Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: nemethmik on February 18, 2010, 11:29:14 AM
-
Two very interesting melodeon tutor books (in German) came with the Hohner Liliput I bought off ebay Germany.
(1) "Deutsche Hadharmonika-Bibliothek Elementarschule fur diatonische Handharmonika nach dem System Koppl" a 24-page tutor book for the Club (gleichton) system 2.5-row melodeons. The booklet was published in 1936 and used the regular music notation, no Griffschrift. This book is an no-Griffschrift alternative to the Alfons Holzschuh tutor book, which uses Griffschrift. I have scanned this booklet and I'd like to upload this 31 Mb PDF to a website where it is publicly available (maybe melodeon.net) for those who are interested in Club-model accordions, can handle an easy German text and prefer avoiding Griffschrift.
(2) The other is The German Accordion School (Die Deutsche Harmonika Schule) by Erhard Kutschenreuter for 2.5-row Club-model accordions. This 48-page tutor book was published in 1936 and used regular music notation, too; no Griffschrift.
I was wondering why Griffschrift was needed when in 1936 Club-system tutor books used regular music notation ??? Anyhow, good to know for Club-system fans that there are tutor books without Griffschrift.
-
It would be interesting to see those books. I have a Club X on its way from germany with a couple more in the box.
-
I have scanned this booklet and I'd like to upload this 31 Mb PDF to a website where it is publicly available (maybe melodeon.net) for those who are interested in Club-model accordions, can handle an easy German text and prefer avoiding Griffschrift.
The Yahoo Group for Diatonic Accordions (http://launch.groups.yahoo.com/group/diatonic/) has a files section, but only 100MB total and a limit of 5MB per file. 31MB seems very large for a 24-page booklet. Can you scan it at a smaller file size? I have a 48-page tuition book PDF at <7MB, and the 66-page Roland instruction manual PDF for the FR3 V-accordion is also 7MB.
-
Can you scan it at a smaller file size?
I did, and the new size is 7MB.
Miki
-
Can you scan it at a smaller file size?
I did, and the new size is 7MB.
Miki
That's good. Now it's time to find out whether melodeon.net is able to provide space for storing files like this. Theo/Clive?
-
I did, and the new size is 7MB.
Miki
That's good. Now it's time to find out whether melodeon.net is able to provide space for storing files like this. Theo/Clive?
If there's any problem or likelihood of delay, email it to me and I'll host it now (i.e. this afternoon). I've got a reseller web hosting account with loads of space and quite happy to host a file or two for melnet. I'd be very interested to see this book anyway. I'll post a link here...
-
It would be interesting to see those books. I have a Club X on its way from germany with a couple more in the box.
I see, you are new owner of that box 8)
I also watched this item on ebay .. but didn't bid for it - I already have a Club X of the same type.
I also have got some old german melodion tutor books with my Hohner Cluh IV some months ago.
-
I’m very interested in the two booklets. Are they already online? If not, I would love to put them on the web. (:)
-
There is no problem hosting them on melodeon.net, but nobody has asked me yet to do it!
-
They are here:
http://www.treewind.co.uk/melnet/DHB-Elementarschule.pdf (http://www.treewind.co.uk/melnet/DHB-Elementarschule.pdf)
http://www.treewind.co.uk/melnet/DHS-Kutschenreuter.pdf (http://www.treewind.co.uk/melnet/DHS-Kutschenreuter.pdf)
(But if Theo wants to copy them and host them on melodeon.net that's fine with me!)
Anahata
-
Thank you! :D
-
I'll put a link to them over on the "main" website.
-
I had a chance (thank you Michael) to have a look at the pages of possibly the first edition of the Club-system melodeon tutor book written by A.Holzschuh, also published in 1936. 1936 was the golden era for accordions and a competition (war) between the diatonic accordion notation systems. In this book the Griffschrift word was not used; instead, it was called Claudeschrift; possibly not coincidentally - the book's publisher was Claude-Paoso.
-
There is another system used in 1930s tutors the Helbing System. This uses a 10 line stave and the direction of the note tails indicates press or draw.
-
Another system I seem to recall has the dots on the notes either filled in or left open to indicate press and draw. What all of the tab systems have in common is that once you've moved beyond the basic scales, they take about as much effort to learn as regular music notation, but they lack the versatility and general availability of regular notation. Still, if it's what you know, I suppose it's useful.
-
What all of the tab systems have in common is taht once you've moved beyond the basic scales, they take about as much effort to learn as regular music notation, but they lack the versatility and general availability of regular notation.
That was one of the reasons, I posted my original message: the two German Club-system tutor booklets I received do not use any TAB notation; instead, they apply the regular well-known music notation with some optional extra symbols or comments. The German Accordion School (Die Deutsche Harmonika Schule) by Erhard Kutschenreuter is quite similar to the notation of Dave Mallinson's tutor book. The German book uses C and F as the "standard" keys, while Mallinson presents the tunes in D and G.
-
Its quite extraordinary how much effort has been put into the business of making clubs, making alternative tab systems for clubs, making tutors for clubs, forming club orchestras, and more recently converting clubs into more popular tuning systems . . . some people even play them!
-
some people even play them!
Just received another Club accordion tutor book in German: The 1 x 1 of Melodeon by Curt Mahr (Das 1 x 1 der Handharmonika). This one is from 1937 and uses the same Griffschrift notation as in the Holzschuh books. In this book, however, it is called Seifert Notation (after the publisher Oskar Seifert).
-
Just received another Club accordion tutor book in German: The 1 x 1 of Melodeon by Curt Mahr (Das 1 x 1 der Handharmonika). This one is from 1937 and uses the same Griffschrift notation as in the Holzschuh books. In this book, however, it is called Seifert Notation (after the publisher Oskar Seifert).
Uploading to http://www.treewind.co.uk/melnet/1x1-Handharmonika.pdf (http://www.treewind.co.uk/melnet/1x1-Handharmonika.pdf) as I type...
-
Well actually I was sitting with the telly muted, playing a few tunes on my clubs (C/F and Bb/Eb) when the phone rang. Whilst discussing hammered dulcimers on the phone, I clicked onto melnet and found this thread...
Rob.
-
Finally had chance to explore the pile of music that came with my Club X. It is all scores rather than tutorial and appears to be all in this 'Seifert' Notation rather than proper music. The book "Wanderlust" is dated 1935, contains 130 tunes, and appears to be aimed at the youngster marching through the hills with their Hohner Lilliputs in there knapsacks. It includes a two page summary of the notation shown bellow.
-
If it's a Liliput on the cover, the lad must be really really small! ;D
-
http://www.treewind.co.uk/melnet/DHB-Elementarschule.pdf
http://www.treewind.co.uk/melnet/DHS-Kutschenreuter.pdf
http://www.treewind.co.uk/melnet/1x1-Handharmonika.pdf
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=3516.0;attach=2765;image
There is a very important plus in all of these tutor booklets: half of the contents of each are about multi-voice (two or three buttons pressed at a time) playing. The tutor books/videos (I have) for English melodeon or Irish B/C button accordion have no sections about multi-voice playing.
-
So, is it possible to still get music written in the Seifert system for Club boxes?
If so, doesn't anyone have a link? I'm new to Club/melodeons and I'm rather enjoying the 1x1-Handharmonika.pdf.
It seems to be a very comfortable system that is easy for me to follow.
Thanks,
Will
-
So, is it possible to still get music written in the Seifert system for Club boxes?
First of all, I am not really a fan of tab notation, to put it mildly, for a bunch of reasons, and I would not recommend it. But there are already other threads dedicated to that subject.
The only tab notation today still in use for Club accordion is Griffschrift. That's the term you may want to google. Mr. Fuchs has a very short history of tab notation (http://www.volksmusikschule.at/entwicklung.htm) for diatonic accordion (Club & Steirische).
-
Will, I don't think so. Unless you have access to German second hand bookshops. Or some old accordion shop. Amazing you like these kind of notation. My local library (Southern Germany) still has some books for diatonic accordions. Every single one uses a different kind of Griffschrift. I hate that. IMO it would be best to switch to standard notation ASAP.
BTW you can have a look at http://www.ggms.nl/Clubmodel.html - there are pdf and soundfiles for club boxes. Button numbers start with 1.
A quick search on amazon.de for "Curt Mahr Handharmonika" turns up a few books, too.
-
The only tab notation today still in use for Club accordion is Griffschrift. That's the term you may want to google. Mr. Fuchs has a very short history of tab notation (http://www.volksmusikschule.at/entwicklung.htm) for diatonic accordion (Club & Steirische).
You'd have to be careful then. Recent books are written for 4 row steirisch boxes. Usually a few tunes can be played on 3 row steirisch boxes.
So most likely you'd have to adapt them. But why? I'd rather prefer these old books from the 50s and 60s.
-
Finally had chance to explore the pile of music that came with my Club X. It is all scores rather than tutorial and appears to be all in this 'Seifert' Notation rather than proper music. The book "Wanderlust" is dated 1935, contains 130 tunes, and appears to be aimed at the youngster marching through the hills with their Hohner Lilliputs in there knapsacks. It includes a two page summary of the notation shown bellow.
Hi Mike,
Any chance I could persuade you to do a scan of the "Wanderlust" book?
Looks like it could have some interesting tunes in it.
Will
-
Will, I don't think so. Unless you have access to German second hand bookshops. Or some old accordion shop. Amazing you like these kind of notation. My local library (Southern Germany) still has some books for diatonic accordions. Every single one uses a different kind of Griffschrift. I hate that. IMO it would be best to switch to standard notation ASAP.
BTW you can have a look at http://www.ggms.nl/Clubmodel.html - there are pdf and soundfiles for club boxes. Button numbers start with 1.
A quick search on amazon.de for "Curt Mahr Handharmonika" turns up a few books, too.
I'm using both Seifert (well, the only stuff I have is in the PDF posted here) and standard notation.
The thing I like about the Seifert system is that it's unambiguous. Notes on the line are on the F row and notes off the line (between lines) are on the C row. I've been trying to notate some ABC files so I can re-reference tricky passages. Trying to decide on fingerings, then looking up which actual notes they represent (I'm still learning all the notes, push and pull) to then adding this to the ABC file is a real pain.
I've googled Seifert and Mahr and have found the following, but it doesn't seem to be available (note this is both volumes 1 and 2):
http://www.musik-direkt.com/Das-neue-1x1-der-Handharmonika-Band-2-gruendlicher-Lehrgang-fuer-das-Handharmonikaspiel_px172888de.html
Does anyone here by any chance have a PDF of volume 2? Then I'd have both of the Mahr method books and quite a few tunes. :)
Will
-
Notes on the line are on the F row and notes off the line (between lines) are on the C row.
Griffschrift. That's the term you may want to google. Mr. Fuchs has a very short history of tab notation (http://www.volksmusikschule.at/entwicklung.htm) for diatonic accordion (Club & Steirische).
-
It's available for about ₤10 via German amazon:
https://www.amazon.de/gp/offer-listing/0203907159/ref=dp_olp_used?ie=UTF8&condition=used
Wanderlust:
https://www.amazon.de/gp/offer-listing/B006XG38DG/ref=dp_olp_used?ie=UTF8&condition=used
-
Notes on the line are on the F row and notes off the line (between lines) are on the C row.
Griffschrift. That's the term you may want to google. Mr. Fuchs has a very short history of tab notation (http://www.volksmusikschule.at/entwicklung.htm) for diatonic accordion (Club & Steirische).
Thanks, but this seems to deal with the Steirisches system, which I did have a look at, but ultimately would require me to do a certain amount of decoding to get value from it.
But I appreciate you pointing it out.
Will
-
Thanks, but this seems to deal with the Steirisches system
The system is the same. You will find a Seifert example in the article.
-
It's available for about ₤10 via German amazon:
https://www.amazon.de/gp/offer-listing/0203907159/ref=dp_olp_used?ie=UTF8&condition=used
Wanderlust:
https://www.amazon.de/gp/offer-listing/B006XG38DG/ref=dp_olp_used?ie=UTF8&condition=used
Thanks, Tom. I'm ordering them now. :D
Vielen Dank in die Runde und ich wünsche Euch einen schönen Tag noch!
Will
-
Thanks, but this seems to deal with the Steirisches system
The system is the same. You will find a Seifert example in the article.
Fair enough. I'll go back and have another gander, then.
Will
-
Here is another example (http://www.stretta-music.com/noten/tasteninstrumente/handharmonika/maduri-der-hula-hup-song-nr-102549.html), somewhat newer (1958), from "Seifert’s Handharmonika-Musik". The system used is normal Griffschrift.
-
Here is another example (http://www.stretta-music.com/noten/tasteninstrumente/handharmonika/maduri-der-hula-hup-song-nr-102549.html), somewhat newer (1958), from "Seifert’s Handharmonika-Musik". The system used is normal Griffschrift.
Does "normal Griffschrift" mean the Steirisches System / Holzschuh / Seifert?
-
Does "normal Griffschrift" mean the Steirisches System / Holzschuh / Seifert?
Sorry, I didn't make it clear enough.
Griffschrift means a tab notation which looks more or less like normal musical notation. The note heads between the lines indicate the buttons on the outer diatonic row of a diatonic accordion, the note heads on the lines indicate the buttons on the next inner diatonic row. This notation for the two outer rows is commono to all variations of Griffschrift.
The following inner rows (one row on Club and one [but with different note layout] to three rows on Steirische) are indicated by #s before the note heads or square note heads or something like this. Here appears a difference between the notation for a Club box and for a Steirische (even if only a three-row Steirische). The indication for the two outer rows remains the same for all types of boxes. (Another difference is, of course, the notation of the basses.)
Griffschrift for the Steirische Harmonika didn't exist prior to 1975 (and even than only for three-row Steirische). So you are safe with older editions. Anyway, I wouldn't suppose many new publikations for Club after 1975.
The edition in question is from the 50s and indikates "Handharmonika" (a term used for Club). (It even shows a Club box on the title page) Publications for Steirische Harmonika tend to use the term "Steirische", because it was (more or less) a new type of melodeon emerging in the 1970s.
-
Does "normal Griffschrift" mean the Steirisches System / Holzschuh / Seifert?
Sorry, I didn't make it clear enough.
Griffschrift means a tab notation which looks more or less like normal musical notation. The note heads between the lines indicate the buttons on the outer diatonic row of a diatonic accordion, the note heads on the lines indicate the buttons on the next inner diatonic row. This notation for the two outer rows is commono to all variations of Griffschrift.
The following inner rows (one row on Club and one [but with different note layout] to three rows on Steirische) are indicated by #s before the note heads or square note heads or something like this. Here appears a difference between the notation for a Club box and for a Steirische (even if only a three-row Steirische). The indication for the two outer rows remains the same for all types of boxes. (Another difference is, of course, the notation of the basses.)
Griffschrift for the Steirische Harmonika didn't exist prior to 1975 (and even than only for three-row Steirische). So you are safe with older editions. Anyway, I wouldn't suppose many new publikations for Club after 1975.
The edition in question is from the 50s and indikates "Handharmonika" (a term used for Club). (It even shows a Club box on the title page) Publications for Steirische Harmonika tend to use the term "Steirische", because it was (more or less) a new type of melodeon emerging in the 1970s.
Thanks, Sebastian. Good information, good to know.
Will
-
It's available for about ₤10 via German amazon:
https://www.amazon.de/gp/offer-listing/0203907159/ref=dp_olp_used?ie=UTF8&condition=used
I've purchased and received the above from Amazon.de, but it would seem the notation system is slightly different from what it was in the older Mahr/Seifert PDFs that have been made available here on Melnet.
In particular, there are no push/pull notations. Rather, there seems to be a thick black line under some measures:
https://www.trekel.de/10709/Handharmonika-1x1-Bd-1-Mahr-Curt-386207.html
I'm referring to the bits that look like this:
|-------------------------------------------|
I'm assuming this means "push" as in the middle of page 3 of my new book it says (translated from the German):
"If a short "push" section appears in a long "pull" section, the air button should be held half-in during the "push" section so that the bellows can be quickly closed and a new "pull" section begun."
This then shows 3 bars of "push" playing followed by a single bar with |--------------------------| under it.
Any advice from those in the know?
Thanks,
Will
-
In particular, there are no push/pull notations.
I might seem a bit like a parrot, but I still would recommend to read this short article on the history of meloden tab notation in Germany: http://www.volksmusikschule.at/entwicklung.htm
Let me quote two passages:
Unter den Bassbuchstaben ist ein durchgehender dünner Unterstrich, der als Zeichen für Zudruck verstärkt ist, Aufzug bleibt dünn. Hier ist also erstmals ein dicker Unterstrich Angabe der Zugrichtung. Nach den mir vorliegenden Unterlagen scheint sich dieses System nach 1945 allgemein durchgesetzt zu haben.
Than for 1975:
Zudruck wird durch einen dicken Unterstrich angegeben, beim Aufzug fehlt der Unterstrich.
Neverthless I want to repeat what I said in the beginning and what was essentially confirmed by TomBom: Stay away from tab notation, if you want to understand your instrument.
-
Thanks, Sebastian. I did go back and look at the page you referenced, but it doesn't fit the model used in my book.
The |------------------| notation used is only of one thickness (i.e. not thick and thin) and does not appear beneath the bass notation, but rather between it and the melody.
I just thought I'd ask. I'm sure I'll figure it out.
And I do use standard music notation, but I'd like to learn about all aspects of the instrument and for a Club, this sort of tab notation seems to be important, even if only historically. And I like history. :)
All the best,
Will
-
;) That's why I wrote
My local library ... has some books for diatonic accordions. Every single one uses a different kind of Griffschrift. I hate that. IMO it would be best to switch to standard notation ASAP.
Will, the |------------------| notation either means push or pull. I can't tell from the sample pages you posted.
I admire your motivation to read these complicated and long-winded explanations! There is a reason these books are out of print for decades. :)
BTW, did you have a look at http://www.delaguerre.com/delaguerre/pedagogy/club/intro.html ?
-
The |------------------| notation used is only of one thickness (i.e. not thick and thin)
Yes, like in the quotation for the later period I put in my last posting. Or maybe I just don't get the point. :-[
When there is a black line underneath the dots, it means: push. It's binary; you have either push or pull. When there is more black, it's push. When there is less or no black at all, it's pull.
I'd like to learn about all aspects of the instrument
You have a point. 8)
But, please, don't fritter away to much time with tab notation. When even Mr. Fuchs, who offers a massive collection of Griffschrift-transcribed tunes, says: "Ein musikalisch vorgebildeter Mensch tut sich vielleicht sogar leichter, nach normalen Noten zu spielen" (and you are a musically skilled person), than you should maybe take that into consideration and switch back to normal notation - be it only on behalf of more efficient progress. (http://www.smilies.4-user.de/include/Girls/smilie_girl_028.gif)
-
Thanks, guys.
TomBom: Yes, I've looked at the Delaguerre site. It's part of why I find the scalar, cross-row playing aspect of the Club so interesting.
I don't spend a lot of time with the Holzschuh / Seifert system stuff.
Mainly just when my brain is overloaded from trying to figure out a good finger for a new tune and I just want to try playing something else, but more straightforward. And believe it or note, I do find the Holzschuh / Seifert system fairly straightforward (well, at least what is in the old 30s-era PDF scans referenced here on Melnet.). :)
Sebastian: I overlooked your further comment (the second one) about |--------------| meaning push and no marks meaning pull. Was a long day and I just went snowblind. :)
All the best,
Will