Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: press on regardless on March 04, 2010, 10:47:39 AM

Title: Help with keys please
Post by: press on regardless on March 04, 2010, 10:47:39 AM

In "Nick Barber's English Choice" TOTM "The Plane Tree" is written with G shown as the time signiture, but I think I am playing it in E minor.

This is also the case with "Bear Dance" in the same book, which I know I play in E minor, but again has G in the time signiture.

All the tutor books I have read point to the time signiture to show what key the tune is in, or have I missed something.  When and why does G become E minor?

Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: juker on March 04, 2010, 10:59:25 AM
.....dorian mode?
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: zubz on March 04, 2010, 11:05:03 AM
Every major key has a "relative minor" - that has the same key signature.
To work it out, start at the 1st note on the major scale (G in this example), go down 3 semi-tones, and that'll be the first note of the minor scale with the same key signature. So ... down 3 from G is F#, F, ... E. So E is the relative minor to G major.

For The Plane Tree it's E minor because it keeps coming back to the "root" - the main note - of E.

Hope that helps a wee bit.

Chris
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: Anahata on March 04, 2010, 11:26:47 AM
.....dorian mode?
Aeolian in this case, because the tune has C naturals in it.

A tune in E Dorian would also have a C#  in the key signature.
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: nemethmik on March 04, 2010, 12:03:22 PM
the G row of a melodeon, playing all the notes from G to the next G is the scale of G major, but playing the same notes from E to the next E is a scale of E minor. Among these notes is F#, all the others being 'natural'. Hence the F# key signature.
Therefore, the # key signature means "play the tune on the G-row and use the bottom bass buttons on the left side" and do not bother if it's G major, A dorian, D mixolydian or E aeolian.
 
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: Lester on March 04, 2010, 12:24:44 PM
the G row of a melodeon, playing all the notes from G to the next G is the scale of G major, but playing the same notes from E to the next E is a scale of E minor. Among these notes is F#, all the others being 'natural'. Hence the F# key signature.
Therefore, the # key signature means "play the tune on the G-row and use the bottom bass buttons on the left side" and do not bother if it's G major, A dorian, D mixolydian or E aeolian.
 

No! if the key sig is one sharp the tune may well be in G major, A dorian, D mixolydian or E aeolian but it really matters which row you play it on as to which basses are available.

So E minor is most often played mostly on the D row to make the Emin chord available in the right places.

Easiest rule for detemining which of the selection of keys a key signature refers too is to look at the tune's last note and it will mostly tell you the key. So Plane Tree in E Minor key sig 1 sharp but both A nd B parts end on an E.
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: nemethmik on March 04, 2010, 12:58:44 PM
the # key signature means "play the tune on the G-row and use the bottom bass buttons on the left side" and do not bother if it's G major, A dorian, D mixolydian or E aeolian.
No!
;)
Still, I am more and more convinced that my statement is basically true, kind of "rule of thumb".
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: Lester on March 04, 2010, 01:04:53 PM
the # key signature means "play the tune on the G-row and use the bottom bass buttons on the left side" and do not bother if it's G major, A dorian, D mixolydian or E aeolian.
No!
;)
Still, I am more and more convinced that my statement is basically true, kind of "rule of thumb".

As a rule melodeon players don't use their thumb except on the air button.   ;D
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: zubz on March 04, 2010, 01:07:25 PM
the # key signature means "play the tune on the G-row and use the bottom bass buttons on the left side" and do not bother if it's G major, A dorian, D mixolydian or E aeolian.
No!
;)
Still, I am more and more convinced that my statement is basically true, kind of "rule of thumb".

As a rule melodeon players don't use their thumb except on the air button.   ;D

... hot or cold?   >:E
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: Fidjit on March 04, 2010, 02:20:34 PM


As a rule melodeon players don't use their thumb except on the air button.   ;D

And on the nose. Right ? :|glug

The way these guys go on. All moody about their modes.

Did you understand any of that Paul ?

Yes it's Em mate. :|glug
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: LJC on March 04, 2010, 02:26:22 PM
If I were confused an was asking about this, I would now be way more confused with these answers!

To put it simply:

The key signature (in the case of G, one #) just indicates which of the notes are sharp or flat relative to C major. This combination of sharps or flats gives each key a unique group of notes and a unique sound.

Every key contains lots of different scales, with funny Greek names. You shouldn't really need to worry about this at the moment. The important thing to know is that the key of G major has what is called a 'relative minor'. This is another key which shares the same notes (and thus the same key signature) but it sounds totally different. In the case of G major, this is E minor.

You can always work out a relative minor by taking the note 3 semi tones lower than the starting note.

For example: The key of D major.

This is made up of 2 #'s (F# and C#). To find the relative minor to D major you count down three semi tones (the smallest gap between the notes) D C# C B. This lands you on a B meaning that the relative minor of D major is B minor.

Example 2: A major

Counting down three semi tones: A G# G F# lands you on an F# meaning that the relative minor of A major is F# minor. The keys are related and share the same notes, but sound completely different.

When is G, G. and E minor E minor? This really depends on the tune and you will probably be able to 'hear' the difference more easily than looking at it technically. Something in E minor is going to sound, well, minor. It will be darker and more menacing in feel than something in G major.

A tune in Em will also seem to stick around the E pull on button 3 of the D row where as a G major will often use the G push on button 3 of the G row. These are what are known as 'root notes'. A tune which feels like it has ended when you play a G note or chord will be in the key of G. A tune such as the Bear Dance which finishes on the E pull are in E minor.

(Post ended up a bit longer than anticipated, but I hope that's clear)

Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: zubz on March 04, 2010, 02:57:30 PM
If I were confused an was asking about this, I would now be way more confused with these answers!

To put it simply:

The important thing to know is that the key of G major has what is called a 'relative minor'. This is another key which shares the same notes (and thus the same key signature) but it sounds totally different. In the case of G major, this is E minor.

...

You can always work out a relative minor by taking the note 3 semi tones lower than the starting note.

When is G, G. and E minor E minor? This really depends on the tune and you will probably be able to 'hear' the difference more easily than looking at it technically. Something in E minor is going to sound, well, minor. It will be darker and more menacing in feel than something in G major.

(Post ended up a bit longer than anticipated, but I hope that's clear)



... sort of what I was trying to say in reply #3. but LJC gives more examples.

 :Ph
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: waldoB on March 04, 2010, 03:36:21 PM
Eric Taylor . ISBN 1-85472-446-0
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: nemethmik on March 04, 2010, 04:37:29 PM
To put it simply:
;)
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: Theo on March 04, 2010, 05:41:19 PM
Humph would have been proud of this thread!

Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: Pete Dunk on March 04, 2010, 06:45:08 PM
Humph would have been proud of this thread!

Bogart or Littleton?  :D
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: Theo on March 04, 2010, 06:54:23 PM
I'm sorry you haven't a clue - Littleton of course! :D
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: press on regardless on March 04, 2010, 07:07:17 PM

er...............................

well thanks people I'll make a few notes about all that then. Not necessarily in the right key though.

When I started to learn the melodeon I made a decision to concentrate on learning to do as much by ear as possible and keep musical theory to the minimum.

One of my better decisions.
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on March 04, 2010, 11:20:59 PM
Were we discussing the ex-Guards Officer-(etc) Humphrey Lyttelton?  :|glug
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: juker on March 05, 2010, 08:08:52 AM
.....dorian mode?

aargh! I was hoping that this shot in the dark would clear the issue up (for me) once and for all. Sadly it is not to be.
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 05, 2010, 09:19:50 AM
Very simple then

Take the box and play the scale on either row. To take D row purely as an example  Play on D row only push/pull

  D1  E2 F#3 G4 A5 B6 C#7 D

But you don't have to start your scale on D ..  There are seven choices. Explore these. They all have different 'colour' These are the classical Greek modes

Right - to answer your question - start your scale (D row only) on E (second mode)

 E1  F#2 G3 A4 B5 C#6 D7 E  (push/pull pattern changes)

This is classical Dorian. THe bottom half of the scale is minor, but top half is somehow more major and bright. Dorian accounts for about 75% of Western minor scale folk music.

So that's the basic concept. Work on dorian and improvise a bit.  Good chords are Em pull and D either way.   Get used to the feel of it. (Impro works better top end)



Now try the same on the G row. You start on A this time (second note ..)

Confusion arises because X dorian is named for it's start note, not the diatonic scale it came from. Once you have the concept of major scale and dorian solid - only then explore the other five.   :Ph
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: Fidjit on March 05, 2010, 11:38:41 AM
 :Ph
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: Falseknight on March 05, 2010, 11:42:03 AM
But doesn't everyone cross row E minor?
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: Lester on March 05, 2010, 01:10:34 PM
But doesn't everyone cross row E minor?

I have met people who quite happily play e minor tune up and down the G row with straight g basses because they didn't understand. Sounded awful  ::)
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: Steve_freereeder on March 05, 2010, 01:30:54 PM
Very simple then

Take the box and play the scale on either row. To take D row purely as an example  Play on D row only push/pull

  D1  E2 F#3 G4 A5 B6 C#7 D

But you don't have to start your scale on D ..  There are seven choices. Explore these. They all have different 'colur' These are the classical Greek modes

Right - to answer your question - start your scale (D row only) on E (second mode)

 E1  F#2 G3 A4 B5 C#6 D7 E  (push/pull pattern changes)

This is classical Dorian. THe bottom half of the scale is minor, but top half is somehow more major and bright. Dorian accounts for about 75% of Western minor scale folk music.

So that's the basic concept. Work on dorian and improvise a bit.  Good chords are Em pull and D either way.   Get used to the feel of it. (Impro works better top end)



Now try the same on the G row. You start on A this time (second note ..)

Confusion arises because X dorian is named for it's start note, not the diatonic scale it came from. Once you have the concept of major scale and dorian solid - only then explore the other five.   :Ph

Nice explanation, Chris.  (:)
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: press on regardless on March 05, 2010, 02:17:46 PM
But doesn't everyone cross row E minor?

I have met people who quite happily play e minor tune up and down the G row with straight g basses because they didn't understand. Sounded awful  ::)

yes,  but you don't have to understand if you just listen. That's one of the nicest things with a melodeon, just try different bass buttons in conjunction with the melody. As you've got to cross row  to get the low E anyway it is logical to use the D row basses then and that gives you a clue.  

Good tip earlier on in the thread about looking for the ending note in tunes with key sig of G but played in E minor.
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: juker on March 05, 2010, 03:06:53 PM
Very simple then

Take the box and play the scale on either row. To take D row purely as an example  Play on D row only push/pull

  D1  E2 F#3 G4 A5 B6 C#7 D

But you don't have to start your scale on D ..  There are seven choices. Explore these. They all have different 'colur' These are the classical Greek modes

Right - to answer your question - start your scale (D row only) on E (second mode)

 E1  F#2 G3 A4 B5 C#6 D7 E  (push/pull pattern changes)

This is classical Dorian. THe bottom half of the scale is minor, but top half is somehow more major and bright. Dorian accounts for about 75% of Western minor scale folk music.

So that's the basic concept. Work on dorian and improvise a bit.  Good chords are Em pull and D either way.   Get used to the feel of it. (Impro works better top end)



Now try the same on the G row. You start on A this time (second note ..)

Confusion arises because X dorian is named for it's start note, not the diatonic scale it came from. Once you have the concept of major scale and dorian solid - only then explore the other five.   :Ph


So is the answer that it is in fact in Dorian mode, not in E minor?
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: LJC on March 05, 2010, 03:11:38 PM
If you are referring to the Plane Tree, no. It is in E minor and not E dorian.

As Chris described, the notes in E dorian are E F# G A B C# D E. Plane Tree is written with one sharp indicating that it is in E minor, and every time the tune has a C note it is C natural not C#.
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: Stiamh on March 05, 2010, 03:41:07 PM
.....dorian mode?
aargh! I was hoping that this shot in the dark would clear the issue up (for me) once and for all. Sadly it is not to be.

Whenever the theory gets confusing, it's useful to approach the topic differently. You know, you probably understand the Dorian mode already at an intuitive level - that is, your ears can recognize the characteristic sound or feel of both Dorian and minor tunes and distinguish between them.

Having been away from English trad music I can't think of any examples from the English tradition, but you may be familiar with, to give a very well-known if not hackneyed example, the Irish tune, Morrison's Jig. If not you can surely find a billion renditions of it on the web. To me, this is a quintessentially Dorian mode tune. You'd probably tell your guitarist it was in E minor - but the C#s give the tune a wonderful open feeling that is addictive the first time you hear it, and a long way from the inward-looking mood of tunes in classical E minor.

Once you know and recognize that feeling, you can say, OK, it's down to the fact that the Cs are sharp where I/you/Tom Dick & Harry, with our western/classical/jazz/pop backgrounds, would expect them to be natural. And that's all there is to the Dorian mode. HTH!
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 05, 2010, 04:28:53 PM
So is the answer that it is in fact in Dorian mode, not in E minor?

There is no "E minor".   The concept just defines the notes E and G in the scale .. but there are five other notes, and some scales have six(or four in Blues)!  We folkies use "E minor" as a shorthand for the second position "dorian" mode of D-scale - more correctly called E dorian.

So yes it's Dorian, and in this forum it's also "E minor". Stop here if you want



The next most common takes it's notes from the G row, start 6th note thereof = Em with a 'natural' C. Technically "Aolian"  or "Neopolitan" minor.  Folkies call it 'modal' minor.  Steve above has termed it 'classical'.   

Theorists would say that Gnat, Cnat, Fnat and Dnat give 'minorness' to an E scale, in rough order of potency.   So there are plenty of others. eg a Hungarian csárdás player , or Spanish flamenco might even play on a 'minor' sounding scale with G# in it! So a complex area.

My advice would be to focus on Trad. 'Dorian' Em to start with.
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 05, 2010, 07:42:09 PM
what shall we do with the drunken sailor?  (rhetorical)

Make him write essays on the importance of the #4th in the improvised line, until he's sober.
Title: Re: Help with keys please
Post by: juker on March 05, 2010, 09:41:41 PM
'So yes it's Dorian, and in this forum it's also "E minor". Stop here if you want'
 :Ph Thanks, I will

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal