Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Andy Simpson on February 10, 2010, 01:25:16 AM

Title: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Andy Simpson on February 10, 2010, 01:25:16 AM
They seem a little hard to get hold of. Do the reed makers accept custom orders from individuals, (I seem to remember reading something here about VA having a minimum order of 5 sets), or do I have to go through a parts supplier?.
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: an bosca ceoil on February 10, 2010, 10:52:50 AM
Binci will deal with individuals.
Compared to Hohner "list" prices, his are favourable (bank charge and post bump up the final bill)
Cannot understand, in view of this, why some people disparage the idea of fitting them to "lowly" instruments.
(Or, for that matter, make such a big deal about TAM grade which little dearer than machinna.)
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Theo on February 10, 2010, 10:58:19 AM
Charlie Marshal (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/)l sometimes has reed sets for sale.

Binci will deal with individuals.
Compared to Hohner "list" prices, his are favourable (bank charge and post bump up the final bill)
Cannot understand, in view of this, why some people disparage the idea of fitting them to "lowly" instruments.
(Or, for that matter, make such a big deal about TAM grade which little dearer than machinna.)

If you buy a few sets of machinna reeds from Italian makers they are much cheaper than Binci or other TAM reeds.  Hohner reeds are very expensive for what they are.  I can only guess that they don't want to encourage the sale of their reeds.
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: LJC on February 10, 2010, 11:57:47 AM
Charlie has some sets on ebay right now - Cagnoni sets for about £50 per row.
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Aaro on February 10, 2010, 02:18:16 PM
Here you will find all kinds of spare parts and reeds.
http://www.accordions-agenziaitalia.com/Lang/index.html (http://www.accordions-agenziaitalia.com/Lang/index.html)
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: IanD on February 12, 2010, 03:55:34 PM
Charlie Marshal (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/)l sometimes has reed sets for sale.

Binci will deal with individuals.
Compared to Hohner "list" prices, his are favourable (bank charge and post bump up the final bill)
Cannot understand, in view of this, why some people disparage the idea of fitting them to "lowly" instruments.
(Or, for that matter, make such a big deal about TAM grade which little dearer than machinna.)

If you buy a few sets of machinna reeds from Italian makers they are much cheaper than Binci or other TAM reeds.  Hohner reeds are very expensive for what they are.  I can only guess that they don't want to encourage the sale of their reeds.

I know Jerry Tozer got a set of the top-grade 'a mano' reeds (the ones using spark erosion to cut the plates) from Harmonikas

http://www.harmonikas.cz/homee.htm (http://www.harmonikas.cz/homee.htm)

which he told me were considerably cheaper than the corresponding Italian ones, and are actually manufactured differently rather than just using more hand processing:

====================================
Very cheap reeds – the czech ‘a mano’ reeds are about the price of voici armonice  tipo a mano, and the tipo a mano half the price of their italian counterparts!

price for your request model 21/8/2 + 4 note DG is :

                    € 163,51    A MANO

                    €  82,08     TIPO A MANO

                    ventils is € 14,10
====================================

And they were happy to supply just one set.

Don't know what the result is yet though...

Ian
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Quebecois on February 12, 2010, 04:00:06 PM
I bought reed sets from Charlie Marshall, good prices and fast delivery. I purchased Cagnoni Macchina reed sets for single-row 2-voice D and also 4-voice Cajun C and I am very satisfied.
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Andy Simpson on February 13, 2010, 01:21:24 AM
Thanks for the replies.

I'm completely rebuilding an old Hohner Club, converting it from C/F to D/G and I'm unlikely to find a set I want off the shelf so I'll probably have to order them specially. I seem to remember reading that Binci would deal with individuals but I also remember hearing about them sometimes being difficult or impossible to fit on Hohner reedblocks due to the longer scaling than Hohner reeds. I'm also thinking of taking the plunge and building a few boxes and I want to get some experience of different reeds and seeing as I've owned two boxes with Binci reeds it'd probably be a good idea to try something else for this one, I'll ask around...eventually.

Those Czech reeds look very interesting indeed....
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on February 13, 2010, 06:17:43 PM
Charlie Marshal (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/)l sometimes has reed sets for sale.

Binci will deal with individuals.
Compared to Hohner "list" prices, his are favourable (bank charge and post bump up the final bill)
Cannot understand, in view of this, why some people disparage the idea of fitting them to "lowly" instruments.
(Or, for that matter, make such a big deal about TAM grade which little dearer than machinna.)

If you buy a few sets of machinna reeds from Italian makers they are much cheaper than Binci or other TAM reeds.  Hohner reeds are very expensive for what they are.  I can only guess that they don't want to encourage the sale of their reeds.

I know Jerry Tozer got a set of the top-grade 'a mano' reeds (the ones using spark erosion to cut the plates) from Harmonikas

http://www.harmonikas.cz/homee.htm (http://www.harmonikas.cz/homee.htm)

which he told me were considerably cheaper than the corresponding Italian ones, and are actually manufactured differently rather than just using more hand processing:

====================================
Very cheap reeds – the czech ‘a mano’ reeds are about the price of voici armonice  tipo a mano, and the tipo a mano half the price of their italian counterparts!

price for your request model 21/8/2 + 4 note DG is :

                    € 163,51    A MANO

                    €  82,08     TIPO A MANO

                    ventils is € 14,10
====================================

And they were happy to supply just one set.

Don't know what the result is yet though...

Ian

I had heard that the Harmonikas are not a good value.  Anyone hear differently?
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: IanD on February 13, 2010, 07:16:35 PM
I had heard that the Harmonikas are not a good value.  Anyone hear differently?

I couldn't find anyone who had actually tried out their better quality reeds, I'm sure Jerry will post something when he's done so.

Having said that, the Harmonikas "a mano" reeds do seem to be the only ones trying out some genuinely new technology (harder alloy, spark erosion cutting, smaller reed to frame clearance) which could improve the sound, as opposed to just more hand finishing of traditionally made reeds which is what the Italians do.

Ian
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: diatonix on February 27, 2010, 12:12:51 PM
Binci is not keen on selling just 1 or 2 sets of reeds to someone he doesn't know. You shouldn't  expect to get an answer to your email.
One possible way of arousing his interest is by asking for a "campione", i.e. a sample set.
It might be easier to order through Carini DeNa.
Czech reeds: My main concern is the fact that they are made from German Eberle steel, and not from high quality Swedish steel used by Italian top reed-makers. And beware: some Italian reed-makers re-sell Czech products as if they were their own...
True italian A mano reeds are made from Swedish band-steel, which accounts for the fact that the "foot" of the reed has blue edges on both sides. Cheaper reeds ("Tipo a mano", "commerciali") are cut from larger steel-plates. And yes, a mano reeds manufactured by top reed-makers CAN make a world of a difference (and justify the considerable extra cost) IF (and only IF) the box-maker knows how to exploit their potential.
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Andy Simpson on February 27, 2010, 10:01:02 PM
So, do I have to go to Castelfidardo and invite Sig. Binci out for coffee before he'll sell me some reeds?.  ;D

I do want to order some Bincis soon-ish though. Practically, going through Carini would be just as difficult, if not more so considering they're a middleman rather than the source, it's just that they're apparently less likely to ignore me. Ho hum.

I think I will give the Harmonikas A Mano reeds a go for the Hohner. I like the fact that they actually seem to be trying something new, all too often it seems the prevailing mentality in instrument making isn't so much "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" as "if it ain't broke, it's obviously perfect and any other way can't possibly be as good so don't even bother trying & even if you do it'll be dismissed out of hand". They might be rubbish but I'll reserve judgment until they're in the box.


Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: an bosca ceoil on February 27, 2010, 10:59:38 PM

Czech reeds: My main concern is the fact that they are made from German Eberle steel, and not from high quality Swedish steel used by Italian top reed-makers.

In what respect is high quality steel produced by Eberle inferior to that made in Sweden?
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 28, 2010, 12:10:57 PM
I do want to order some Bincis soon-ish though. Practically, going through Carini would be just as difficult, if not more so considering they're a middleman rather than the source, it's just that they're apparently less likely to ignore me. Ho hum.

When I ordered a Mori direct from F Castagnari, I sent a good deposit with order. Binci is (if nothing else) surely Italian, and my experience has been that this sort of approach stimulates them. (Castagnari also took my order - Sandro later confiding that Hobgoblin's 'monopoly'on GB imports was news to him)!

In what respect is high quality steel produced by Eberle inferior to that made in Sweden?

Will Czech - and come back to you   ;D
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: diatonix on February 28, 2010, 12:11:16 PM
I'm not saying it's inferior, in my opinion it's less suitable when it comes to reeds. There is less power and they break more easily (at least, this is my personal experience). Sweden has  century-long traditions when it comes to special steels and has acquired know-how other producers have difficulties in competing with.
I think it was Hohner who, some time ago, introduced high quality Swiss steel - which turned out to be a total failure when used in accordion-reeds!
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on March 01, 2010, 01:49:44 PM
Well to add to the debate.  My Double Ray is as I type this being upgraded to TaM Binci.  Yes I know the purists have issues with this.  However when I asked my box technician if the Harmonikas reeds were a good value over the Binci's his answer was an emphatic no! He offers a range of reeds from Cagnoni to Binci's and used to carry Harmonikas but no longer.  I did not ask him to expand on his answer, maybe I can find out his reasons. 
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: diatonix on March 04, 2010, 04:14:02 PM
Tipo a mano from Binci? Then they must be made some 12 or 13 years ago, when he still offered them as a less expensive option. And while I'm at it: Bincis' reeds are not without issues. That's why I last year  bought several sample-sets (a mano only) from another newly established reed-maker. I was, as usual, sceptical to start with, but they turned out to be absolutely fabulous. Moreover, I spent almost no time re-adjusting them, tuning was a delight, and I keep getting lots of e-mails from enthusiastic customers...
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Gandy on March 04, 2010, 05:35:26 PM
Tipo a mano from Binci? Then they must be made some 12 or 13 years ago, when he still offered them as a less expensive option.

They're advertised by Irish Dancemaster in the US, although I wouldn't call those prices a "less expensive option"
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Stiamh on March 04, 2010, 06:07:16 PM
Shurely shome confusion between "a mano" and "tipo a mano"...
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Andy Simpson on March 04, 2010, 06:27:00 PM
The two Binci-reeded boxes I've owned, one made in the mid 80's and one finished only a few weeks ago, both have reeds stamped "Professional". I believe the Binci Professional reeds are only claimed to be "assembled and finished" by hand.

In fact, I'm sure Rees has said somewhere on this forum that Sig. Binci himself told him that "true" a Mano reeds aren't really made anymore.
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Quebecois on March 04, 2010, 09:50:44 PM
The hands hold the plates while a stamping machine sets the rivets!
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on March 07, 2010, 12:42:05 AM
Tipo a mano from Binci? Then they must be made some 12 or 13 years ago, when he still offered them as a less expensive option.

They're advertised by Irish Dancemaster in the US, although I wouldn't call those prices a "less expensive option"
Since Michael at Dancemaster is about the only one who actually puts the cost on his site (although to be fair those quotes on his site are for installation and tuning) It would be interesting to know what the actual wholesale cost is for reeds only.  
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: IanD on March 07, 2010, 12:00:40 PM
I'm not saying it's inferior, in my opinion it's less suitable when it comes to reeds. There is less power and they break more easily (at least, this is my personal experience). Sweden has  century-long traditions when it comes to special steels and has acquired know-how other producers have difficulties in competing with.
I think it was Hohner who, some time ago, introduced high quality Swiss steel - which turned out to be a total failure when used in accordion-reeds!

Isn't this a bit like saying "I drove a Skoda once and it was crap, so all current Skodas must be crap?"

Unless the reeds were from the same manufacturer and identical apart from the steel, surely you don't know whether it's the steel making the difference or just the fact that the reeds made from the German steel weren't very good -- and might have been just the same if Swedish steel had been used?

Ian
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Andy Simpson on March 07, 2010, 03:53:43 PM
I've become very sceptical about claims made about the superiority or inferiority of certain materials for instrument making.

I've heard some very ordinary sounding guitars with Brazilian Rosewood back and sides yet the owners were absolutely convinced they were amazing because it was Brazilian Rosewood and therefore had endowed their instrument with magical tonal properties. Traditional, (ie, narrow-minded), guitar and violin makers are all also in agreement that European Spruce is by far the best soundboard wood and if you ask for their opinion of Englemann Spruce from North America then it'll be dismissed as a cheap substitute that only approximates noble European Spruce. However, it approximates it so well that a significant quantity of "European" Spuce in circulation is actually Englemann that's been resold as European Spruce at a huge premium by unscrupulous merchants and nobody can tell the difference, Englemann in Euro clothing has only ever been identified by stamps or markings left on it that have been recognised as being from an American mill.

A non-musical example of adjusting interpretation to match expectations can be found in Iain Banks' Raw Spirit where he candidly admits to him and a friend once agreeing that a bottle of 40 year-old Laphroaig they were enjoying was in a class of its own, head and shoulders above the standard 10 year-old...until they realised that it was a standard 10 year-old where someone had skillfully turned the 1 into a 4 on the label. He also notes that the water used to make Glenmorangie has to be treated with salt, literally bucketloads added, to make it suitable for whisky making yet they don't mention this and it's not generally known that they do it and nobody ever says Glenmo is remotely salty...
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: LJC on March 07, 2010, 04:10:38 PM
A case of the emperors new clothes?
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: IanD on March 07, 2010, 04:46:21 PM
Tipo a mano from Binci? Then they must be made some 12 or 13 years ago, when he still offered them as a less expensive option.

They're advertised by Irish Dancemaster in the US, although I wouldn't call those prices a "less expensive option"
Since Michael at Dancemaster is about the only one who actually puts the cost on his site (although to be fair those quotes on his site are for installation and tuning) It would be interesting to know what the actual wholesale cost is for reeds only.  

Price quote from Harmonikas:

>price for your request model 21/8/2 + 4 note DG is :
>
>                     € 163,51    A MANO
>
>                     €  82,08     TIPO A MANO
>
>                     ventils is € 14,10

Ian

P.S. "ventils" are valves
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: diatonix on March 07, 2010, 08:29:41 PM
Well, all I can say is that out of natural curiosity I ordered several sets of reeds from Harmonikas and even went myself to Louny, where the factory is located. My final opinion, formed after testing the reeds and talking to the management (very nice people by the way), induced me to continue to do my shopping in Italy, where I know I can get the sort of quality i need to survive and thrive in my business, even if it costs me several thousands of �/year more.
Czech "a mano" reeds are certainly not "crap", but they are definitely not the best either, which makes them totally uninteresting to me.
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: IanD on March 07, 2010, 09:06:53 PM
Well, all I can say is that out of natural curiosity I ordered several sets of reeds from Harmonikas and even went myself to Louny, where the factory is located. My final opinion, formed after testing the reeds and talking to the management (very nice people by the way), induced me to continue to do my shopping in Italy, where I know I can get the sort of quality i need to survive and thrive in my business, even if it costs me several thousands of � more.
Czech "a mano" reeds are certainly not "crap", but they are definitely not the best either, which makes them totally uninteresting to me.

That's interesting and useful, you're the first person I've heard from who's actually tried them -- was this the "a mano" reeds or the lower quality ones?

(I was just posting the price to answer the question, not trying to promote them)

If they're not as good as the Italian reeds then that's a pity, it did look like they were trying to do something different :-(

Ian
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Andy Simpson on March 07, 2010, 09:21:50 PM
Well, all I can say is that out of natural curiosity I ordered several sets of reeds from Harmonikas and even went myself to Louny, where the factory is located. My final opinion, formed after testing the reeds and talking to the management (very nice people by the way), induced me to continue to do my shopping in Italy, where I know I can get the sort of quality i need to survive and thrive in my business, even if it costs me several thousands of € more.
Czech "a mano" reeds are certainly not "crap", but they are definitely not the best either, which makes them totally uninteresting to me.

Why didn't you say that before?.  ;D

My own preference for the Hohner, having owned and been generally pleased with a box with Antonelli Super Durals, would be some decent Italian Dural reeds but 2 1/2 row 12 bass sets are a bit hard to find off the shelf and it appears that I have to order several sets and I don't think I'll get round to using the others for quite some time. The outlay for several sets would be a bit much as well.
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: diatonix on March 07, 2010, 09:30:44 PM
No one asked me  :|glug
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: IanD on March 07, 2010, 09:32:42 PM
No one asked me  :|glug

So when I asked some time back whether anyone had tried the Harmonikas reeds you didn't see this?

Ian ;-)
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: diatonix on March 08, 2010, 07:47:34 AM
I suggest you order a set and form your own opinion.
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Quebecois on March 08, 2010, 06:38:58 PM
The old adage once again: you get what you pay for!
Title: Re: Who sells reeds?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on March 11, 2010, 12:45:59 AM
The two Binci-reeded boxes I've owned, one made in the mid 80's and one finished only a few weeks ago, both have reeds stamped "Professional". I believe the Binci Professional reeds are only claimed to be "assembled and finished" by hand.

In fact, I'm sure Rees has said somewhere on this forum that Sig. Binci himself told him that "true" a Mano reeds aren't really made anymore.
Well Signor Binci would be pleasantly surprised to know my Plumber friend here in North Carolina that makes his own Concertina reeds on occasion.  Now that said he certainly doesn't make them commercially but they sound fairly good in his old Lachenals.  I believe he uses high end scrap steel. 
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal