Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: sqwzboxstudent on February 19, 2010, 08:20:58 PM
-
did paolo soprani ever used to make any d/g boxes back in the 40s/50s/60s or was it all irish tunings? just imagine if you cold get an old grey in d/g? when i say irish tuning was it b/c or c/d*? just pondering the idea... G.L
-
The flat keyboard models we all know from the irish music scene were made especially for the british isles and ireland. In fact, a friend of mine went to castelfidardo with his old grey paolo, and found nothing but confused and stunned people when showing a flat keyboard paolo. The rest of europe got the stepped keyboard models - they were also made around that time, but only in limited numbers, and I've yet to see one in grey. I've seen a few in green, and numerous in red, all with celluloid grilles (apart from the pepperpot grille models).
I don't think they made D/G's. Previous discussions on this board has covered the history of the D/G system, and the conclusion seems to be that apart from 3-row ADG's, the D/G combination is fairly 'new' in Italian box making. At least new compared to the G/C, C/F, A/D, Bb/Eb and even F/Bb's made by Paolo Soprani in the early days.
So to sum up my views - all the 20's-50's flat keyboard ones I've seen has been semitone from original, and all the flat keyboard from the 20's-50's has been quint tuned from original.
-
The flat keyboard models we all know from the irish music scene were made especially for the british isles and ireland. In fact, a friend of mine went to castelfidardo with his old grey paolo, and found nothing but confused and stunned people when showing a flat keyboard paolo. The rest of europe got the stepped keyboard models - they were also made around that time, but only in limited numbers, and I've yet to see one in grey. I've seen a few in green, and numerous in red, all with celluloid grilles (apart from the pepperpot grille models).
I don't think they made D/G's. Previous discussions on this board has covered the history of the D/G system, and the conclusion seems to be that apart from 3-row ADG's, the D/G combination is fairly 'new' in Italian box making. At least new compared to the G/C, C/F, A/D, Bb/Eb and even F/Bb's made by Paolo Soprani in the early days.
So to sum up my views - all the 20's-50's flat keyboard ones I've seen has been semitone from original, and all the flat keyboard from the 20's-50's has been quint tuned from original.
Hi Lars,
Am I right that you meant to write "all the stepped keyboard from the 20's - 50's have been quint tuned from original" ?
But on another point, I don't think you made a typo -- I think you meant what you wrote -- but I have different experience. I have seen a good few aluminum grille (but not "pepperpot") Paolos that were quint-tuned and stepped-keyboard.
Here are two Paolos (plus a Busilacchio). The Paolos now have (non-original) flat keyboard plates, but the aluminum grille in each case is original. The big Paolo was G/C 4 voice, the little Paolo was F/Bb 2 voice: