Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: TonyRussellDavis on February 18, 2010, 08:49:54 AM
-
Does anybody actually use the thumbstrap for playing? How? T.
-
Yes. One row Cajun players that don't use a shoulder strap.
-
Hi Tony, I do. Principally because I was shown how to hold a melodeon by another guy who also uses the thumbstrap - his name is Jack (surname escapes me right now) and he plays with Ghost of Mansfield Morris. I met him at Whitby one day whilst I was browsing the boxes on Theo's stand, and he took one down and showed me how to hold it. The rest, as they say is history. Perhaps, best forgotten history!
;D
AL
-
I used to and then stopped when I bought my Saltarelle (which doesn't have one). Glad I did, as I think that using one restricts your RH movement considerably.
-
I did when I first started playing (on a Hohner Erica), because it was there. After a while I found I didn't need to put my thumb very far through the strap. Eventually it was just the tip of the thumb, just to give me a reference point. I soon realised that it was serving no real purpose and just getting in the way, so I cut it off (the strap, that is (:)).
None of my other instruments have them, and if they had I'd remove them. I agree with ukebert that they restrict the movement of your hand.
-
I think that coming from English Concertina playing I was happy and used to putting my thumb into a strap. Personally I find that it gives me a greater sense of freedom when playing as it allows my hands the flexibility to come around and over the top of the button board. Without the strap I struggle a bit as I feel I need to anchor my hand via the thumb to the back of the instrument. Horses for courses and it's down to individual taste I suppose. What I do like however is a thumstrap that allows the hand to rotate. A fixed strap will inevitably get distorted.
AL
(Never without a strap!)
-
For me, it varies according to the box I am playing. I use the thumb strap (and a shoulder strap) when I am playing my one-row Cajun accordion, but there isn't one on my three-row Castagnari boxes - and I wouldn't use it if there was.
-
I did , until my thumb dropped off from restricted circulation :D
-
I've always assumed they were just there to use if you wanted to play without shoulder straps. Otherwise I can't see the point of them, because if the box is properly supported by the shoulder straps and/or your knees (if you're sitting down) then you don't need to hold it with your thumb as well.
Personally, when I've tried to use one, I haven't been able to reach more than a few of the buttons without risking dislocating my thumb, or as Tyker just said, having it drop off through lack of blood supply!
-
Thanks guys; I shoulda made clear I meant "without a shoulder strap too"! Got my answers though. T ;D.
-
When I got my new Dino last week the very first thing I did after taking it out of the case, before even opening the bellows straps, was remove the thumb strap. I don't know why they still bother putting them on new boxes, players that actually use them must surely be in the minority.
-
When I got my new Dino last week the very first thing I did after taking it out of the case, before even opening the bellows straps, was remove the thumb strap. I don't know why they still bother putting them on new boxes, players that actually use them must surely be in the minority.
But they still exist and removing a strap is a 2 minute job, sourcing one and fitting it is a far longer task.
-
When I got my new Dino last week the very first thing I did after taking it out of the case, before even opening the bellows straps, was remove the thumb strap. I don't know why they still bother putting them on new boxes, players that actually use them must surely be in the minority.
But they still exist and removing a strap is a 2 minute job, sourcing one and fitting it is a far longer task.
Yeah but the mark of where they were is often visible, no one wants that.
-
When I got my new Dino last week the very first thing I did after taking it out of the case, before even opening the bellows straps, was remove the thumb strap. I don't know why they still bother putting them on new boxes, players that actually use them must surely be in the minority.
But they still exist and removing a strap is a 2 minute job, sourcing one and fitting it is a far longer task.
I've taken them off all of our instruments. The Liliput, the Club 1B, and the Touptit didn't have one to start off with. You have to ask if you want one on Bernard Loffet's boxes. [NWKUI] If you drill out the rivets on a Hohner to get it off, the spare shelf hole filler plugs from your kitchen cabinets will plug the holes nicely.[/NWKUI]
-
Yeah, there's now a hole in the back of the Baffetti's keyboard, I could fill that in with sawdust and glue or even make a cherry dowel and plug it with that....but....it has an off the gun satin finish and the filled area will have a different reflectivity after it's been levelled, you can't match repairs with them unless the affected area has been shined up with use.
If you don't use one, thumb straps get in the way when they're left on and leave marks when they're removed. They're a hangover from a time before strap brackets were fitted to most boxes as standard and few people use them today, especially on 2 rows, so I think the minority of players that really want them should have to go to the trouble of having one fitted rather than inconveniencing the majority with the melodeon equivalent of a vestigial tail. ;D
-
I think manufacturers affix it for a reason...
-
To help foster fellowship among players by creating an argument about whether or not they have any practical use? ??? :-* :||:
-
I think manufacturers affix it for a reason...
Do many models have them these days, other than one rows?
As far as I can remember, the only ones I've ever had with thumbstraps have been my pokerwork and my erica. My Erika Club hasn't got one, and looks like it never did have.
-
My Tommy has got a thumb strap...don't use it though.
-
Shows how good my memory is then!
-
Sit down Cajun players do without the shoulder strap.. its traditional ..
Personally I like standing up
-
[NWKUI] If you drill out the rivets on a Hohner to get it off, the spare shelf hole filler plugs from your kitchen cabinets will plug the holes nicely.[/NWKUI]
Not useless at all, I was just wondering how to deal with this :D Why rivet on a thumbstrap, seriously?!
-
There is an earlier thread here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,937.0.html) and as an experiment I have continued playing my one row G with the thumb strap only, it gives a totally different feel to playing but unfortunately it has not transformed me into Oscar Woods.
-
Malcolm - thanks for the link. I read it carefully and note that "tradition" seems to be at least as important as practicallity ::). The old 1-row thumbstrap players must have gone through hell with new melodeons until the bellows eased up! My 1-rows bellows are still stiffish. Maybe I need to play them more. T.
-
[NWKUI] If you drill out the rivets on a Hohner to get it off, the spare shelf hole filler plugs from your kitchen cabinets will plug the holes nicely.[/NWKUI]
Not useless at all, I was just wondering how to deal with this :D Why rivet on a thumbstrap, seriously?!
How else can you attach a thumb strap to a plastic fingerboard?
-
[NWKUI] If you drill out the rivets on a Hohner to get it off, the spare shelf hole filler plugs from your kitchen cabinets will plug the holes nicely.[/NWKUI]
Not useless at all, I was just wondering how to deal with this :D Why rivet on a thumbstrap, seriously?!
How else can you attach a thumb strap to a plastic fingerboard?
I've seen a 3/16th nut, washer an' roof bolt used on a couple of keyboards
"warning" watch out for holes in the clothes though...
-
How else can you attach a thumb strap to a plastic fingerboard?
Mine is a wooden fingerboard...
-
......Why rivet on a thumbstrap, seriously?!...
Having been in mid-performance and had the b.thing fall off once......
I play my one-rows on thumbstrap - I always have, probably because the old chap who started me off playing did, much in the same way as I play guitar left handed thanks to the example set by my older, left handed brother! I'm actually right handed. The Excelsior melodeon on my avatar is being played on the thumb, as it were. There's no other strap on it. If I do play it stood up I put my left leg up on the melodeon's case and rest the melodeon on my thigh just as I do when I'm sat down. Yes, I know I'm one of a dying breed doing this! In contrast, when I play my c.1935 Theo'd Erika I use it's two shoulder straps. It doesn't have a thumb strap anyway and never has, instead having a concave edge to the keyboard. Playing a two-row on thumbstrap tends to put your wrist at a bad angle, particularly on the outside buttons.
Mike
-
Does anybody actually use the thumbstrap for playing? How? T.
I do. By putting the thumb through. Only for the bigger ones (clubs) I prefer shoulder-straps.
-
Does anybody actually use the thumbstrap for playing? How? T.
I do. By putting the thumb through. Only for the bigger ones (clubs) I prefer shoulder-straps.
I recently acquired one row box with only a thumbstrap. I have been playing it that way, while waiting for some strap brackets on order. Not only was the box more difficult to play (push and pull wise), but every time I got into spirited playing, the strap would come loose from my thumb, and I would either have to restrain myself quite noticeably, or lose it altogether. No fun having the right side go completely free on you in mid tune! I also found that my right hand had less dexterity than I wished. I was even worried that the reeds were not speaking easily, as it was so much work to play.
When the strap brackets arrived, I wasted no time getting them on. Viola, the box was transformed! No slipping off, no anxiety, right hand free to move, no aching thumb joint, and playing effort reduced immeasurably. I have seen players on the 'Tube use only the thumbstrap, and my hat is off to them, but I need my whole body behind it, not just a thumb.
-
Playing a two-row on thumbstrap tends to put your wrist at a bad angle, particularly on the outside buttons.
/quote]
Been thinking a little about this Mike - and I figure that I don't have a problem playing my 2 or 3 row using the thumb strap perhaps because I have quite a small hand. Certainly I feel supported by the strap. I use the thumbstrap more on the two-row as I only use 1 shoulder strap. Whereas the three-row has two shoulder straps so I don't feel the need so much to be anchored to the box :D maybe size does matter after all? ;)
AL