Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: ladydetemps on February 08, 2010, 10:57:42 AM

Title: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: ladydetemps on February 08, 2010, 10:57:42 AM
Just something I'd like to know.

Are you trying to play like someone else? Who would that be? Would you like to sound exactly the same or do it in your own way? Do you want to create your own style/sound that others will copy or not as the case may be?

Me I'd like to sound like myself playing well, rather than be compared to others.

(I think thats what put me off fan fiction....I was great at imitating someone's style of writing but when having to do an original story with original characters in my own style I was lost.)

But is it possible to be original or will there always be elements of other players in there?

What other elements influence playing style?
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Howard Jones on February 08, 2010, 11:16:22 AM
I think it's better to try to develop your own style, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't be influenced by other players whose style you admire.

Listen to (and where possible watch) as many players as you can.  I think the best approach is to try to reproduce the things you like best from someone's style, but not to slavishly imitate them.  In time, these will merge together with your own ideas to form the foundation of a style of your own.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Lester on February 08, 2010, 11:20:48 AM
I think it's better to try to develop your own style, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't be influenced by other players whose style you admire.

Listen to (and where possible watch) as many players as you can.  I think the best approach is to try to reproduce the things you like best from someone's style, but not to slavishly imitate them.  In time, these will merge together with your own ideas to form the foundation of a style of your own.


What Howard said
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: oggiesnr on February 08, 2010, 11:24:59 AM
My style on one instrument is also influenced by the other instruments that I play (and vice versa, I play a lot of double notes on mandolin for example).

Style is also an amalgam of my limitations (vibration white finger and other hand injuries limits speed) and the different musical influences I've been exposed to.  I started out as a morris musician then discovered irish music and then jazz.  The result is that none of the music I play would probably satisfy a purist but it is just the way I play.

Steve
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Clive Williams on February 08, 2010, 11:26:46 AM
I think it's ok to try to copy other people's styles; you'll inevitably do something just a little different to them anyway and I expect you'll find yourself wanting to copy more than one person. So before you know it, presto, you've got your own style which is different to anything you're trying to copy. 

Different players have different tricks and techniques - if you can figure out what some of them are (workshops are very good for that) and build yourself a repertoire of tricks, you'll find yourself well placed to be flexible in your playing. One other thing... don't just consider copying melodeon players; careful listening to other instrumentalists can teach you different ways of approaching a tune - it's not all about ornamentation and technical cleverness - a lot of it is about musicality which is applicable to any instrument.

Cheers,

Clive

Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: juker on February 08, 2010, 11:32:01 AM
Believe me, If I was capable of slavishly imitating DTN I would do it! :|||: :|||:
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Andy in Vermont on February 08, 2010, 11:43:37 AM
At this point, I've learned tunes from many different sources in many different ways.  I'm trying to play each tune in the best way I can, trying to make it sound "right" according to what my ears tell me the tune is "supposed to" sound like --- again, a product of a lot of listening.  The style simply emerges from this, not from any special effort to sound original.  If I felt the need to press my identity into the music, I would compose a tune (which would, again, be subject to the influences mentioned earlier...).  I guess that I'm not a big fan of the notion of originality as it is conventionally understood!  "May the circle be unbroken."
-Andy
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: ladydetemps on February 08, 2010, 11:52:27 AM
Mum said to me the other day I play like I speak, short, sharp, quiet with occasional mumbling. lol!
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: LIAM-ROBINSON on February 08, 2010, 12:16:07 PM
As time goes by, you will create your own style.  The style will be influenced by all the people you listen to and play with (whether they are melodeon players or not), it's something that happens over time and you probably won't notice it developing.  Don't be too conscious of it - divorcing your analytical and conscious mind from the creative artistic part of your mind and the relaxed state this creates can do wonders for the quality and experience of playing music -

In fact, there is lots and lots of focus on technique and the nuts and bolts of playing but very seldom is the idea of relaxation, philosophy and state of mind during playing mentioned. 

Just like anything, if you can achieve a relaxed but focused state of mind and put aside the issues that the conscious logical side of your mind raises - for example the fear of making a mistake in a difficult passage, then your playing will probably improve.  By blocking those negative messages from the conscious mind, we can release all of the information stored in the creative part of the brain and allow it to flow freely without it being cut off by doubts and fear...

Blimey this sounds like I'm starting some kind of cult.....apologies to everybody!!!!!  :-)
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 08, 2010, 12:20:05 PM
Yes -  what Howard, Clive and Liam have said. Spot on, all three of you, in my opinion!
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: LIAM-ROBINSON on February 08, 2010, 12:51:46 PM
Not sure what the conscious mind has done to deserve such a bad press. I wouldn't be without mine, even when playing.
And if you want a less sanguine view of the unconscious you only have to read a bit of Freud (Sigmund, that is, not Clement)

The terms I used were just a way of visualising a method of achieving a relaxed state of mind.  I don't think I would want to be without my consciousness but as a way of explaining this particular theory, this works ok.  It's more about relaxation and focussing than a deeper look at the nature inner thought ;-)  

And if I took this too far I think I'd probably end up starting a cult and wearing robes to gigs....:-)
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Mike Gott on February 08, 2010, 12:57:59 PM
Personally, I've always gone out of my way to avoid playing like anyone else - I've never been to a workshop or anything like that, being more concerned with having my own identity as a player and letting that develop naturally. Having got into this through a traditional musician rather than the folk scene has probably had an influence here in that I don't have a studious approach to what I'm doing, I'm just someone who knocks out tunes on a melodeon. Of course there will be players who will subconsciously influence how you play or approach playing, but that's a different thing. Personally, I can't see the point of copying somebody else. Tonight, Matthew, I'm still going to be me.

I remember old Jimmy Shand being interviewed and being asked what his best bit of advice was to upcoming players, and he said "..not to copy anybody else, develop your own style.." and that does for me too. But we're all different, thank goodness.

Mike

PS - nice to see Liam on here, Lincolnshire melodeon players unite...........
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Bob Ellis on February 08, 2010, 01:03:09 PM
I think you begin to develop your own style, Sarah, the moment you move away from the written musical score and start playing from memory. You are then listening to the tune as it sounds in your own mind and reproducing that as far as your level of skill will allow.

One way of encouraging the development of your own style is to hum or sing tunes to yourself when you are doing something else (I often do it when I am walking my dogs). Ways of ornamenting the tune or adding emphasis to certain notes whilst lightening others will occur naturally and these can then be incorporated into your playing of the tune.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: mikesamwild on February 08, 2010, 01:03:41 PM
I was reading the other day about MRI scan of the brains of golfers in action.  The less experienced had lots of areas flickering on and off  whereas the pros had a few areas very focussed ( a bit like our cat with its eye on a bird!)

I wonder if such players 'in the zone' listen much to other folk in sessions though ;)
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: ladydetemps on February 08, 2010, 01:04:03 PM
Not sure what the conscious mind has done to deserve such a bad press. I wouldn't be without mine, even when playing.
And if you want a less sanguine view of the unconscious you only have to read a bit of Freud (Sigmund, that is, not Clement)

The terms I used were just a way of visualising a method of achieving a relaxed state of mind.  I don't think I would want to be without my consciousness but as a way of explaining this particular theory, this works ok.  It's more about relaxation and focussing than a deeper look at the nature inner thought ;-)  

And if I took this too far I think I'd probably end up starting a cult and wearing robes to gigs....:-)

Don't think music for me has ever been relaxing...too much thought involved. Reading books however puts me to sleep.

The Cult of Liam? :D lol
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: ladydetemps on February 08, 2010, 01:06:56 PM

I wonder if such players 'in the zone' listen much to other folk in sessions though ;)
I hate that feeling when I don't know if its me thats gone wrong or someone else with a similar sounding instrument...it puts me off and then I get nervous every time I get to that same point.

I think you begin to develop your own style, Sarah, the moment you move away from the written musical score and start playing from memory. You are then listening to the tune as it sounds in your own mind and reproducing that as far as your level of skill will allow.

One way of encouraging the development of your own style is to hum or sing tunes to yourself when you are doing something else (I often do it when I am walking my dogs). Ways of ornamenting the tune or adding emphasis to certain notes whilst lightening others will occur naturally and these can then be incorporated into your playing of the tune.
I'm always suspicious of my memory....it tends to corrupt tunes and hear them in a lazy way and think 'close enough' rather than actually being accurate.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Theo on February 08, 2010, 01:18:47 PM

I wonder if such players 'in the zone' listen much to other folk in sessions though ;)
I hate that feeling when I don't know if its me thats gone wrong or someone else with a similar sounding instrument...it puts me off and then I get nervous every time I get to that same point.

It takes time and much practice to get to the point where you can play with the relaxed state of mind described by Liam.  It can't be achieved by simply saying to yourself "stop worrying and relax" though giving yourself messages like that can be a help.  How long it takes is a question only you will only be able to answer, when you start to get there.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: george garside on February 08, 2010, 01:28:21 PM
[quote author=Mike Gott link=topic=3452.msg42012#msg42012 date= . Personally, I can't see the point of copying somebody else. Tonight, Matthew, I'm still going to be me.

I remember old Jimmy Shand being interviewed and being asked what his best bit of advice was to upcoming players, and he said "..not to copy anybody else, develop your own style.." and that does for me too. But we're all different, thank goodness.

Mike

Quite agree Mike, I also think that by & large those who learn tunes by ear & play from memory are more likely to , either accidentally or on purpose , develop a distinctive style, particularly in the way they ';play the gaps'  whereas many avid dot readers  feel absolutely unable to play i a tune even a wee bit different to the as writ version - its all a question of long & short notes rather than quavers & croshits etc!

george ;)
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 08, 2010, 01:29:22 PM
..... I've never been to a workshop or anything like that, being more concerned with having my own identity as a player and letting that develop naturally.....
Just to pick up on this one.....
I understand what you are saying Mike. However, I think you could be mistaken in equating attending a workshop with losing your identity as an individual player as a result. It doesn't work like that. There are some really good workshops around, with some good things to learn about technique and style which you may not have thought of previously. It doesn't mean that you will be 'corrupted' with someone else's style.

Think of a workshop as a means of equipping yourself with some extra tools. It's then up to you how you go away and use them. The analogy would be going on a digital photography course, where everyone is taught to use the same type of camera and computer software. However the end result will be completely different for each person; everyone will bring their own creativity into play and everyone's photos will be completely different.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: ladydetemps on February 08, 2010, 01:32:02 PM

Think of a workshop as a means of equipping yourself with some extra tools. It's then up to you how you go away and use them. The analogy would be going on a digital photography course, where everyone is taught to use the same type of camera and computer software. However the end result will be completely different for each person; everyone will bring their own creativity into play and everyone's photos will be completely different.
In my case photo's would be out of focus. lol!
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: michik on February 08, 2010, 01:38:36 PM

Are you trying to play like someone else? Who would that be? Would you like to sound exactly the same or do it in your own way? Do you want to create your own style/sound that others will copy or not as the case may be?

What other elements influence playing style?

No, I do not try to play like someone else, I try to play the music as I hear it in my head and how I'd like to hear it.
I'm taking lessons, so I will take over some technical things from my teacher, but not the complete "style" as a whole.

Michael.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: LDbosca on February 08, 2010, 01:45:27 PM
..... I've never been to a workshop or anything like that, being more concerned with having my own identity as a player and letting that develop naturally.....
Just to pick up on this one.....
I understand what you are saying Mike. However, I think you could be mistaken in equating attending a workshop with losing your identity as an individual player as a result. It doesn't work like that. There are some really good workshops around, with some good things to learn about technique and style which you may not have thought of previously. It doesn't mean that you will be 'corrupted' with someone else's style.

Think of a workshop as a means of equipping yourself with some extra tools. It's then up to you how you go away and use them. The analogy would be going on a digital photography course, where everyone is taught to use the same type of camera and computer software. However the end result will be completely different for each person; everyone will bring their own creativity into play and everyone's photos will be completely different.

Gonna second this. What's the point in being 100 percent original at the expense of missing out on the techniques and ideas you might not have thought of or noticed that you could learn at something like a workshop? All the great players listen and learn every place they can. The more things you pick up from other players the more components you have that will form part of your style, making it richer.

I find it curious that amateur or semi-professional players (like most of us are) would be so concerned that they're losing they're great spark of originality by copying people. Unless you're at a pretty serious level this probably doesn't matter in the slightest. Even when I've really tried to cop someone else's style I'm still applying their techniques on top of everything I've learned so far and also then influenced by my own musical taste, so something new is happening from the start. Even if it sounds exactly like them for the first few days of playing it doesn't for long after that.

Listen! Copy! Adapt!
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: nfldbox on February 08, 2010, 04:06:45 PM
Believe me, If I was capable of slavishly imitating Joe Derrane I would do it!  :||:
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: forrest on February 08, 2010, 04:38:58 PM
I'm always suspicious of my memory....it tends to corrupt tunes and hear them in a lazy way and think 'close enough' rather than actually being accurate.

 Memory is one of those tools we need in order to widen our abilities. What does it mean to "corrupt" a tune? If you are a classically trained musician, you must reproduce precisely the contents of the score, even down to the tempo, volume, and to some extent expression, that is indicated thereon. This seems quite limiting, (and corruptable) at least in my view.
   Part of the joy of playing the music we choose is to express it in our own way to some extent. If we examine this music, we can see that it has evolved through the playing of others before us. To me, that seems to be the essence of folk music. Now, laziness, that's another thing altogether...... ;D
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: ladydetemps on February 08, 2010, 04:40:20 PM
I'm always suspicious of my memory....it tends to corrupt tunes and hear them in a lazy way and think 'close enough' rather than actually being accurate.

 Memory is one of those tools we need in order to widen our abilities. What does it mean to "corrupt" a tune? If you are a classically trained musician, you must reproduce precisely the contents of the score, even down to the tempo, volume, and to some extent expression, that is indicated thereon. This seems quite limiting, (and corruptable) at least in my view.
   Part of the joy of playing the music we choose is to express it in our own way to some extent. If we examine this music, we can see that it has evolved through the playing of others before us.
You can't join in with everyone else if your not playing the same thing can you?
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: LIAM-ROBINSON on February 08, 2010, 04:43:42 PM
It takes time and much practice to get to the point where you can play with the relaxed state of mind described by Liam.  It can't be achieved by simply saying to yourself "stop worrying and relax" though giving yourself messages like that can be a help.  How long it takes is a question only you will only be able to answer, when you start to get there.

[/quote]

i think whatever level you're playing at you can benefit from relaxation and focussing techniques and yes it is more complex than just saying "stop worrying and relax".  Some of my ideas come from "The Inner Game of Music" by Green and Gallwey but there is loads of stuff out there about performance related relaxation techniques.  Playing music when somebody else is listening is a really exposing thing and our nerves usually start working over-time.  whether you're a beginner or a seasoned performer removing some of this tension is going to really help.

Has anybody else on here ever used any techniques like this successfully????
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on February 08, 2010, 04:48:15 PM
i take insparation from the players around me but i try and pick different bits out that i hear in scottish irish and newfoundland music to be different, like, i might try a few little ornaments that i have heard jacky daly play, and fit them in to a tune i know and then play it in the style i like, so insteasd of being "dartmoor style" its "tommys dartmoor style" i gues it just comes down to what you like?
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: oggiesnr on February 08, 2010, 04:52:50 PM

 Memory is one of those tools we need in order to widen our abilities. What does it mean to "corrupt" a tune? If you are a classically trained musician, you must reproduce precisely the contents of the score, even down to the tempo, volume, and to some extent expression, that is indicated thereon.

Not necesarily true.  If it were most conductors and soloists would not be needed.

As an example listen to the Elgar Cello Conerto played by Dupree, Rostropovich and Yo-Yo Ma.  Each is very different even though it's the same piece.

Steve
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: GbH on February 08, 2010, 05:03:23 PM
Speaking as someone who's on the 'autistic spectrum', I tend to consider 'individuality' as being something of a double-edged sword.  It seems that there are a lot of people who speak of creativeness and difference as being a good thing, only to get upset when they actually encounter it.    :(
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Theo on February 08, 2010, 05:11:15 PM

You can't join in with everyone else if your not playing the same thing can you?

I know what you mean LDT,  but it does not you have to play exactly the same, it just has to fit into the same musical framework.  If that were not true there would be no such thing as harmony, counterpoint, improvisation etc etc, and the world of music would be very bare and uninteresting.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: forrest on February 08, 2010, 05:29:44 PM

Not necesarily true.  If it were most conductors and soloists would not be needed.

As an example listen to the Elgar Cello Conerto played by Dupree, Rostropovich and Yo-Yo Ma.  Each is very different even though it's the same piece.

Steve

  I'm not familiar with the example, but only trying to indicate (perhaps not skillfully) that there is sufficient leeway in our chosen music genre to step outside the box, as I think is well demonstrated by the members of this website.

You can't join in with everyone else if your not playing the same thing can you?

In my estimation, you only need be 'close enough'. One of the delights of listening to good session music is that each player has it slightly different, and this 'raggedness' gives it the charm, instead of everyone playing in absolute lock-step unison.....


Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Mike Gott on February 08, 2010, 06:10:50 PM
.... learn about technique and style which you may not have thought of previously. ....

Thanks for that Steve, but I guess I'm just happy to plough my own furrow outside of the classroom type environment. I've just always been happy to work it out for myself, and if I can't do that, I'm happy simply not to do it! Like I say, I'm not playing melodeon as any kind of study or excercise and the whole thing of of sitting in a class with teacher just is'nt for me. For other people it's just what they need and that's great, I don't have a problem with that. I guess you'll just never catch me at Witney!

Mike
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: nfldbox on February 08, 2010, 07:39:40 PM
It boggles my little old mind why anyone would avoid all teaching, including group teaching, in anything. I have done a lot of home renovation and a bit of proper education could have saved me a few broken pipes and wonky joins.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Mike Gott on February 08, 2010, 08:34:35 PM
It boggles my little old mind why anyone would avoid all teaching, including group teaching, in anything........

I suppose, when you're looking at something that you're doing for pleasure, if you don't like the classroom type learning environment with people telling you what to do, you don't go into it if you don't need to. For reasons I've never really understood, the world of folk music has a suprisingly large number of participants who work in the education business, so maybe the classroom and formalised teacher/student approach is what a significant number are most at home with as a learning medium? Personally I prefer a seat of the pants type approach, and I don't like to feel that I'm being processed. Maybe I'm living in the wrong era - others have said this - and would have been better placed in the pre-folk revival days when people had to learn to play without festivals, workshop weekends, webgroups and the like and just sat down and got on with it......

To each their own. Anybody have a time machine I could borrow?

Mike
 
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: nfldbox on February 08, 2010, 09:37:04 PM
But if you follow the stories of most famous traditional musicians from the past, they learned from important teachers, often in very restrictive environments where their teachers told them exactly what to do and it was that way or the doorway. I think a trad workshop is much more open-minded.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 08, 2010, 10:01:31 PM
.... learn about technique and style which you may not have thought of previously. ....

Thanks for that Steve, but I guess I'm just happy to plough my own furrow outside of the classroom type environment. I've just always been happy to work it out for myself, and if I can't do that, I'm happy simply not to do it! Like I say, I'm not playing melodeon as any kind of study or excercise and the whole thing of of sitting in a class with teacher just is'nt for me. For other people it's just what they need and that's great, I don't have a problem with that. I guess you'll just never catch me at Witney!

Mike
Then fair enough, Mike. In music, and probably the creative arts in general, there is no 'one size fits all''. You have clearly worked out what is best for you, so stick with it.  (:)  I admire your honesty.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: LJC on February 08, 2010, 10:43:58 PM
I had an interesting chat with Tony Hall when he was in Lewes and he said that he started playing the melodeon when he was young, and never saw or heard another player for many years. He started playing guitar and taking it to folk clubs instead of his box because he didn't think it would be appropriate there - it was a revelation when he found it was an accepted instrument and you could play tunes on it (apparently he was learning Beatles tunes of the radio at that point).

The point of this story? Don't listen to melodeon players and you'll come out sounding totally original and unique!
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: ladydetemps on February 08, 2010, 10:46:49 PM
My time machine is in the garage.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Sandy on February 08, 2010, 10:59:36 PM
Listen! Copy! Adapt!

 I generally follow this too. I can be creative but need the basic tools to build something. Listening to more players and attending a range of workshops is what I really need.

Sandy
 (:)
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Ollie on February 08, 2010, 11:24:39 PM
I like to think that my style of playing is an amalagmation of different people's styles, together with my own personal slant on it that is impossible to get away from. The more I play, the more my style develops and changes. I don't deliberately copy things from people, although if I'm playing with someone at a festival, and they do something that I like, I will more often than not try to imitate that and encorporate that into my playing.

Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Bob Ellis on February 09, 2010, 10:55:44 AM
I guess I'm just happy to plough my own furrow outside of the classroom type environment. I've just always been happy to work it out for myself, and if I can't do that, I'm happy simply not to do it! Like I say, I'm not playing melodeon as any kind of study or excercise and the whole thing of of sitting in a class with teacher just is'nt for me. For other people it's just what they need and that's great, I don't have a problem with that. I guess you'll just never catch me at Witney!

Mike

You may have got the wrong idea about workshops, Mike! In my experience, most of them are not the formalised classroom teaching you might think them to be. They are more like a group of musicians sitting around sharing ideas about how to play tunes and picking up tips from each other in a relaxed and informal manner. In some workshops, I have picked up as much from fellow as students as I have from the leader of the workshop. As others have said, these tips become absorbed into your own style and enhance it rather than imposing someone else's style on your playing.

Having said that, if you are comfortable with working things out for yourself, then fine. There are many ways to enjoy playng, but I wonder whether you might be denying yourself the opportunity to develop in ways that would not occur to you without input from someone else.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Theo on February 09, 2010, 12:34:31 PM
Thanks for that Steve, but I guess I'm just happy to plough my own furrow outside of the classroom type environment. I've just always been happy to work it out for myself, and if I can't do that, I'm happy simply not to do it! Like I say, I'm not playing melodeon as any kind of study or excercise and the whole thing of of sitting in a class with teacher just is'nt for me. For other people it's just what they need and that's great, I don't have a problem with that. I guess you'll just never catch me at Witney!

Mike

I have a lot of sympathy with your point of view Mike, and I'm an ex-teacher!  In the past few years, since I escaped from school work, I've signed up for two adult education courses, not music related at all.  In both I was so bored by the deadly slow pace of learning that I stopped going less than half way through.  I think some of us prefer to teach ourselves, while others like to have a guiding hand. 

I have been to a good number of music workshops though, some wonderfully inspiring some terribly disappointing, and what makes a good workshop for me is getting an idea of something that I can work on, ideally something that I can explore and develop over subsequent days, weeks, months....  What I'm not keen on is just going to a workshop to learn tunes, unless the tunes are used as a means of some sort of musical development.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: ladydetemps on February 09, 2010, 12:40:19 PM
I actually find workshops petrifying....but still sign up for them. I have no idea why...maybe they are a bit addictive...kinda like the rides at a theme park.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: juker on February 09, 2010, 12:51:45 PM
The closest that I have come to a workshop so far (only playing for about a year) is learning the Tunes of the Month, watching the other  performances and reading some of the interesting critiques from people knowledgeable enough to offer constructive criticism or point out strengths in other's playing of a particular piece. I have learned a lot from this I think but I am completely incapable of consciously imitating someone else's playing and trying to learn a tune at the same time, so the world is safe from the possibility of a serious competitor to any of the great players out there coming from my part of the world (:) However I am a reasonably skilled artist and I still attend a regular painting class, partly because working with other painters challenges me and can push me out of the comfort zone that I might slip into I didn't engage with other people's ideas and ways of interpreting them. Perhaps workshops serve this function too.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Theo on February 09, 2010, 12:53:30 PM
I actually find workshops petrifying....but still sign up for them. I have no idea why...maybe they are a bit addictive...kinda like the rides at a theme park.

 But after you have put yourself through the workshop do you feel you have benefited?

In an earlier post you mentioned worrying about playing a wrong note.  You could try telling your self-critical part that it doesn't matter (it really doesn't). If you do play a different note from the others all that matters is that you are aware that its different, then you can decide if its was a good different note or not.  The great advantage of melodeon is that if you press either button next to the one you intended it almost always sound ok, so all you have done is a bit of improvisation.

Two useful things to think about:  1 all musicians, however brilliant were once complete beginner, 2) all musicians, however brilliant make the occasional mistake

Liam mentioned "The Inner Game of Music" by Green and Gallwey a few posts back.   I think you would find it useful.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: ladydetemps on February 09, 2010, 01:07:38 PM
I actually find workshops petrifying....but still sign up for them. I have no idea why...maybe they are a bit addictive...kinda like the rides at a theme park.

 But after you have put yourself through the workshop do you feel you have benefited?

Hmmmm....straight after...no. But a year after Yeah....
After a year usually just getting to grips with what was learnt. lol!
I am sooooo slow.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: melod-ian on February 09, 2010, 01:15:50 PM
a good combination of both  imitation & individuality… when I started out I wanted to play as good as john Kirkpatrick and Roger Watson … and although I was tutored by Roger.. our styles have ended up completely different.

Imitation works at the beginning .. and individuality comes later.., personally I’ve avoided workshops as much as possible..but that’s been my way, I don’t go to folk festivals
I think the day I discovered blues was the day that changed my style for good..
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: mikesamwild on February 09, 2010, 03:11:24 PM
But if you follow the stories of most famous traditional musicians from the past, they learned from important teachers, often in very restrictive environments where their teachers told them exactly what to do and it was that way or the doorway. I think a trad workshop is much more open-minded.


That's very interesting. William Kimber said his father told him ' those are the notes and you don't play any others'. The bards of Gaelic culture had a very rigorous training before they 'found' their own voice or style. Where would Dylan have been without his imitation of Woody Guthry et al?

'My way or the highway' does seem to be the approach of  a lot of teachers but they are part of the process of committed teaching and handing on of tradition. You can vote with your feet if it's not to your taste.

A topic in itself and one I'm sure has been ,  and will be, dealt with again on this and other forums (fora if we are being pedantic)


We have a friend who came to play at our pub who could do Anji and Albatross perfectly on guitar but nothing else.  We still called for a performance and gave him rapturous applause and meant it, he was one of us!
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Matthew B on February 09, 2010, 03:13:28 PM
 Believe me, If I was capable of slavishly imitating Joe Derrane I would do it!  :||:  

However, I strongly suspect that if you could, you wouldn't want to any more.  
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Ellison on February 09, 2010, 04:52:34 PM
When I started playing I definitely copied others' style. In fact you could probably tell where I'd learnt the tune by the way I played it - Rod Stradling, John Kirkpatrick, Bob Cann, Oscar Woods, Tufty Swift etc. etc. I had multiple melodeon personalities. I did this partly because I thought you had to but most likely because the way they played was attracting me to the tune.

Of course over time all these influences were (hopefully) absorbed and I hope I've developed my own style but it's a natural process not forced. Sometimes it annoys the stink out of me that I can't waltz off into Cajun or French or Irish or Tex-Mex - it just sounds like me.

But I still do it now! For instance if I'm learning a tune from a recording (can't read music anyway) I'll play along as close as I can to the player's style (and not just melodeon players) because I like the phrasing etc. I'll go away and play the tune over and over to get it fluent and in the muscle memory, go back to the recording and it's totally different - it's me again.

In short read 'copy' in the long term as 'absorb', it's all grist to the mill-odeon.

Martin
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: melod-ian on February 10, 2010, 02:03:22 PM
When I started playing I definitely copied others' style. In fact you could probably tell where I'd learnt the tune by the way I played it - Rod Stradling, John Kirkpatrick, Bob Cann, Oscar Woods, Tufty Swift etc. etc. I had multiple melodeon personalities. I did this partly because I thought you had to but most likely because the way they played was attracting me to the tune.

Of course over time all these influences were (hopefully) absorbed and I hope I've developed my own style but it's a natural process not forced. Sometimes it annoys the stink out of me that I can't waltz off into Cajun or French or Irish or Tex-Mex - it just sounds like me.

But I still do it now! For instance if I'm learning a tune from a recording (can't read music anyway) I'll play along as close as I can to the player's style (and not just melodeon players) because I like the phrasing etc. I'll go away and play the tune over and over to get it fluent and in the muscle memory, go back to the recording and it's totally different - it's me again.

In short read 'copy' in the long term as 'absorb', it's all grist to the mill-odeon.

Martin

I guess if your only playing by ear with a recording your going to take on that particular style…whether that becomes YOUR style or not depends your ability
im find that out right now with  Mamou Two Step… as with most Cajun stuff there’s millions of versions littered across the Net.. I’ve gone with my favourite,  Roddie Romero’s version (if anyone’s interested) – more complicated than most, but if I end up sounding anything like the recording… Job done


Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: forrest on February 10, 2010, 04:51:24 PM
I guess if your only playing by ear with a recording your going to take on that particular style…whether that becomes YOUR style or not depends your ability...........
.................. more complicated than most, but if I end up sounding anything like the recording… Job done

  It's part of a process:
                           a. How do they do that?  ???

                           b. I understand how they do that.  :D

                           c. Hey! I'm doing that!  ;D

                           d. I still like that, but I think I'll  change this part just a bit.......  ::)
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on February 10, 2010, 10:57:42 PM
I thought they'd stopped doing that in Paris. They've got this d****d great obelisk in La Place now instead of the late Madame G. Certainly all the knitters have returned to Dent.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: nfldbox on February 10, 2010, 11:48:52 PM
J.W. Forrest:
 
It's part of a process:
                           a. How do they do that? 

                           b. I understand how they do that. 

                           c. Hey! I'm doing that! 

                           d. I still like that, but I think I'll  change this part just a bit.......

Beautifully put 
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Bob Ellis on February 11, 2010, 08:18:20 PM
Certainly all the knitters have returned to Dent.

I was in Dent yesterday and didn't see any knitters - 'terrible' or otherwise. Perhaps they were having a knit and natter party - or perhaps a guillotine party.  >:E
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Sandy on February 11, 2010, 10:58:12 PM
I guess if your only playing by ear with a recording your going to take on that particular style…whether that becomes YOUR style or not depends your ability...........
.................. more complicated than most, but if I end up sounding anything like the recording… Job done

  It's part of a process:
                           a. How do they do that?  ???

                           b. I understand how they do that.  :D

                           c. Hey! I'm doing that!  ;D

                           d. I still like that, but I think I'll  change this part just a bit.......  ::)

I can relate to that  (:)
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 11, 2010, 11:45:41 PM
Certainly all the knitters have returned to Dent.

I was in Dent yesterday and didn't see any knitters - 'terrible' or otherwise. Perhaps they were having a knit and natter party - or perhaps a guillotine party.  >:E

http://www.english-lakes.com/dent.html

Oh the Terrible Knitters of Dent,
Their fingers are gnarled and they're bent,
And the tourists are staying where inn signs are swaying,
And the fountain sings Sedgewick's lament.


(1st verse of song by Mike Donald in "Yorkshire Songs of the Broad Acres")
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Donald-Mike-Yorkshire-Songs-Of-The-Broad-Acres-LP-Folk_W0QQitemZ350270478030QQcmdZViewItemQQptZUK_Records?hash=item518dbf56ce

'Settle and Carlisle Railway':
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S1nr_O8TP08
Three of Mike's songs on here, although not the 'Terrible Knitters', unfortunately.

Sorry - just couldn't resist. Not Dent, but not far away either....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8X7mVOZk54M

Edited to replace defunct link.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: GuyWyatt on February 12, 2010, 07:58:54 AM
Quote
Sorry - just couldn't resist. Not Dent, but not far away either....
http://www.youtube.com/watch#v=8X7mVOZk54M&feature=related

Hmmm.....
Couldn't really dance to that rhythm could you?
Guy
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Bob Ellis on February 12, 2010, 04:14:26 PM
I didn't know that you are a gricer, Steve, but they can't touch you for it - you don't even need a licence!   ::)
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 12, 2010, 04:38:26 PM
I didn't know that you are a gricer, Steve, but they can't touch you for it - you don't even need a licence!   ::)
Beautiful elegant machines; I love them. Part of my childhood. My grandfather used to build 4" gauge steam locomotives in his workshop at the bottom of his garden. He taught me to use a lathe when I was 4 years old. And we'd go to watch the LMS trains from the footbridge on Luton Midland Road station bound for St Pancras or Sheffield
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Quebecois on February 12, 2010, 05:10:48 PM
"Never play the same note the same way twice".
-- Louis Armstrong
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Bob Ellis on February 12, 2010, 09:48:24 PM
I didn't know that you are a gricer, Steve, but they can't touch you for it - you don't even need a licence!   ::)
Beautiful elegant machines; I love them. Part of my childhood. My grandfather used to build 4" gauge steam locomotives in his workshop at the bottom of his garden. He taught me to use a lathe when I was 4 years old. And we'd go to watch the LMS trains from the footbridge on Luton Midland Road station bound for St Pancras or Sheffield

I quite agree. Although I spend more time building finescale railway models than watching the real thing.

Sorry about the thread drift, folks. I'll go and stand on the naughty step and take my railway models with me.  :|bl
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: george garside on February 13, 2010, 12:25:23 PM
 Whitby folk week has two 'extra' benefits for those of us who love steam traction.

 - steam trains running into the main station in the town by the side of the harbour.

-   the only 6 wheel steam bus in existance running regular 20 minute or so trips from the bandstand every day  (Sentinal DG6) - wonderful to watch it climbing the Kyber Pass ( yes, a hill in Whitby so named!)

- and its  one of the best festivals in the callender

george
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: ladydetemps on February 24, 2012, 03:44:25 PM
I was wondering......do I sound like 'me' yet?
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: mory on February 24, 2012, 04:16:58 PM
You'd have to know what you sound like first, otherwise you wont be able to tell if it's you or not  ;D
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: ladydetemps on February 24, 2012, 04:28:56 PM
You'd have to know what you sound like first, otherwise you wont be able to tell if it's you or not  ;D
I mean if there was a musical equivalent of a police line up could you pick out which was me playing? Or am I still generic beginner sounding?
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Pat. on February 24, 2012, 05:20:56 PM
I was told years ago  by an outstanding Irish B/C player that listening to good fiddle music was a great aid in playing B/C button accordion ,I think he was correct,not that I listen to fiddle music much but I feel if you hear a good tune on a fiddle then try it on the button accordion you will almost certainly put yuor own stamp upon it.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on February 24, 2012, 11:10:38 PM
Sarah - prehaps you are trying too hard? Do you ever find yourself playing while watching tv or reading a paper? Or do you take time to sit down and practice without distractions , a bit like you are studying ?
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: ladydetemps on February 27, 2012, 04:13:04 PM
You do sound like yourself, I think - you sound kind of East Anglian maybe?
Oooh, do I? :)

Sarah - prehaps you are trying too hard? Do you ever find yourself playing while watching tv or reading a paper? Or do you take time to sit down and practice without distractions , a bit like you are studying ?
I generally wizz through a couple of tunes up in my room (usually whatever the TOTM is and a random selection of about 3 others) before dinner. Couldn't watch TV and play....TV is for sewing/knitting. ;)
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Noodle on March 02, 2012, 04:29:16 AM
I've given up deliberately trying to play in a style of my own. Instead, I play it how I think I would like to hear it.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: michik on March 02, 2012, 08:23:53 AM
I've given up deliberately trying to play in a style of my own. Instead, I play it how I think I would like to hear it.

Actually this _is_ your own style.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Quebecois on March 02, 2012, 06:30:25 PM
(...) Instead, I play it how I think I would like to hear it.
Isn't this the only way to play ?!?
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Lester on March 02, 2012, 06:50:31 PM
(...) Instead, I play it how I think I would like to hear it.
Isn't this the only way to play ?!?

Yep!    ;)
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Noodle on March 03, 2012, 06:21:35 PM
I've given up deliberately trying to play in a style of my own. Instead, I play it how I think I would like to hear it.

Actually this _is_ your own style.

Sometimes it is, sometimes it's copying someone else's style because it sounds better. It's encouraged to try and always be different, but it might be detrimental to the tune. I'm not sure I understand or agree with that mindset. Perhaps I've misunderstood the general message to beginners though. Is there a difference between "play your own style" and "try to be unique"?
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 04, 2012, 09:09:00 AM
Your own style is one that you feel comfortable with and that sounds right to you. It doesn't have to be unique. It will probably include (consciously or unconsciously) elements of the style of musicians you admire.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Anahata on March 04, 2012, 09:56:26 AM
I've given up deliberately trying to play in a style of my own. Instead, I play it how I think I would like to hear it.
Actually this _is_ your own style.

Sometimes it is, sometimes it's copying someone else's style because it sounds better.

Nobody really has a style of their own in a vacuum - it's a carefully selected and weighted mix of all the other players you've heard and enjoyed, sometimes tempered with your own technical limitations or those of your instrument.

In my experience, copying someone else's style doesn't result in a perfect copy, but the attempt to do so often results in something good and different happening. There's always something to be learned when you push the boundaries of your playing by doing something different from what comes automatically.


Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: george garside on March 04, 2012, 01:15:36 PM
  the ultimate test    depends on  what others think of  'ones own style'  be they friends, enemies, dancers, singers, listeners or whatever!

george >:E
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: oggiesnr on March 04, 2012, 07:43:15 PM
It also depends on what types of music and other instruments you play.  I find I tend to import bits.  In one English session  was accused as sounding Irish whilst shortly afterwards at an Irish session I was accused of sounding English!

I just hope I sound like I'm enjoying myself!

Steve
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Gary P Chapin on March 05, 2012, 04:26:56 AM
I wouldn't say I imitate other players, but there are certainly stars that I navigate by -- F. Paris and J. Blanchard being the brightest in my firmament.

I've never given much thought to developing my own individual style -- how could I not?  I don't particularly value my own originality as a goal.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: pikey on March 05, 2012, 01:32:11 PM
I sound like me!

Having picked up various bits of styles from a small number of people over 30 years ago,  notably Jim Sharp (Ebor Morris), Micky Davis (Blackheath Morris), John Portlock (Grimsby & Adlington Morris), and Jim Bainbridge, the combination is me - I wouldn't want it any other way!  ;D
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 05, 2012, 03:22:43 PM
I have my own distinctive style that I have nurtured carefully over several years until it is now approaching perfection. It consists of playing any tune I start reasonably the first time through and then falling off the notes the second time through.  :|bl Maybe I should patent it.  ::)
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Noodle on March 06, 2012, 04:05:05 AM
Sounds like me, except I like to fall off on the first pass through and hope no one heard.
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: george garside on March 06, 2012, 09:54:58 AM
Sounds like me, except I like to fall off on the first pass through and hope no one heard.

I consider the art of camouflage (a device or expedient designed to conceal or decieve) to be an essential part of my style for when the above mentioned eventualities occur!

george ;D
Title: Re: Imitation & Individuality
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on March 06, 2012, 02:06:11 PM
"Like".

Chris.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal