Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Hasse on February 25, 2008, 07:45:11 PM

Title: Harmonic minor on a B/C box???
Post by: Hasse on February 25, 2008, 07:45:11 PM
I guess the B/C box was designed to be a smooth box for playing in D and G. But how about other keys?
I've been thinking about buying a B/C box as a supplement to my D/G box. I'm not intending to play my present D/G repertoire on the B/C box, my plan is to try out traditional Swedish fiddle tunes in keys of A, D, G, C harmonic minor. Is it going to be too difficult and sound like ….?

Any advice on this would be very appreciated :)
Title: Re: Harmonic minor on a B/C box???
Post by: Quebecois on February 25, 2008, 08:52:55 PM
Wouldn't C#/D work better to play in D and G ?
Title: Re: Harmonic minor on a B/C box???
Post by: risto on February 25, 2008, 09:17:06 PM
Quite conveniently you brought this up as I have added the Harmonic Minor in the Chords.doc, see the Morgane C#/D thread. You probably won't find the theoretical HM scale 'as is' in Swedish folk music.

(FYI: The Harmonic Minor is seldom used 'as is' even though it is the foundation of minor harmonics in classical music. The reason being that the upper tetrachord (notes 5,b6,7,1) sounds like Arabic music. In practise, the HM scale is altered so that when played from low to high the  natural 6 is used instead of the b6 and when played from high to low the 7th is flattened to b7).


EDIT: typos...
Title: Re: Harmonic minor on a B/C box???
Post by: Stiamh on February 25, 2008, 10:17:45 PM
Wouldn't C#/D work better to play in D and G ?

D, possibly initially, but after a while getting up to speed, D is no problem on the B/C and generally smoother (depending on the way tunes are put together - arpeggios or linear passages). G is quite easy on either. For A major, C#/D might have a slight edge, while B/C would have a similar edge for A minor (with F nats).

» edited to add: scrap the next comment, it applies to C# minor, duh:  C minor would be a lot more straightforward on B/C - you'd play it more or less straight up and down the B row, possibly crossing over for the 6th degree if it's a true harmonic minor.  end scrap. « C minor would be a little easier on B/C but - like D minor on C#/D  :'( - it's a bit of a finger-twister.

Flat keys are generally easier on B/C, sharp keys on C#/D. Anything can be done on either, though, provided you practise enough. See the recent links to videos of Dermot Byrne  ;D
Title: Re: Harmonic minor on a B/C box???
Post by: Hasse on February 26, 2008, 07:16:39 PM
Thanks for all the replies!
So if I understand this right the B/C box should (at least in theory) work fine for playing fiddle tunes in harmonic minor, especially A and C minor. I guess with a C#/D box it would complicate the fingering some, but as Steve Jones puts it:
Flat keys are generally easier on B/C, sharp keys on C#/D. Anything can be done on either, though, provided you practise enough.

Well, maybe I should start to look out for a B/C box...  ;)
Title: Re: Harmonic minor on a B/C box???
Post by: TomB-R on March 13, 2008, 12:49:54 PM
I guess the B/C box was designed to be a smooth box for playing in D and G.

Slightly off topic, but this thread was sleepy anyway....

Not criticising Hasse's post, but  just as a matter of interest I assume there wasn't actually any conscious design about it.  Hohner and others made lots of B/C boxes because of the white key/black key piano parallel, and because they were also producing lots of B/C chromatic harmonicas.  The bass layout surely shows that there was no expectation of playing in  D & G!
So there were plenty of these boxes around when pioneering players discovered the cross-row possibilities, which meant a "critical mass" was reached relatively quickly, there were enough second hand boxes around for those who wished to pick up the new style.

Or am I wrong?
Tom
Title: Re: Harmonic minor on a B/C box???
Post by: Stiamh on March 13, 2008, 01:16:01 PM
Not criticising Hasse's post, but  just as a matter of interest I assume there wasn't actually any conscious design about it.  Hohner and others made lots of B/C boxes because of the white key/black key piano parallel, and because they were also producing lots of B/C chromatic harmonicas.  The bass layout surely shows that there was no expectation of playing in  D & G!
So there were plenty of these boxes around when pioneering players discovered the cross-row possibilities, which meant a "critical mass" was reached relatively quickly, there were enough second hand boxes around for those who wished to pick up the new style.

I think the first halfstep boxes were in "outside in" configurations such as C/C#. According to Steve Chambers, George Jones produced the first "chromatic melodeon" in the 1880s, and it was a C/C#. Apparently there were also outside-in halfstep-down boxes (C/B or equivalent) in France in the 1920s or thereabouts - probably the ancestors of the D/C# style popular in Irish circles in the US in the 1940s and 1950s.

From what I've gathered, the "pioneering players" who developed the B/C style ("inside out") were the Wyper Brothers (in about 1915?). The Scots picked up on this style fairly quickly - didn't Jimmy Shand play B/C before adopting the B/C/C#? George or Bill W or Eejay will doubtless be able to provide more reliable information.

The Irish were a bit slower on the uptake and it was Paddy O'Brien in the early 1950s who launched the B/C craze over there that became a tidal wave, sweeping all other systems before it, for a few decades at least. Where all the boxes came from to fuel this trend, I don't know. But in Ireland most of them seem to have been made by Paolo Soprani rather than Hohner.

There's an article on the Wypers HERE (http://www.mustrad.org.uk/articles/wypers.htm) but it doesn't mention the tunings they used. I don't know what keys they favoured either, not having a copy of any of their recordings.
Title: Re: Harmonic minor on a B/C box???
Post by: Larry Anthony on March 13, 2008, 02:25:15 PM
I guess the B/C box was designed to be a smooth box for playing in D and G.

Slightly off topic, but this thread was sleepy anyway....

Not criticising Hasse's post, but  just as a matter of interest I assume there wasn't actually any conscious design about it.  Hohner and others made lots of B/C boxes because of the white key/black key piano parallel, and because they were also producing lots of B/C chromatic harmonicas.  The bass layout surely shows that there was no expectation of playing in  D & G!
So there were plenty of these boxes around when pioneering players discovered the cross-row possibilities, which meant a "critical mass" was reached relatively quickly, there were enough second hand boxes around for those who wished to pick up the new style.

Or am I wrong?
Tom

The chromatic harmonicas were, and still are I believe, tuned in C/C#.

Title: Re: Harmonic minor on a B/C box???
Post by: TomB-R on March 14, 2008, 01:54:49 PM
Interesting, so not as straightforward a progression as one might think. It would be interesting to know how many B/C boxes pre-dated the Irish B/C style.

Yes, now you mention it Larry I think the chromatic harmonica I had years ago used to go up a semitone when you pressed in the slide, not down.
Tom
Title: Re: Harmonic minor on a B/C box???
Post by: EeeJay on March 17, 2008, 09:46:21 PM
I think the first halfstep boxes were in "outside in" configurations such as C/C#. According to Steve Chambers, George Jones produced the first "chromatic melodeon" in the 1880s, and it was a C/C#. Apparently there were also outside-in halfstep-down boxes (C/B or equivalent) in France in the 1920s or thereabouts - probably the ancestors of the D/C# style popular in Irish circles in the US in the 1940s and 1950s.

From what I've gathered, the "pioneering players" who developed the B/C style ("inside out") were the Wyper Brothers (in about 1915?). The Scots picked up on this style fairly quickly - didn't Jimmy Shand play B/C before adopting the B/C/C#? George or Bill W or Eejay will doubtless be able to provide more reliable information.

The Irish were a bit slower on the uptake and it was Paddy O'Brien in the early 1950s who launched the B/C craze over there that became a tidal wave, sweeping all other systems before it, for a few decades at least. Where all the boxes came from to fuel this trend, I don't know. But in Ireland most of them seem to have been made by Paolo Soprani rather than Hohner.


From what I can gather, and with some credence from Steve Chamber's correspondence, the B/C probably filtered into Ireland via Glasgow during the 30s/40s - the tide of migrant workers ebbing back and forth, and ready money, coupled with the fact that Forbes's Accordions of Dundee (who also had branches in Glasgow, Kirkaldy and Edinburgh) were doing a lot to plug their brand new B/C Double Ray model and homespun tuition system.

There was some mention of Forbes's B/C tuition books on the old board. Suffice to say, from what I recall they were really odd, with very limited application... certainly the Irish didn't seem to bother with them...

Here's an evolutionary step towards the B/C/C# currently on eBay. (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&rd=1&item=280209581623) Late 1930's at a guess...

Post WW2, Paolo Soprani helped to define the typical Irish B/C style... as did the general avoidance of stradella basses - in all likelihood, tacitly enforced by the Comhaltas ideas of standards, competition, tradition, yadda, yadda... kinda rich, seeing as the box is about as traditionally Irish as linguine... ::)

Incidentally, I had a try yesterday on a restored early 1900's Paolo Soprani 3 row in G/C/B. Yup - the B row half a step down... some variation on a proto-accordéon mixte...

Ed J
Title: Re: Harmonic minor on a B/C box???
Post by: george garside on March 17, 2008, 10:20:55 PM
I understand  that Jimmy Shand made his  early recordings  - 1933 - ?36 using a Bc 36 bass organola like the one on ebay.
george
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal