Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Chris61 on February 11, 2010, 09:13:40 AM
-
I have a Hohner pokerwork D/G melodeon, and although it was virtually new when I acquired it a year ago, the G on the G row has always been a bit gurgly for want of a better term. In fact it is same on push and pull, I have had the reed block out on several occasions, and checked the valves etc but all to no avail. Sometimes when I have put it all back together it will play ok for about two tunes, and then resorts back to the frustrating gurgling!!! Should I just replace the reeds, or is there a simpler fix? ???
-
I have a Hohner pokerwork D/G melodeon, and although it was virtually new when I acquired it a year ago, the G on the G row has always been a bit gurgly for want of a better term. In fact it is same on push and pull, I have had the reed block out on several occasions, and checked the valves etc but all to no avail. Sometimes when I have put it all back together it will play ok for about two tunes, and then resorts back to the frustrating gurgling!!! Should I just replace the reeds, or is there a simpler fix? ???
No doubt Theo and others may advise with more authority, but it sounds like a valve problem to me. Even though it looks OK, sometimes a valve can be a 'rogue' and just happens to have the right degree of resilience to set it vibrating in sympathy with the reed. Replacing the valve is probably your best bet, though the job is rendered a bit fiddly because it will be on the underside of the reed plate, i.e. beneath the G reed. So you will have to remove the reed plate to get to the valve, replace the valve, and then re-wax the reed plate back into place.
A few years ago I had a burbling valve on a (new) Saltarelle Nuage on one of the pull notes. I couldn't be bothered to take it back to the dealer to get it fixed, and I didn't have a spare valve (one of the plastic ones). So I just added a tiny blob of blue-tac on to the tip of the valve to disrupt its resonance property, and hey-presto! It worked a treat. I always intended to replace the valve eventually, but somehow never got round to it; the blue-tac stayed in place, and I eventually sold the box on - still in that state. :|bl
-
If its a push valve that's causing a problem it should be easy to get to as it is the valve facing you on the top of the 3rd plate along. My money would be on a duff valve. Rather than adding material to the valve to change its resonance, if there is plenty of valve covering the hole, try cutting a mm or so of material off the front bit of the valve and see if that helps (but don't cut it so much that you compromise the ability of the valve to be airtight!).
Where are you based? There could well be someone on the board local enough to put a new valve on for you a check the tuning afterwards.
-
I agree with Steve that it sounds like a valve problem. Since its almost new my first suspicion would be that the valve on the underside of the reed is either partly trapped under the edge of the reedplate, or it is catching on the side of the reed chamber. You can check this quite easily. Take the reedblock out. Find a good light so you can peer up the hole in the base of the block then use a jewellers screwdriver of something similar to press down on the tip if the reed. The reed will push the valve up, and when you let go the valve should drop back without any delay. You might also be able to hear the valve brushing against the wood. Remember to check both G reeds. If this identifies the probleb the reed will have to come off, whatever is catching the valve will need to be cleared, the the reed has to be waxed on again, preferably with fresh wax.
This is a surprisingly common problem on new instruments.
-
I have had another look at the reeds and valves,but cannot see anything obviously amiss, so I decided to try removing a reed. Not quite sure what I am doing, but I ran a soldering iron around the edge of the reed and eased it out. Nothing appeared to be catching, and replaced everything,but the burbling sound is just the same. Maybe attack an old floppy disc to make new valves with. ???
-
Not quite sure what I am doing, but I ran a soldering iron around the edge of the reed and eased it out.
Rather a messy way of taking a reed out. a blunt knife run round the reed is quick, and does not get sticky wax on your fingers.
-
Well it's just a learning curve for me, but I will try that next time. So if I decide to change the valves, are they just glued on at the end with an all purpose glue?
-
Yes - but some glues react with plastic/vileda valves so its worth testing your glue on a spare one first. Changing the valve will also effect the tuning to some extent, so you might find the note your changing has more/less tremolo compared to before or other notes.
Take the old valve off by pulling it away and clean any residue with a bit of white spirit. When replacing take care not to get glue in the reed slot or on the tongue!
-
Thanks for all the tips etc, I have had the thing apart again and reseated the valves. It's definately better now although still a little burbly on the pull note, but I can live with that! I have a C/C# box in bits at the moment, and will be re-building that slowly whilst learning at the same time, I knew I should have stuck to guitar, at least changing a string is pretty easy!!!! ;D
-
Changing the valve will also effect the tuning to some extent, so you might find the note your changing has more/less tremolo compared to before or other notes.
What causes this?
-
I have removed the bass reed block on the C/C# box that I am tinkering with, and have removed the reeds and cleaned all the old wax off. I have replaced all the leather valves, so am now in a position to re-seat all the reeds. Am I right in assuming that the reeds are located in position, and then the wax rolled in strips around the edge, and then carefully melted with a warm soldering iron to make a neat seam, or is there a better way of doing this job?
We sow seeds but sew seams so it seems!!!
-
Let Charlie explain all: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q7-MUhBc1ho
You can push wax around the plates and melt with a soldering iron, but you have to be careful its not too hot or it will burn the wax and getting it too close to the valves can damage them too (especially plastic ones, which just melt). You'll find you need way less wax than you might imagine.
Most accordion/melodeon makers have a special spoon tool to run the wax around the plates, you can find them for sale online.
-
Let Charlie explain all: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q7-MUhBc1ho
It's a pity that Charlie's hand obscures the view at the critical moments! :(
-
Thanks for the info, I have watched the clip on youtube and it seems a pretty good way of fixing the reeds, I will have a dummy run and see how it goes!! (:)
-
Charlie's method with the brush works just fine, the secret is to not use too big a brush, it is quite straightforward when you get the hang of it. ;D
-
Charlie's method with the brush works just fine, the secret is to not use too big a brush, it is quite straightforward when you get the hang of it. ;D
Awesome, that's the first thing I'll do this holiday then ;D
-
Charlie's method with the brush works just fine
So now I'm taking an interest in this... where's a good place to get the wax?
-
Charlie's method with the brush works just fine
So now I'm taking an interest in this... where's a good place to get the wax?
Try Charlie's web site (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/index_files/Page5768.html)
-
If you do not want to use leather. Or Vileda.
Is it appropriate to use the old X-ray film?
Is it appropriate to use the old PC floppy disks?
Are there any other suitable material for valves?
-
In an emergency you have to improvise, but otherwise why would you not want to use good quality materials?
-
Mostly because the box is worthless.
Improperly repaired with thick leather. From shoes.
They have curled.
All reeds on one plate. Glued with lacquer for letters, instead of wax. The bellows is leaking.
And many other problems.
The box called Trocadero, AD, is quite light. Fun to take apart!
-
So you have nothing to loose! Try the materials you have and see what is good and what is bad. The smaller reeds should have thinner more flexible material.
-
Charlie's method with the brush works just fine, the secret is to not use too big a brush, it is quite straightforward when you get the hang of it. ;D
I use this method too; be aware that some very cheap brushes have synthetic hair whose melting point is dangerously close to that of reed wax (guess how I know this!). You don't need an expensive brush - in fact you need to regard it as disposable because it will fairly soon get beyond cleaning - but try to avoid the REALLY cheap ones that come in sets of about 20 for a pound (or less) in markets and pound shops.
Graham