Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: sqwzboxstudent on February 15, 2010, 06:51:04 PM

Title: key trouble!!!
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on February 15, 2010, 06:51:04 PM
can anyone tell me what the difference betyween d major and dmixoldian is please??? im trying to learn toss the feathers, and im trying to fathom out the dots
Title: Re: key trouble!!!
Post by: GbH on February 15, 2010, 06:57:57 PM
D mixolydian has a C natural, in place of the C sharp that you'd find in D major.  Both have F sharp.
Title: Re: key trouble!!!
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on February 15, 2010, 07:20:13 PM
thanks gbh, but i think im just gonna have to go by ear!!!
Title: Re: key trouble!!!
Post by: sticky fingers on February 28, 2010, 01:06:52 PM
dmixylodean is also a fatal disease to box players. o'h and rabbits!.
Title: Re: key trouble!!!
Post by: juker on February 28, 2010, 01:09:18 PM
D mixolydian has a C natural, in place of the C sharp that you'd find in D major.  Both have F sharp.

I know this is a very dumb question, but every time this mixolydian thing comes up I am tempted to ask - doesn't that make it G (the key I mean, not the note)?
Title: Re: key trouble!!!
Post by: Theo on February 28, 2010, 01:32:32 PM
If a tune is in G major it will almost always end on the note G, or will feel as if it wants to.   If its in D mixolydian it will almost certainly end on D or feel that it should end on D.  If you listen to examples of each you can hear that the tune in D mix has a very different 'flavour' to one in G major. 
Title: Re: key trouble!!!
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 28, 2010, 03:12:14 PM
To ignore those 'difference' notes .... (for 2 lines anyway)

  D major is a tune in D played on the D row of a D/G box

  D myxolydian is a tune in D played on its G row (strictly)

The defining difference is that your G row carries a C rather than C#.

All other notes are the same  (different order though).  So a practical difference is that the pattern of push/pull changes. That's the thing you get to 'feel' on a one row.  On a 2 row you'll also then usually pick different left end chords - typically bringing in C chords when playing D myxolydian to emphasise that 'characteristic' C natural  in its scale. 

All these modes are all simply the notes from the scale of the row .. but you start on one of its seven differing notes. G A B C D E F# in the case of G row. Counting up from G - it's the 5th mode of the scale - so called myxolydian.  But we name it for its start note. So it's "D myxolydian"

Of course 'up and down row' may not be the most efficient way to play a mode. On the mouth organ it's the only way.  Meloneonists have the option to cross finger - a good reason to try this.

It's confusing as there are several layers. or ways of looking at this. I think of myxolydian in dots as a D tune with a C natural. On the instrument I think of it as D, with C bass chords, and pull that C note on the G row.
Title: Re: key trouble!!!
Post by: strad on February 28, 2010, 04:39:32 PM
I have my answer to this but can't work out how to attach the .txt file to my reply. I put the file into 'Attachments' but then nothing happens!
Title: Re: key trouble!!!
Post by: george garside on February 28, 2010, 04:50:50 PM
  same fingering as Gsharrplessl A on D row
george
Title: Re: key trouble!!!
Post by: strad on February 28, 2010, 05:03:50 PM
I'll try a different approach! These are the notes in each of the modes in the keys we're most likely to use:-

No sharps or flats
 
C Ionian      c   d   e   f   g   a   b   c     
D Dorian      d   e   f   g   a   b   c   d     
E Phrygian   e   f   g   a   b   c   d   e     
F Lydian      f   g   a   b   c   d   e   f     
G Mixolydian   g   a   b   c   d   e   f   g     
A Aeolian      a   b   c   d   e   f   g   a     
B Locrian      b   c   d   e   f   g   a   b   

1 sharp
 
G Ionian      g   a   b   c   d   e   f#   g     
A Dorian      a   b   c   d   e   f#   g   a     
B Phrygian   b   c   d   e   f#   g   a   b     
C Lydian      c   d   e   f#   g   a   b   c     
D Mixolydian   d   e   f#   g   a   b   c   d     
E Aeolian      e   f#   g   a   b   c   d   e     
F# Locrian   f#   g   a   b   c   d   e   f#   

2 sharps
 
D Ionian      d   e   f#   g   a   b   c#   d     
E Dorian      e   f#   g   a   b   c#   d   e     
F# Phrygian   f#   g   a   b   c#   d   e   f#     
G Lydian      g   a   b   c#   d   e   f#   g     
A Mixolydian   a   b   c#   d   e   f#   g   a     
B Aeolian      b   c#   d   e   f#   g   a   b     
C# Locrian   c#   d   e   f#   g   a   b   c#

3 sharps

A Ionian               a            b           c#         d            e           f#         g#          a
B Dorian               b            c#         d           e            f#         g#         a            b
C# Phrygian          c#          d           e           f#          g#         a           b            c#
D Lydian               d            e           f#         g#          a           b           c#          d  
E Mixolydian          e            f#          g#        a            b           c#         d            e
F# Aeolian            f#           g#         a          b            c#         d           e            f#      
G# Locrian            g#          a           b          c#          d           e           f#           g#  

1 flat
 
F Ionian      f   g   a   Bb   c   d   e   f     
G Dorian      g   a   Bb   c   d   e   f   g     
A Phrygi   a   Bb   c   d   e   f   g   a     
Bb Lydian      Bb   c   d   e   f   g   a   Bb     
C Mixolydian   c   d   e   f   g   a   Bb   c     
D Aeolian      d   e   f   g   a   Bb   c   d     
E Locrian      e   f   g   a   Bb   c   d   e   

2 flats
 
Bb Ionian      Bb   c   d   Eb   f   g   a   Bb     
C Dorian      c   d   Eb   f   g   a   Bb   c     
D Phrygian   d   Eb   f   g   a   Bb   c   d     
Eb Lydian      Eb   f   g   a   Bb   c   d   Eb     
F Mixolydian   f   g   a   Bb   c   d   Eb   f     
G Aeolian      g   a   Bb   c   d   Eb   f   g     
A Locrian      a   Bb   c   d   Eb   f   g   a   

It's not as neatly laid out as in my copy which is in a table but it's there.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal