusive, as anyone will know who has played two 'identical' new instruments  with the same soundboard material, and found that they don't sound quite the same.
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: IanD on March 27, 2008, 10:48:52 PM
The only way to prove this for sure would be to make two identical boxes with metal and wooden soundboards, both with the same thickness and size/shape of air holes. I'd bet good money that nobody could tell which was which...

Cheers

Ian

And even if there was a difference that still would be inconclusive, as anyone will know who has played two 'identical' new instruments  with the same soundboard material, and found that they don't sound quite the same.

Indeed, but something I forgot to mention -- you use the same set of reed blocks in both instruments, this would account for almost all the sound difference (again, think what makes the sound and how it reaches our ears).

This would mean you couldn't do an instantaneous A/B comparison, it would have to be done by recordings, but the result would be equally valid.

Ian
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: JohannPascher on June 23, 2008, 06:16:10 PM
Hi,

I made some comparing of boxes with different soundboard on the same instruments.

There is a difference if different sound boards are used.
I used 0.5mm fiber glass 2mm aluminium and in the end i changed it back to 4mm pear wood.
The thickness of the board is within the possible range a major influence.

The contribution of the wood type is very little.

Wood type of the casework and the bass section especially with Helicon reeds has more effect.

I also made an other instrument without soundboard where the flaps operate on to the removable reed blocks.
All usable but in the end different to tell form where the differences all originate.

best regards, Johann



Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: JohannPascher on June 23, 2008, 06:43:12 PM
Stormy wrote:

Quote
What I have learnt is that if anything moves in response to the reed or resonator we can then loose some of the sound, or get something a lot worse a "wolf".

Yes that is what is was telling for a long time, resonance in combination with reeds acts as attenuation not as amplification.

Or compared with electronic circuits it is not a parallel resonance it is a serial resonance.

But this does not mean we don't have resonance effect that change the sound quality.

best regards, Johann


Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Geoffleft on June 24, 2008, 01:57:46 PM
Hi All.Just me.

Peter. Fond regards.

At a party the other night, one of your Box's was being played by a lady I had not seen before. Given that the gathering included a young but very talented BC player on his new 3v Saltarelle, and my noisy self, I was quite impressed.

With the other boxes sounding quite decently, I was impressed with the 'Hyde' in a session environment. I had not had the honour of meeting one before. I do not know if its insides were balsa, foam or anything else, the music played on it certainly sounded good to my humble ear though!

All the fundamental fundumentals were where they should have been, and the result was - music.

More power to your overhead router mate. Congratulations on a great result.
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: JohannPascher on June 24, 2008, 03:51:16 PM
Hi again,

Unfortunately i never had the opportunity to hear one of Stormy Hydes boxes in reality.

I would love to he one especially this new foam Melodeon.

i only used balsa on one instrument for the reed blocks but not totally the top and the sole was pear wood.
Also the Helicon reed chambers ware made from balsa but also not totally.

Soundboard treble side aluminum with registers and soundboard bus section pear wood.

Treble side very good results but bass section more overtones and brighter as usual if i use spruce instead of balsa and pear wood.

I would think that for the buss section one needs some more weight to compensate  especially on very low notes.
Still the bass section is normally strong but quit different in sound middle range of tones are stronger as usual,
if i compare the spectrogram's with similar instruments by using the same reeds (replaces reeds).

I would have some questions on the construction of this Foam Melodeon.
About the mounting of keyboard and other mechanical parts, how did you overcome this problems if very soft material is used?

Is the keyboard traditional?
Is the soundboard as well made of Foam sandwich board?

How thick is the soundboard?


Best regards, Johann Pascher

Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Peter Stormy Hyde on July 14, 2008, 12:15:22 PM
Hi again,

Unfortunately i never had the opportunity to hear one of Stormy Hydes boxes in reality.

I would love to he one especially this new foam Melodeon.

i only used balsa on one instrument for the reed blocks but not totally the top and the sole was pear wood.
Also the Helicon reed chambers ware made from balsa but also not totally.

Soundboard treble side aluminum with registers and soundboard bus section pear wood.

Treble side very good results but bass section more overtones and brighter as usual if i use spruce instead of balsa and pear wood.

I would think that for the buss section one needs some more weight to compensate  especially on very low notes.
Still the bass section is normally strong but quit different in sound middle range of tones are stronger as usual,
if i compare the spectrogram's with similar instruments by using the same reeds (replaces reeds).

I would have some questions on the construction of this Foam Melodeon.
About the mounting of keyboard and other mechanical parts, how did you overcome this problems if very soft material is used?

Is the keyboard traditional?
Is the soundboard as well made of Foam sandwich board?

How thick is the soundboard?


Best regards, Johann Pascher


The sound board, (if we must call it that) is 4 mm thick, made up with 3 mm foam with .5 mm timber veneer on either side. This makes for a very strong and rigid board and there is no way the treble mechanism will pull out.
The treble mechanism is very traditional, but is 95% foam with wooden leavers and wire pallet arms.
This is a very small single voice 1 rower, but a person who has placed an order with me for a full sized foam instrument after playing the smaller one.

Any area where I have to put screws in have held very well by priming the holes first with PVA glue then waiting for it to dry before using the screw, this is also my practice in Balsa as well, where i have used it for the capping's on the reed blocks

If anybody would like to see a photo if this instrument then send me an email and I will send you a photo of it. Unfortunately I have just not had time to do a recording of it, but give me time.

I hope this finds you all well.
Stormy
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Malcolm Austen on July 14, 2008, 12:45:41 PM
What type of foam? I have looked through this thread several times and I don't think it has been specified. Fascinated by it all,
malcolm
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Peter Stormy Hyde on July 14, 2008, 01:13:44 PM
What type of foam? I have looked through this thread several times and I don't think it has been specified. Fascinated by it all,
malcolm
G'day Malcolm
This is where I have to draw the line I'm afraid, the person who is himself  an instrument maker (but not boxes) gave me the first bit of information on this, did ask that I do not mention the name of the product in my ramblings, as he has been using it for years and he feels it gives him a very big edge over his competition.
The only thing I can say is that it is definitely not polystyrene foam or anything like it.  I can only say look further afield.
Regards
Stormy
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: JohannPascher on July 14, 2008, 02:14:29 PM
Quote from: Peter Stormy Hyde
The sound board, (if we must call it that) is 4 mm thick, made up with 3 mm foam with .5 mm timber veneer on either side. This makes for a very strong and rigid board and there is no way the treble mechanism will pull out.
The treble mechanism is very traditional, but is 95% foam with wooden leavers and wire pallet arms.
This is a very small single voice 1 rower, but a person who has placed an order with me for a full sized foam instrument after playing the smaller one.

Any area where I have to put screws in have held very well by priming the holes first with PVA glue then waiting for it to dry before using the screw, this is also my practice in Balsa as well, where i have used it for the capping's on the reed blocks

If anybody would like to see a photo if this instrument then send me an email and I will send you a photo of it. Unfortunately I have just not had time to do a recording of it, but give me time.

I hope this finds you all well.
Stormy

Thank you for taking your time to answer, i am really surprised that you could use the foam material to that extent, i can understand that you are unable to give away all the details. I would be interested to see some pictures you could contact me personally at

johann.pascher@gmail.com.

best regards, johann
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Malcolm Austen on July 14, 2008, 02:57:45 PM
What type of foam? I have looked through this thread several times and I don't think it has been specified. Fascinated by it all,
malcolm
G'day Malcolm
This is where I have to draw the line I'm afraid, the person who is himself  an instrument maker (but not boxes) gave me the first bit of information on this, did ask that I do not mention the name of the product in my ramblings, as he has been using it for years and he feels it gives him a very big edge over his competition.
The only thing I can say is that it is definitely not polystyrene foam or anything like it.  I can only say look further afield.

Regards
Stormy

No problem, it was just out of general interest. By the way I had a go on the box you made for Chris Timson, lovely box but very confusing to play so I look forward to trying a more standard box some time.
Finally have you ever tried aluminium reed blocks?

regards malcolm
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Peter Stormy Hyde on July 15, 2008, 12:24:36 AM
What type of foam? I have looked through this thread several times and I don't think it has been specified. Fascinated by it all,
malcolm
G'day Malcolm
This is where I have to draw the line I'm afraid, the person who is himself  an instrument maker (but not boxes) gave me the first bit of information on this, did ask that I do not mention the name of the product in my ramblings, as he has been using it for years and he feels it gives him a very big edge over his competition.
The only thing I can say is that it is definitely not polystyrene foam or anything like it.  I can only say look further afield.

Regards
Stormy

No problem, it was just out of general interest. By the way I had a go on the box you made for Chris Timson, lovely box but very confusing to play so I look forward to trying a more standard box some time.
Finally have you ever tried aluminium reed blocks?

regards malcolm
Thanks for that plug on Chris's box , it is unusual as it is a Jeffries concertina layout ( G/D/ Accidental) with all the notes on the right hand, it is like the right hand of the concertina where you go up rather than down to the cross key scale. I found it good as I used to play a G/D Jeffries. and I intend to take it up again in retirement.
I have not tried aluminum reed blocks, as it would play havoc with the band saw, or the machining or casting would be very expensive, but if it was easier my inclination would be, that it would be very good.

If any of you run into Tristan Glover from the Chipolatas have a word with him about the foam box as he had a play on it at Port Fairy folk festival.
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Pete Dunk on July 15, 2008, 10:32:20 PM
Again; I'm no expert on the fiddle, but are the back and the front the resonators, and they have a sound post between them to keep them in phase? From this; it would suggest to me that if the timber in the melodeon was to resonate to much we would quite likely end up needing sound posts to keep all the parts in phase, I have never heard of one that was out of phase and would not play have you?

One of my problems is that I read too much and then forget where I've seen it (senior moments  ::)) but I recently read something about banks of treble reed blocks in instruments with three voices (MMM) needing to be physically 'shorted out' and I believe that was to keep them in phase and prevent the tremolo reeds cancelling each other out. My old Hohner three voice has what look like nails bridging the gaps between the blocks and I had wondered what they were there for as the blocks don't seem to be in imminent danger of toppling over.

Or am I talking rubbish as usual?

Pete.
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on July 16, 2008, 01:28:55 AM
Pete, see this thread 

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?PHPSESSID=152b41b171589f0db4dbeab0d1fa2a81&topic=631.0 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?PHPSESSID=152b41b171589f0db4dbeab0d1fa2a81&topic=631.0)
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Peter Stormy Hyde on July 16, 2008, 11:42:09 AM
Pete, see this thread 

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?PHPSESSID=152b41b171589f0db4dbeab0d1fa2a81&topic=631.0 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?PHPSESSID=152b41b171589f0db4dbeab0d1fa2a81&topic=631.0)
Thanks for that Malcolm,
Interesting; Some boxes need those braces between blocks, here it is the sound post of a violin!!! I have tried it when I have had similar problems but no improvement. Oscillators to close to one another, and pulling each other, I seem to recall when I have had the problem I have slightly detuned a reed to stop it happening. I did have a customer who cut the cavity out between the two cavity's so the unison reeds would pull one another into the same phase; YUCK YUCK, I tried to tell him he might as well have just one reed as it would be far better!!!!
Regards
Stormy
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Peter Stormy Hyde on July 16, 2008, 12:06:37 PM
Hi All.Just me.

Peter. Fond regards.

At a party the other night, one of your Box's was being played by a lady I had not seen before. Given that the gathering included a young but very talented BC player on his new 3v Saltarelle, and my noisy self, I was quite impressed.

With the other boxes sounding quite decently, I was impressed with the 'Hyde' in a session environment. I had not had the honour of meeting one before. I do not know if its insides were balsa, foam or anything else, the music played on it certainly sounded good to my humble ear though!

All the fundamental fundumentals were where they should have been, and the result was - music.

More power to your overhead router mate. Congratulations on a great result.
Thanks for those kind words Mate;
I know who's box that was, and she lives in Melbourne. It is one of my flutinas made before I got into the foam, so the concertina styled reed pan within is made from balsa with a 1.5 mm ply on each side to stiffen.

 It was 2 identical flutinas I used  to put the foam to the test, one had balsa and the other one had foam reed pans, both had B/C hand made reeds from the same maker. The foam one seemed to me at first that I had lost my top end, but when we analyzed the sound we found that I had picked up an improvement of about 33% on the lower fundamental and the 3rd, and after that I seem to recall that we picked up an improvement of about 10- 15% across the board up to about the 13th with no pick up of the evens. So the box sounds lower, and sometimes people have thought they were listening to bassoon reeds on some of my other foam boxes (reed blocks only) when in fact they were listening to tenor reeds.

The nice thing about foam it is so easy to work, today I was fitting the reeds to a new box, and the new reed plates from my maker were thicker than usual, I have designed my boxes right down to the last MM, so I had rivets stopping me getting my reed blocks right home, so it was a very easy job to run the reed blocks over a sanding plate to get that extra 0.5 mm that I needed.
 
But wear a respirator all the time, even when cutting timber.
Stormy
Title: Re: Foam Melodeon
Post by: Peter Stormy Hyde on July 16, 2008, 12:30:12 PM
When I started using balsa wood in my accordions about 10 years ago, to my knowledge there was no other accordion makers using it. People used to look at me very strangely at festivals when I said I was using balsa to make my reed blocks, mostly thinking I was off my rocker. It was only when an English Accordion web site interviewed me where I said that I was using it in reed blocks, they then published it listing timber for reed blocks as balsa plus others, and it seems it has became an acceptable timber for the job. I bet the same will happen with foam!!!!
And by the way people look at me even more strangely at festivals when I tell them that I use foam, but I do believe in letting people know what I'm doing, can you imagine the shock horror if someone bought an instrument and opened it up and found foam, and had no idea that I had used it.

All the best for now
Stormy
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal