Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Stiamh on February 26, 2008, 06:31:55 PM
-
Here's a nice Norwegian waltz on YouTube (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qos5LVrdDOs).
Apart from enjoying the tune, I was struck by the player's r/h fingering. For almost all of the tune he (?) is using the middle and ring fingers principally, with the first finger and little finger coming into play at either end of the keyboard. This must be the result of having the thumb tethered in a strap that seems to be placed very low. The hand and wrist seem to twist a great deal, too.
It's completely at odds with what I do. I put my thumb on the edge of the keyboard and use fingers in order of proximity to the thumb - heavy use of 1 and 2, a bit less of 3, and practically none of 4. I just can't imagine leaving my index finger flapping idle for great chunks of a tune like that, seems a total waste, and it made me itch watching it, especially that quick run up using 2 & 3... But, very nice playing.
Curious to know how others would compare their r/h technique with what's seen in this clip.
-
Whatever works!
I suppose that this player has developed a "2-finger" technique that works for him.
Check this Poll (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=331.0) on the right hand, and see the variety of settings.
I agree that using all fingers might be a "better" use of available resources :)
(BTW. Greetings from Toronto, I am originally from Montréal)
-
. I just can't imagine leaving my index finger flapping idle for great chunks of a tune like that, seems a total waste, and it made me itch watching it, especially that quick run up using 2 & 3... But, very nice playing.
Curious to know how others would compare their r/h technique with what's seen in this clip.
[/quote]
It just goes to prove that there are as many ways of fingering 2 row semitone boxes as there are players, and probably more ways of fingering 3 row semitone boxes than there are players!
Its not so much a question of whether to use 2,3 or 4 fingers as this can vary with the same player according to the needs of the tune, the art residing in finding the best fingering technique for particular passages . Thus if a goodly amount of playing is focused on say 4 or 5 buttons situated in close proximity it may be best to use 2 middle fingers , reserving the outer ones for the odd notes that crop up at a distance ,so to speak. Another reason for using 2 fingers is that it is sometimes quicker to 'walk' up or down the keyboard. Eg in the 4th bar of harvest home (in D) there is a 12 note run . I play it on the outer 2 rows i.e.BC rows using middle two fingers for 10 notes and first finger for just the 2 A's. Athol Highlanders (in A on either 2 or 3 rows) I play almost entirely with first 3 fingrs but randomly play the F# (outside row)with little finger!
Neither of these examples is either 'correct' or 'incorrect' and I find the most useful guideline to fingering to be 'if the fingering and bellows work of a bit of a particular tune feels very difficult experiment slowly with use of different fingers and also the use of the alternative B & E (on BC boxes) or their equivelant on other semitone boxes. Usually with a bit of perseverence a much easier way of doing it will emerge from the depths of somewhere.
george
-
Well I'm all for using two-finger sequences, George - see my contributions to the scales discussions. It's just that using middle and ring to the virtual exclusion of the first finger struck me as bizarre. There is an even more striking example of the same player's technique in this clip: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rIcnPhb4o1w But - works for him (her?)
Makes we wish we could see his bass hand - maybe he's using middle and index there too! ;D
-
How about using three fingers (http://youtube.com/watch?v=6fTqL9FTC_Q)then?
-
Well I'm all for using two-finger sequences, George - see my contributions to the scales discussions. It's just that using middle and ring to the virtual exclusion of the first finger struck me as bizarre. There is an even more striking example of the same player's technique in this clip: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rIcnPhb4o1w But - works for him (her?)
...
It looks as if the bulk of the tune falls easily within the reach of the middle 2 fingers , leaving the 1st &4th figner to deal with anything a bit furthur away which is actually quite a sensible way of doing it as it minimises hand movement. Not so much only using 2 fingers but more like a pretty sensible division of labour between the 4 fingers. It also leaves fingers 1 & 4 free for the playing of grace notes or chords whilst the middle two are doing their stuff with the tune. A technique that well be worth experimenting with.
george
-
Hey, Django Reinhardt make his hallmark playing guitar chords with only two fingers!
-
I've been using a similar fingering pattern myself especially when I cross rows,the 3rd finger finds itself on the outside,mid finger on the inside row and 1st finger on the inside.I found that when I was playing upper octave scales(ironicaly on scandinavian waltzes) my 1st and mid fingers would trip over themselves.Finger length has determined that this is a more natural and comfortable fingering for me.
Btw I'd seen this fellows video's before and I'd forgotten how good he is.He plays with perfect rythym and his Corso sounds beautiful.I much prefer his versions of scandinavian tunes than any I've heard by the pros on their dry tuned Costalottis.
On this Mazurka clip you can see the bass being played and there are some nice bass runs around 0.50 onwards. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-DmtvUvsnVI&feature=related
-
The Newfoundland box player Bernard Felix has a truly dazzling technique and he's missing at least two fingers on his right hand (his day job is in a muffler shop). I'm not sure which two fingers he lacks, but he's one of those guys who turns most of (my) understanding of box technique, genres, and idioms on its head. He plays a combination of Acadian and Irish one-row style on an Italian A/D/G. There's a very distinctive Newfoundland style which he weaves in there as well. Great stuff!
-
Btw I'd seen this fellows video's before and I'd forgotten how good he is.He plays with perfect rythym and his Corso sounds beautiful.I much prefer his versions of scandinavian tunes than any I've heard by the pros on their dry tuned Costalottis.
On this Mazurka clip you can see the bass being played and there are some nice bass runs around 0.50 onwards. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-DmtvUvsnVI&feature=related
Great playing. 8)
Once again its the player, not the box that makes the music.
-
I just can't imagine leaving my index finger flapping idle for great chunks of a tune like that, seems a total waste
The guy in the clip might just have a bad index finger; I know other players who don't use all fingers due to old injuries. But there are other reasons for letting it 'flap idle'. For some tunes I was tought not to use my index finger for the melody in order to use it later for lower harmonizing notes. That way you can use the same fingering for the melody and play a nice countermelody in the repeat.