Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: waltzman on February 05, 2010, 12:11:21 PM

Title: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: waltzman on February 05, 2010, 12:11:21 PM
I was under the impression that the Tommy had fewer bass reeds in it than the standard size Hascy for space saving reasons.  The website, however, indicates that both have 3 reeds on the bass side.  Do they really contain the same number of reeds with the Tommy just being a more compact design?

Michael
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: Theo on February 05, 2010, 12:16:24 PM
All the Tommys I've looked inside have fewer reeds that the Hascy.  The trick the Tommy does is to share one of the tonic reeds between the chord and the bass.  So play a chord and it has 3 reeds, play the bass and it has three reeds, but play both together and there are only 5 reeds.  All the left side reeds are mounted on one big reedblock with a connection within the reedblock to enable the reed sharing. One unwanted consequence of this is that the shared reed does not play exactly the same pitch when played as part of the chord compared with being played as part of the bass, so there has to be a small compromise in the tuning.

I think it is the lowest bass reed that is missing in the Tommy.  If I have that right its probably the main reason for the difference in sound. 
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: Lester on February 05, 2010, 12:44:33 PM
Have a look here for learned treatise on Tommy Bass config (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2193.msg23274.html#msg23274)
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: ganderbox on February 05, 2010, 02:32:57 PM
I had a fairly newTommy for a while last year, and it had 3 bass reeds and 3 chord reeds, no shared reeds. I believe they changed the design of the bass end a couple of years or so ago.
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: ladydetemps on February 05, 2010, 02:41:45 PM
I had a fairly new Tommy for a while last year, and it had 3 bass reeds and 3 chord reeds, no shared reeds.
Ooh that's the one I've got now isn't it?
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: ganderbox on February 05, 2010, 02:46:16 PM
That's the one! ;)
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: LJC on February 05, 2010, 03:39:22 PM
The Tommy I have has a stupid design where by the bass end is permanently glued to the bellows - this makes it really awkward to get the bass/chord blocks out. I've not taken a Hascy apart but I'm pretty sure that I've seen bellows pins on the bass end as well as the treble.
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: waltzman on February 05, 2010, 03:51:45 PM
The Tommy I have has a stupid design where by the bass end is permanently glued to the bellows - this makes it really awkward to get the bass/chord blocks out. I've not taken a Hascy apart but I'm pretty sure that I've seen bellows pins on the bass end as well as the treble.

I can't imagine any advantage to that design.
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: waltzman on February 05, 2010, 04:03:49 PM
In my own experience in switching between an Lilliput, and Erica and a three-row corona that the smalller the bellows the 'faster' it feels.  Of course there is a weight difference but I think there is a signifcant difference in how rapidly you can change pressure on the reeds i.e. the smaller the bellows the easier it is to make rapid pressure changes.  This makes sense from the standpoint of physics.  Where this would be most apparent would be the 4v one row (which I have never tried) which has about the same number of reeds as a two row on the treble side but a much smaller bellows.  This is what got me to thinking about the Tommy and the Hascy which are basically the same instrument in term of reeds but the Tommy has a smaller bellows.   Comments anyone?
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: ganderbox on February 05, 2010, 04:26:20 PM
If you play mostly on the row, then a smaller box with smaller bellows is going to be lighter to work, therefore you'll be able to play it faster.
If you play more across the rows, smaller bellows mean you can sometimes run out of air. so you have to play it faster!
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: LDbosca on February 05, 2010, 04:54:41 PM
All the Tommys I've looked inside have fewer reeds that the Hascy.  The trick the Tommy does is to share one of the tonic reeds between the chord and the bass.  So play a chord and it has 3 reeds, play the bass and it has three reeds, but play both together and there are only 5 reeds.  All the left side reeds are mounted on one big reedblock with a connection within the reedblock to enable the reed sharing. One unwanted consequence of this is that the shared reed does not play exactly the same pitch when played as part of the chord compared with being played as part of the bass, so there has to be a small compromise in the tuning.

How come the shared reed doesn't sound the same pitch in both instances? Forgive my ignorance.
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: Rob2Hook on February 05, 2010, 06:01:02 PM
Smaller cross section bellows will produce a higher pressure for the force exerted to push or pull.  This is why it is easier to play loudly on a smaller instrument.  It's the same difference as a pump for car tyres (~30psi) which is short and broad or for bicycle tyres (~90psi) which is long and thin.  The limitation of the length of ones arms is why you run out of air with small bellows - more noticeable for one of my diminutive stature (shorta+se).

And yes, if you play a Max with gusto it deafens most listeners, but runs out of air very quickly!

Rob.
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: **DTN** on February 05, 2010, 06:58:49 PM

And yes, if you play a Max with gusto it deafens most listeners, but runs out of air very quickly!

Rob.

YEP!!
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: Lester on February 05, 2010, 10:46:08 PM
All the Tommys I've looked inside have fewer reeds that the Hascy.  The trick the Tommy does is to share one of the tonic reeds between the chord and the bass.  So play a chord and it has 3 reeds, play the bass and it has three reeds, but play both together and there are only 5 reeds.  All the left side reeds are mounted on one big reedblock with a connection within the reedblock to enable the reed sharing. One unwanted consequence of this is that the shared reed does not play exactly the same pitch when played as part of the chord compared with being played as part of the bass, so there has to be a small compromise in the tuning.

How come the shared reed doesn't sound the same pitch in both instances? Forgive my ignorance.
They do. On my Tommy it has a low bass reed and a high bass reed that is shared with the chord. (Well it would have if I had not taped it off the low reed along with the chord thirds - my Tommy has a very spare sounding bass end  (:) )
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: melodeon on February 07, 2010, 04:30:38 AM
I ahve owned 6-7 Castagnaris

The Tommy was the only box  I ever ran out of air.. offed it with great pleasure..intensely disliked it.
I had other "issues" with it  but running out of air was the deal breaker.

Hascy:  Finest Castagnari and possibly the finest accordeon I ever owned. I am still sick about having sold it..
a proper accordeon  .. great size, excellent tone and playability...and there is good reason the Hascy is considered THE classic Castagnari.  I am tempted to get a new version  ( and promptly remove the affected script logo and precious embossed button )

I also owned a MAX in C..  I play with gusto and I have never run that box out of air.

All these were bought new and dated to somewhere around 1999-2001...
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 07, 2010, 08:30:32 AM
The Tommy was the only box  I ever ran out of air.. offed it with great pleasure..intensely disliked it.I had other "issues" with it  but running out of air was the deal breaker.

I'd echo that (playing other people's) A deeply clever box, but not enough lungs for all the widgets. A real physical problem if you naturally 'play in chords', or do long stretches on the pull. Rather less so if you are and up and down the rows sort of fell fella.   That clever bass is also a slight hostage to fortune. I had one very similar on my Lilli -  the hooks/wiring to achieve it was soldered, and eventually one joint failed. Needed hiospitalisation in Cleckheaton (albeit this was after about 15 year's play)  ;)

Yes, HaskysHandrys** and Moris* are superb robust boxes.  Heavy* though. Particulatly so if you are that up and down the rows push-pull player. In that case consider either the Tommy, or get a chest expander to develop your left arm  :Ph

[edit] See I got my hasky and handry models muddled. :|bl  1.6kg different. Comment re Tommy's lung capacity and cleverness still stands. Chris
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: Owen Woods on February 07, 2010, 12:09:00 PM
( and promptly remove the affected script logo and precious embossed button )

I hate that button. I have no idea how anyone could possibly justify it.
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: ladydetemps on February 07, 2010, 01:41:36 PM
Just wanted to say I love my tommy. Its just the right size for petite me. (Short arms, fingers etc.)It also looks smart. The red of the bellows matches my shoes. And I like the little symbol thing on the D row, wish there was one on G row too makes it much easier to find where I am.
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: melodeon on February 07, 2010, 03:42:33 PM
What I left out:
In my most polite PC verbage.....

I concluded the Tommy was a "chick" box.  I sold it to a lady.  She "adored" it.. her words.  Thereby confirming my opinion.

I have also owned Lillys and liked them (except D/G) and do not consider them to be "chick" accordeons.

The embossed button is unnecessary and is at minimum a self absorbed design "affectation"  as is the "look at me, look at me"  new age script.. I have no doubt they are using a yuppie focus group for design input. They shopuld bag the button, the script and the new hideous grille designs and go back to the 80's  even earlier with the "window" boxes.. definitiely would show more class.  There is a distinct difference between style and class.

As to the weight of a Hascy.. I do not find the weight of a box to be a problem.. and thought  the Hascy to very manageable.
I do find balance to be an issue with some "heavier" accordeons . however, the Hascy is well balanced and a joy to play.

Just my usual humble opinion.
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: waltzman on February 07, 2010, 05:39:03 PM
What I left out:
In my most polite PC verbage.....

I concluded the Tommy was a "chick" box.  I sold it to a lady.  She "adored" it.. her words.  Thereby confirming my opinion.

I have also owned Lillys and liked them (except D/G) and do not consider them to be "chick" accordeons.

The embossed button is unnecessary and is at minimum a self absorbed design "affectation"  as is the "look at me, look at me"  new age script.. I have no doubt they are using a yuppie focus group for design input. They shopuld bag the button, the script and the new hideous grille designs and go back to the 80's  even earlier with the "window" boxes.. definitiely would show more class.  There is a distinct difference between style and class.

As to the weight of a Hascy.. I do not find the weight of a box to be a problem.. and thought  the Hascy to very manageable.
I do find balance to be an issue with some "heavier" accordeons . however, the Hascy is well balanced and a joy to play.

Just my usual humble opinion.
There is no need for this to degenerate into derogatory labeling.  Bellows size is just one of the many variables in melodeon construction.  All other things being equal,  the smaller bellows optimizes rapid pressure changes with less effort which would be best for fast tempo  dance music with lots of bellows reversals.  A larger bellows would optimize slower tempo and cross row playing with lots of chords.










Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: ladydetemps on February 07, 2010, 06:11:54 PM
Which is better Hascy or Tommy? There's only one way to find out...FIGHT!!!
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: nfldbox on February 07, 2010, 07:49:22 PM
The phrase "chickbox" certainly presents an interesting comment on the nature of the melodeon/accordion. I used to be an avid cyclist and often wound up in sports clinics for one injury or another. It amazed me that there were usually more musicians than athletes. The specific injuries were interesting but the usual answer was "if you play the violin you can't avoid this." You could do particular exercises to deal with the problem but the way of playing was as it was.
With the melodeon there are so many variations in terms of size. I play a small box and thus weight is not an issue. Also I play sitting down, Irish style, so the only real strength I need is in my left arm. I am a very large man--height not weight--but almost sixty with various beginnings of arthritis--a good part of which goes back to the cycling injuries--and I don't think I could handle something very heavy. I suppose the Cairdin mini could be a "chick box" but it certainly suits me.
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: melodeon on February 07, 2010, 08:55:00 PM
OK  OK   I apologize

I'll just call it a "girly" box.

Is that better ?
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: Lester on February 07, 2010, 09:36:20 PM
OK  OK   I apologize

I'll just call it a "girly" box.

Is that better ?

Who are you calling "girly"? As an 18 stone married father of two of advanced age I kind of think I am not an archetypal "girly" but I do play a Tommy. I have never had air problems with it and have played it vigorously for both morris and in my band.
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: Owen Woods on February 07, 2010, 11:15:44 PM
I am curious as to what "girly" or "chick box" really mean, other than the obvious, small and light? Which is by no means an accurate stereotype, I have seen millions of women strapped to wardrobes bigger than they are and I have seen strapping young with tiny little boxes. I would class myself in the latter bracket, I would really like a Lilliput or similar (:)
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: Andy Simpson on February 08, 2010, 02:45:29 AM
That's just reminded me of Lester's old avatar with him playing his Mignon that, with the absence of anything else for scale, could have been a photo of a giant playing a normal sized melodeon.  ;D

Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: Pete Dunk on February 08, 2010, 12:52:34 PM
I have seen millions of women strapped to wardrobes bigger than they are

Did we need to know this?   >:E
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: strad on February 08, 2010, 04:28:46 PM
I have seen millions of women strapped to wardrobes bigger than they are!

Tell us more!

Nigel

Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: melodeon on February 08, 2010, 09:58:50 PM
Just as Miatas and the New Age Mini is a "chic" car or a "girly" car..
so goes the Tommy

Where as the original Mini Cooper and Lotus Elan were not chickified ( I used to work on both )

I suggest that one might need to turn in your "man card" to buy or play a Tommy
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: LJC on February 08, 2010, 10:29:51 PM
I've been playing a Tommy (which was on loan, but I'll be posting up for sale soon) quite happily, and quite oblivious of any slur to my manhood it might be causing.

The treble end is good, 3rd voice is nice, I would rather have a 4th button start and loose the dog whistles up the far end. The stepped keyboard isn't quite to my liking.

The B fundamental on the bass end is pitched in the wrong octave in my opinion - its way to high compared to the others on the box, and other B bass notes on different boxes.

A few tweeks and it could be perfect, but I wouldn't pay £2999 or whatever crazy new price they are now for one.

That's my 2p worth anyway.
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: Guy on February 08, 2010, 10:48:18 PM


I can't believe I'm reading some of these comments in 2010! Or are these just ironic and  I've undergone a "sense of humour" by-pass? Personally, I play a Tommy. And a Giordy. And a big, bulky 2.5 row....I use them for different things, and don't change gender or sexual preference each time I pick up a different instrument. At least I don't think I do(Sudden moment of self-doubt)...And as for switching between the uke and the double bass....now then I get real identity confusion....

Cheers,
Guy
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: Keithypete. on February 09, 2010, 01:40:35 AM
Which is better Hascy or Tommy? There's only one way to find out...FIGHT!!!

LOL.


I can't help but wonder what would happen if Tommy and Sara - you know, sort of got it together.



Chickbox ??? ??? ???
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: Ellison on February 09, 2010, 08:04:44 AM
Which is better Hascy or Tommy? There's only one way to find out...FIGHT!!!

LOL.


I can't help but wonder what would happen if Tommy and Sara - you know, sort of got it together.



Chickbox ??? ??? ???

That's how the Saltarelle "Tara" was conceived
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: ladydetemps on February 09, 2010, 09:12:25 AM
Which is better Hascy or Tommy? There's only one way to find out...FIGHT!!!

LOL.


I can't help but wonder what would happen if Tommy and Sara - you know, sort of got it together.



Chickbox ??? ??? ???
What so the Smallness of the Tommy, but the tone of the Sara? That would be cool. (I keep them in seperate rooms and the Sara stays in the box).
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: Theo on February 09, 2010, 09:21:35 AM
What so the Smallness of the Tommy, but the tone of the Sara? That would be cool. (I keep them in seperate rooms and the Sara stays in the box).

Trouble is that trying to pack a lot into a small case, like the Tommy, inevitably leads to some compromises, eg fewer, or smaller bass reeds, and simply having a lot of reeds packed into a small space can make a big difference to the sound. 
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: Pushpull on February 09, 2010, 02:46:24 PM
Hello I'm Pushpull - and I have a small box.
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: paul earwicker on April 20, 2011, 02:06:49 PM
I had a fairly newTommy for a while last year, and it had 3 bass reeds and 3 chord reeds, no shared reeds. I believe they changed the design of the bass end a couple of years or so ago.

I have looked into two Tommys which are 15 years apart in age and they both have 16 reed plates mounted on one block.

A new Hascy has 24 reed plates mounted on two blocks.

Now to the sums!!
Let  b  be the number of bass reeds and   c  the number of chord reeds.  For the Hascy,
   24 = 4b + 4c   where the '4's are the number of buttons.
Dividing by 4 gives,
   6 = b + c.
So if  b = 2 then c =4.

For the Tommy,
   16 = 4b + 4s + 4c   where   s is the shared reed.
So,
   4 = b + s + c.       b =1,   s =1 and c = 2.
The bass note is b+s and the chord is s+c.  A two note bass and three note chord from 4 reeds.

A Lilly I have looked in has a similar block to the Tommy but does not share a reed.   b = 1  and c = 3.

Any questions or must I post snaps?
(I apologise for the algebra)
 
Ah! have just listened more carefully to the Hascy basses and b=3 and c=3.  i.e. three octaves for the bass note.  No wonder it sounds rather good.

Correction to the Lilly comments.  I have looked harder at the Lilly and it is the same shared reed arrangement as the Tommy.  However some reeds are smaller and sound and octave up.  This made the two notes in the base hard to hear.
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: Noodle on April 20, 2011, 02:45:47 PM
Oh go on then, I'll bite.

I think what melodeon's trying to articulate is that he's seen more women playing a Tommy than he's seen men play one. Would I be correct?
Title: Re: Tommy vs Hascy
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 20, 2011, 03:57:55 PM
1. Having had the honour of meeting Lester, there is not even the merest hint of 'girlie'
2. I own a Tommy because it fitted my small hands and felt comfortable, and was the most responsive I could find at a very large festival in UK.
3. I have no idea about 'chick box', though have confessed to having heard of Lindford Christie's 'lunch box'....
4. I agree with Guy and am somewhat taken aback about designating boxes with sexist labels.....

Surely it's different boxes for different people/playing styles?
Q
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal