Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: neilm on March 16, 2010, 06:45:50 PM

Title: Fiddler wants a melodeon for pub playing including irish !
Post by: neilm on March 16, 2010, 06:45:50 PM
Evening all - new member - have played english and irish fiddle for a long (long) tbut my ime - pubs, festivals, at home. Fantastic instrument ! But have also dabbled on melodeon in a variety of keys - none expertly. I want to be able to `play in` with other musicians - guitar, fiddles, in keys that suit them, and also be able to use left hand chords-for irish. I have a mix of horrible old melodeons - F/C, C/Csharp- and have just bought a shiny new B/C but find I do not have chords to accompany the tune (when playing across both rows- so I may exchange it for different keys - but which ? Irish tunes, with left hand chords to suit for when playing solo, and in a key that other musicians find easy ?






Title: Re: Fiddler wants a melodeon for pub playing including irish !
Post by: Lester on March 16, 2010, 07:01:47 PM
Welcome Neil - sorry that's it - can't answer your questions but some one will be along soon who can   (:)

Title: Re: Fiddler wants a melodeon for pub playing including irish !
Post by: Stiamh on March 16, 2010, 09:10:52 PM
Hello Neil

Here is a simplified scenario:

If you want maximum chordal possibilities from a restricted range of keys (basically keys you can get easily on a D tin whistle), get a D/G. To make use of all the chordal possibilities of course you will have to know the instrument well and cross-row judiciously.

If you want maximum tune possibilities with useful but more restricted chordal possibilities, get a C#/D. Another bonus: less cross-rowing to worry about in common keys! (Or a B/C, which may give you slightly better tune possibilities depending on the keys you want to play in, but probably even more restricted chordal possibilites.)

A C#/D with 12 basses will arguably give you chordal possibilities to equal those of a D/G. They don't grow on trees though as I know to my cost.  >:(

For even more key and chord possibilities, there is the B/C/C# system which has several illustrious exponents on these forums.  Biggest, heaviest and scarcest though, and with the steepest learning curve of all I would contend.
Title: Re: Fiddler wants a melodeon for pub playing including irish !
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on March 16, 2010, 09:59:55 PM
As a Morris fiddler, I took the easy way out and bought a D/G, but haven't found any real snags with my choice of keys yet. Funnily enough, when I first started playing for the Morris, I was told "We always play in D or G, because that's what the melodeons are in!"  :||: :|glug
Title: Re: Fiddler wants a melodeon for pub playing including irish !
Post by: Falseknight on March 17, 2010, 07:59:22 AM
Irish B/C players don't tend to use the chords (bass end) much - there are also different layouts for the bass end of a B/C which might answer your problems.

I play D/G, (and C/F) but it is not a complete solution to the 'Irish Question'.
Title: Re: Fiddler wants a melodeon for pub playing including irish !
Post by: neilm on March 17, 2010, 08:50:07 PM
thanks for all advice thus far, will go for the plunge and get a G/D - and as far as I can will pursue gaelic melodies, and will revert to the fiddle for anything too complicated !  Am so at ease with the fiddle that I am entirely unaware of what key I play in - can transpose pretty much anything into any key, so moving to another instument, which I will never be able to master to the same degree, inevitably brings compromise.
-
anyone near west wales, Borth, the friendship pub, second saturday night of the month- mixed session irish, fiddles, boxes, crazy guy on bagpipes- next to the sea. starts about 9 till (very) late ! and a newish melodeon player with fallback fiddle !

Title: Re: Fiddler wants a melodeon for pub playing including irish !
Post by: pete /acorn on March 17, 2010, 10:59:52 PM
Hi,
Don't want to upset your thoughts too much,my daughter is also a fiddle player ,she decided a ADG was her best choice,she picked up a Saltarelle Laurentides and it sounds great.

Pete
Title: Re: Fiddler wants a melodeon for pub playing including irish !
Post by: Tony Gibbons on March 19, 2010, 10:27:21 PM
hi Jilly

I play a D/G for Irish and always have. I have made a few changes to tuning which I feel has enhanced the range of tunes played. I use bass all the time although sometimes sparingly depending on the tune etc. always keeping it very light so as not to detract from the melody.
My changes are:  turn the lower 'D' on the G row into an E; remove the accidentals and extend the scale downwards to low 'G' keeping it on par with fiddle. Below the G on the 'G' row I have:- F#(pull),E(push), C(pull),B(push). on the 'D' row below D I have:- C#(pull), A(push), A(pull), G(push). The 'E' on the G row I find is used greatly and enhances smoothness when cross-rowing lower down in the scales.
I did contemplate a BC but decided against purely on harmonic grounds especially when acompanying song. Occassionally I enjoy putting in chords in with the right hand.

hopec that gives food for thought.

TG
Title: Re: Fiddler wants a melodeon for pub playing including irish !
Post by: flipper on March 21, 2010, 01:52:24 AM
I also play Irish (not very well ) on D/G but have a friend who plays English concertina and Accordion and gives me music in various keys so have a B/C as well which we generally play tunes in other keys.

Sue
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal