Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Lin Leighton on March 07, 2008, 10:21:07 AM

Title: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Lin Leighton on March 07, 2008, 10:21:07 AM
I guess everyone has been here and done this and bought the T shirt, but I just wondered if anyone had any tips to get over what happened last night.
Ive practised and practised a really easy tune at home to the nth degree so I could play it at a local session - its perfect, with basses and everything.  Im really happy about how it sounds and my playing.  So on the night I make a complete mess of it, Im nervous, I cant remember the tune, I get the sequence mixed up  etc etc.  I throw my beloved Tommy on the floor (not literally!!!! Steve) have a paddy and say Im not doing it anymore!!!!  now I'm among friends, so they all just laugh and say it will get easier, but as I thought to myself, Ive been doing this learning thing for about 4 years now, its time I got it better in public.
Any tips to get over nervousness greatfully accepted!!!!  :-\
Lin
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Theo on March 07, 2008, 10:46:22 AM
Hi Lin

I think we've all been there, I certainly have.  It does get better though.

Things I found helpful:

Get someone to listen to you play at home, that can put a surprising amount of pressure on even with the most supportive listener.  Then when you play out it not such a big step from playing alone.

At home play the same tune lots of times and try not to play it exactly the same each time,  just little variations eg playing long notes as two short ones, simplifying the tune by maybe just playing the first note of each bar, or just the notes on the main beats.  The point of this is to get away from just having one 'perfect' version that you have to remember. 

Find a playing buddy to practice with then play your tune together at the session

Enter a novices class at a competition.  It will be the most pressure you can play under.  It will probably go horribly wrong, but everything else will seem so relaxed and easy by comparison.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: george garside on March 07, 2008, 10:54:58 AM
I guess everyone has been here and done this and bought the T shirt, but I just wondered if anyone had any tips to get over what happened last night.
Ive practised and practised a really easy tune at home to the nth degree so I could play it at a local session - its perfect, with basses and everything.  Im really happy about how it sounds and my playing.  So on the night I make a complete mess of it, Im nervous, I cant remember the tune,  
Lin

Hi Lin

just a few random thought for what its worth

You don't say whether you were effectively playing a solo (as sometimes happens in a singaround/playaround type of happening) or whether in a session where somebody/everybody joins in)  In the join in stype of session the trick to get over nervousness is to pick tunes that you are absolutely sure a reasonbable number of others will join in, don't play to loud and if you are having a afit of nerves or just forget what comes next you can stop/ease off or whatever without anybody realising that they are following themselves rather than you!   you can then go in & out of the tune as necessary but in all probablility it wont be.

in a big(ish) session don't get into a musical fight if somebody with a loud instrument is effectively taking over, just let them get on with it & console yourself with the thought that is they who are lacking in good manners.

Another vital bit is to feel comfortable making a cock up - we all do it!  I was leading a very big session (about 150  players) at Sidmouth a few years ago - everybody was doing their stuff and at least a third were playing well -  exept me - I knew I was doing something badly wrong but it took quite a while before I realised that I was playing the melody in D but playing the bass to go with it in G - it sounded blody awful  but nobody realised exept me.

Doing a solo spot is  different  & nerves are the norm exept amongst the thick skinned !  If you lose it early on just stop - say oh dear or words to that effect & start again.  If you forget the B part  either repeat the A part or stick the A or B part of another tune on  as if that was what you intended doing.  If well into the tune don't stop but make a bit up on the hoof  with the right rhythm - you will probably get away with it.  

I find that either more or less closing my eyes or focusing on the far wall  helps inhindered concentration.

george
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Clive Williams on March 07, 2008, 11:07:14 AM
I guess everyone has been here and done this and bought the T shirt, but I just wondered if anyone had any tips to get over what happened last night.

Yep, been there. Got the T Shirt. Go out and try again - your friends are right, it gets easier the more you do it, and before long you'll be wondering what the fuss is. The best way to practice playing in public is, like it or not, to play in public. Rather like the best way to be able to play while drunk is to practice when you're drunk! We sometimes forget that everyone else at a session is so engrossed in their own performance that they've just done/are about to do that they won't care in the slightest if you make a mistake or stop in the middle of a tune, so don't worry about what people think... because 5 minutes later, they've forgotten!

Cheers,

Clive


Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Quebecois on March 07, 2008, 11:25:54 AM
Sometimes we worry more than the people who listen to us and even though we know we went wrong in a tune the listeners may have not noticed! I often start a tune and play the B part of another by mistake and then come back to the A and no one complain.

Don't be too hard on yourself, and most of all, enjoy playing!
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Lin Leighton on March 07, 2008, 11:26:32 AM
yep -- all good advice which I will try to act on -- thanks  ;D

George   the session is one where each person takes the lead, in turn around the room, so everyone gets the chance to play a tune they know (thats if they can remember it ha ha ), and everyone else joins in too, but the lead person is recognised as that and no takes over - theyre a great bunch of guys and have let me play right from the beginning of my career!  it was me who got upset with myself for getting it wrong AGAIN, but of course you are quite right Clive, I accept that people are more concerned with how they themselves sound, thats why I myself wanted myself to get it right ha ha.

Theo, you have touched a nerve there  ;)  I am currently thinking that my playing is very "samey", cos Im so busy learning all those dratted tunes I just play them the same way 3 times through, which must be boring for the listener, so my homework will be to try to vary things slightly
thanks again one and all
Lin
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Malcolm Austen on March 07, 2008, 11:42:36 AM
As has been mentioned you just have to keep doing it but everyone else there will have been through it and should understand. It is though most alarming just how difficult it can be to play in public at first. When I encountered this and having decided not to just give up I adopted the ten to one rule that if I could play a tune through ten times at home with out getting it wrong I could get through it in public. One part of this is relaxing, one of the early problems I had was my left arm would lock up and trying to play for longer periods at home helped this.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Ellie on March 07, 2008, 01:40:09 PM
Hi Lin, I think everyone else has covered all the bases, but just to add that from my personal experience, playing at home with people interrupting is absolutely the best practise without actually being in public. I try not to only practise when there isn't anybody around these days, as then you are used to other people hearing mistakes and just being able to carry on (it's the carrying on and catching the tune again that I always find hard!). I still do get terrified of playing in public, but I do believe that's fairly normal :D
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Matthew B on March 07, 2008, 02:42:57 PM
There's a list of things that can, and therefore do, go wrong, and I suppose its a right of passage to endure them all (usually repeatedly).  The list includes, but is not limited to:

forgetting the tune (all of it, part of it, its name, the words)
playing the tune in the "wrong" key
playing the tune at the "wrong" speed
changing waltzes to jigs, or reels to mazurkas, or whatever
experiencing a major instrument malfunction (broken shoulder straps and stuck keys produce the most hilarious results)
punching a fellow musician with over-vigorous bellows work (the strength of the punch is directly correlated to the fragility and value of the other person's instrument)
stopping or starting, or not stopping or starting when everyone else does
experiencing a major wardrobe malfunction (belt failure, flies undone, etc)

A few things I've found very helpful over the years in developing some appearance of calm when coping with these things:
1.  Playing background music for some other event: it's public (and sometimes you get paid!), but you're not "on stage"
2.  Playing for dancers: they just carry themselves along, and mistakes get washed away in the energy of the moment, just keep that right foot tapping out the time.
3.  Organize your own session in your kitchen with a few beers and a couple of friends, and then bring those same folks to your public session. 
4.  Busking.
5.  And best of all: playing for kids.  If you ever need any affirmation at all about your music, go play a set for a local primary school class.  There's no money in it, and no glory, but it is such fun, and they will love you, mistakes and all.  And if your instrument breaks, or your pants fall down in the middle, they'll just love you more. 
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Lin Leighton on March 07, 2008, 02:55:42 PM
buuuuuut ......  dont Primary Schools have those horrible things called ....... children.  I dont really have to play to them, do I?????   what a shock!!  do they hurt????
Im definately giving up music now   LOL
 ::)
Lin
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Theo on March 07, 2008, 03:30:12 PM
I'd echo Matthew's suggestion to play for children.   They will be fascinated.  Many children nowadays have never been in the same room as an actual person playing a musical instrument, apart perhaps from a piano to accompany singing.  Even fewer have ever seen any kind of squeezebox.  Even cynical teenagers can be stimulated to take notice.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Quebecois on March 07, 2008, 03:51:57 PM
Kids also like to dance! Show them a few steps, then play a tune and they will all enjoy.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: trombonetom on March 07, 2008, 05:12:05 PM
Some Cynical teenagers actually play squeezeboxes!
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Theo on March 07, 2008, 05:29:17 PM
Some Cynical teenagers actually play squeezeboxes!

Just goes to show what might happen when any of us play to your contemporaries. :D
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Matthew B on March 07, 2008, 05:43:20 PM
Some Cynical teenagers actually play squeezeboxes!

I beg to differ: any teenager playing any musical instrument is, by definition, exceptional.  And if playing a squeezebox, truly exceptional.  But you probably knew that already.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Hello on March 07, 2008, 06:10:35 PM
Wise words indeed from the masses.

Personally I don't like playarounds, where a group takes it in turn to play or sing something. I've found that sitting there while x other people do their bit and then having to suddenly do something induces a sort of fatigue that is very difficult to overcome and hence increases the probability of a cockup compared to performing a medley. Also if you start your tune and cock it up then the host of the playaround swiftly moves on to the next person so you've no chance to redeem yourself. You then wait for the x other people and so continues the vicious circle.

Ultimately though it's down to practice. Play in public as much as possible. Go to live gigs and watch professionals cock it up and see how they deal with it. In some ways, the cockups, provided they aren't terminal, add character to a performance that you don't get in todays sterile but perfect electronic world.

The most nervewracking thing is recording where your cockups can be played over and over again.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Folkiekay on March 07, 2008, 08:15:41 PM
Howdy,

Finally a topic I understand and can talk about with a bit of knowledge.  I was the same way when I started to play - and figured out my own way to go about getting over playing in front of people.  When I started out, I was only going to play for myself, but as time went on, I realized that I didn't only want to play just for me my whole life.

I started out by calling up my friends and asking if I could go to their houses and play for them.  They were all kind about it and invited me over.  I remember one friend saying to me..."are you wanting that tune to go fast and slow, fast and slow?"  Well - obviously I was not very good and couldn't play the tune in a normal 3/4 manner.  It took awhile, but I kept playing for people.  It even got to the point that I would play for strangers who came to my door just to play for someone. 

The most important thing to remember is that nobody really cares if you mess up a tune.  In 50 years nobody is going to be talking about it. Or even next month.  People who hear you obviously would like to hear you play well, but nobody is going to hold it against you if you don't. 

The next important thing to do when you make a mistake - smile.......  Don't frown or grimace.  It lightens up an awkward moment. :o

Another bit of advice is to become a busking street musician.  Most people are just passing by and not staying to watch and listen, and as time goes on it gets much easier and you will screw up fewer times, and even if you do mess up a tune, it doesn't really matter in the big scope of life.

I'm giving a workshop this coming week at the National Accordion Convention on this very subject!!

Kind regards,
Kay
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: TomB-R on March 07, 2008, 10:48:00 PM
Lots of good advice already in this thread. I'd just add that I reckon playing in your local session can be one of the highest pressure situations there is.  In the past I've found it more nervous-making than playing solo (admittedly for dancers) on a Festival stage.

Playing at a "strange" session where you don't know anyone is less pressure.
Playing in a concert situation is less pressure (possibly because you know they've "got" to listen to you.)

Having said all that, I reckon playing one to one in a lesson with a professional player (not professional teacher) is toughest of all!

I guess my point is just to suggest that "your friendly neighbourhood session" is actually a bigger challenge than it seems, but as others have said accumulating "mileage in public" makes all the difference.

YMMV, of course!
Tom
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: C age ing on March 08, 2008, 05:27:41 AM
Paul, who used to play guitar to my banjo in a folk duo a long time ago, used to do 'Freight Train' "As taught to me by Elizabeth Cotton". He would then proceed to play a terrible version by playing a fret out, remarking deadpan at the end, "Of course she was pissed at the time." This was before Les Dawson's piano efforts, maybe he should sue the estate for intellectual theft.

Prepare a really terrible version of something, deliver it deadpan, funny remark at the end and nobody will be able to tell whether it is meant to be serious or not.
Old Bill.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Steve_freereeder on March 08, 2008, 08:29:54 AM
I guess everyone has been here and done this and bought the T shirt, but I just wondered if anyone had any tips to get over what happened last night.
Ive practised and practised a really easy tune at home to the nth degree so I could play it at a local session - its perfect, with basses and everything.  Im really happy about how it sounds and my playing.  So on the night I make a complete mess of it, Im nervous, I cant remember the tune, I get the sequence mixed up  etc etc.  I throw my beloved Tommy on the floor (not literally!!!! Steve) have a paddy and say Im not doing it anymore!!!!  now I'm among friends, so they all just laugh and say it will get easier, but as I thought to myself, Ive been doing this learning thing for about 4 years now, its time I got it better in public.
Any tips to get over nervousness greatfully accepted!!!!  :-\
Lin
Lin,

There's been lots of good advice already, so I don't have much more to add. Don't give up. Do it again (and again, and again...). Glad you haven't thrown the Tommy on the floor. ;)

I do agree with the view that the 'round the room' type of session is not the easiest. I like the 'just jump in and start a tune' type session best. Although at  first it might be thought of as a recipe for one or two people dominating the session, in practice (at least in the sessions I go to) most people are polite enough to see that everyone who wants to gets a chance at starting tunes.

I also like the suggestion of a 'playing buddy'; someone to work up a few tunes with and play together at a session. Happy to oblige :)

Finally, I think you are being too hard on yourself. I've heard you play in sessions several times and you are FINE! Just because you may have crumbled this one time doesn't signal the end of the world. Forget it - just let it go; next time you will be fine.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: mikesamwild on March 08, 2008, 11:05:32 AM
I would recommend a workshop session with a beginner's class or a festival orchestra class. Last year at Whitby Folk Festival in Yorkshire a few musicins put on a bog standard session in a friendly pub and got loads of support from a very fun, mixed crowd. A sensitive leader held it together with good humour and there was no ego.
Avoid 'elite' sessions! Practice by ear and eventually busk discretely in a supportive session. I know some very good musicians who early on never actually made a sound as they were playing in sessions. Fiddlers can use butter on their bow!

We've all been there!
Mike in Sheffield
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: BruceHenderson on March 08, 2008, 02:37:28 PM
   And there's a completely different place you may get to.  For some reason (dunno why or when or how), I've developed a thing where I play *better* in public.  The excitement of being with people and the experience (and here I mean the immediate experience of doing it - the "warm up) of getting your chops going makes me enjoy playing more.  And I get into it and the notes just seem to come out easier and I (almost always) enjoy it.

   Like I said, it's nothing I can take credit for or have any idea why it works -- and I can't tell you how to get there -- but it's sure a good feeling.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Quebecois on March 08, 2008, 02:40:05 PM
:) Adrenaline has its good sides!!!
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Kevin Mack on March 10, 2008, 10:12:02 AM
Hi Lin,
I don't know if anyone has suggested this, but as someone who makes loads of mistakes, I can vouch for it.
You have to practise playing it wrong! Deliberately throw in all the worst wrong notes you possibly can, but keep on playing without missing a beat. Never stop till you've finished the tune or passage. That way you learn to play right through any errors, and your subconcious learns not to 'panic' when you hit the odd wrong note.
It will sound atrocious, so find somewhere you can be alone, but take my word for it, if you do this regularly, it makes a big difference.
Actually, the odd deliberate mistake can turn out to sound quite good! So doing this you can occasionally pick up stuff you would never have discovered by playing it right.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Pushpull on March 10, 2008, 10:32:30 AM
Hi Lin,
I don't know if anyone has suggested this, but as someone who makes loads of mistakes, I can vouch for it.
You have to practise playing it wrong! Deliberately throw in all the worst wrong notes you possibly can, but keep on playing without missing a beat. Never stop till you've finished the tune or passage. That way you learn to play right through any errors, and your subconcious learns not to 'panic' when you hit the odd wrong note.
It will sound atrocious, so find somewhere you can be alone, but take my word for it, if you do this regularly, it makes a big difference.
Actually, the odd deliberate mistake can turn out to sound quite good! So doing this you can occasionally pick up stuff you would never have discovered by playing it right.

I half agree with Kevin in that learning to keep going is very important. However deliberately playing it wrong I don't think is a good approach - the brain seems to have a nasty habit of remembering the wrong way in preference to the right way. I would cut back the speed and practice playing it right.

Lin, I think you play for a Morris side don't you? If I'm right, do you play at practices? Playing the same tune over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over (you get the idea) is certainly the best way to embed it. It also means you have to keep going as Kevin said or get used to where to come back in (you can always say you stopped for dramatic effect!). I also start adding twiddles during the practices when the public performance nerves aren't in evidence and then if things start getting too much reverting to a non-twiddled basic version feels much easier.

Sadly, performance nerves are a part of playing in public and most people suffer to a greater or lesser extent. I find when I'm nervous my internal metronome goes crazy (which the dancers don't always appreciate, even if William Kimber would).

Oh and a music prof at a US university (not a melodeon player, but hey) pointed out that a great performance looks easy to the audience - BECAUSE it's easy. In other words you need to be on top of the piece and able to play in front of an audience.

It is sadly, just down to practice.

Roy.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Quebecois on March 10, 2008, 11:26:43 AM
"Amateurs practice until they get it right. Professionals practice until they can't get it wrong."
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Lin Leighton on March 10, 2008, 11:48:37 AM
Hi all
this has turned out to be a great topic, and full of helpful advice  :)

I had never actually analysed it before, but having given it some thought I think you are right when you say that a turn about session is a high pressure situation, and perversely knowing that that seems to have eased the pressure!!   ;D
Playing for Morris is totally different to sessions -- you just have to get on with it,-  ride over any mistakes, - and you are playing all the time (thus agreeing with the pressure build up when awaiting your turn in sessions)

Thanks for all the helpful comments.  I just had a paddy because I had practised this easy tune to the nth degree at home, and then made a mess of it, so it was myself I fell out with!! ha ha

Going off topic slightly, I am also finding that it is the new tunes I lear, that I forget most easily, and old favourites seem to stick - probably, but no necessarily  :D to do with that age -related memory loss thing!!!
Lin

Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: C age ing on March 10, 2008, 12:57:45 PM
Going off topic slightly, I am also finding that it is the new tunes I lear, that I forget most easily, and old favourites seem to stick - probably, but no necessarily  :D to do with that age -related memory loss thing!!!
Lin
Oi! You having a go at me? Keep on like that and I'll introduce Sharia Law to Rattlejag.
Can you play Tommy with your toes? >:(
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Alison Scott on March 10, 2008, 02:52:28 PM
I've just caught up with this thread, which I completely identify with. I can now play along with, oh, all manner of tunes, provided there is another melodeon player there I can hide behind. And I can play tunes at home, and they sound fine. But if I try to start tunes at sessions it all goes Horribly Wrong. Even worse is the little scratch band at the folk club; some nights I'm the only person who turns up with a melody instrument, so I have to try to start things, and I'm wholly exposed if I miss notes. And for all I know that the audience is not actually listening (they just want some pleasant music to drink to before the club starts), I clam up completely. I have had some slight success in the last by choosing Winster Gallop as the tune to start with; even I can manage to get through that. Mostly.

And at the very best I'm feeling sick and shaky by the end of our little set. I know that Susan Jeffers says I should Feel the Fear and Do it Anyway but I don't understand why I'm so petrified. I don't get anything like as scared when I'm singing: by comparison, last week I sang an unaccompanied 8 verse song, well known in versions by Norma Waterson and June Tabor, which I'd not begun to learn until 2pm that afternoon, and was only slightly nervous.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on March 10, 2008, 03:29:29 PM
Have you tried throwing your Morris Tunes at the folk club audience? I did this when I was brushing up my fiddle playing after 20 years absence and it was really appreciated. Did wonders for my confidence as well.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: george garside on March 10, 2008, 04:33:30 PM
 
And at the very best I'm feeling sick and shaky by the end of our little set. I know that Susan Jeffers says I should Feel the Fear and Do it Anyway but I don't understand why I'm so petrified. I don't get anything like as scared when I'm singing: by comparison, last week I sang an unaccompanied 8 verse song, well known in versions by Norma Waterson and June Tabor, which I'd not begun to learn until 2pm that afternoon, and was only slightly nervous.
[/quote]

Hi Alison
probably singing less worrysome as you've been opperating the gob since birth & by now have completely mastered the singing of the notes.  On the other hand the opperating of the fingers, arm etc is , in comparison, relatively new and so there is an understandable fear of   not being able to transfer whats going on in the head to the instrument!

Most of us -exept the deaf or big headed - are very concious of playing wrong notes, particularly when  without
other musicians to  help out.  You hit the nail on the head with winster gallop i.e. one you know you can play drunk or sober! Never but never  attempt anything but your sunday best if you are feeling nervous, play less tried & tested stuff in sessions etc with others to hide behind - in time some of those tunes will move up into the sunday best catagory  without you even thinking about it.

george
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Kevin Mack on March 10, 2008, 07:13:38 PM
=========================
quote : I half agree with Kevin in that learning to keep going is very important. However deliberately playing it wrong I don't think is a good approach - the brain seems to have a nasty habit of remembering the wrong way in preference to the right way. I would cut back the speed and practice playing it right.
==========================

One would expect that, but it doesn't happen, not in my case anyway. What it does is give confidence in being able to get back onto the tune, when you do go wrong. I think a break in rhythm always sticks out more than a wrong note.
I think pressure is a lot higher when playing in front of musicians, rather than people who don't play. You know non players are generally impressed because they can't do it themselves, but playing in front of good players is real pressure.
Try imagining they are all naked!! It might take the mind off it!
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Quebecois on March 10, 2008, 07:28:58 PM
I don't think playing wrong notes in order to keep up the speed is a good idea, sorry. One should rather play fewer good notes, if speed is the essence!

Better: if you can't keep up with the speed it's because you don't know the tune well enough. Practice slowly, let your brain remember all the notes and bellows movements. Your brains will naturally remember the tune if you play it often and pay attention to get it right. Increase the speed slightly when you can play the tune without missing anything. After a while, you will acquire both the precision and speed for the tune. You will be surprised how fast you can then go when everything falls well into place! I use a metronome in order to set the pace when learning a new tune; it is useful to measure your progress once you can increase the speed. Having great timing and meter is important, especially if you play for dancers.

Most of all: ENJOY your playing!
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: george garside on March 10, 2008, 07:31:10 PM
=========================
 

 
Try imagining they are all naked!! It might take the mind off it!

the version I hear was imagine them sat on the bog with their keks round their knees - a vision that totally stops you taking them seriously.
george
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Andy Next Tune on March 10, 2008, 11:54:31 PM
Lin - Been there - still there!
So my session survival thoughts are -
- If playing a set of tunes, I tend to play the newly learnt tune first and then will often change to an old favourite, it gives me a known and trusty escape route and people will join in which reduces the pressure on the second half.
- Definitely play your favourite morris tunes - just because you play them every week, doesn't mean everyone else knows them.
- Relax and smile! It keeps the audience on your side.

Personally I prefer not to imagine everyone sitting with their keks around their knees - it is a little too distracting, particularly if you hear paper being rustled :)

Andy
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: johnp_g on March 11, 2008, 02:39:47 AM
"Amateurs practice until they get it right. Professionals practice until they can't get it wrong."


Arnold Parmer said “It's a funny thing, the more I practice the luckier I get”

and Thomas Jefferson “I'm a great believer in luck, and I find the harder I work, the more I have of it.”


 :D

John

(edited to add Thomas Jefferson's quote...and to confess to never playing in public... I'm not lucky enough yet!)
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Malcolm Austen on March 11, 2008, 08:29:20 AM
Practice, practice, practice.
It is easy to say but very difficult to keep up over the years if you are teaching yourself. I once read an article stating that good classical musicians going into a music degree will have done about 2,000 hours practice and the natural ability they all had was to be able to keep up the practicing year after year.

I also put my "play it 10 times at home with out a mistake and you can play it once in public" rule to the test last night and yes, I can nearly play my new tune 10 times at home and I nearly played it once at our local session.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Quebecois on March 11, 2008, 11:13:51 AM
Practice, practice, practice.
(...)       
I also put my "play it 10 times at home with out a mistake and you can play it once in public" rule to the test last night and yes, I can nearly play my new tune 10 times at home and I nearly played it once at our local session.
Best advice so far, IMHO!

Practice often, and practice smartly.

The great singer Charles Aznavour used to say:
"No one can argue against working 17 hours a day".
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Lin Leighton on March 11, 2008, 12:58:12 PM
I would recommend a workshop session with a beginner's class or a festival orchestra class. Last year at Whitby Folk Festival in Yorkshire a few musicins put on a bog standard session in a friendly pub and got loads of support from a very fun, mixed crowd. A sensitive leader held it together with good humour and there was no ego.
Avoid 'elite' sessions! Practice by ear and eventually busk discretely in a supportive session. I know some very good musicians who early on never actually made a sound as they were playing in sessions. Fiddlers can use butter on their bow!

Hi Mike
I go to Whitby Folk Festival too, but I struggle to find sessions other than Irish or singarounds (apart from the official workshops of course and Georges easy one in Middle Earth).  Last year I was lucky to fine one in a pub (whose name escapes me).  Could you let me in on the secret of finding sessions, cos most festivals I go to I seem to hear loads about singarounds but not much about sessions.   ???  We did have a mel.netters meet in the old town a couple of years ago, perhaps we could do that again??   ;D.  Sorry Theo, nearer the time we will start a proper thread for Whitby, promise.
Lin
Lin
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: A Nonny Mouse Esq on March 11, 2008, 04:15:55 PM
Shy, retiring, I make mistakes and go to pieces Lin in action here:-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G6VF0vR1D4I (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G6VF0vR1D4I)
 ;D
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Pushpull on March 11, 2008, 05:18:56 PM
Practice, practice, practice.
It is easy to say but very difficult to keep up over the years if you are teaching yourself. I once read an article stating that good classical musicians going into a music degree will have done about 2,000 hours practice and the natural ability they all had was to be able to keep up the practicing year after year.


Apparently on average it takes around 2000 hours to get to Grade 8 standard (which might get you onto a degree course). The same Mr. Average takes around 10000 hours to be "expert". Consider how many hours you have put in through education and training to become really proficient at your job and I reckon it's about right.

Roy (many thousands of squeezing hours to go).
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: george garside on March 11, 2008, 05:24:10 PM
[
Apparently on average it takes around 2000 hours to get to Grade 8 standard (which might get you onto a degree course). The same Mr. Average takes around 10000 hours to be "expert". Consider how many hours you have put in through education and training to become really proficient at your job and I reckon it's about right.

Roy (many thousands of squeezing hours to go).
[/quote]

bloody hell! on that basis its 5.479 years at 1 hour per day to get to grade 8 or 27.397 years to become an 'expert'/

george
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Quebecois on March 11, 2008, 05:34:46 PM
This is why re-incarnated players have an edge on most of us...
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Ellie on March 11, 2008, 05:41:28 PM
Ha, best to start young then? ;D Besides, surely there's expert, and then there's 'folk' - a different category altogether surely!
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: george garside on March 11, 2008, 06:11:53 PM
Ha, best to start young then? ;D Besides, surely there's expert, and then there's 'folk' - a different category altogether surely!

with apologies to the newcatle alumni  does the very worthy newcastle uni degree in folk music produce folking experts.

george
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Lin Leighton on March 11, 2008, 08:23:07 PM
Old Bill
who said I was shy and retiring?? ::)   just suffer from nerves in sessions
but from now on its going to be  8) me as I picture them in the buff, sat on the loo, not listening to me anyway etc etc


:-*
Lin
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: GuyWyatt on March 11, 2008, 10:30:34 PM
OK so its off topic but on the subject of sitting on the loo... (Look, I didnt raise the issue did I?). An old acquaintance of mine told me that when he was first learning to play he lived in an open plan house, so in order not to distress his housemate he practiced in the only room in the house with a door, ie the loo. He says that now he only really feels comfortable playing the melodeon if he has his trousers round his ankles. If that is right I imagine that when he is playing in a session he uses the opposite system to George, ie instead of visualising the audience sitting on the loo, visualising himself doing so.  No, truly I've only been drinking tea. The bottle of Chardonay is still in the fridge, honest....
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: george garside on March 12, 2008, 10:40:10 AM
OK so its off topic but on the subject of sitting on the loo... (Look, I didnt raise the issue did I?). 

whilst off topic  the visuialisation of somebody sat keks round knees on bog is a very good wa ;Dy of dealing with an irate boss at work.  It throws them completely if your response to their rantings is just to look at them with a grin on your face.
george
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Pushpull on March 12, 2008, 11:27:25 AM
Ha, best to start young then? ;D Besides, surely there's expert, and then there's 'folk' - a different category altogether surely!

Consider the very best folk musicians you can think of? How many hours do you reckon they spend playing? I know of one smallpipes player (no name, no pack drill, but loads of tattoos), who apparently on his trip to the crossroads and back, practiced 7 hours a day. Classical students (college standard) are probably putting in 3 -5 hours a day. But hey, that's their job.

Roy.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Lin Leighton on March 12, 2008, 11:38:02 AM
but what a lovely way to spend 7 hours  :D

also does this sound familiar to anyone??  I like English Country dance music , but when asked which is my most favourite tune, it seems that the answer is -  the one Im currently learning!!!  is that normal????  can I like the "tune of the day" best of all, or is there something wrong with me???  ::)
::)
Lin
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Theo on March 12, 2008, 12:29:42 PM
No Lin, I think its quite normal.  The tune you are learning has taken your fancy and you want to play with it, dance with it, even develop a relationship with it.  At present I'm learning a completely crazy Playford tune called The Purlongs.  I'm playing it countless times every day, its got its hooks into my brain, so its my favourite tune at present.  Its almost like having a new baby in the family.  All the excitement centres around the new arrival, but you still love the others just as much.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: C age ing on March 12, 2008, 01:42:33 PM
Theo,
That's 'The Furlongs'. Very appropriate as it is, well not today, the Cheltenham Festival.
Amazing the things GCHQ gets involved in. When I was younger even to mention the name was an offence, just a minute, the doorbell is ringing
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Theo on March 12, 2008, 02:20:00 PM
Its called Purlongs in my book. 

Sorry your agile brain is too fast for me, what is the connection with Cheltenham and GCHQ?
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: C age ing on March 12, 2008, 04:49:55 PM
Sorry Theo, being interviewed at the moment about how I knew GCHQ was based in Cheltenham. It was in the papers when they built the new circular version. Don't ask what the old shape was as I do not know.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Lester on March 12, 2008, 05:36:09 PM
Sorry Theo, being interviewed at the moment about how I knew GCHQ was based in Cheltenham. It was in the papers when they built the new circular version. Don't ask what the old shape was as I do not know.
Do we have to shoot you now?
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: rees on March 13, 2008, 12:31:17 AM
Lin

It's normal.
I've been playing for thirty odd years and my favourite tune is always the one I've just learned.

It's normal.
The trouble with normal is it always gets worse!
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Malcolm Austen on March 13, 2008, 08:23:07 AM
off topic and off bike
"Don't ask what the old shape was as I do not know" there were a lot of long rectangular buildings and I once fell off my bike outside the main gate.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Rob2Hook on March 13, 2008, 09:58:41 AM
Yes, we all suffer from nerves!  Even some of the best like to mellow out with a pint before trying to lead a session with their current favourite, just learnt tune.  Our band rate all tunes by the number of beers required before attempting it!  When I first played at a local session, I was sweaty palmed and set off at a gallop with my heart pounding in my ears.  Luckily, my mates joined in quickly and steadied the tempo - after which I could enjoy playing the tune. 

Playing for a North West side does little for stopping that rush, but for a Border side it helps to actually stomp in time and that slow hornpipe becomes much easier.  For country dancing, it's the same thing.  Just imagine you're dancing and it drops into place - your fingers start dancing with a lighter touch.  Just like interview technique, visualize the outcome before you start. 

Of course, sometimes the mood is not upon you - I find it best to just laugh at my own cock-ups and let someone else take over.  When someone else starts one of your favourites you can get back in the groove without being in the spotlight.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Quebecois on March 13, 2008, 11:15:54 AM
Stage fright is a strange thing. When we hear soloist we all wish we could do the same and be in the spotlight, and when we are given that opportunity our brains lock up and we just freeze... Some people seem to have a natural gift to perform well under the spotlight, for the others it can be a matter of training and conditioning before the stress can be controlled.

When we look at young kids, we can see how easy it it for some of them to be the center of attention in a group and sing, dance or do some kind of artistic performance and really enjoy it. But most get really shy and hide.

A chap I used to work with has practiced trumpet since he was in high school, and he is a good player. A few years ago I proposed that we perform a little trumpet/cornet duet of carols at the office's Christmas potluck (I also play brass), we had a few practice sessions and it worked really well. But the very day before the party he just got cold feet and quit... claiming he just could not do it in front of the people!

What is the point of playing of an instrument in your basement for the rest of your life!

I used to work as a classroom instructor and lecturer, at the beginning I was really nervous, sweating and all, and needed to look at my notes and slides all the time. But after a while, it became a second nature and I could jump in a classroom and do my whole 5-hour presentation sessions almost from memory. And I WAS ENJOYING IT.

I think the enjoyment factor is a key to public performance. The hard part is being able to transport this enjoyment in front of other people and communicate it. Takes some practice...
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Lin Leighton on March 13, 2008, 11:39:30 AM
I tell you what though.  The best thing was having you wonderful bunch of people out there to come to my aid and support in my hour of need.  A trouble shared is a trouble halved, and I feel much better and happier now.  A million thanks to all.

Lin

Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Howard Jones on March 16, 2008, 02:57:02 PM
After playing and singing in public for more than 30 years, I've come to learn that no matter how hard I've practiced a new piece, the first time I play it in public I'll get it wrong.  Now I make sure that the first time I play a new piece out, it's among friends who'll be sympathetic, usually my local session.  Once I've got the first performance nerves out of the way, subsequent performances are usually easier.

I've found that thinking too hard about how the next verse, or phrase of the tune, goes is fatal, you have to get into a kind of zen zone where it suddenly all comes back to you just as you get to it.

Or not ... :)  If that happens, it's helpful to develop bluffing skills to gloss over any mistakes.  It's easier with songs, you can throw in an instrumental break, repeat a verse (this happens a lot in folk songs anyway), make up the words (easier than it sounds) or just mumble!.  With tunes, just keeping the rhythm going counts for a lot.  A lot of the time your audience won't even notice the mistake, and probably won't care too much anyway.  You'll be far more critical of your own performance than they are.

The great John K, who despite being a god quite often makes mistakes (admittedly while trying something fiendishly difficult), just laughs them off.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Folkiekay on March 18, 2008, 05:54:36 PM
Just back from the National Accordion Convention that took place in Texas, and my music partner and I did a workshop partially about stage fright, and we had a psychiatrist in the audience, who told us there are prescription medications for people with serious performance anxiety.  I didn't know this - so I suppose for anyone with really serious anxiety, that might be the way to go.  Check with your doctor.  Also - another good idea was to pretend when you play alone at home and are practicing, to pretend in your mind that you are playing in front of a lot of people.   Some people like to pretend they are playing in front of people they don't know, but there were some others who like to pretend they play in front of people who don't like them.  Strange, but I think it's good to try whatever works.

Kay
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Quebecois on March 18, 2008, 08:59:55 PM
Just back from the National Accordion Convention that took place in Texas, and my music partner and I did a workshop partially about stage fright, and we had a psychiatrist in the audience, who told us there are prescription medications for people with serious performance anxiety.  I didn't know this - so I suppose for anyone with really serious anxiety, that might be the way to go.  Check with your doctor.
There are indeed drugs to cut off anxiety, but is this really the way to go ?!?!?!? Some people simply use beer...


 
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Ellie on March 19, 2008, 12:40:18 PM
Quote from: québécois
There are indeed drugs to cut off anxiety, but is this really the way to go ?!?!?!? Some people simply use beer...

I wouldn't recommend that in the long term, either! :D
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Pushpull on March 19, 2008, 02:47:59 PM
Just back from the National Accordion Convention that took place in Texas, and my music partner and I did a workshop partially about stage fright, and we had a psychiatrist in the audience, who told us there are prescription medications for people with serious performance anxiety.


Beta blockers I suppose. I recall reading recently that bananas contain some sort of relaxant and people quite often nibble at those, not just for energy, but for the relaxing effect too.


Also - another good idea was to pretend when you play alone at home and are practicing, to pretend in your mind that you are playing in front of a lot of people.


Some music teachers would say every time you play it should be as though you are performing - even scales and studies.

Roy.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: george garside on March 19, 2008, 03:12:17 PM
 
Some music teachers would say every time you play it should be as though you are performing - even scales and studies.

Roy.
[/quote]

If this is in the sense of listening carefully to every note you play I agree.  Assuming you have developed the manual dexterity required to play whatever you play easily at its correct speed listening enables you to get the best out of the presentation of the tune (dynamics - note length - phrasing - ornementation etc etc) 

It also has the  (totally free of charge) benefit of concentrating your mind on what you are playing  rather than on worrying about cocking  up in front of an audience.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Accordion Dave on February 01, 2009, 06:30:07 PM
When I am playing at home on my front porch, I can go on for hours from one tune to the next, but playing in public is different. At various German/American events, I play my piano accordion during intermission in exchange for beer and bratwurst. The most difficult thing for me is dealing with distraction. People want to carry on a conversation whilst I am playing. Generally, I just smile or nod and continue playing until I can end the tune in a logical place. I have not developed a time-sharing brain that can have discussions and continue to play well at the same time. Also, I play from memory, but sometimes my mind goes blank and I can't remember the many tunes that I know. I have taken to carrying a piece of paper listing the songs I can play well. Two summers ago I got a 1-row Hohner in Bb. Last summer I added a Chinese 2-row G/C melodeon and I started bringing them along for some variety. I now have two additional 2-row instruments, a Lombardi Db/Ab and a Koch Eb/Bb. People seem to enjoy the smaller button boxes in addition to the huge 120-bass piano accordion. Speaking of small, I also like to bring along one of my Hero Chinese 7-button 1-rows for fun. For events involving children, I will bring along a bunch of the little  Chinese boxes and have an impromptu jam session with the kids.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Accordion Dave on February 01, 2009, 07:24:07 PM
Note: The Lombardi is Ab (G#) on the outer row and Db (C#) on the inner row.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Wurdal on February 10, 2009, 07:54:21 PM
Its a good idea to have a set of tunes that you fell really comfortable with. They might be simple but as long as you can paly them competently it doesn't matter. Its also quite useful if you have a friend that you play with. When I played in sessions I usually was playing with a friend. We might have two or three sets which we knew back to front and when we set off playing that set the agenda for that set. After that if the session is big enough you can hide behind the general noise. Remember its mainly about fun and if you mess up then you mess up. In the scheme of things it doesn't matter. Remember just as there will always be someone who is better than you there will be someone worse.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: waldoB on February 10, 2009, 07:59:55 PM
Its a good idea to have a set of tunes that you fell really comfortable with. They might be simple but as long as you can paly them competently it doesn't matter. Its also quite useful if you have a friend that you play with. When I played in sessions I usually was playing with a friend. We might have two or three sets which we knew back to front and when we set off playing that set the agenda for that set. After that if the session is big enough you can hide behind the general noise. Remember its mainly about fun and if you mess up then you mess up. In the scheme of things it doesn't matter. Remember just as there will always be someone who is better than you there will be someone worse.
A very sound strategy - unlikely TWO players will miss the same note at the same time
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: old geezer on February 11, 2009, 10:36:53 AM
Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!

bananas contain some sort of relaxant and people quite often nibble at those, not just for energy, but for the relaxing effect too.

here we were, going down the drain...
now we're going round the bend....
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Accordion Dave on February 13, 2009, 03:56:12 AM
I play for food, but I don't like to eat at the same time I am playing. The grease from the bratwurst makes it difficult to play the keys and the buttons. I like to have clean dry fingers and a grease-free accordion. Folks bring me food whilst I am playing and can't understand why I don't eat in between individual songs.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: mikesamwild on February 16, 2009, 11:11:57 AM
Me too
I find a harmonica rack like Bob Dylan's can accomodate a hot dog or several bananas if I want a calming influence.  Play on the blow not the suck or you choke!

If you wear an Australian bush hat you can string it with apples, not corks to keep off flies, then you can bob for apples whilst playing, if you get a good rhythm you will get to the core of the tune
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Accordion Dave on February 17, 2009, 12:03:32 AM
Mike: Are you from a family of circus folk?
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: ladydetemps on May 26, 2009, 03:36:28 PM
ressurecting an old thread...but just wanted to say on Monday went round my grandparents for family BBQ. I'd got what I was going to play planned and been practicing for two weeks trying to get them right.
I had a quick practice about an hour before my 'performance' then...when it came to the moment..it all went pearshaped. I think I only played one tune with 95% right. :(
The rest well I got put off/distracted by a) everyone deciding to sing along, b) mum dancing with my auntie. :P
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v28/imbored22001/th_CIMG6838.jpg) (http://smg.photobucket.com/albums/v28/imbored22001/?action=view&current=CIMG6838.flv)
Oh dear....I'm never going to be able to play with someone else in the room.  :'(

The game of guess which song I'm murdering on the concertina went well though. lol! I managed to confound then 50% of the time. :P
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Ellie on May 26, 2009, 04:10:05 PM
Ah, well, playing in a session is much easier than playing in front of a family audience! I always mess things up when I know people are listening too :)

Quote from: mackem
Its also quite useful if you have a friend that you play with. When I played in sessions I usually was playing with a friend.

I obviously missed this before, but this is an excellent point. Of all the sessions I've been to, by far the most enjoyable are the ones where there has been a friend or two present (always worth having some backup!)  :D
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: ladydetemps on May 26, 2009, 04:41:15 PM
..it all went pearshaped. I think I only played one tune with 95% right.
95% right? I think you're setting yourself impossibly ambitious targets.
I thought getting at least 100% of one tune right would be a resonable target  ???
I need one tune I can play perfect on demand as a 'show off' tune to impress.

Ah, well, playing in a session is much easier than playing in front of a family audience! I always mess things up when I know people are listening too :)
Especially annoying when they hum the wrong tune or sing the wrong words to the wrong part.  ::) :o
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: GbH on May 26, 2009, 06:20:48 PM
Although it often proves depressing and disspiriting, I've found that making videos has helped identify where problems are likely to occur and where the reality of what I'm doing differs greatly from what I think I'm doing.  This has definitly given me an extra degree of confidence when I've since tried playing something live in front of other people.

Yesterday, for the first time, I spent 20 minutes or so wandering around an outdoor event, just playing whatever tunes occured to me at the time, without any specific preparation.  What's more, people seemed to be enjoying it, despite the inevitable mistakes here and there.  I know I couldn't have done that 4 months ago and feel that forcing myself to record, listen to and sometime share what I've been playing has played a significant part in this progress.  I realise this isn't a proper substitute for actual live playing, but it does, at least, seem to help a bit.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Quebecois on May 26, 2009, 07:20:27 PM
The person the mistakes worry the most is yourself!!! We all make mistakes, and besides, how many people listening to your playing know how to play melodeon, or play anything?!?

Recording is indeed a good way of polishing your playing, since you try to do everything as perfect as possible so you won't have to record again.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Owen Woods on May 26, 2009, 08:52:09 PM
I've been performing for the last 15 years in one capacity or another and I still have problems sometimes. I'm a great believer in willpower, forcing yourself to be calm and pretending to yourself that it is no different from playing at home.

Of course the adrenelin can help, although sometimes in disturbing ways. I've played pieces before in concerts with my brain screaming at my fingers to not do things without involving it. Doing an entire piece on muscle memory in front of a room full of people is not exactly relaxing...
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Quebecois on May 26, 2009, 09:16:29 PM
When doing anything in public, playing, speaking, singing, do it primarily for yourself, not for the public! If you are good doing what you do for yourself, the public will like it too!
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 27, 2009, 12:37:39 AM
Playing in public is like anything else. It gets easier the more you do it. At first, we are all tense and nervous and that leads to mistakes. There are also the distractions of looking at and hearing the audience and whatever else is going on around you that don't occur when rehearsing in private. Trying to block out what is going on around you and focussing on nothing but the tune you are playing can help, but don't try that if you are playing for dance. One musician of my acquaintance who plays for a Morris side is oblivious to all signals from the dancers to speed up or slow down and has been known to keep playing when the dance has ended because he is unaware that it has done so.   :-[
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: xgx on May 27, 2009, 12:42:06 AM
..... Trying to block out what is going on around you and focussing on nothing but the tune you are playing can help, but don't try that if you are playing for dance.  :-[

concentrating on playing the tune and blocking distractions is definitely the key to success...

putting it into practise is another matter ;D
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Accordion Dave on May 27, 2009, 04:58:48 AM
Ah yes, distraction!
I played at the German Club for the Memorial Day breakfast. It is all quite amusing in retrospect.

With this group, I frequently just have to stop playing in the middle of a song. I can't keep playing when people want to talk about sports, hand me food or beer, shake my hand, slap me on the back or hit me in the head with a music stand.

There are two ladies that yodel. Our timing got completely screwed up. It sounded like their voices were coming from a LOUDspeaker on a mountain 1/5 of a mile away. The public address system operator had turned on "digital echo". The 1 second delay from the speakers was louder than the singers standing right next to me. I guess this was to give an authentic Swiss Alps echo effect.

Also, the sound system is always on the verge of feedback. One particular musical note from my accordion can set it into a deafening howl.

There is one positive note to this circus. The guy with the sound system was late, so I got to play for nearly an hour without electronic distraction.

Of course the house band started setting up equipment and tuning up during my performance which is also quite distracting.

From now on I am going sit as far away from any microphones as possible. I was told that my music could be heard just fine without the sound system from hell.

For July 4th I think I will play in a location central to the picnic tables, rather than on the "stage" where the band plays. (Actually it's not a stage but a concrete slab, 6 inches high.)

I played about a dozen different songs on my 2-row melodeon in addition to my main squeeze, the piano accordion. I am getting quite used to the bisonoric box. 

I even got to try a genuine Steirische Harmonika owned by one of the band members. I have never actually heard him play it because he only plays it with the over-powering brass band and never solo. I love the sound of the Helikon bass. I want one for Christmas!!!
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: petefoth on May 27, 2009, 09:16:28 AM
One point from my experience/history of performing in public (as a musician, actor and classroom teacher) is that You are your own worst critic. You will always be painfully aware of the faults in your performance. Most of your audience will not have noticed them at all.

Like a lot of things, playing an instrument - whether in public or just for your own benefit - should be fun, so the thing to concentrate on is Enjoy yourself and smile ;D

Regards

Pete
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Pushpull on May 27, 2009, 09:16:55 AM
Also, the sound system is always on the verge of feedback. One particular musical note from my accordion can set it into a deafening howl.
Folk and PAs. Don't get me started.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 27, 2009, 12:21:08 PM
..... Trying to block out what is going on around you and focussing on nothing but the tune you are playing can help, but don't try that if you are playing for dance.  :-[
concentrating on playing the tune and blocking distractions is definitely the key to success...
putting it into practise is another matter ;D
Well I understand the point being made here, I think. But as a general rule I don't think this makes for very good performance - or at least not one which is worth watching and listening to. The whole point about performance is interaction between performer and audience. The real trick is not to let that interaction, whatever it is, put you off. And this is easier if what you are concentrating on consciously is being musical rather than hitting the right notes.
I agree entirely, but we are trying to advise someone who is new to public performance and who is tensing up, falling off the notes, &c. The first thing to do is to overcome the nerves sufficiently to be able to play the tune. Blocking out distractions can help. Once LDT is able to hit the right notes in public, she will begin to relax and will then be able to consider the performance rather than just playing the tune....and performance does, of course, require an interaction with the audience.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: ladydetemps on May 27, 2009, 12:27:01 PM

Quote
I agree entirely, but we are trying to advise someone who is new to public performance and who is tensing up, falling off the notes, &c. The first thing to do is to overcome the nerves sufficiently to be able to play the tune. Blocking out distractions can help.
I find the only way to block others out is to concentrate on the written music infront of me.

Quote
and performance does, of course, require an interaction with the audience.
once I get the files I need converted I'll put up two recordings of the 'audience participation' ;)
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 27, 2009, 12:35:01 PM
I find the only way to block others out is to concentrate on the written music infront of me.
You might find it better to learn the tunes by heart. Reading the music can itself be a distraction. Keep practising the same tunes until you can play them without the music and, in time, the fingering pattern will become automatic. This will make it easier to play in public and especially in pub sessions.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: ladydetemps on May 27, 2009, 12:36:43 PM
I find the only way to block others out is to concentrate on the written music infront of me.
You might find it better to learn the tunes by heart. Reading the music can itself be a distraction. Keep practising the same tunes until you can play them without the music and, in time, the fingering pattern will become automatic. This will make it easier to play in public and especially in pub sessions.
It doesn't matter if I learn a tune off by heart...once I'm in front of someone my mind goes blank. :(
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 27, 2009, 12:43:07 PM
It doesn't matter if I learn a tune off by heart...once I'm in front of someone my mind goes blank. :(
That happens to all of us at some time or other, but don't let it put you off. The more thoroughly you internalise a tune, the easier you will find it to remember.
Do you have a friend who plays? It doesn't have to be a melodeon - almost any instrument will do. If so, learn the same tunes and then, if your mind goes blank in public, your friend can start the tune, which should remind you how it goes and then you can join in with him/her.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: ladydetemps on May 27, 2009, 12:52:19 PM
Do you have a friend who plays? It doesn't have to be a melodeon - almost any instrument will do. If so, learn the same tunes and then, if your mind goes blank in public, your friend can start the tune, which should remind you how it goes and then you can join in with him/her.
I have one friend who plays violin but whenever I ask her to come round and 'play' she always seems to have something better to do. :(
My siblings refuse to play my sort of music....I might just get my sister intrested if I learn a bob dylan or woodie guthrie song.
Other than that I'm stuck....I have a cousin who plays violin/recorder but its hard to get them to play music with me as they live quite far away. :(
But after my little 'demonstration' her dad said he wanted a melodeon..so maybe there is hope yet.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 27, 2009, 12:59:29 PM
I have one friend who plays violin but whenever I ask her to come round and 'play' she always seems to have something better to do. :(
My siblings refuse to play my sort of music....I might just get my sister intrested if I learn a bob dylan or woodie guthrie song.
Other than that I'm stuck....I have a cousin who plays violin/recorder but its hard to get them to play music with me as they live quite far away. :(
But after my little 'demonstration' her dad said he wanted a melodeon..so maybe there is hope yet.
You might try going along to a Morris dance side or to a pub that has music sessions, where you could make new friends who play our sort of music. They could also advise you better than we can because they will see and hear you play.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: PaulFreeman on May 27, 2009, 01:22:40 PM
I have one friend who plays violin but whenever I ask her to come round and 'play' she always seems to have something better to do. :(
My siblings refuse to play my sort of music....I might just get my sister intrested if I learn a bob dylan or woodie guthrie song.
Other than that I'm stuck....I have a cousin who plays violin/recorder but its hard to get them to play music with me as they live quite far away. :(
But after my little 'demonstration' her dad said he wanted a melodeon..so maybe there is hope yet.
You might try going along to a Morris dance side or to a pub that has music sessions, where you could make new friends who play our sort of music. They could also advise you better than we can because they will see and hear you play.
The key for me was to play in a pub session, but I really needed it to have other melodeon players in there. If you're the only one, then the pressure is enormous - everyone can hear when you get it wrong, especially on the left hand. And people end up blaming you for speeding things up, even if it's not actually your fault, because you're the only one "defining" the tempo, thanks to being the only one with any bass. It's a hard life, it really is!

But playing a tune once in a session, in "practise" terms, is worth playing it 5 or ten times at home at least.

And these days it seems I'm often the only melodeon player in the session, but I'm OK with that now. So I'm now learning things like "if you are going wrong, don't break the rhythm when you recover" otherwise the whole thing falls to pieces. Fiddle players have it easy, I tell you.

Mind you, when I talked to Simon Care about learning the melodeon, before I'd got my own, he said that it's easy, because if you get hit a wrong note, at least you're in the right key, so it can sound like it was intentional.

Interestingly, last night I recorded myself playing, to pass on to a friend who wants to learn playing "with people", and the main thing I had to concentrate on was NOT concentrating too much. When I thought about getting it wrong, I went and got it wrong...

cheers,

Paul
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Sebastian on May 27, 2009, 01:34:39 PM
It doesn't matter if I learn a tune off by heart...once I'm in front of someone my mind goes blank. :(
Maybe you want to go outside. Summer is coming. Sit down on a park bench and play something for yourself. It is easier if you have a friend with you who just sits beside you, but not as an auditory, but for chatter.

First time is horrible, second time is easier.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: ladydetemps on May 27, 2009, 02:40:33 PM
Two recordings audio only.

http://www.onmvoice.com/play/5941
http://www.onmvoice.com/play/5942
now you see what I mean...
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: xgx on May 27, 2009, 02:52:57 PM
Yep ;D

Loadsa good advice on here already...some relevant now, some for the future...

it will happen for you at some point (meantime, repeat all tunes ad nauseam)
 if it was so easy everyone would be playing!!


patience is a virtue ...  by desired by many, possessed by few (if you find a supplier let me know ;D :|||:
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Hello on May 27, 2009, 03:49:55 PM
There's no such thing as a perfect live performance, a fact which has become less well known with the advent of modern recording techniques, and there are always things that you think you could have done better.

People generally don't mind if you make a mistake and their reaction is more likely to be a reflection of your reaction.
The real key is not to stop and to be able to rejoin the tune after a detour with the minimum disruption to the general flow. To do this it helps to know the tunes by heart pretty well and to be able to play them almost without thinking.

The other thing is not to get hung up about it.  Performing in public requires you to play in a completely different emotional state than in the back room at home.  This is something that becomes more familiar the more playing in public you do.

Tips:
Perform tunes that you feel confident with or can get right most of the time at home.

When practising, play a tune hundreds of times. This can be similar to repeating a word over and over. Your mind gets bored after a while and starts distorting it. This is when you're likely to make a mistake, so practice getting though it without crashing.

Practice the difficult bits slowly and precisely.

Watch out for starting tunes faster than normal - easy to do if you're nervous.

Resist the temptation to steel yourself with half a bottle of brandy.

Keep a positive mental attitude. The audience wants to have a good time and to see you enjoying yourself. 
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 27, 2009, 04:34:30 PM
Bisoronic Bloke has provided lots of good advice about how to learn tunes. I would add just two things.
1. Practise often (every day if possible) and practise in a way that is fun.
2. When learning a tune, you need to play it frequently, but if you are going to play it, say, 24 times in a day, try to play it 6 times through four times a day rather than 24 times all at once. That way you will learn it more quickly and it will stick in your mind more firmly.
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Sandy on May 27, 2009, 05:06:45 PM
I don't particularly like performing solo but it is the best practice for your nerves and concentration. Last year someone asked me to represent the local folk club and play in a competition. It didn't really appeal but I said okay to be polite.......and then found out that the adjudicator was John Kirkpatrick!!! When playing, I has to detach myself from the whole situation and so I focused on a scratch in the floor. As an inexperienced player, that was the only way that I could combat wobbly fingers.

If things go wrong for me when playing then I have gradually learnt not to feel uncomfortable because it makes those watching feel even more uncomfortable.  I think a rehearsed cry of DOH!! with a big smile is worth while.

Most of my nerves build up prior to performance so I try and distract myself if there is a long wait before playing.

In my younger years I played a lot of sport. You could train all the hours under the sun but you just couldn't beat match practice!!

cheers

Sandy
 ;D



Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 27, 2009, 07:22:30 PM
Last year someone asked me to represent the local folk club and play in a competition. It didn't really appeal but I said okay to be polite.......and then found out that the adjudicator was John Kirkpatrick!!! When playing, I has to detach myself from the whole situation and so I focused on a scratch in the floor. As an inexperienced player, that was the only way that I could combat wobbly fingers.
If it is any consolation, I have seen John K make mistakes when performing on stage (the Saturday night concert at Melodeons at Witney the last time he was there was a case in point). Pete Coe, John Spiers, John Tams and Chris Parkinson are among others I have seen do so. They all react in the same way: they make a joke of it and accompany the quip with a dazzling smile - yet another thing I have learnt from these maestros. I am getting quite good at the smile, but my jokes need as much work as my playing!  :-[
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Morrisbox on May 28, 2009, 05:33:17 PM
Quote
When playing, I has to detach myself from the whole situation and so I focused on a scratch in the floor. As an inexperienced player, that was the only way that I could combat wobbly fingers.

Great advice from Bob and Bisoronic Bloke, I must confess that when I am nervous playing in public, I do the focus on something (I use the bass end stops rather than a scratch on the floor).  This, I think, allows the flow from brain to fingers to go unimpeded.  The probelm for me is when I start to consciously think about the tune, and I break the flow and fall over!.  For me, once I relax and start to enjoy it, I can start to look around and have fun.  I think that the key is that the audience are there to enjoy themselves as well, and if you fluff the odd bit here and there, often they don't notice, or think it is variations.

Making mistakes is not a hanging offence - we all make mistakes, it's how we learn!  And I have to say, playing in public does get easier with time!

Trevor   
Title: Re: playing goes to pot in public!!!
Post by: Pushpull on May 29, 2009, 09:31:01 AM
Folk and PAs. Don't get me started.
cross-threading? (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1723.0.html)
I meant PA as in Public Address.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal