Yup.
.......
And a smattering of ... percussion in between
What do you mean, "another" instrument?I don't get what the issue is? You'll have to clarify for me. It is simple enough did you play a musical instrument that wasn't a melodeon before you took it up. ::) Should I speak....slower? ;) :P
[Edit: I see jb has made the point already.]
Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
(and what were they?)
Should I speak....slower? ;) :P
If you can play a tune on it it's an instrument IMO ;)Should I speak....slower? ;) :P
No, just check the following boxes in your control panel:
[ ] Allow self-deprecating humour
[ ] Allow irony
;)
"Another" implies that the melodeon is a musical instrument. There are people who would dispute that...
If you can play a tune on it it's an instrument IMO :||:
I guess there's any number of other instruments that I've purchased, in a fit of temporary music shop enthusiasm. Some of these I can vaguely get by with, using skills learnt from other instruments. Others, I can't ::).
I guess there's any number of other instruments that I've purchased, in a fit of temporary music shop enthusiasm. Some of these I can vaguely get by with, using skills learnt from other instruments. Others, I can't ::).That sounds familiar....
but the others I still play regularly to varying degrees of incompetence.
getting really bored with all the egos the guitar entails!
Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
(and what were they?)
Hah! Just as I suspected, I am surrounded by proper musicians!
Guy
Then saw a melodeon for the first time and decided that I might just manage a keyboard with no black notes.
Similarly I have recently started on the trombone and I am finding it far harder than the melodeon. There are so many variables that go into the production of the note and its quality on a trombone that just don't apply on the box; press the button - get the note.
Guy
I've often thought that there are two basic dimensions on which you can locate and compare instruments:
[1] how easy it is to produce a good sound/intonation
[2] how obvious/intuitive is the positional/physical relationship, on the instrument, between different notes
I'd place something like trombone or violin as low on [1] and high on [2] and, as such, diametrically opposite to melodeon.
I could play one tune on recorder (infants school - if you asked me to play now I wouldn't have a clue where to start), and I wouldn't say I ever played keyboard (senior school) I just made sure I sat next to the boy who could play it and occasionally mashed a few keys. I've attempted several instruments but they've never lasted more than a week maximum.Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
(and what were they?)
What about you LDT?
I've attempted several instruments but they've never lasted more than a week maximum.Looks like you've found your "home" then, seeing as you're now into your 2nd year! :|||:
I've since started fiddle in an attempt to do some of the things that don't work on a box. Learning fiddle is so hard compared with melodeon.
I've since started fiddle in an attempt to do some of the things that don't work on a box. Learning fiddle is so hard compared with melodeon.
Agreed - I've been playing the fiddle for about 13 years & am convinced that it was invented by someone as a joke, as trying to master it seems suspiciously like trying to find the mythical pot at the end of the rainbow!!
I've since started fiddle in an attempt to do some of the things that don't work on a box. Learning fiddle is so hard compared with melodeon.
Agreed - I've been playing the fiddle for about 13 years & am convinced that it was invented by someone as a joke, as trying to master it seems suspiciously like trying to find the mythical pot at the end of the rainbow!!
I've always wondered how the fiddle came to be invented, because it is so hard to play that any sensible inventor who made the first one would have quickly concluded it was impossible to play, and scrapped it. Thank goodness (s)he didn't scarp it.
I have the same sort of puzzled awe over the invention of a dance like the polska.
I have the same sort of puzzled awe over the invention of a dance like the polska.
I thought selling degrees was illegal in this country!! >:E
I also own a guitar and a mandolin but can't get the hang of either of those at all!
I envy the vast majority of you who seem to have played several instruments before the melodeon, often from an early age. For me, music was a spectator sport until I reached the age of 50. I didn't even get my hands on any musical instruments when I was in school. :( The melodeon was my first instrument and is still my main one, although I now dabble a bit with the pipe and tabor.
I feel it's such a shame when "youths" (teenagers plus, usually) give up playing an instrument. It's often because they're playing stuff that's "not right for them". How often do you hear people say "oh, yeah, I used to play [piano etc] at school, but gave up ... and really regret it." Could this be a curse of the "grading" system? (Hmmm ... another thread topic p'haps.)
Although I have classical lessons, I told my teacher I never wanted to do grade exams, although I was happy to learn the scales etc I just didn't want to be "examined" (bad turn of phrase I know!). However, she encouraged me to bring along music I wanted to play as well, so although the lesson starts with classical music, we always end the lesson with a folk piece!Brilliant! If people learn music they enjoy, they'll enjoy learning the instrument more.
Although I have classical lessons, I told my teacher I never wanted to do grade exams, although I was happy to learn the scales etc I just didn't want to be "examined" (bad turn of phrase I know!). However, she encouraged me to bring along music I wanted to play as well, so although the lesson starts with classical music, we always end the lesson with a folk piece!Brilliant! If people learn music they enjoy, they'll enjoy learning the instrument more.
And then there's more chance of longevity.
I have a vague understanding of why the fiddle player hates playing in C...
Because he/she isn't a very good fiddle player, perhaps? C is hardly a challenging key, even for folkies - after all, the fingering is exactly the same as G, only one string over...
Because he/she isn't a very good fiddle player, perhaps? C is hardly a challenging key, even for folkies - after all, the fingering is exactly the same as G, only one string over...
Yes, but only if you accept the lower tone - suitable for a waltz, but jigs sound dead down there.
Because he/she isn't a very good fiddle player, perhaps? C is hardly a challenging key, even for folkies - after all, the fingering is exactly the same as G, only one string over...
Yes, but only if you accept the lower tone - suitable for a waltz, but jigs sound dead down there.
Hmm, I did consider the blandness argument before posting my comment, but discounted it. I rather like the mellowness of C. Some hackneyed and very bright-sounding reels in D like the Maid Behind the Bar sound rather refreshing in C on the fiddle, IMO.
The trouble is that thanks to Peter Kennedy's efforts in the 1950s (a mixed blessing IMO) we have become so flooded out by D/G melodeons that other keys like C, F or Bb rarely get a look in, and the monoculture D/G 'disease' has since spread like the grey squirrel (to mix my metaphors).
No, no! I'm not against playing in C.Phew!
My four stop is in C (like the most common East Angian boxes) and it goes great with the anglo.Yes I like that combination too. (:)
I like playing my C/F Clubs, too. It's just that the fiddle tends to fade into the background against that kind of competition.I can understand this point of view, but my guess is that the fiddle is more audible than you think; if it wasn't there, you'd notice its absence.
In the ceilidh band, our concertina player is very keen on the combination of anglo and four stop - mostly Scottish tunes, though. I guess that's the influence of the bothy box. We got cornered by an ex-pat Aberdeen lady visiting from Australia who hadn't heard the sound since her childhood.
General question for everyone:
Do you get the feeling that in the last couple of years or so, more English melodeon players are experimenting with instruments not in D/G? I do hope this is the start of a trend. There certainly seems to be a steady market in buying up C/F Club boxes and they do make a lovely sound.
I also noted a lot of new one row envy at Mendlesham, myself included. (:)General question for everyone:
Do you get the feeling that in the last couple of years or so, more English melodeon players are experimenting with instruments not in D/G? I do hope this is the start of a trend. There certainly seems to be a steady market in buying up C/F Club boxes and they do make a lovely sound.
To build on the drift, it is not only the keys that are changing, as observed by Steve, but there is a definite drift away from flash Italian melodeons back toward Hohners and vintage one at that. At Witney last year most of the tutors were playing them.
General question for everyone:
Do you get the feeling that in the last couple of years or so, more English melodeon players are experimenting with instruments not in D/G? I do hope this is the start of a trend. There certainly seems to be a steady market in buying up C/F Club boxes and they do make a lovely sound.
Risk of some serious thread-drift here, as we move on to discussing playing in keys other than D and G, but never mind, it's definitely a worthwhile topic. General question for everyone: Do you get the feeling that in the last couple of years or so, more English melodeon players are experimenting with instruments not in D/G? I do hope this is the start of a trend. There certainly seems to be a steady market in buying up C/F Club boxes and they do make a lovely sound.
Both my present boxes can get into Gm, to my ear is a quite ethereal key not much used here (yet) but very current in Scandanavia.
I agree about Gm - it is a lovely key in which to play. To my mind, it sounds quite Middle Eastern. The last three tunes I have learnt have all been in Gm.
We even use it for our Morris side, where we play Cuckoo's Nest in Gm.
Here's another vote for the joys of playing in C!Ooh! Where? When? :||: :||: :|||: :|||:
A group of players here have even got a 'dedicted' C session going so we don't upset the D/G melodeonists. We have a growing repertoire of tunes that sound great - mostly from 'Before The Night Was Out'.
It was the beautiful sound of the Bastari treble concertina reeds that made me interested in free reed instruments, so that led to the melodeon.Actually I think that uses accordion reeds rather than concertina reeds. Never understood quite the difference but there seems to be a different sound.
Yes. I too would lik eto play my C box with somebody else, i fonly to improve my weak mastery! :||: in ("C") !!
inster 5allop
;D Happy Christmas Theo! It's a 5/4 variant of a well known tune from 5erbyshire!inster 5allop
Oo i new tune? I don't think I've ever heard inster 5allop :o >:(
C on the fiddle takes a bit of practice.
Even just holding the silly thing takes practice.C on the fiddle takes a bit of practice.
Understatement of the year!
Anything on the fiddle takes a bit of practice.
Even just holding the silly thing takes practice.
Sorry...mine got packed away for a month ....Have you moved house?
inster 5allop will be learned on "C" box! :||:I think it ought to be Tune of the Month (in all its variations and manifestations)! ;)
Nope. My sister decided to decorate which involves her dumping everything out of her room in my room. >:(Sorry...mine got packed away for a month ....Have you moved house?
inster 5allop will be learned on "C" box! :||:I think it ought to be Tune of the Month (in all its variations and manifestations)! ;)
Steve
(who lives close to the 5erbyshire border and the Eek 5istrict Irrational Ark)
The only thing that I would like to persevere with in future is, dare I say it, the Anglo concertina. I'll have to take care that MAD doesn't become CAD if I do.
I do sometimes wonder if the purpose of school music departments is to put people off music. My music teacher was similarly prejudiced against guitar. He recognised I had some musical aptitude ,and throughout my school career wrote in my end of term reports "Should learn an instrument". During this time I was teaching myself guitar and starting to figure out anglo concertina. I was not interested in either the instruments or the music that he could offer.
So far as he was concerned, "music" meant only classical. And yet the way he taught it did nothing to inspire me to take an interest in classical music. We once spent a entire term "studying" Beethoven's 5th but it wasn't until the final lesson that he actually played us the bloody thing. It took another teacher, an amateur musician, to open my ears to classical music.
Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
(and what were they?)
|
Wow, I'm a rich professional who enjoys life and drinks beer which apparently with a certain amount of prejudice to other races and musical persuasions make me a melodeon player. Great ;D :|||:
All the
choice
you'd
ever
need
here ;)(http://chrisryall.net/img/instr200.png) (http://chrisryall.net/img/instruments.png) Click me
What's a bassoon? Isn't it a type of monkey? :p
All the
choice
you'd
ever
need
here ;)(http://chrisryall.net/img/instr200.png) (http://chrisryall.net/img/instruments.png) Click me
According to that, I should be an opera singer... ::)
All the
choice
you'd
ever
need
here ;)(http://chrisryall.net/img/instr200.png) (http://chrisryall.net/img/instruments.png) Click me
What's a bassoon? Isn't it a type of monkey? :p
All the
choice
you'd
ever
need
here ;)(http://chrisryall.net/img/instr200.png) (http://chrisryall.net/img/instruments.png) Click me
So we are all people who want to be professional musicians, who like enjoying life, who like beer, who don't want to play classical or jazz but are not German.
So we are all people who want to be professional musicians, who like enjoying life, who like beer, who don't want to play classical or jazz but are not German.That's flawed. I don't like beer. Don't want to be a professional musician.
So we are all people who want to be professional musicians, who like enjoying life, who like beer, who don't want to play classical or jazz but are not German.That's flawed. I don't like beer. Don't want to be a professional musician.
ah that's funny :))
All the
choice
you'd
ever
need
here ;)(http://chrisryall.net/img/instr200.png) (http://chrisryall.net/img/instruments.png) Click me
Hmm, Ich will zu ein profimusiker, Ich liebe leben und bier, klassische musik und jazz sind nicht nach meine geschmack...aber es einen fehler...
That's flawed. I don't like beer. Don't want to be a professional musician.
I have seen a similar chart for choosing a medial specialtiy. It's scarily accurate, in my experience. http://www.usmletomd.com/tips4match/uploaded_images/choosing-a-specialty-788196.jpg
Maybe we need to create a Melnet version of this, with more folk instruments and an option of several types of melodeon? It could also included alternatives such as piano accordion, recorder, bodhran, concertina, pipes, spoons, etc, to which people not worthy of the melodeon could be directed.
Very good !!... looks like my daughter will be a 'Drumming Dermatologist' :D Sandy (:)
I enjoyed the flow chart but it needs a bit of tweaking for straight women.
Daughter no1 wants to do Obs & Gyn (aka lady bits doctor), so I'm completely confused on both charts.
This thread is beginning to divert towards I'm Sorry I Haven't A Clue - late arrivals at the medical school music club!
Andy