Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: ladydetemps on February 23, 2010, 11:36:03 AM

Title: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on February 23, 2010, 11:36:03 AM
I noticed one of the future themes of the month is
"Tunes you've written yourself"
Well I haven't written one...so thought I might be a bit stuck when it gets to that point. And I don't know how long it takes to write a tune so thought maybe if I started now it might give me a fighting chance.
Problem is....I don't know how to write a tune, where to start what to include....I don't understand all the music theory stuff. Do I just look for patterns I like and throw them together, take an existing tune and change several notes at a time till it sounds different, or is there a different approach?
Can someone with my naivety and inexperience actually possibly write a tune?
Enlighten me please.
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Lester on February 23, 2010, 11:58:37 AM
Do I just look for patterns I like and throw them together

Yes, this is usually successful

Quote
take an existing tune and change several notes at a time till it sounds different,

This can work, you could also consider changing time sig (see the Plane Tree/Shottiche a'Bethinie thread)

Quote
or is there a different approach?

You could try being really creative and clever and just write a tune  ::)

Quote
Can someone with my naivety and inexperience actually possibly write a tune?

Yes
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Theo on February 23, 2010, 12:01:02 PM
I've written a couple and I don't think you need to know any music theory, it  will be helpful to some, but if you are not well up on theory don't let that stop you.  Have a look at tunes you like and see how they are structured,  look for repeated phrases, and things that look as though they repeat, but then go somewhere different.

How long a tune takes to write can vary from a few minutes to months.  For me I seem to need to have something happen to trigger off the process.  The last one was for my parents diamond wedding.

I usually start with a short phrase, just 4 or 5 notes or so and then I build on that.  Its not difficult, give it a go.  What is hard is to write a really great tune that people hear and then want to learn off you.  
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on February 23, 2010, 12:10:10 PM

Quote
or is there a different approach?

You could try being really creative and clever and just write a tune  ::)
Lets just say I started doing as before adverts with changes...and now I do adverts from scratch. I needed stabilisers when learning to ride a bike. I needed armbands when learning to swim....
I tried just going with the flow and it didn't work...didn't fit any time signature and sounded like a dirge.

I usually start with a short phrase, just 4 or 5 notes or so and then I build on that.  Its not difficult, give it a go.  What is hard is to write a really great tune that people hear and then want to learn off you. 
what is the best key to write in? Should I just stick to 'G'?
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: rees on February 23, 2010, 12:15:45 PM
Best to stick to G for now as it's the key you are most familiar with.
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 23, 2010, 12:24:04 PM
When I write a tune (not that it happens very often), it starts off as a tune in my head, which I sing, hum, whistle, etc. whilst doing something else totally different, like walking to the corner shop or being stuck in traffic in the Sheffield rush hour.  

That's the real creative bit.

The thing to do next is to hum it into a recording device of some sort, so you don't forget it. At this stage you can try different versions too.

Next, depending on how you normally learn tunes, you can either have a go at poking around on the melodeon or keyboard or whatever you have (often it is a penny whistle or descant recorder in my case, as those are the instruments I can play easiest by ear), and/or then have a go at writing it down in music, tablature, numbers, etc... whatever suits you best.

To re-emphasise - it's not necessary to write the tune down, but make a recording of it in some way or form so you don't forget it. You can always send the recording to someone else to transcribe into dots for you  ;)
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Scallyanglo on February 23, 2010, 12:28:31 PM
Funnily enough I have been wondering about writing tunes as well - hadn't seen Theme of the month but had picked up a book called 'Sound Foundations' with CD -"source of reference and a guide for aspiring composers." (James Rae & Mike Cornick) It's target is secondary schools (and its few lines on accordion say listen to the theme from 'Allo 'allo!) but it's telling me many things I want to know.
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on February 23, 2010, 12:41:58 PM

Just to proove my point this was 2 attempts on concertina....just sounds dreadfull

http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=7555

http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=7556

Didn't have a clue what I was doing just pressing buttons as I went along. I can't stand listening so I don't know how anyone else would.
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: strad on February 23, 2010, 12:42:39 PM
A system that I find works well is to noodle until you find a short phrase that sounds good. If you take that phrase as being the question, then another phrase the same length, similar but different, is the answer. The two together should be (in non musical terms) either 8 or 16 foot taps. So that's the first part done. The second half of the tune usually seems to follow on from what the first part tells you. But the question and answer system is good for both halves, though frequently the second half of the second half (if you understand) can frequently be the second half of the first half. So that means only 12 bars to write instead of 16.

When you think the entire tune is done, put it aside for a day or so, then come back to it and see if it sounds right. Change any bits you aren't happy with and there's your tune! A tape recorder is a useful tool during this process.

Just changing a few parts of an existing tune isn't a good option. Infringing copyright can be costly. Go for an original tune every time. When you have learnt to play your masterpiece take it to a session and play it. If people join in straight away, you may have written someone elses tune.
So back to the drawing board.

You're then at the point where you need to start learning how to write it down in some form. So it's time to learn the written form. Just like learning the box, one thing follows another. Just enjoy it.

Nigel
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Stiamh on February 23, 2010, 01:15:43 PM
How much music theory do you think was known to most of the people who fashioned the great traditional music we play?

Anyway, get away from the idea that tunes are "written". They are composed - which, translated into plain English, means made up.

I've made up a good few over the years and they fall into two groups: those that I work out on an instrument, and those that come to me while I'm doing something else, like walking somewhere or having a shower, and which I work on by singing or humming.  [Edit: like Steve_FR above!]

The former are usually trickier to play and may have some ideas in them that I think are rather clever, and I enjoy playing them. But the ones that catch on and are played by others nearly all fall into the second category!

Who remembers The Old Grey Whistle Test music show? The expression came from tin pan alley, I believe. When you'd composed a tune, you played it to the mature lady who cleaned the building. If she could whistle it back to you, you might have a hit. If she couldn't, forget it!
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: TomB-R on February 23, 2010, 01:31:42 PM
If "your" tune comes easily, chances are it is from unconscious memory rather than original.

Play it to a few friends, they may well say, "sounds like a version of..."

It should have a "hook" something distinctive and memorable. 

There are loads of "patchwork" tunes around that people claim to have written that are just stock phrases from other tunes stuck together.

If people say "that's great" then question their motivation. Do they want you to play "their" tune!

Tune writing should not be encouraged, then hopefully only the better ones will come through!

(Nothing in this post is to be taken too seriously!)  ::)
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Theo on February 23, 2010, 01:32:27 PM

Just to proove my point this was 2 attempts on concertina....just sounds dreadfull


Yet again I have to disagree with your low opinion of your music making!    There are plenty of good ideas there that you can work on and you might end up with more than one tune.  I would describe what you have there as a musical notebook, which includes plenty of material that you can work on and develop.   Some suggestions to bear in mind during the editing:


The final irony of making your own tunes is that once they are written you still have to learn to play them!
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on February 23, 2010, 02:17:01 PM
Is one type easier than another? e.g. is a waltz easier than a jig or vice versa?


Yet again I have to disagree with your low opinion of your music making!    There are plenty of good ideas there that you can work on and you might end up with more than one tune.  I would describe what you have there as a musical notebook, which includes plenty of material that you can work on and develop.   Some suggestions to bear in mind during the editing:

  • decide on a time signature. Clip one sounds to me as if its wants to be in 3/4 but it could become 4/4 if you want.  
  • consider using more repetition, most trad tunes have lots of repetition
  • don't be afraid to throw out some bits, so you simplify the tune and pare it down to the pure essence

The final irony of making your own tunes is that once they are written you still have to learn to play them!

I've forgotten what buttons I used and I can't play by ear...so that's the end of that. Back to the drawing board.
Now you see why I'm drawn to the cut n paste approach to get the basic structure before tweaking is into unrecognizeability (bit like fractal art using scripts).

Is there a 'template' for each type I could use as a starting point?
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Anahata on February 23, 2010, 02:47:04 PM
I had a go at writing tunes very infrequently many years ago, and the results weren't good.
Then recently I started again, under a certain amount of pressure from Pig Dyke Molly, whose previous main musician wrote all his own tunes, and found it a lot easier. I'd also read a few thoughts about tune writing that gave me some ideas.
Things that helped:

I now have 4 of my own tunes in regular use with Pig Dyke Molly - the most successful has been "Pig Flu Blues" - some kind person's made a YouTube video (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RKcbacB12rk) of it. Signs of a misspent youth playing piano rags and listening to old blues heroes...

Anahata

Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on February 23, 2010, 03:34:44 PM
Having to produce a tune of a particular type (rhythm, speed, length) to order. Limitations like that concentrate the mind wonderfully. You could decide to restrict it to a range of notes, or not have an F# anywhere in it, or whatever...

Well I did have some criteria in mind. No more than 5 different buttons used (so I don't have to move my hand around). No cross rowing needed to play it. And some thing a beginner wouldn't find impossible. I'd also like it to be a 6/8 because I hate 3/4.

I suppose simple tunes like that are all taken by now.
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Anahata on February 23, 2010, 04:17:47 PM
Well I did have some criteria in mind. No more than 5 different buttons used (so I don't have to move my hand around). No cross rowing needed to play it. And some thing a beginner wouldn't find impossible.
Well there's a challenge for us all!
Quote
I'd also like it to be a 6/8 because I hate 3/4.
What about 4/4?
Quote
I suppose simple tunes like that are all taken by now.
"The composer Schoenberg once remarked that there are 'still many good tunes to be written in C major'..."

Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on February 23, 2010, 04:26:32 PM
Quote
I'd also like it to be a 6/8 because I hate 3/4.
What about 4/4?
I find it hard to tell if something is 4/4 so I wouldn't want to try writing a tune in it if I hadn't even got the remotest chance of telling if I was going wrong.

Plus I enjoy playing jigs somehow my fingers seem to like playing the basses that way. ;)
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 23, 2010, 07:52:45 PM
Quote
I'd also like it to be a 6/8 because I hate 3/4.
What about 4/4?

I suspect the correct compromise might be 4½/4  >:E  

http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=7555
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=7556

Absolutely nothing wrong with either of these. True to the key in use, (mostly) nicely on the beat, and some interesting phrasing. The John Cage quote on the second one was also entertaining ...
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: oompahman on February 23, 2010, 09:37:24 PM
I sometimes find myself picking up the box with no particular tune to learn.So i start doodling around using the sounds & styles i like(e.g.Bob Cann or Dan Quinn).The hard bit is not turning your efforts into a clone of someone elses tunes.If i feel i've ended up with something original i record it for future practise(or amendment.All this is mainly for my own amusement-don't usually play them out in sessions.
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: GbH on February 24, 2010, 01:00:40 AM
How much music theory do you think was known to most of the people who fashioned the great traditional music we play?

Possibly not much formal theory, but I bet they had a great practical knowledge, learnt from experience and instinct. 
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: xgx on February 24, 2010, 01:17:21 AM
Had a friend who wrote a tune.... the resemblance to 'Any Dream will Do' (ALW?) was striking.

It wasn't exactly the same but close enough for a numpty who can't hold a tune for longer than a Goldfish (me) to recognise  ;)

Look to bagpipe music... despite the limitations of only 9 notes, new tunes proliferate at a rate to shame Rats and Rabbits  ;D
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Stiamh on February 24, 2010, 02:44:34 AM
How much music theory do you think was known to most of the people who fashioned the great traditional music we play?

Possibly not much formal theory, but I bet they had a great practical knowledge, learnt from experience and instinct.  

Exactly. I was trying to reassure Sarah though  ;)
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on February 24, 2010, 08:56:41 AM
Well I did have some criteria in mind. No more than 5 different buttons used (so I don't have to move my hand around). No cross rowing needed to play it. And some thing a beginner wouldn't find impossible.
Well there's a challenge for us all!
Go on Anahata, take on the challenge. :)

The John Cage quote on the second one was also entertaining ...
the what? Where? who's he?

I sometimes find myself picking up the box with no particular tune to learn.If i feel i've ended up with something original i record it for future practise(or amendment.All this is mainly for my own amusement-don't usually play them out in sessions.
You should put some of your recordings up here Mike.


Okay people....I have a title at least....and as its descriptive gives me something to fit the tune to.
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Sandy on February 24, 2010, 09:42:23 AM

The John Cage quote on the second one was also entertaining ...
the what? Where? who's he?


Okay people....I have a title at least....and as its descriptive gives me something to fit the tune to.


Didn't John Cage shut close and open the piano lid to indicate the start of the second movement !!

Titles are great. They make me want to listen to tunes. I just had to learn Herbert the Sherbert based on the title. It's a fantastic tune too. (Thank you Martin)

I have written two tunes on the box which have come about by 'doodling' . I'm hoping to write a third one soon called
'Sunday Trousers MacKenzie'.  Goodness knows what that will bring ? Hopefully a bit of fun.  (:)

Cheers

Sandy
 (:)

Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Nick Hudis on February 24, 2010, 11:13:55 AM
While you definitely don't need any theory knowledge, a bit of structure helps. So if you feel confident to count the number of bars you are playing, try this.

Many tunes have an A part of 8 bars and a B part of eight bars.  As Theo said there can be a lot of repetition.  So you cna play around with something like this.

1.  Find a pattern you like that fits into two bars. (eg 4/4 dum dum diddle diddle dum dum dum)

2. Find another pattern that seems to go follow pattern 1. (diddle diddle dum dum dum dum)

3. Repeat pattern 1 (dum dum diddle diddle dum dum dum)

4. find a new pattern thats a bit different to pattern 2. (diddle diddle diddle diddle  dum diddle dum)

Hey presto you have an 8 bar A part!

Do the same again but on higher notes and you have have a B part.

Instant tune!  Lots of trad tunes have a structure similar to this.

I play around with snatches of tune like this in my head humming or whistling all the time, its great fun.  I did once come up with a tune to sing the ballad "The laily worm and the mackrel of the sea" which was really good.  I performed it once then forgot the tune, so record anything that seems to work. Most of the tunes I make up are fun at the time but consigned to history.
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Anahata on February 24, 2010, 11:21:22 AM
No more than 5 different buttons used (so I don't have to move my hand around). No cross rowing needed to play it. And some thing a beginner wouldn't find impossible.
Go on Anahata, take on the challenge. :)
Actually I came up with something last night that fits your requirements, an adaptation of something I wrote before.
I even titled it "The Essex Girl" in your honour ;D
...but I thought the whole idea was *you* wanted to write something. (:)
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on February 24, 2010, 11:33:50 AM

Instant tune!  Lots of trad tunes have a structure similar to this.

thanks for the tips.

No more than 5 different buttons used (so I don't have to move my hand around). No cross rowing needed to play it. And some thing a beginner wouldn't find impossible.
Go on Anahata, take on the challenge. :)
Actually I came up with something last night that fits your requirements, an adaptation of something I wrote before.
I even titled it "The Essex Girl" in your honour ;D
...but I thought the whole idea was *you* wanted to write something. (:)

I'm honored. :)

Oooh...Can't wait to hear it.

My subconcious is working on a tune as we speak. ;)
Already decided on the first and last bar.... :|glug

Actually I dreamt a really good tune...but when I woke up couldn't remember it. :(
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: baz parkes on February 24, 2010, 12:06:25 PM
["The composer Schoenberg once remarked that there are 'still many good tunes to be written in C major'..."

I didn't realise he was East Anglian (:)

Baz
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: TomB-R on February 24, 2010, 02:25:09 PM
["The composer Schoenberg once remarked that there are 'still many good tunes to be written in C major'..."

I didn't realise he was East Anglian (:)

Baz
Some of the Germanic tribes stayed at home, others invaded Britain and settled in East Anglia!!!
 ;D
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: LJC on February 24, 2010, 02:31:17 PM
I suspect the correct compromise might be 4½/4  >:E  

1/4 = 2/8 so isn't (4 1/2)/4 just 9/8? (and i.e a slip jig?)  ::) ::) ::)
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on February 24, 2010, 02:40:57 PM
I suspect the correct compromise might be 4½/4  >:E  

1/4 = 2/8 so isn't (4 1/2)/4 just 9/8? (and i.e a slip jig?)  ::) ::) ::)

[found slumped over desk after brain implodes]*thud*[/found slumped over desk after brain implodes]
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Anahata on February 24, 2010, 03:10:44 PM
1/4 = 2/8 so isn't (4 1/2)/4 just 9/8? (and i.e a slip jig?)  ::) ::) ::)

More like Dave Brubeck's Blue Rondo a la Turk
9/8 : yes. Slip jig : no. It's (2+2+2+3)/8 mostly, then (3+3+3)/8 every 4th bar.

X:0
T: Blue Rondo a La Turk
C: Dave Brubeck
M:9/8
K:F
AF AF AF EFG | AF AF AF BAG | AF AF AF EFG | FGA GAB ABc |
cA cA cA ^GA=B | cA cA cA dc=B |

etc...
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Bob Ellis on February 24, 2010, 04:15:32 PM
What a wonderful webforum this is!

I was happily minding my own business and getting on with a bit of work when I thought: "I'll have a break and see what is happenng on melodeon.net". I stumbled on this thread, became infected and have spent the whole afternoon writing two tunes - the first ones I have ever written! I had no intention of writing any tunes when I sat down at the computer and now I have written two, for which contributors to this thread are entirely to blame!  :o

Listening to Personal Composer playing midi files of them, I liked the sound of both tunes, so I have christened one of them Gayle Beck because it was inspred by the sound of water flowing over rapids and waterfalls in the beck in my village. The other is called Farewell to Ambleside because the first two parts reflect the sadness and uncertainty I felt when leaving Ambleside after living there for several years and the third part reflects the joy of return home to our Wensleydale roots.

Now, when is this "Tunes Wot I Wrote" theme taking place which will give me a legitimate reason for inflicting them onto a public who will doubtless wince at their lack of musicality?
...and what excuse can I give to my publisher for missing my latest deadline?
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on February 24, 2010, 04:38:02 PM
What a wonderful webforum this is!

I was happily minding my own business and getting on with a bit of work when I thought: "I'll have a break and see what is happening on melodeon.net". I stumbled on this thread, became infected and have spent the whole afternoon writing two tunes - the first ones I have ever written! I had no intention of writing any tunes when I sat down at the computer and now I have written two, for which contributors to this thread are entirely to blame!  :o

Have I started something again? ;) :P
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Pete Dunk on February 24, 2010, 04:41:17 PM
...and what excuse can I give to my publisher for missing my latest deadline?

Just give him the tunes and tell him to publish 'em!
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on February 25, 2010, 09:01:49 AM
Okay...I erm went a bit mad and composed away (with the help of a demo program).
Got 3 that have sound and image but one that's just written down as I forgot to record it before I closed the program. I would be apprecitive to anyone who can convert to ABC, or offer any advice or critique.
First is a waltz (thanks to Nigel for getting me started with that) its in C coz its for the 'tina.

A Lady Of Our Time
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v28/imbored22001/LOTtunewltz.jpg)

Next is Lady D's Jig (which conforms to criteria)
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=14915

Then I tried a 4/4 tune....
Promenade the pier
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=14914

Then my fave result
A minor idea (a minor suprise)
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=14916

Comments welcome. Actually if you want to play them your welcome.
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 25, 2010, 09:11:27 AM
Well done Sarah!
I like Promenade the Pier especially - it has a sort of dreamy strolling quality to it. I can imagine you walking lazily along Southend pier in a long frock with a parasol in the sunshine on a warm summer morning.

You've got to learn to play it now!

Edited to add:
I particularly like the way the B-music compliments the A-music. The B-music takes the tune to it's next level, a sort of answer to the question posed by the A-music. Returning to the A-music for a second time through the tune is a pleasure. The whole tune is dreamingly endless. It could go round and round for ever.
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on February 25, 2010, 09:32:47 AM
Well done Sarah!
I like Promenade the Pier especially - it has a sort of dreamy strolling quality to it. I can imagine you walking lazily along Southend pier in a long frock with a parasol in the sunshine on a warm summer morning.

You've got to learn to play it now!

Edited to add:
I particularly like the way the B-music compliments the A-music. The B-music takes the tune to it's next level, a sort of answer to the question posed by the A-music. Returning to the A-music for a second time through the tune is a pleasure. The whole tune is dreamingly endless. It could round and round for ever.

Its funny that tune all came from a bar in a hymn that I really liked and wanted to get that dramatic 'lift' without copying it...took a lot of tweaking and effort to achevie it....which is why I got lazy copy n pasted the first 8 bars and just tweaked that which is what must have made it more Q&A.

Annoyingly I wrote it in D so have got to write the button numbers down to learn it. lol!

Are you gonna have a go at it steve? Would love to hear different interpretations.

As for strolling down the pier on a sunny day....I only go down in the spring, autumn and winter to avoid the tourists.  lol!

Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Anahata on February 25, 2010, 11:35:36 AM
Okay...I erm went a bit mad and composed away

Blimey, you don't hang about, do you  (:)
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: juker on February 25, 2010, 12:14:25 PM
Fantastic Sarah! You are an inspiration (:)
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Pete Dunk on February 25, 2010, 12:26:38 PM
I would be apprecitive to anyone who can convert to ABC, or offer any advice or critique.
First is a waltz (thanks to Nigel for getting me started with that) its in C coz its for the 'tina.

A Lady Of Our Time
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v28/imbored22001/LOTtunewltz.jpg)

X:25
T: Lady of Our Time, A
C: LdT
R: Waltz
Q: 1/4=140
L: 1/4
M: 3/4
K: C
c/d/ e c | f d2 | B/c/ d d | e c2 |
c/d/ e e | f d2 | B/A/ G/A/ B/d/ | e c2 |
c/d/ e e | f d2 | B/c/ d d | e c2 |
c/d/ e e | f d2 | B/c/ d/A/ G/F/ | e c2 |
A/c/ e e | c e2 | d/e/ f f | d e2 |
c/d/ e c | c d2 | B/c/ d/B/ A/B/ | e c2 |
c/e/ g g | c d2 | d/e/ d2 c/ z/ | d e2 |
c/d/ e e | c d2 | B/c/ d/B/ A/F/ | e c2 ||

 ;D
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Falseknight on February 25, 2010, 01:05:53 PM
I suspect the correct compromise might be 4½/4  >:E  

1/4 = 2/8 so isn't (4 1/2)/4 just 9/8? (and i.e a slip jig?)  ::) ::) ::)

No!

6/8 implies 2 groups of three (tripletted quavers, a march: the Irish march in 6/8 - try marching to 'Lark In The Morning' etc. and see how fast you go). 9/8 implies three groups of three - like a tripletted waltz.
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Anahata on February 25, 2010, 02:03:11 PM
Actually I came up with something last night that fits your requirements
Oooh...Can't wait to hear it.
Well, at great inconvenience because I'm at work and this involved shuffling files about on my PC at home by remote control... well, never mind all that, here's the dots.

We've just sent this to Annie Dearman who's celebrating a significant birthday around now (think bus pass, don't tell her I told you...) and she's also from Essex, so accidentally lucky choice of title...

Get the last two bars of line 3 and beginning of line 4 right, and the rest is easy... MP3 or video will be available some time soon if needed.
(http://www.treewind.co.uk/melnet/essexgirl600.png)
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Owen Woods on February 25, 2010, 02:22:48 PM
I could write a tune today instead of working (:) Good idea! :P
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Sandy on February 25, 2010, 02:30:28 PM
Well done LDT,

Wow, I thought I was doing well with a tune a year. That's amazing. Maybe the D in LDT is 'dynamic'  :D

cheers
Sandy
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on February 25, 2010, 02:34:48 PM

Well, at great inconvenience because I'm at work and this involved shuffling files about on my PC at home by remote control... well, never mind all that, here's the dots.

We've just sent this to Annie Dearman who's celebrating a significant birthday around now (think bus pass, don't tell her I told you...) and she's also from Essex, so accidentally lucky choice of title...

Get the last two bars of line 3 and beginning of line 4 right, and the rest is easy... MP3 or video will be available some time soon if needed.

Cool. Thanks.
Wish I had a buss pass. I hate being young coz you have to be 'responsible'.


I could write a tune today instead of working (:) Good idea! :P
I am sooooo bored with work..there's plenty to do but I'd rather be doing something else.

Well done LDT,

Wow, I thought I was doing well with a tune a year. That's amazing. Maybe the D in LDT is 'dynamic'  :D

Thanks...although I think with me its quantity over quality. ::)
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Stiamh on February 25, 2010, 03:10:50 PM
Things that helped:
  • Having to produce a tune of a particular type (rhythm, speed, length) to order. Limitations like that concentrate the mind wonderfully. You could decide to restrict it to a range of notes, or not have an F# anywhere in it, or whatever...
  • Taking a musical style that you'd like to emulate and trying to copy it (you won't exactly succeed, but the attempt produces a lot of creativity)

Good points, those. Tchaikovsky was apparently frequently given insanely precise and restrictive instructions by his choreographer  - x bars of this type of music with this type of tempo and mood leading into x bars of the other - and came up with the sublime ballet music we all know and love in response.

More recent example - closer to home for me: 12-suites for one-handed tin whistle (http://www.rogermillington.com/jeanduval/homeen.html) composed by my good friend Jean Duval. As a challenge (inspired by Packie Byrne) and to amuse himself on long drives to and from work every day (with one hand on the wheel and the other on the whistle) he came up with an astonishing variety of really good tunes in different keys and styles, with (most of the time) a gap of two consecutive whole tones in the middle of the scale. Mind you, he is what I would call a composer, as opposed to someone who comes up with a halfway decent tune about every five years or so (that's more my profile).

Quote
  • Big insight for me: a whole tune doesn't come into your head all at once. You try things out, pull it apart, put it back together in a different order, find answering phrases to fit what you already have, discard stuff because it "doesn't work" and also be prepared for it to go off in a totally unexpected direction.

Agree about the whole tune not coming into your head at once - usually I find there's a need for a considerable period of work and refinement, sometimes very considerable, and sometimes I end up scrapping the whole venture.

On a few happy occasions though I've been lucky enough to have the opposite experience, when it really feels that a good tune has come to you, needing only tiny adjustments, dropping straight out of the sky as it were, rather than your having done anything towards composing it. Then there's always the worry that it must be an existing tune (as mentioned by Tom earlier) but so far - touch wood - this hasn't happened to me. These little windfalls definitely don't happen to order though >:(
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: LJC on February 25, 2010, 07:31:53 PM
I suspect the correct compromise might be 4½/4  >:E  

1/4 = 2/8 so isn't (4 1/2)/4 just 9/8? (and i.e a slip jig?)  ::) ::) ::)

No!

6/8 implies 2 groups of three (tripletted quavers, a march: the Irish march in 6/8 - try marching to 'Lark In The Morning' etc. and see how fast you go). 9/8 implies three groups of three - like a tripletted waltz.

I was just being facetious with the maths of an impossible time signature, and am well aware of 6/8 and 9/8 - ignore!  ;D
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on February 25, 2010, 11:25:24 PM
And I thought it was 41/2/4 = 5.125!  >:E
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 26, 2010, 12:04:24 AM
I suspect the correct compromise might be 4½/4  >:E 

1/4 = 2/8 so isn't (4 1/2)/4 just 9/8? (and i.e a slip jig?)  ::) ::) ::)

No!

6/8 implies 2 groups of three (tripletted quavers, a march: the Irish march in 6/8 - try marching to 'Lark In The Morning' etc. and see how fast you go). 9/8 implies three groups of three - like a tripletted waltz.

I was just being facetious with the maths of an impossible time signature, and am well aware of 6/8 and 9/8 - ignore!  ;D
Actually, a time signature of 4½/4  isn't as daft as it sounds. In Melodeons at Witney 2004, Tim van Eyken taught us a Swedish polska which, although notated with a 9/8 time signature, was nothing like a slip jig at all (1-and-a 2-and-a 3-and-a)
Instead, the pulse of the tune was 1-and 2-and 3-and 4-and-a  - in other words 4½/4.

In 'classical' music (I use the term loosely, meaning not traditional music), especially orchestral music, where the time signature is non-symmetrical e.g. 5/4, 5/8, 7/8, etc., the conductor will often beat a slow lop-sided pulse. An example is in the last movement of Shostakovitch's 2nd piano concerto, where there is a section written in 7/8. The fast rhythm of the music goes diddle-diddle-um diddle-um dum dum, but the conductor will beat a lop-sided 3 like this:  1, 2, 3-and, where the beats correspond to the underlined parts of the fast rhythm. In other words the time signature of this section of the music is more akin to 3½/4 rather than 7/8. It makes much more musical sense.
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Anahata on February 26, 2010, 01:27:17 AM
Actually, a time signature of 4½/4  isn't as daft as it sounds. In Melodeons at Witney 2004, Tim van Eyken taught us a Swedish polska which, although notated with a 9/8 time signature, was nothing like a slip jig at all (1-and-a 2-and-a 3-and-a)
Instead, the pulse of the tune was 1-and 2-and 3-and 4-and-a  - in other words 4½/4.

Exactly the same as Dave Brubeck's Blue Rondo A La Turk which I posted about earlier.
All those Bulgaruian and Macedonian tunes in strange time signatures like 11/8 are actually made up of a much smaller number of beats which they call long and short beats, corresponding to 3 and 2 quavers respectively. So a Gankino Horo in 11/8 is really 5 beats: | short short long short short | per bar which you still have to get used to but it's always the same pattern all the way through the dance and tune so it's not all that hard.

Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 26, 2010, 08:23:47 AM
Actually, a time signature of 4½/4  isn't as daft as it sounds. In Melodeons at Witney 2004, Tim van Eyken taught us a Swedish polska which, although notated with a 9/8 time signature, was nothing like a slip jig at all (1-and-a 2-and-a 3-and-a)
Instead, the pulse of the tune was 1-and 2-and 3-and 4-and-a  - in other words 4½/4.

Exactly the same as Dave Brubeck's Blue Rondo A La Turk which I posted about earlier.
All those Bulgaruian and Macedonian tunes in strange time signatures like 11/8 are actually made up of a much smaller number of beats which they call long and short beats, corresponding to 3 and 2 quavers respectively. So a Gankino Horo in 11/8 is really 5 beats: | short short long short short | per bar which you still have to get used to but it's always the same pattern all the way through the dance and tune so it's not all that hard.


Yes - that's it, Anahata. I'm always fascinated by irregular time signatures and rhythmic pulses. I go out of my way to seek them out, and as you say once you get the idea of the patterns they are not that hard at all and can feel quite natural.

As a general observation, we do seem to be so conditioned and constrained by 'ordinary' time signatures, so much so that we get tripped up when something apparently a little more complex comes along. In my orchestra there are still players (professional music teachers, some of them) who are freaked out when a 5/8 or 7/8 time signature appears in front of them.  :|bl
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Anahata on February 26, 2010, 12:08:55 PM
Yes - that's it, Anahata. I'm always fascinated by irregular time signatures and rhythmic pulses. I go out of my way to seek them out

In that case, Linsey Pollak's Macedonian Folk Music (http://www.linseypollak.com/publications.html) (the red one) is recommended for hours of instructive and challenging fun. The accompanying CD is nice too but you won't find a single melodeon on it.
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: strad on February 26, 2010, 12:12:25 PM
I've written a couple of 5/4 tunes in the past. It's a pleasure to see the look on the faces of guitar, bodhran, bass players when they try to play along.

Here's one of them:
X:366
T:The Estonian Fiddler
R:Reel
C:Nigel Hallett
M:5/4
L:1/8
K:G
GABc d2 c>A f2|cAFA cA G>B D2|GABc d2 c>A f2|cAFA c>A G2 G2:|
c<eAc e2 d>B G2|cA-Af af g>d B2|c<eAc e2 d>B G2|cAFA c>A G2 G2:|
K:G Dor
Bd-dB GB A>^F D2|Ac-cA ^FA G>B d2|Bd-dB GB A>^F D2|AccA ^F>D G2 G2:|

Have fun
Nigel

Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Anahata on February 26, 2010, 12:51:42 PM
T:The Estonian Fiddler
Have fun
Ooh - I will - that looks nice (just staring at ABC rendered into dots on the screen now, looks promising)
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on February 26, 2010, 01:18:57 PM
Okay...now this is going to sound really wierd but I see tunes as shapes. And my problem is I have a shape in my head but I can't get what I play to represent that.
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v28/imbored22001/notes/tune.jpg)
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Anahata on February 26, 2010, 02:43:41 PM
And my problem is I have a shape in my head but I can't get what I play to represent that.

Well, it's got to be 8 bars in 6/8 time (:)
(and your post crossed with mine in another thread)

I hear the A music of "Tafarn Y Wheatsheaf" (Welsh for "The Wheatsheaf" Pub):
X: 0
T: The Wheatsheaf
Z: Anahata <anahata@treewind.co.uk>
B: LLewelyn Alaw Pocket Book ed. Robin Huw Bowen
O: Wales
M: 6/8
K: G
gfg d2B | cde d3 | cac BgB | Adc BAG |
gfg d2B | cde d3 | caf gdB | cAF G3 :|
BAB GAB | cBc ABc | Bdc BAG | FDE FGA |
BAB GAB | cAF DEC | B,CD EFG |1 AGF G3 :|2 ABc def ||
(http://www.treewind.co.uk/melnet/wheatsheaf.png)
http://www.treewind.co.uk/melnet/wheatsheaf.png (http://www.treewind.co.uk/melnet/wheatsheaf.png)
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Anahata on February 26, 2010, 04:43:39 PM
(1)
I promised I'd upload a performance of The Essex Girl so here it is on a 1 row in C (I think it suits that box well) - http://www.treewind.co.uk/melnet/essexgirl.mp3 (http://www.treewind.co.uk/melnet/essexgirl.mp3) (MP3, sound only)

(2)
That "Estonian Fiddler" tune in 5/4 is an absolute cracker! Thanks for that and I'm totally learning it. Apart from the time signature, going in to G minor for the last section on a D/G melodeon will score a lot of "surprise factor" points when I toss it into our local session ;D ;D
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on May 03, 2010, 12:08:55 PM
Just attempted to write a tune....erm...without writing it down.
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=19894
oh it sorta has words too...well a chorus
"its a grey and stormy day today, that's why I can't go out and play...."
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Anahata on May 03, 2010, 06:53:35 PM
Just attempted to write a tune....erm...without writing it down.
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=19894

That is gorgeous and going to get written down here even if you don't do so, and learnt.
Just the right mixture of familiar structure and nice surprises!
You've struck oil this time  :|glug :|glug :|glug
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on May 03, 2010, 07:07:35 PM
Just attempted to write a tune....erm...without writing it down.
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=19894

That is gorgeous and going to get written down here even if you don't do so, and learnt.
Just the right mixture of familiar structure and nice surprises!
You've struck oil this time  :|glug :|glug :|glug

ooh, thank you. Glad you like it. Anyone is welcome to have a bash at it. :)

It sorta came to me by accident I was playing bear dance and my sister asked me a question I lost concentration and that riff came out...and I thought 'I like that'. And it went from there.
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 04, 2010, 03:25:34 PM
I've made a transcription of Sarah's tune in ABC and as a PDF and sent them to her via private e-mail. But it's up to Sarah to say whether she wants it to be posted on here.
I think the tune sounds good if you play the A-music again to finish.  
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on May 04, 2010, 03:28:34 PM
I've made a transcription of Sarah's tune in ABC and as a PDF and sent them to her via private e-mail. But it's up to Sarah to say whether she wants it to be posted on here.
I think the tune sounds good if you play the A-music again to finish.  
Just got your email.

Thanks for doing that for me. :)

the tune is here (posted it in seperate thread so it didn't get 'lost')
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3983.0.html
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on May 04, 2010, 10:59:19 PM
She might not admit to knowing more than two chords, but she sure can write a tune!   :|||:
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on May 05, 2010, 09:22:08 AM
She might not admit to knowing more than two chords, but she sure can write a tune!   :|||:
You having a go at playing it next then? Any instrument welcome...

When I said I hadn't written it down....well I sorta had...well button numbers grouped by phrase with a dot above the button to put the umph on. At least for the A part....the b part was a bit ore improv. lol!
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on May 05, 2010, 09:26:37 PM
I pulled off the abc and will try something from that (but not at this time of night!) Thanks Sarah.

Chris.
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: ladydetemps on May 06, 2010, 09:59:04 AM
I might have a bash at it on concertina tonight...see how it turns out.
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: oggiesnr on May 31, 2010, 11:02:33 PM
My first effort at a tune (and writing in ABC).  The tune title is a bit of an in-joke. Mr MacIllivray's leg was saved by maggot therapy earlier this year, as he had already lost his other leg (diabetes) I wanted a stately dance tune  (:)

X:1
T:Mr MacGillivray's Maggot
M:3/4
L:1/4
K:G
| : g2d | B>AG | EFG | DEF | G>AB | c>de | d>cB | A3 |
g2d | B>AG | EFG | DEF | G>AB | c>de | dcA | G3 :|
|: gbg | fef | e>ge | dBG | c>de/>c/ | dBG | dcB | A3 |
gbg | fef | e>ge | dBG | c>de/4c/4e/4c/4 | dBG | d>cB | G3 :|


This is as near as I can get it. I know it's simple but I enjoyed the proccess.

Steve
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: Anahata on May 31, 2010, 11:20:03 PM
T:Mr MacGillivray's Maggot

Very nice (just looking at the dots, not tried actually playing but can hear in my head)
Quote
I wanted a stately dance tune  (:)
Yes, I was tempted to imagine a 6/8 morris tune, especially as the A music is a bit like John Kirkpatrick's Hammersmith Flyover - but the semiquavers in the B music force a "stately" speed on the rest of the tune.

Sounds like there ought to be a Playford-style dance to go with it.
Title: Re: Writing tunes?
Post by: oggiesnr on May 31, 2010, 11:29:37 PM
Yes, I was tempted to imagine a 6/8 morris tune, especially as the A music is a bit like John Kirkpatrick's Hammersmith Flyover - but the semiquavers in the B music force a "stately" speed on the rest of the tune.

Sounds like there ought to be a Playford-style dance to go with it.


I haven't heard Hammersmith Flyover but I was also thinking in terms of Playford, sort of Newcastle or similar.

Steve
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal