Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: GuyWyatt on February 27, 2008, 08:28:55 PM

Title: Volume
Post by: GuyWyatt on February 27, 2008, 08:28:55 PM
Doubtless this was covered on the old forum, however....

I am interested in what makes one melodeon louder than another. Some of the answer doubtless lies in the current thread started by Stormy Hyde on his experiments with foam.

What about other issues. Does the tuning of the reeds have any effect? How the reeds are mounted? Certainly opening up the structure makes a difference but to my ear not a huge one.

I play for a North-West morris side and am always drowned out by the other boxes, particularly a Pokerwork, so it is a bit of an issue for me.  I have a Bernard Loffet Petit, which in spite of the name is not particularly small. It is a fabulous box with a glorious tone (thanks Bernard, if you are out there) but rather soft spoken. Fine for playing around the house without deafening the long suffering love of my life, but definitely not an outdoor box. The truth is this is an essentially theoretical query as I am not going to tinker about with the Loffet, anyway in my case quiet is probably good.

Guy
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: mike delta on February 27, 2008, 10:28:11 PM
Guy,
I'm surprised that your Loffet Petit is a "quiet" instrument. I have just sold a Loffet Touptit single voice and as I'm sure the new owner will testify it is far from being a quiet box. Similar sort of volume to the Castagnari Lily.
Did you buy direct from Bernard and did you specify the type of tone/volume you desired.
I explained to Bernard when ordering my Touptit that it was specifically for noisy sessions and outside work too and I think he set it up for that purpose.
Maybe it requires re voicing to bring out the type of sound and volume you require. In addition Bernard runs a good after sales service in my experience so it may be worth returning to box for voicing.
Mike.
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: hibbs3 on February 27, 2008, 10:31:30 PM
I don't know if there is any truth to this, but I've been told (By Frans Van Der Aa) that fastening the reedblocks together with a strip of aluminium or some metal makes your accordion a bit louder...maybe someone can correct me on this or knows the reasoning...
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: risto on February 28, 2008, 12:32:13 AM
It's plain physics and much can be reasoned from there without inspecting an accordion. The basic answer lies in how much air wave energy reaches your ear.

The reed tongue is one of the main factors. A large tongue with large surface area is capable of giving the airwaves a higher amplitude, ie. more energy.

The shape and stiffness of the tongue etc. define the upper harmonics of the reed. How the total energy is devided between these and the basic frequency has some affect to how loud you hear the basic frequency.

The mass of the base plate (of the reed) and how the reed is attaced to it, determines how much of the vibration energy is carried into the accordion construction; the more, the less remains in the reed vibration to produce sound. I guess the gap between the tongue and base is of some importance too.

The construction of the accordion, holes etc. define how well the air waves can pass from the reeds to ones ear.

And finally, and the most important thing is how strongly you push and pull the bellows, but you probably didn't mean that.  ;)
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 28, 2008, 12:09:36 PM
I play for a North-West morris side and am always drowned out by the other boxes, particularly a Pokerwork, so it is a bit of an issue for me.  I have a Bernard Loffet Petit, which in spite of the name is not particularly small. It is a fabulous box with a glorious tone (thanks Bernard, if you are out there) but rather soft spoken. Fine for playing around the house without deafening the long suffering love of my life, but definitely not an outdoor box. The truth is this is an essentially theoretical query as I am not going to tinker about with the Loffet, anyway in my case quiet is probably good.
Guy, if it's any consolation, your melodeon is maybe not as quiet as you think. Whenever I've heard you play, the Petit does not strike me as being significantly quieter than a pokerwork. In my experience, what the player hears/perceives and what the listener hears are two different things - something to do with the direction of sound projection, I suspect. On your box, the basses especially are very rich and fruity.
Cheers,
Steve
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: Quebecois on February 28, 2008, 01:28:22 PM
Guy, if it's any consolation, your melodeon is maybe not as quiet as you think. Whenever I've heard you play, the Petit does not strike me as being significantly quieter than a pokerwork. In my experience, what the player hears/perceives and what the listener hears are two different things - something to do with the direction of sound projection, I suspect. On your box, the basses especially are very rich and fruity.
Cheers,
Steve
That's very likely, we never hear ourselves as others do because the sound does not project upwards and back of the instrument. Also, since this is happening to everyone in a group, sometimes all players start playing louder, thinking all others play louder than themselves! So we get the "I can play louder than you" syndrome and everybody get short on their air supply or risk damaging their reeds!

Do all melodeon players play the same melody? If so, try playing harmonies to the tune, that will be heard!
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: Theo on February 28, 2008, 05:11:28 PM
Also, since this is happening to everyone in a group, sometimes all players start playing louder, thinking all others play louder than themselves! So we get the "I can play louder than you" syndrome and everybody get short on their air supply or risk damaging their reeds!

The root of this particular problem is not the perceived quietness or otherwise of our own instruments.  It is misuse of our ears :o  When playing with other musicians whether in a band, session or workshop its important to listen to the other players at least as carefully as we listen to ourselves.   

That's why I always try to politely back out from any conversations along the lines of "Oh I need/have a brandX melodeon/concertina because its loud and it can cut through in sessions"  and slink away to find some fiddlers to play with. ;D ;D
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: Quebecois on February 28, 2008, 06:01:31 PM
That's why I always try to politely back out from any conversations along the lines of "Oh I need/have a brandX melodeon/concertina because its loud and it can cut through in sessions"  and slink away to find some fiddlers to play with. ;D ;D
Absolutely! I always look for venues where there are no other melodeon players ;D
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: GuyWyatt on February 28, 2008, 06:14:12 PM
Thank you all. I ought to say that there is no competitive element in my interest in volume, just a desire to be heard around thirty feet away, outdoors, when there are a dozen women in clogs jumping up and down in between. A humble aspiration, I know.
Cheers,
Guy
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: Theo on February 28, 2008, 06:27:29 PM
A humble aspiration, I know.

But an honest one
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: BruceHenderson on February 29, 2008, 01:40:28 AM
(snip) a dozen women in clogs jumping up and down in between. A humble aspiration, I know. 

__.  Guy, you're a poet - you bring tears to my eyes. 

__.  But to go back to the original question (which I'll paraphrase as "what makes volume louder in a melodeon", my first impulse was "about everything".

__.  Here's a quick list of things that I've heard described as increasing volume:

Reeds flat to the soundboard, material of reedblocks, volume and shape of cavities in sound blocks, design of reeds, method of attaching reeds, design of "flappers" (N. Amer)/"valves (UK, Euro), volume of bellows, shape of cavity that flappers/valves are in, type or design of grille or cloth over that cavity, material of soundboard, material of "case", tuning of reeds, design of "stops" or switches, and whether Uncle Tom Cobbly is wearing shoes or not.  And "playing styles" (yes, mainly whether the player is really wailing down on it but also other things) make a difference, too; as well, (allegedly) the "running in" of the melodeon and reeds.
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: george garside on February 29, 2008, 09:19:15 AM
[
 , design of "flappers" (N. Amer)/"valves (UK, Euro), 

Ah! now I know what flappers are!  I must admit I prefer the term to the somewhat clinical  'valve' as one can visualise the buggers   beavering  away behind the scenes.

Has anybody any experience of the effect of varnishing the inside of the box . I once did it on a pokerwork  & subjectively  it seemed to sound ?better ?crisper presumably because the varnish prevented the sound being absorbed by the wood - or was it just my imagination like a sort of 'placebo' effect.

george
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 29, 2008, 12:23:54 PM
....design of "flappers" (N. Amer)/"valves (UK, Euro), ....
I don't think this is quite right, Bruce....
Flappers are what we call pallets, and what we call valves are the plastic or leather things on the reed plates to stop the air going through the reed in the wrong direction. These are what you call 'leathers' or 'skins', I think.
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: Theo on February 29, 2008, 12:41:12 PM
....design of "flappers" (N. Amer)/"valves (UK, Euro), ....
I don't think this is quite right, Bruce....
Flappers are what we call pallets, and what we call valves are the plastic or leather things on the reed plates to stop the air going through the reed in the wrong direction. These are what you call 'leathers' or 'skins', I think.


Yes I'd agree with that Steve.  But just to add to the confusion Italians and some N Americans use 'valves' for what we call pallets and what Bruce calls flappers. 
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: george garside on February 29, 2008, 12:44:35 PM
....design of "flappers" (N. Amer)/"valves (UK, Euro), ....
I don't think this is quite right, Bruce....
Flappers are what we call pallets, and what we call valves are the plastic or leather things on the reed plates to stop the air going through the reed in the wrong direction. These are what you call 'leathers' or 'skins', I think.

Steve,
I must admit that  until I read Bruce's posting I also took flappers to be pallets.   Oh well, that shatters my vision of all those 'flappers' merrily flapping away within the box!
george
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: an bosca ceoil on February 29, 2008, 01:03:51 PM
.

Has anybody any experience of the effect of varnishing the inside of the box . I once did it on a pokerwork  & subjectively  it seemed to sound ?better ?crisper presumably because the varnish prevented the sound being absorbed by the wood - or was it just my imagination like a sort of 'placebo' effect.

.I do not think it is your imagination. I cannot see some makers doing it (and the blocks) for purely aesthetic reasons.
My reasoning is that it must penetrate the timber, making it  more inert, in line with the idea of using MDF.
I once thought I had spoilt  a"wormy" old Hohner by soaking wood that had been drying out for  half a century with turpentine. That had the exact opposite effect to ?better ? crisper, so I resorted to varnishing and it did work.
Well I think it did!
Regards,Bruce
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: BruceHenderson on March 01, 2008, 01:14:00 AM
I don't think this is quite right, Bruce....
Flappers are what we call pallets, and what we call valves are the plastic or leather things on the reed plates to stop the air going through the reed in the wrong direction. These are what you call 'leathers' or 'skins', I think. 

__.  Yes, you're quite right!  There's only one thing for it.  Britain must call for an EU commission on "Standardization of melodeon nomenclature".  After about 7 years and the expenditure of about 59 million Euro's of your taxes, we'll have the official United States of Europe list of melodeon bits.  Of course, by then, the North American Standards and Trading Yearbook (NASTY) will have adopted the agreed-upon North American standard names -- which will, of course, differ from the standard European names.  But at least we'll have standardised different names so we'll know what each other aren't talking about.

(Actually, I used to w*** in the motorcar industry and the above scenario isn't just plausible but actually happened over and over again ... and probably still is.)
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: C age ing on March 01, 2008, 05:49:54 AM
Saxophones and some other wood and brasswinds are fitted with 'resonator discs'. These discs are fitted to the pads that seal the tone holes but are of smaller diameter. The purpose is to increase volume and affect the timbre.
Theo, could you provide a quotation for retro-fitting 'rectangular resonators' to my Erika's pallets? ;D
Old Bill.
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: Steve_freereeder on March 01, 2008, 07:43:20 AM
There's only one thing for it.  Britain must call for an EU commission on "Standardization of melodeon nomenclature".  After about 7 years and the expenditure of about 59 million Euro's of your taxes, we'll have the official United States of Europe list of melodeon bits.  .....
Hey - I'll do it in 7 weeks for € 30 million - half price, in 2% of the time; now there's a bargain that can't be missed  ;D
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: BruceHenderson on March 01, 2008, 01:01:17 PM
Hey - I'll do it in 7 weeks for € 30 million - half price, in 2% of the time; now there's a bargain that can't be missed  ;D 

    Big Awbutt, the EU bureaucrats' shop steward, will be around shortly to sort you out.  You don't really need knees and knuckles that point in the same direction, do you????
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: Quebecois on March 01, 2008, 02:42:46 PM
Saxophones and some other wood and brasswinds are fitted with 'resonator discs'. These discs are fitted to the pads that seal the tone holes but are of smaller diameter. The purpose is to increase volume and affect the timbre.
Now we're getting into "instrument voo-doo"... I heard the same about trumpets, valve alignment, heavy caps and all... More psychological effect than anything else, IMHO and experience.

I think the bottom line is: try the melodeon before you buy it. If you like the sound, fine. If you don't, try another one!

A bit like trying to change your spouse after you get married: a very complicated endeavour with little chance of success...
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: Theo on March 01, 2008, 03:49:17 PM
I think the bottom line is: try the melodeon before you buy it. If you like the sound, fine. If you don't, try another one!

A bit like trying to change your spouse after you get married: a very complicated endeavour with little chance of success...

I completely agree with 'try before you buy'

But, and its quite a big but,  for the box to be able to give its best it is quite likely to need some setting up.  String players see this as completely to be expected, and I think box players should too. 

The main area of work is to get the optimum reed response, for the way the owner plays. 

I would prefer not to comment on the possibility of altering the behaviour of a spouse.
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: Hello on March 01, 2008, 04:30:31 PM
I'm not sure that melodeons are that different in volume but some melodeons are definitely more penetrating than others. 
For example, I think the Erica is more penetrating than the pokerwork, although it's apparently the same underneath. 
I sometimes play a pokerwork for morris and have noticed that instruments with reeds an octave lower tend to be more audible outdoors.  It seems that the wetter the sound, the less penetrating it is.
I've found you can increase your volume by playing more notes simultaneously.
More notes = more reeds = more noise. Octaves are particularly effective.

You hear of some accordions having double cassotto chambers. I'm not entire sure what this is but it seems to imply that, whatever reeds you're using, the contruction of the box plays an important part.



Title: Re: Volume
Post by: george garside on March 01, 2008, 10:19:52 PM
 
 
You hear of some accordions having double cassotto chambers. I'm not entire sure what this is but it seems to imply that, whatever reeds you're using, the contruction of the box plays an important part.




[/quote]

cassoto sounds like a trapped fart trying to get out!

george
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: Hello on March 01, 2008, 11:34:06 PM
So a double cassotto is like two farts trying to get out?

But trying to get out of what...
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: Quebecois on March 02, 2008, 01:41:02 AM
I would prefer not to comment on the possibility of altering the behaviour of a spouse.
Well, you know how it works: you get married, your wife spend the next 15 years making you change, then the marriage breaks up because, as she says: "you are not the same guy I married 15 years ago." :(
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: george garside on March 02, 2008, 06:55:42 PM
So a double cassotto is like two farts trying to get out?

But trying to get out of what...

more like one having twice the obstacles to circumnavigate before reaching the outside world.
george
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: IanD on March 24, 2008, 01:24:31 PM
Saxophones and some other wood and brasswinds are fitted with 'resonator discs'. These discs are fitted to the pads that seal the tone holes but are of smaller diameter. The purpose is to increase volume and affect the timbre.
Theo, could you provide a quotation for retro-fitting 'rectangular resonators' to my Erika's pallets? ;D
Old Bill.

The mechanism producing the sound in a sax is the resonant column of air inside the instrument, anything which absorbs even a small amount of sound energy reduces the Q and will particularly affect the higher harmonics which give the sound its "edge" -- since the pads are made of soft material they absorb some sound, the hard "resonator discs" cover up most of the pad area to stop this happening. This matters because there are a lot of closed pads which should not be absorbing any sound.

Free reed instruments don't make the sound in the same way (they generate a series of air pulses as the reed vibrates) and are much less sensitive to this -- there's only one pad in the air path of a reed and it's open not closed, the air just flows past it, so a "resonator pad" would have no significant effect -- if you want to get technical the pad is at a low-pressure high-flow point, as opposed to a high-pressure low-flow point like a saxophone.

The air inside the end of the box (under the grille) does form a resonant chamber, and anything inside this which absorbs sound (like lots of thick soft felt pads) could have an effect. Using hard varnish inside will reflect more high-frequency sound and make the box sound brighter -- for anyone building their own treble horn speakers out of wood, these should always be varnished inside for the same reason.

Ian
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: Lin Leighton on March 31, 2008, 03:28:03 PM
 Yes, you're quite right!  There's only one thing for it.  Britain must call for an EU commission on "Standardization of melodeon nomenclature".  After about 7 years and the expenditure of about 59 million Euro's of your taxes, we'll have the official United States of Europe list of melodeon bits.  Of course, by then, the North American Standards and Trading Yearbook (NASTY) will have adopted the agreed-upon North American standard names -- which will, of course, differ from the standard European names.  But at least we'll have standardised different names so we'll know what each other aren't talking about.

Question ::::  How many people work at EU HQ????



Answer::::

About one third of them

I will get my coat


Lin
 ;D
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: george garside on March 31, 2008, 03:48:04 PM
 

Question ::::  How many people work at EU HQ????



Answer::::

About one third of them

I will get my coat
 

as many as that!

george

Lin
 ;D
[/quote]
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: Gus V on April 01, 2008, 01:06:14 AM
.

Has anybody any experience of the effect of varnishing the inside of the box . I once did it on a pokerwork  & subjectively  it seemed to sound ?better ?crisper presumably because the varnish prevented the sound being absorbed by the wood - or was it just my imagination like a sort of 'placebo' effect.

.I do not think it is your imagination. I cannot see some makers doing it (and the blocks) for purely aesthetic reasons.
My reasoning is that it must penetrate the timber, making it  more inert, in line with the idea of using MDF.
I once thought I had spoilt  a"wormy" old Hohner by soaking wood that had been drying out for  half a century with turpentine. That had the exact opposite effect to ?better ? crisper, so I resorted to varnishing and it did work.
Well I think it did!
Regards,Bruce

I once visited the Petosa factory while I was in Seattle. Other than having a very good collection of underused, very old Melodeons amongst their high quality Piano and Continental boxes, and speaking a lot of trash about Hohner. They spoke at length about varnishing both the reed blocks and chamber, they seem to think that it makes all the difference. I spoke directly to one of the builders, and he was very proud of that bit.
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: Rob2Hook on April 04, 2008, 11:10:37 AM
Has anyone mentioned the pressure of the airwave?  In general, the smaller cross section the bellows have, the higher pressure is achieved.  I have a Dino Baffetti Black Pearl II, ordinary machine finished reeds, but the small cross section bellows mean I can squeeze a lot of pressure out - some say too much!

This is the same as the difference in design between a bicycle pump (aimimg to achieve 100psi - long and thin) and a car tyre pump (40psi - short and broad).  The broad cross section adds to the volume pumped but limits the pressure achieved.

In practice it also means that playing a small box loudly will give you problems of air control - the bellows close awfully quick!

The example of a Pokerwork against say a Castagnari seems to prove that perception thing.  The wet tuning of a standard Pokerwork makes it appear loud in all directions.  The typically dry or swing tuning of a Castagnari makes it more directional.  Difficult to hear what you're playing when stood next to a Hohner player, but the dancers will hear your melody more distinctly.  This is probably why I'm told I play too loud in sessions when I can only just hear what I'm playing.

Rob.
Title: Re: Volume
Post by: IanD on April 05, 2008, 02:30:25 PM
Has anyone mentioned the pressure of the airwave?  In general, the smaller cross section the bellows have, the higher pressure is achieved.  I have a Dino Baffetti Black Pearl II, ordinary machine finished reeds, but the small cross section bellows mean I can squeeze a lot of pressure out - some say too much!

This is the same as the difference in design between a bicycle pump (aimimg to achieve 100psi - long and thin) and a car tyre pump (40psi - short and broad).  The broad cross section adds to the volume pumped but limits the pressure achieved.

In practice it also means that playing a small box loudly will give you problems of air control - the bellows close awfully quick!

The example of a Pokerwork against say a Castagnari seems to prove that perception thing.  The wet tuning of a standard Pokerwork makes it appear loud in all directions.  The typically dry or swing tuning of a Castagnari makes it more directional.  Difficult to hear what you're playing when stood next to a Hohner player, but the dancers will hear your melody more distinctly.  This is probably why I'm told I play too loud in sessions when I can only just hear what I'm playing.

Rob.

The smaller area is one reason people often think small boxes are louder -- they're not given the same air pressure, but you have to play a bigger box harder to achieve this. Many small boxes seem to be more prone to blowing reeds for the same reason.

The "louder" sound of wet tuning is nothing to do with which direction the sound comes out in, that's down to something different (the shape and construction of the box). Pairs of reeds with detuning sound louder because the ear is attuned to picking out changing/pulsating sound not steady ones; as you detune reeds from dry tuning the apparent volume gets bigger and eventually reaches a peak at about 7-8Hz difference, beyond which the sound just gets increasingly nasty but no louder.

Research was done on this some time ago both for instruments and voices (vibrato rather than detuned reeds) -- it turned out that most old-style opera singers (where absolute maximum unamplified volume is crucial) used almost identical vibrato frequencies in the 7-8Hz region, just where the ear is most sensitive.

Nowadays most people find this much tremolo rather obtrusive (think the old wet-tuned Scottish accordion sound -- or indeed, a coloratura opera singer) and opt for something much drier. I settled on 2Hz sharp/2Hz flat across the whole keyboard many years ago as a good compromise between sweetness of sound and volume (for a 2 reed box -- also means RH chords are in tume with themselves and the LH), and quite a few people who've heard the results have had their boxes tuned the same way -- I think Nils Nielsen told me this used to be called "Viennese" tuning.

Cheers

Ian
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal