Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Chris Ryall on February 04, 2010, 08:36:10 PM
-
Someone told me in France last year that I must always place my instrument on it's end - on the little feet. This to stop gravity moving the valves out of alignment.
Is this a real issue? (The guy was defo the obsessive type). I've personally not bothered. and so far no problem. ???
-
Someone told me in France last year that I must always place my instrument on it's end - on the little feet. This to stop gravity moving the valves out of alignment.
Is this a real issue? (The guy was defo the obsessive type). I've personally not bothered. and so far no problem. ???
Much discussed in another place (concetina.net) where they like to lay their concertinas lengthways to stop valve droop. Can say as I have ever noticed.
ps That would be "its" not "it's"
-
Someone told me in France last year that I must always place my instrument on it's end - on the little feet. . ???
Hi Chris
I believe Pete Coe says something similar at the outset of his workshops. Which begs the question what do we poor one row players do? ???
Cheers
Baz
-
I always stand my Castagnaris on their feet, mainly because they are less likely to get scratched like that, but, as Baz has implied, one-row boxes have no feet and can only stand on their sides or lie on their backs. When my Junior Martin Cajun one-row is in its case, it rests on its end, but when it is out of its box, I have never been sure whether it is better to stand it on its side or to lie it on its back.
-
I suggest this guy's obsession may be based upon the French attitude (aesthetic mainly, I think) to bellows straps. Notice how many French accordeons (even the big ones) don't have them.
I initially thought a lot of the big boxes had some kind of internal bellows lock... but apparently, not.
However... I think this fella was more concerned with storage issues. It is generally reccomended by manufacturers that Vienna style diatonics need to sit on their feet when stored - so if that's what they say, that's what I do. Sure valve droop can happen, but I'd say other influence may also be at work (climate, central heating, moisture, etc...). I'd guess that plastic valves are less prone to droop...
Which begs the question what do we poor one row players do? ???
German (aka Cajun) style 1 rows (as modelled on the 'Sterling'... with the inverted T shaped blocks) need to be stored in the orientation as played...
1 rows with 2 removable vertical blocks (like HA114 or Weltmeister... or the Casti Max - I think? :-\) are stored the same way as Vienna boxes... keyboard skyward...
Ed J
-
I suggest this guy's obsession may be based upon the French attitude (aesthetic mainly, I think) to bellows straps. Notice how many French accordeons (even the big ones) don't have them.
This is certainly Loffet's argument for not putting bellows straps on his boxes. He says they aren't needed because at all times the accordeon is either being played, or is resting on its feet, as if there are no other possibilities!
-
I always put my box in the case but I am not careful as to which way it sits.
Could we have a comment from some of the people who work on boxes all the time. Is "valve droop" one of the many modern diseases manufactured by the overly cautious?
-
Could we have a comment from some of the people who work on boxes all the time. Is "valve droop" one of the many modern diseases manufactured by the overly cautious?
Absolutely YES! Unless you leave it in the same position for a decade or so. Yawn. :|glug
-
Thanks for the advice so far. I get the drift. My advisor is Mexican not French btw. And all the French in that particular group seem to use 2 straps (I'm the exception).
-
Much discussed in another place (concetina.net) where they like to lay their concertinas lengthways to stop valve droop.
Surely in that position some of the valves are pointing vertically upwards, isn't that a problem as well? I note that most old concertina cases hold the instrument on end.
-
if a box is placed 'on it's feet' to stop gravity moving the valves out of alignment (in relation to the treble reed valves), hence valve droop;
what happens if anything, to the valves on the bass and cord reeds, as the fixed (or glued) part is at the bottom or lower end (ie. closest to the box feet) with the moving part of the valve upwards?
-
I don't think its a real problem, just one of those things that can cause needless worry.
True, concertina valves will droop if the concertina is stored on its end for long periods, but concertina valves are made of very much softer leather than used in accordions. Plastic valves don't seem to curl at all, though when old they may fall off as glue fails. When I see diatonic or other accordions with curled valves, it is always the case that the valves are curled away from both sides of the reedblock. So whatever is causing them to change shape, its not gravity.
There are far greater risks when you play in a pub or outside - rain, beer, and in the past tobacco smoke.
This is a departure form my usual view that gravity is one of the most dangerous things in everyday life. ;D
-
There are far greater risks when you play in a pub or outside - rain, beer, and in the past tobacco smoke.
I did some work on Stan Hugill's old melodeon for his son Martin.
When I removed the bellows, out wafted the pungent aroma of Stan's pipe tobacco.
It brought a tear to my eye in more ways than one. :'(
-
I always put my Pokerwork on its feet between dances. You can stand at least three pints of beer on the grille. ;D
Rob.
-
I always put my Pokerwork on its feet between dances. You can stand at least three pints of beer on the grille. ;D
Rob.
Shorter members of the audience can also stand on it to get a better view. >:E
-
I put mine on the feet as (1) its less likely to fall over and (b) its the only way it fits in the small gap next to the concertina case at home.
-
I always put my Pokerwork on its feet between dances. You can stand at least three pints of beer on the grille. ;D
Rob.
The thought makes me cringe! I once stood my Oakwood on its feet in a pub, and some kind soul knocked a glass containing some clear liquid straight onto the grille. Nobody claimed the drink, so we didn't know whether it was lemonade, vodka, water or what. No lasting damage seems to have been done so we assume it was water, but I've been a lot more careful about leaving my boxes lying around uncovered, on their feet or otherwise.
-
I must have had dribbles of beer go into the Pokerwork, but as you know spilling beer is a cardinal sin for a morris man! One of our members had a glass of lemonade spilt into his (box, not beer) and had to strip it and wash the sticky sugar solution off everything - put me off shandy for life.
Being of short stature, I like the idea of using the box as a hop-up.
I wouldn't leave an Oakwood in harm's way either, nor do I risk my Trilly. But, I have had a piece kicked off my Max, mics snapped off, can't find the box for the pile of jackets on it... Why the **** do dancers think I can play for them when they've buried my box??? One of the few things that really p****s me off!
Rob.
-
I wouldn't leave an Oakwood in harm's way either, nor do I risk my Trilly. But, I have had a piece kicked off my Max, mics snapped off, can't find the box for the pile of jackets on it... Why the **** do dancers think I can play for them when they've buried my box??? One of the few things that really p****s me off!
Rob.
I often have to dig through clothes and other stuff to get at my box to play for the dancers to! At Sword specin York the other year I had to borrow a box that was on the top of the pile as mine was buried under 3 teams worth of stuff as I was first to the stand. As for beer/other liquids in it, I try to avoid this no matter what box I'm playing but the inevitable has happened to my melodeon once or twice. No nasty damage though. I try never to let my concertinas be damaged by anything. Much too expensive...
-
I had a nasty experience at a festival in Spain with my Castagnari, its soft carrying case, and a bottle of wine which taught me never to mix these elements. I was able to dry it out in time for the evening performance with no lasting damage apart from rather fetching pink stains on the grill fabric, but the rest of the band have never let me forget it....
Cheers,
Guy
-
On a medieval banquet gig, a thrown jacket potato (no we weren't that bad, it was a miss aimed jollity among friends!) was spectacularly shredded in our hammer dulcimer player's brand new Oakwood. He left the stage in high dugeon. I felt it an inappropriate moment to suggest he should play a melodeon.
-
Why? >:E
-
On a medieval banquet gig, a thrown jacket potato (no we weren't that bad, it was a miss aimed jollity among friends!) was spectacularly shredded in our hammer dulcimer player's brand new Oakwood. He left the stage in high dugeon. I felt it an inappropriate moment to suggest he should play a melodeon.
Hahahaha! You sound like a supremely tactful and sensitive person ;D
-
On a medieval banquet gig, a thrown jacket potato (no we weren't that bad, it was a miss aimed jollity among friends!) was spectacularly shredded in our hammer dulcimer player's brand new Oakwood. He left the stage in high dugeon. I felt it an inappropriate moment to suggest he should play a melodeon.
I'm glad that it's not just us that plays at medieval banquets that turn into food fights!
Definitely the best sort though.
-
Yes, I have played at those events. Oliver Cromwell once hurled a huge lump of pig fat across the marquee.
It landed in the top of the bellows of my brand new Castagnari.
There was almost another war!
-
If of course it had been Pease Puddding, there would have been "Peas, Perfect Peas". :|bl (I'll get my coat!)
Singed,
An Unknown Wellwisher.
-
I always put my Pokerwork on its feet between dances. You can stand at least three pints of beer on the grille. ;D
Rob.
The thought makes me cringe! I once stood my Oakwood on its feet in a pub, and some kind soul knocked a glass containing some clear liquid straight onto the grille. Nobody claimed the drink, so we didn't know whether it was lemonade, vodka, water or what. No lasting damage seems to have been done so we assume it was water, but I've been a lot more careful about leaving my boxes lying around uncovered, on their feet or otherwise.
Same happened to me during a session at a morris weekend, I was playing baritone sax when someone knocked a pint of cider over, most of which flowed off the edge of the table straight into the treble end of my Oakwood which was sitting on the floor by my feet.
Also not any worse for wear other than the outside being a bit sticky. Maybe if Oakwood were still making boxes they could use this spilled drink immunity in their advertising?
Ian
-
Back to topic (just briefly) what 'gravity' was the beer?
[edit] Seems I need to define (original) gravity of a beer - related to the weight/ml of the extracted malt must. It used to be written on the beer pumps. In modern times the pubs and brewers simply give the measured alcohol content 3/4/5% Nowadays would seems there is a biochemist in every inglenook...
-
Specifically?