Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: smiley on February 24, 2010, 09:45:55 PM

Title: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: smiley on February 24, 2010, 09:45:55 PM
I really like the size, feel & compact spacing of the r.h. buttons on my Baffett BPII D/G but now I want to get a 2.5 row box. There don't seem to be any 2.5 row boxes on Baffetti's website and there isn't a shop within cooee of where I live that stocks a range of 2.5 row boxes to try out, so I'm hoping some mel.netters might be able to help me out.

Can anyone suggest a 2.5 row box that would have a similar feel on the treble side to my Black Pearl? I'm considering the Saltarelle Pastourelle II but the two row (flat keyboard) Saltarelles I've played feel a bit unwieldy in comparison to my little Baffetti box. What boxes in general have other Black Pearl players found to have a similar playing feel?


Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: theSmoiler on February 24, 2010, 11:04:13 PM
Can anyone suggest a 2.5 row box that would have a similar feel on the treble side to my Black Pearl? I'm considering the Saltarelle Pastourelle II but the two row (flat keyboard) Saltarelles I've played feel a bit unwieldy in comparison to my little Baffetti box. What boxes in general have other Black Pearl players found to have a similar playing feel?


I've not tried a Black Pearl in a very long time - but I did sell my Saltarelle Connemara II 2 1/2 row to someone (on this Forum) who previously played one. And he loved the Salterelle.

The nearest 'chunky' feel to the Baffetti RH side is probably the Oakwoods or Excelsiors in my experience. I did once have a  2 1/2 row Oakwood, but it wasn't a light-weight... My own quest for a compact 2 1/2 row hasn't born fruit. I'm not sure if Verde don't do something in this line (Rees would know).

 Diane
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: nfldbox on February 24, 2010, 11:18:28 PM
"within cooee" I used to live in Australia and that certainly takes me back
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: Andy Simpson on February 24, 2010, 11:21:56 PM
Have you thought of the Saltarelle Cheviot?. It has the same number of buttons, (27), as the Connemara/Pastourelle II but across 3 rows, (10, 9, 8 ), and in a smaller box which would probably feel more like your Dino. I'm sure they can accommodate a layout of your choice.
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: Owen Woods on February 25, 2010, 01:21:59 AM
If you want a compact 2.5 row there's always the Lilliput or Presciosa.
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: old geezer on February 25, 2010, 08:14:04 AM
If you want a compact 2.5 row there's always the Lilliput or Presciosa.

I thought the Liliput was tuned to either Bb/Eb or C/F
(reed replacement maybe a problem, as these were made with a narrow reed plate)
( or are 14mm reed plates still available? where from please. )
 
I've read somewhere; the Bb/Eb could be re-tuned to D/G with a 4th button start,
I have not had the pleasure to have felt the 'feel' of a Baffetti
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: LJC on February 25, 2010, 08:28:58 AM
I've played a few Dino's including the BP and the other one they make which seems to be the defult Dino Morris box. The Saltarelles I've played are (in my opinion) much nicer boxes and I don't think you would be disappointed with a Pastourelle or Connamara. Changing up to any 2 1/2 row box is almost always going to feel bigger compared to a 2 row just because its accommodating more 'stuff'. Once you get used to it I wouldn't think there was much which would hold you back size wise.
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: smiley on February 25, 2010, 10:12:07 AM
If you want a compact 2.5 row there's always the Lilliput or Presciosa.

I'm afraid one of those compact boxes might look a bit funny perched on my beer gut - and you know how seriously we melodeonistas are about our appearance  ::)

The 3-row Saltarelle Cheviot is an interesting option that I hadn't considered ... a 19 button D/G with an extra inner row of 8 accidentals/reversals would be a fairly wild idea!

Any other comments from ex-Black Pearlers out there ...?
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: Owen Woods on February 25, 2010, 02:24:51 PM
I thought the Liliput was tuned to either Bb/Eb or C/F
(reed replacement maybe a problem, as these were made with a narrow reed plate)
( or are 14mm reed plates still available? where from please. )
 
I've read somewhere; the Bb/Eb could be re-tuned to D/G with a 4th button start,
I have not had the pleasure to have felt the 'feel' of a Baffetti

Yes, I have to admit that I have no played either the Baffetti or the Lilliput, so my contribution was probably superfluous. But if I was looking for a compact 2.5 row then I'd know where I'd look! Theo or whassisface (thread on him a while back) convert or have converted Lilliputs to D/G.
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: Huw on February 25, 2010, 03:27:16 PM
As someone who plays a Dino Black Pearl II as my favourite box after playing Castagnaris, Saltarelles and Hohners
I think you have a job to find anything that comes even close to the playability of the underrated Black Pearl.Good luck however
and if you do find something that compares let me know as I haven't been able to !!
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: Rob2Hook on February 25, 2010, 03:39:59 PM
I have to agree that the BP II is underrated.  My pride and joy is a Castagnari Trilly, but I still take the BP out regularly.  It's light and lively and can cut through most noise.  I've never found a 2?? row that's as lively, except an Oakwood, which struck me as light and responsive - albeit larger, of course.  I've tried a Pastourelle III and that felt a little cumbersome, maybe the Pastourelle II is the one?  Certianly Ed Rennie does rather well with it!

Rob.
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: Anahata on February 25, 2010, 03:59:44 PM
I've never found a 2+1/2; row that's as lively [as a Dino Baffetti], except an Oakwood, which struck me as light and responsive

I was going to say something very similar. I don't own a Baffetti but I've tried out several (2 rows) and they were a very tempting runner up when I got my Oakwood - nothing else had that nice heavy-but-bouncy feel to it. My Saltarelle Connemara III is a lovely sounding box but it's nothing like a Dino Baffetti or the Oakwood.
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: James Fitton on February 25, 2010, 04:56:21 PM
I play both a Baffetti BP and a Saltarelle Pastourelle. I'm very fond of both, but they feel nothing like each other. The Baffetti is perfect for driving out dance tunes, light and manoevrable with lots of oomph. The Saltarelle has a much subtler range of sounds - I tend to use it mostly for song accompaniment. I fear what you're looking for may be something of a contradiction in terms, but I'd be very interested to hear if anyone has experience of anything which suggests otherwise.
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: pete /acorn on February 25, 2010, 07:25:29 PM
Hi,
I've got a 2.5 row Oakwood and it weighs in at 4kg,  I am making a model similar which will be out later this year,should have been out now but got too involved with Manfrini accordions.
If you are near York you are welcome to try my Oakwood.

Pete

Sorry Dogbox,could be a bit far from Australia,just checked your profile
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: oggiesnr on February 25, 2010, 09:23:29 PM
I have a BP II, bought from Mally just after he started importing them (£550 which shows how long ago it was).  I keep looking to replace it and I've played hundreds of boxes since but there is always something missing.  I love the right hand of the Castagnaris but the left hand sounds...

If I had a huge budget and could afford a custom built then maybe I would find something, as it is I still regard the BP II as the best basic melodeon known to man.  (:)

Steve
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: old geezer on February 26, 2010, 06:04:08 AM
If you want a compact 2.5 row there's always the Lilliput or Presciosa.
I'm afraid one of those compact boxes might look a bit funny perched on my beer gut - and you know how seriously we melodeonistas are about our appearance  ::)

so; some blokes have a veranda over their t**l shed (it took me many years), we find a chair an' while our rear is on the seat, rest the treble end on either leg an' push the bellows an' buttons. I find that it doesn't wear the shirt and bellows tape quite as much, and don't forget the piece of pelt over the leg to save the trousers....
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: smiley on February 27, 2010, 03:14:11 AM
I found an old ad for a Pastourelle II at http://www.eaglemusicshop.com that says:

Quote
Pastourelle II D/G melodeon (As New) Used Melodeons)
A two and a half row, D/G melodeon made by Dino Baffetti in Italy for the French company Saltarelle in walnut casing.

Does anyone know if they're really made by Baffetti?
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: Andy Simpson on February 27, 2010, 03:33:43 AM
I found an old ad for a Pastourelle II at http://www.eaglemusicshop.com that says:

Quote
Pastourelle II D/G melodeon (As New) Used Melodeons)
A two and a half row, D/G melodeon made by Dino Baffetti in Italy for the French company Saltarelle in walnut casing.

Does anyone know if they're really made by Baffetti?

Yes, Saltarelle don't actually manufacture their own boxes, they contract Italian manufacturers to make their designs for them and in at least one example I can think of, slap their name on an existing model and charge a premium for it. I believe the Bouebe and now defunct Berry were originally sold in the UK as the Dino Baffetti Morris II and III respectively.

Unless I'm mistaken, I think all Saltarelles are now made by Baffetti.
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: Huw on February 28, 2010, 10:24:16 AM
Comparing my BPII with my Saltarelle Nuage couldn't be more different in many ways, but  strap brackets , bellows straps, bass strap adjuster and cases- make nice matching luggage !! all out of the same parts bin by the look of it. Just like the motor industry the badge on the front is just a marketing ploy and doesn't mean a thing.
Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: smiley on February 28, 2010, 09:26:06 PM

[/quote]
Unless I'm mistaken, I think all Saltarelles are now made by Baffetti.
[/quote]

... and another comforting certainty in my small world just got turned on its head :)

Title: Re: Looking for a 2.5 row box with a Baffetti 'feel'
Post by: David J on March 16, 2010, 01:38:25 PM
I've had a BPII for a year and I think it's brilliant for playing out with the morris, but the bass side is a bit heavy for sessions. The only thing I've found which has the same appeal and even better feel and also solves the bass issue is the 'Oakwood-ised' version that the Music Room sell, which has Binci reeds and 3rds and low bass stops if you want them. But it hasn't 2.5 rows or a low treble reed. If there were a Baffetti with that spec which weighed under 4kg Ii'd buy it today, but John at the Music Room says that, although they've asked, Baffetti won't make it, so the search goes on!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal