Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: ladydetemps on March 26, 2010, 11:19:53 AM

Title: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: ladydetemps on March 26, 2010, 11:19:53 AM
Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
(and what were they?)
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Lester on March 26, 2010, 11:23:44 AM
Nope
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Ellie on March 26, 2010, 11:30:42 AM
Yep - I played (and still do play sometimes!) flute. Fairly seriously for about 4 years. No help when it came to understand a melodeon though - I had no idea about chords, chord sequences or anything like that!
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: zubz on March 26, 2010, 11:45:06 AM
Yep.
Piano for most of my life.
Double bass for last 8 years (my first foray into folk, but of the Eastern European flavour).
Dabble with guitar.
Also a bit of wind.  :|bl

Oh, excuse me, I should clarify that: oboe.  >:E

In April it'll be my first melodeon anniversay. I must say that I've absolutely loved the mental challenge to become reasonably fluent, and now am really enjoying upping the musicianship learning for box. TOTM is just brilliant for that - completely enlightening to see different interpretations of the same piece. Long may it continue!  :|glug
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: uofdoboe on March 26, 2010, 11:47:54 AM
Yup.

Piano for the last 19 years
Oboe for the last 18
Great highland bagpipes for the last 7
And a smattering of bassoon, clarinet, and percussion in between
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: zubz on March 26, 2010, 11:49:38 AM
Yup.
.......
And a smattering of ... percussion in between

No ... "hitting things with sticks" doesn't count!  >:E  ;)
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Stiamh on March 26, 2010, 11:59:13 AM
What do you mean, "another" instrument?

[Edit: I see jb has made the point already.]
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: ladydetemps on March 26, 2010, 12:01:19 PM
What do you mean, "another" instrument?

[Edit: I see jb has made the point already.]
I don't get what the issue is? You'll have to clarify for me. It is simple enough did you play a musical instrument that wasn't a melodeon before you took it up.  ::) Should I speak....slower? ;) :P
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 26, 2010, 01:33:51 PM
Guitar , chromatic harmonic a bit, - anglo concertina. A lot of a capela singing  particularly amongst the strong close harmony people in the North East (eg Wilsons, Unthank, Magean and co). I didn't realise at the time (<25 years) how rare and very special that was.

I think that is what leads me perceive tunes in terms of chords and harmony. Interestingly when working out chords I still often imagine them on a guitar (though now taken over by my son). We all have our individual journeys!
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Pushpull on March 26, 2010, 02:11:51 PM
Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
(and what were they?)

A bit of "folk" guitar - rubbish.
Viola - classical, somewhat better.
Classical guitar - what was I thinking of?

Singing - small classical choral ensemble for a few years.

Interesting there are oboists about. I started oboe AFTER the melodeon. I have to admit it's my no.1 now.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: tedrick on March 26, 2010, 02:27:05 PM
My first instrument was the harmonica -

I played trumpet all through school - had a lot of great experiences doing wind ensemble/jazz/drum corps - but after you're out of school it's hard to find the motivation to keep your chops up -

I took up the box after getting into Irish traditional music - since the box is just like the harmonica, I took to it like a duck to water.

Just sold my trumpet to get into my new box... now I tell everyone to follow the path of traditional music instead of institutional "legit" music - because you can enjoy trad your entire life, you can enjoy it anywhere anytime - band/orchestra playing... not so much.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Stiamh on March 26, 2010, 02:59:35 PM
Should I speak....slower? ;) :P

No, just check the following boxes in your control panel:

[  ] Allow self-deprecating humour
[  ] Allow irony


 ;)








"Another" implies that the melodeon is a musical instrument. There are people who would dispute that...
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: michik on March 26, 2010, 03:03:04 PM
I played  - and still play - the hurdy gurdy for 2 1/2 years when I started with the melodeon 1/12 year ago.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Falseknight on March 26, 2010, 03:17:11 PM
Guitar (electric and acoustic), bass and mandolin.

And I've had two spells playing melodeon.  I played for about seven years in the 80s and stopped when we had children.  i decided to have another go about two year ago, but still perform mostly on fretted instruments.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Quebecois on March 26, 2010, 03:21:22 PM
Learned the guitar in 1968, then drums, studied violin, piano, trumpet; then got onto electric bass. Since taking up the melodeon I also acquired and learned to play mandolin and 4-string banjo!
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Clive Williams on March 26, 2010, 03:23:48 PM
Guitar, badly.
Recorder, a bit better than I could play it at school (found it a lot easier when I tried to play it by ear).
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: ladydetemps on March 26, 2010, 03:46:17 PM
Should I speak....slower? ;) :P

No, just check the following boxes in your control panel:

[  ] Allow self-deprecating humour
[  ] Allow irony


 ;)




"Another" implies that the melodeon is a musical instrument. There are people who would dispute that...
If you can play a tune on it it's an instrument IMO ;)
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: zubz on March 26, 2010, 03:55:10 PM
Quote
If you can play a tune on it it's an instrument IMO :||:

Oh ... in that case I forgot to mention the kazoo, swanny whistle and noseflute.
And bongos ... oh hang on, no tune on them - scrap that.  >:E

 :||: :|glug
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: BCC#er on March 26, 2010, 04:05:33 PM
Highland Pipes (more then 10 years up to date), flute (about 25), whistles (a bit longer then the pipes), piano accordion ::) (last 3 years). Some other stuff as harmonica, banjo, bouzouki but not for long. Ah, I forgot about 5 years of church organ :D
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: pbsalt on March 26, 2010, 04:20:47 PM
Piano,then Piano Accordion 
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: HallelujahAl on March 26, 2010, 04:48:14 PM
Recorder, guitar, piano, clarinet (the only instrument  ever learnt properly - got to grade 8 while in senior school), every kind of brass instrument in a brass band from cornet through double Bb bass, English Concertina, piano accordion...and then I met a melodeon. It's been downhill ever since  ;D
AL
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Matt Langley on March 26, 2010, 05:50:51 PM
Tuba (or BBb bass to be more precise) - although many years ago now...
Stuff with frets attached to a neck type thing (guitar, 'zouki, mandolin) - still working on this (and progress is being hampered cos I actually like playing the box more at the moment).

Still thinking (with the benefit of hindsight) that my mums advice about playing the piccolo was good - have you ever tried getting a tuba on a train??  Trust me, its not worth it...

Matt
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Ollie on March 26, 2010, 05:52:13 PM
Yes - recorder, piano, guitar, mandolin, fiddle, whistles, trombone, ukulele, and I used to sing in a few choirs too.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Martin Duffy on March 26, 2010, 06:04:37 PM
Yep - for the last 13 years I've played violin, trained classically but I prefer playing English folk!
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: GbH on March 26, 2010, 06:13:27 PM
Recorder, violin and piano lessons whilst at school.  The first two had their moments, mainly due to group playing, but didn't really lead anywhere.  Piano was mostly just learning how to pass exams - not a complete waste of time, but not far off.  I also taught myself how to play brass instruments and I'm still a member of two brass bands now.

Since school, I've tried to teach myself piano accordion on more than one occasion.  I pretty much had to teach myself the right hand from scratch, given how little I got from the piano lessons.  The last attempt was at the beginning of 2008, prompted by a friend looking for someone to play music with.  It was six months after that when I switched to the dark side!

I guess there's any number of other instruments that I've purchased, in a fit of temporary music shop enthusiasm.  Some of these I can vaguely get by with, using skills learnt from other instruments.  Others, I can't  ::).  Oh, I got a bodhran as a present the Christmas before last, so can hit that a bit, now.  And my most recent purchases have also been percussion related (shaky eggs and more...).

  
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: GuyWyatt on March 26, 2010, 06:34:20 PM
Hah! Just as I suspected, I am surrounded by proper musicians!
Guy
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Eric Barker on March 26, 2010, 06:41:41 PM
I started guitar in high school, discovered tunings during my years at the university, picked up the mountain dulcimer sometime later, toyed with 5 string banjo but put it down, in the mid 90's I got into Irish music and took up the tenor banjo and the bouzouki, problems with using a flat pick lead me to put those down.  I flirted with the tin whistle but started on the English concertina shortly after.  The concertina has been a winner but I stepped back in favor of the melodeon about 4 years ago.  Why melodeon?  I was listening to Bert Jansch and someone suggested Christy Moore, which led to The Pogues to Terry Woods to Steeleye Span to Fairport, which led to Richard Thompson and finally to Morris On.  I have been a melodeon fan ever since. The best folk rock bands have melodeons.  Eric B.  
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: nfldbox on March 26, 2010, 07:18:02 PM
In order of taking up: piano, bassoon, saxophone, euphonium, five-sting banjo, tenor banjo, whistle, anglo concertina, english concertina, duet concertina.
In order of proficiency: bassoon, piano, duet concertina, five-string banjo, whistle, anglo concertina, english concertina, tenor banjo.
Saxophone and euphonium were just errors along the way.
In proficiency the melodeon/accordion at present sits just below the duet but will soon move to just below piano. I doubt that it will ever surpass bassoon but I have hopes.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Pete Dunk on March 26, 2010, 07:35:54 PM
I joined the school brass band aged 11, working my way from baritone to tenor horn, trombone and finally cornet/trumpet, I also took piano lessons for two years. Started playing guitar at 16, discovered fingerstyle playing a year or so later and still play now to a decent standard although I'm rather less practised these days. I built and played several mountain dulcimers and two hammered dulcimers although I don't really get on with either and I've messed around with mandolin and five string banjo. I play English concertina fairly well and will have a go at anglo one of these days if I ever finish repairing the rather cheap model 20 button Lachenal that I bought a while ago. I mess about with melodeon but would hardly describe myself as a player.  :|glug
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: juker on March 26, 2010, 07:50:44 PM
Guitar (of the three chord variety), learned piano for a year or so as a child, learned piano accordion for a couple of years as a child.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Anahata on March 27, 2010, 09:40:48 AM
Cello
Piano
Piano accordion
B/C/C# button accordion (Hohner Gaelic IV)
Anglo concertina
Melodeon

Since then I've acquired a couple of sets of bagpipes but I wouldn't call myself a piper...
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Andy Simpson on March 27, 2010, 10:46:18 AM
Yep, got my start with ones you blow into. My first instrument was the recorder when I was 5 and I've also played the clarinet, flute, harmonica and whistle to varying levels of success and duration.

I also play the fiddle and a great part of my life is dedicated to frets, I've played the guitar for 10 years, the mandolin for 4 and my work leads me to others. On the bench at the moment are a virtually complete bouzouki, a pair of nearly done tenor guitars and a bizarre 8-string baritone guitar in its early stages.

I've attempted to get into the piano a few times and I now know my way around a keyboard but I've never really got along with it, I find it very useful for making sense of chords and scales but unresponsive and uninteresting to actually play. I also

In the works are a nyckelharpa, (started one and got the bow), and a hurdy gurdy, (know somebody who can lend me the plans anyway), and I still intend to one day to get a trombone, the first instrument I actually wanted to learn when I was a child but have thus far never even touched one.  I'm always tinkering with new instruments but I haven't really picked up a new one in earnest since the melodeon.

I guess there's any number of other instruments that I've purchased, in a fit of temporary music shop enthusiasm.  Some of these I can vaguely get by with, using skills learnt from other instruments.  Others, I can't  ::).

That sounds familiar....
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Anahata on March 27, 2010, 11:49:16 AM
I guess there's any number of other instruments that I've purchased, in a fit of temporary music shop enthusiasm.  Some of these I can vaguely get by with, using skills learnt from other instruments.  Others, I can't  ::).
That sounds familiar....

Oh yes... in that category come a gaida, kaval and gadulka, all Bulgarian and hanging decoratively on the wall...
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: TonyRussellDavis on March 27, 2010, 12:32:37 PM
Wasn't sure whether to join in or not in case it becomes a competition, but I guess this thread identifies like minded melodeon players and I'm certainly glad to find out what similar interests we have on the forum. So here goes :|glug.
In addition to melodeon (4-stop and BCC#) I've been paid to play - guitar (electric 8) & acoustic), mandolin family, ukulele ;D, pedal steel guitar :o, dobro & lap steel; English concertina, Northumbrian pipes :-X. I can play some "old-timey" 5st. banjo - but don't ::). Own a fiddle :-\! Oh, and some tin whistles of course.   :Ph T.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: willriding on March 27, 2010, 02:23:59 PM
Self taught guitar but not much cop at melody stuff.Got the box fever over several years sitting round late night sessions at folk camp listening to French dance tunes and the like... eventually couldn't stand it any longer and got one meself.
Funnily enough my preferred guitar technique (alternating bass and fingerpicking) has helped my progress on the box and the box playing has encouraged me to play more single note stuff on the guitar. Been playing nearly 18 months and I'm having a good time with it and practising daily for at least an hour..though two jobs and two kids makes finding more time problematic ...
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on March 27, 2010, 04:55:04 PM
Fiddle (Passable)
Guitar (Passable)
Anglo (failed practical)
English (failed practical)
Whistle (failed practical)
PA (severe left hand problems!)
Not a great record of success, I'm afraid.  >:(  :|glug
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: TonyRussellDavis on March 27, 2010, 07:30:41 PM
Here's where the networking comes in - Chris, d'you know my pal Dave Gregory? I just suspect you might go to a Sunday night playaround in York. Tony  (:)
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Nick Hudis on March 27, 2010, 08:02:05 PM
Piano since age 12.  Classical Guitar since 16 which I took up to teaching diploma level and taught for several years. Mandolin, lute, dulcimer, whistle, piano accordion, church organ, double bass, bouzuki, anglo concertina - brief forays with varying degrees of success.  I've sung in choirs all my life.

I now play melodeon, folk style guitar (but on a classical instrument) and am resting from singing due to chronic laryngitis.

I've been playing melodeon for just over two years now and feel very at home.  I may be finally realising that just because I like an instrument I don't have to learn to play it and indeed may not be clever enough to do so.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Accordion Dave on March 27, 2010, 08:34:48 PM
The first instrument I played with as a child was the chord organ. This has a keyboard on the right and chords on the left. The white keys are identified by number... 1 for C, 2 for D, 3 for E, etcetera. The black keys get a plus sign... 1+ is C-sharp or D-Flat, 2+ is D-sharp or E-Flat. Perhaps you get the idea. There were two rows of chords, major and minor, identified by letter, capital M for Major. lower case m for minor. CM is C-Major, Cm is C-minor. 

I figured out how to play using the numbers and the letters in the music. I bought a 12 bass Hohner piano accordion for 35 cents at a garage sale. I immediately recognised that the keyboard and chords were laid out the same way as the chord organ, except that I had bass and major rows of chords. There was no minor row on the Hohner.

When I was a teenager, I graduated to 120-bass piano accordion. I also learned to play piano and organ. The organ pedal board gave my feet something to do.

Playing the melodeon is quite recent for me. I have long enjoyed Alpine, Cajun, and Mexican music that use button box accordions.

I have a growing collection of accordions of many different varieties. Some would call it madness and implore me to feel guilty about it. I call it fun.

I also get the impression that some would like me to shun the piano accordion in favor of the melodeon. Not a chance... I enjoy both.

I wish I could afford a Steirische Harmonika. I dream of finding one at a garage sale.

Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: oggiesnr on March 27, 2010, 10:21:56 PM
Recorder, violin, whistle, bass guitar, guitar, anglo concertina, mouth harp, mandolin, bodhran, dulcimer, balalaika.

Of these the violin and balalaika have fallen by the wayside, I no longer own a bodhran (but can still play), my anglo needs serious repair work as the removal men crushed it, but the others I still play regularly to varying degrees of incompetance.

Steve
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Pete Dunk on March 27, 2010, 11:13:02 PM
but the others I still play regularly to varying degrees of incompetence.

Now that sounds strangely familiar!  >:E
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Owen Woods on March 28, 2010, 03:57:01 PM
Yes, Piano to Diploma level, Clarinet to Grade 8, although when I started playing box I was not to that leve in either of them. Since taking up the box I've also learned ukulele (and others), Harmonica (very badly), Flageolet and a few others.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: LJC on March 28, 2010, 04:20:35 PM
I got a degree in Jazz and Popular Guitar before getting really bored with all the egos the guitar entails! Moved to Bouzouki, then Mandolin, Fiddle, Piano, then Melodeon. I've since started playing the Ukulele and always have dabbled with piano.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Andy Simpson on March 28, 2010, 05:38:20 PM
getting really bored with all the egos the guitar entails!

Now that sounds familiar!.  ;D
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: LJC on March 28, 2010, 05:48:08 PM
I don't know why, it's just an instrument that attracts egos like a magnet! Something to do with the electricity perhaps?

Once you have a firm understanding of music, learning a new instrument just becomes a matter of adjusting to that particular set of technicalities, the 'music' doesn't change. If you put enough hours into playing an instrument, you don't tend to slide to far if you pick up another one, but I've beginner pupils who have tried to do this and its really detrimental to their progress. Perhaps in the long run it would even its self out... we shall see!
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: juker on March 28, 2010, 06:21:30 PM
Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
(and what were they?)

What about you LDT?
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Theo on March 28, 2010, 11:32:19 PM
Hah! Just as I suspected, I am surrounded by proper musicians!
Guy

No you aren't the only improper musician.

I had terrible piano lessons when I was primary school age.   They only lasted a few months but put me off learning an instrument till I was 45!  Then saw a melodeon for the first time and decided that I might just manage a keyboard with no black notes.

I've since started fiddle in an attempt to do some of the things that don't work on a box.  Learning fiddle is so hard compared with melodeon.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: GuyWyatt on March 29, 2010, 08:03:52 AM
Similarly I have recently started on the trombone and I am finding it far harder than the melodeon. There are so many variables that go into the production of the note and its quality on a trombone that just don't apply on the box; press the button - get the note.
Guy
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Anahata on March 29, 2010, 08:11:15 AM
Then saw a melodeon for the first time and decided that I might just manage a keyboard with no black notes.

This could be the starting point for a thread about incongruous reasons for choice of melodeon as an instrument to play...
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: jb on March 29, 2010, 08:26:28 AM
Similarly I have recently started on the trombone and I am finding it far harder than the melodeon. There are so many variables that go into the production of the note and its quality on a trombone that just don't apply on the box; press the button - get the note.
Guy

I've often thought that there are two basic dimensions on which you can locate and compare instruments:
[1] how easy it is to produce a good sound/intonation
[2] how obvious/intuitive is the positional/physical relationship, on the instrument, between different notes
I'd place something like trombone or violin as low on [1] and high on [2] and, as such, diametrically opposite to melodeon.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Theo on March 29, 2010, 08:44:41 AM
I've often thought that there are two basic dimensions on which you can locate and compare instruments:
[1] how easy it is to produce a good sound/intonation
[2] how obvious/intuitive is the positional/physical relationship, on the instrument, between different notes
I'd place something like trombone or violin as low on [1] and high on [2] and, as such, diametrically opposite to melodeon.

I'd add:

[3] how much expressive control is there over a note

Which is what makes the fiddle so hard to learn, but gives it so much potential.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: ladydetemps on March 29, 2010, 10:09:23 AM
Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
(and what were they?)

What about you LDT?
I could play one tune on recorder (infants school - if you asked me to play now I wouldn't have a clue where to start), and I wouldn't say I ever played keyboard (senior school) I just made sure I sat next to the boy who could play it and occasionally mashed a few keys. I've attempted several instruments but they've never lasted more than a week maximum.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: zubz on March 29, 2010, 10:14:54 AM
I've attempted several instruments but they've never lasted more than a week maximum.
Looks like you've found your "home" then, seeing as you're now into your 2nd year!  :|||:

(Hope you're feeling better, btw)

It looks (& sounds) like everyone had a great weekend.
Now looking forward to Witney again ....
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Howard Jones on March 29, 2010, 01:20:57 PM
School recorder
Guitar
Anglo concertina
Hammered dulcimer

Also dabbled with mandolin (briefly) and Appalachian dulcimer for rather longer.  I sometimes play bones, and even shaky egg when required (:).  I can play bodhran but don't.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: zubz on March 29, 2010, 01:26:43 PM
Heard on the radio recently:
Definitinition of a gentleman - someone who knows how to play the bagpipes* ... but doesn't.  ;)

(*I guess you could replace with any instrument-to-be-insulted.  >:E )
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: BCC#er on March 29, 2010, 02:16:02 PM
Oh aye! Ancient joke ;D
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Johnjo on March 29, 2010, 03:33:01 PM
Started with harmonica as a spotty youth (30+ years ago), and have dabbled since but only occasionally. Also tried tin whistle, and came to the melodeon a couple of years ago via anglo concertinas.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Martin Duffy on March 30, 2010, 09:00:23 PM
I've since started fiddle in an attempt to do some of the things that don't work on a box.  Learning fiddle is so hard compared with melodeon.

Agreed - I've been playing the fiddle for about 13 years & am convinced that it was invented by someone as a joke, as trying to master it seems suspiciously like trying to find the mythical pot at the end of the rainbow!!
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: jonm on March 30, 2010, 09:46:43 PM
In chronological order:
Piano, piano accordion, classical, electric and acoustic guitar, mandolin, tenor and octave mandola, English concertina, cittern, then melodeon.
Dabbled in (either never owned or never gigged): ukulele, fiddle, acoustic bass, harmonium.

Oh, yes - the harmonium has just moved into the garage to make space for the PhD - does anyone want one? PM me...
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on March 30, 2010, 11:05:28 PM
I'll ignore the school recorder lessons which were more an exercise in breathing together than making music, and I had no part of the decision making process.

The first instrument I chose to play was the Anglo Concertina, starting with a bright red cheap 20 key beast from East Germany in some unhelpful key. Decent Anglos were/are expensive for a graduate so saved my pennies, sold the concertina and bought a Pokerwork. And a 4 stop in G 12 months later.

And I've spent more time in the past three years learning to play the melodeon, than the previous 25+!

Andy
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Susanne on March 31, 2010, 09:51:01 AM
Yes, too many. Mandolin is actually my main instrument, then I've been playing around with fiddle, guitar, bouzouki and tin whistle. Started learning some English concertina before the strap screws broke, got an anglo that I started learning, but never got past that "started".
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Theo on March 31, 2010, 10:10:36 AM
I've since started fiddle in an attempt to do some of the things that don't work on a box.  Learning fiddle is so hard compared with melodeon.

Agreed - I've been playing the fiddle for about 13 years & am convinced that it was invented by someone as a joke, as trying to master it seems suspiciously like trying to find the mythical pot at the end of the rainbow!!

I've always wondered how the fiddle came to be invented, because it is so hard to play that any sensible inventor who made the first one would have quickly concluded it was impossible to play, and scrapped it.  Thank goodness (s)he didn't scarp it.

I have the same sort of puzzled awe over the invention of a dance like the polska. 
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: juker on March 31, 2010, 11:16:50 AM
I've since started fiddle in an attempt to do some of the things that don't work on a box.  Learning fiddle is so hard compared with melodeon.

Agreed - I've been playing the fiddle for about 13 years & am convinced that it was invented by someone as a joke, as trying to master it seems suspiciously like trying to find the mythical pot at the end of the rainbow!!

I've always wondered how the fiddle came to be invented, because it is so hard to play that any sensible inventor who made the first one would have quickly concluded it was impossible to play, and scrapped it.  Thank goodness (s)he didn't scarp it.

I have the same sort of puzzled awe over the invention of a dance like the polska. 

Dances like the polka are a natural response to being unco-ordinated and tripping over while trying to keep up with one's partner - necessity being the mother of invention, as it were  >:E
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 31, 2010, 02:13:40 PM
I have the same sort of puzzled awe over the invention of a dance like the polska.

Long ago a Swedish dance instructor told me - the Waltz swept Europe in the 19th century but took almost 50 years to finally reach Sweden. They knew it was a 3/4 dance but had no tunes. Polkas were adapted. I still fing this slightly far fetched and  suspect Suzi or Jan might have further info ...
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Stiamh on March 31, 2010, 02:45:44 PM
Tunes for the Swedish polska, with an S, are in 3/4. I'm sure you know that Chris, but you wrote polkas. They don't sound like waltzes, having emphasis on beats 1 and 3, but the fact that they are in 3/4 makes the idea of their being morphed into waltzes more plausible than adapting what we think of as polkas.

Also, Juker, I recall (from my c. 1980 visit to Gothenburg with a folk-dance and Morris team from Towersey, takes me back) that the polska is considerably more confusing to dance than a polka.

Polonaise would probably be the closest English (haha) equivalent of polska.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Earbrass on March 31, 2010, 02:56:12 PM
Melodeon is my 5th instrument:

Piano / keys   (since about 1965 - mostly jazz/blues, but I did up to Grade VI many years ago)
Guitar       (since 1971 - but I don't play much)
Bass guitar   (since 1977 - currently my main instrument, as I play it in a trippy 'pagan' space-rock band)
Piano Accordion     (since Mar 2009)
D/G Melodeon   (since Nov 2009)

Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Susanne on March 31, 2010, 02:57:24 PM
I think the polska came from Poland to Sweden in the 17th century or such, and became so popular that it developed and became a typical Swedish dance... I guess I should do a bit more research on this.. Yeah, it's in 3/4 timing but with emphasis on beat 1 and 3 and very difficult to dance, in my opinion, although I've done it a little bit. My favourite type of polska is the polonaise, or slängpolska as they are called in certain areas (there is some confusion as to what the difference is between slängpolska, polonaise and bleking).

Polka has NOTHING to do with polska whatsoever.

Regarding the fiddle, it probably takes a lot of time to master, I'm only in some kind of beginning stage, but have past the worst squeaky stage (when everything sounds like cat fights), and I definitely think that fiddle is NOTHING compared to the anglo concertina. At least the scales are logical and you can find the way around them on the fingerboard and all you need to worry about is to get nice tone and bow work. I don't get anywhere with the concertina, more than playing one-row... I've learned two Irish tunes in G using multiple rows but it took me a few days just to figure them out.. baah. No more concertina right now. I guess the inspiration will come back some day.

Oh - I found this about polska dances: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polska_(dance) (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polska_(dance))
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Anahata on March 31, 2010, 03:07:13 PM
It's perfectly obvious that the fiddle is almost impossible to play.
Even Maxim Vengerov has to practise for 8 hours a day.
 (:)
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: juker on March 31, 2010, 05:39:24 PM
"Polka has NOTHING to do with polska whatsoever."

That is interesting Susi and Steve, though polska (which I though just meant Polish, not the name of a dance as well) is obviously what the original post was referring to. Learnt something new today (:)
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Susanne on March 31, 2010, 11:09:11 PM
It actually DOES mean Polish. Just that it's also become the name of a dance. I don't think we translate the name of the dance into other languages, we just say "polska dance". Guess it's to not confuse it with other Polish stuff.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 31, 2010, 11:37:37 PM
I envy the vast majority of you who seem to have played several instruments before the melodeon, often from an early age. For me, music was a spectator sport until I reached the age of 50. I didn't even get my hands on any musical instruments when I was in school.  :(  The melodeon was my first instrument and is still my main one, although I now dabble a bit with the pipe and tabor.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on March 31, 2010, 11:45:56 PM
Quote from: jonm link=topic=3729.msg46492#msg46492 date=1269982
Oh, yes - the harmonium has just moved into the garage to make space for the PhD - does anyone want one? PM me...

[/quote

I thought selling degrees was illegal in this country!!  >:E
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Lizwardo on April 01, 2010, 03:46:42 PM
Fiddle for 16 and a half years (I was 10 when I started) and oboe for 12 and a half.  I'm much better at playing the oboe than I am at the fiddle!

In the past I have also played piano, recorder, baritone horn, euphonium, cornet (I rather miss my brass band days!) and tin whistle.  I also own a guitar and a mandolin but can't get the hang of either of those at all!
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Pete Dunk on April 01, 2010, 07:49:25 PM
I also own a guitar and a mandolin but can't get the hang of either of those at all!

I thought mandolin was tuned the same as a fiddle? Mind you that doesn't help much when it comes to learning how to use a flat pick! I do envy you the oboe, such a lovely instrument with a beautiful haunting voice.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: zubz on April 02, 2010, 05:31:35 PM
I envy the vast majority of you who seem to have played several instruments before the melodeon, often from an early age. For me, music was a spectator sport until I reached the age of 50. I didn't even get my hands on any musical instruments when I was in school.  :(  The melodeon was my first instrument and is still my main one, although I now dabble a bit with the pipe and tabor.

Well more power to you and your like, Bob.  :|glug I feel it's such a shame when "youths" (teenagers plus, usually) give up playing an instrument. It's often because they're playing stuff that's "not right for them". How often do you hear people say "oh, yeah, I used to play [piano etc] at school, but gave up ... and really regret it." Could this be a curse of the "grading" system? (Hmmm ... another thread topic p'haps.)

That in itself is such a shame, but even moreso is the "really regret" mindset. Why regret? Just start (again)! Life's too short for regrets!

My wife now teaches piano to quite a few adults who just want to start learning ... the more people who act like that the better!
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Martin Duffy on April 03, 2010, 12:17:09 AM
I feel it's such a shame when "youths" (teenagers plus, usually) give up playing an instrument. It's often because they're playing stuff that's "not right for them". How often do you hear people say "oh, yeah, I used to play [piano etc] at school, but gave up ... and really regret it." Could this be a curse of the "grading" system? (Hmmm ... another thread topic p'haps.)

I think another problem is the number of people (who normally don't play anything) who think it's just hilarious to criticise the noise you make when learning.  I had a little of it when I first started the violin, you know the type, "your playing sounds like a cat screeching...ha ha ha...", and it puts you off wanting to practice.  Thankfully my partner has never been like this, but I've known plenty of people whose progress was stifled through wanting to avoid being poked fun at.

Although I have classical lessons, I told my teacher I never wanted to do grade exams, although I was happy to learn the scales etc I just didn't want to be "examined" (bad turn of phrase I know!).  However, she encouraged me to bring along music I wanted to play as well, so although the lesson starts with classical music, we always end the lesson with a folk piece!
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: zubz on April 03, 2010, 08:06:29 AM
Although I have classical lessons, I told my teacher I never wanted to do grade exams, although I was happy to learn the scales etc I just didn't want to be "examined" (bad turn of phrase I know!).  However, she encouraged me to bring along music I wanted to play as well, so although the lesson starts with classical music, we always end the lesson with a folk piece!
Brilliant! If people learn music they enjoy, they'll enjoy learning the instrument more.
And then there's more chance of longevity.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Theo on April 03, 2010, 07:23:03 PM
Although I have classical lessons, I told my teacher I never wanted to do grade exams, although I was happy to learn the scales etc I just didn't want to be "examined" (bad turn of phrase I know!).  However, she encouraged me to bring along music I wanted to play as well, so although the lesson starts with classical music, we always end the lesson with a folk piece!
Brilliant! If people learn music they enjoy, they'll enjoy learning the instrument more.
And then there's more chance of longevity.

I am occasionally saddened by some of the uses of music exams (please note I'm not trying to make a blanket condemnation)  because teachers and learners loose sight of the fact that of all the things that children learn at school music is unique in that it is something that is almost always done entirely for its own sake.  If you do not get pleasure from playing music then it becomes pointless.   Every other human endeavour that has to be learned is to some extent a means to an end, though of course that does not exclude the possibility of enjoying maths, science, languages, engineering etc, but the pleasure of these things is rarely the prime reason for doing them.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Rob2Hook on April 03, 2010, 08:27:28 PM
I just voted, but to be truthful I can't really claim to have played as much as the number of instruments I have played with.  My parents sent me for piano lessons, I played guitar in folk clubs (Paul Simon and Ralph McTell, mostly), started fiddle at college until my landlady pleaded with me to stop - she was a violin teacher, mandolin and mandola, electric guitar to annoy the neighbours, English concertina that was once my gran's and anglo.  I just can't get anything out of the Konzertina, though (forerunner of the Bandonion).  To reach the buttons my little hands are through the straps up to the wrists and then I can't reach the air button.

The useful parts of all this?  I have a vague understanding of why the fiddle player hates playing in C and why Anglo is better for dance music than English.  I still think in terms of a piano keyboard when trying to work things out, which is handy as the Mozart transcription programme is based on the keyboard.

Rob.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Stiamh on April 03, 2010, 09:11:32 PM
I have a vague understanding of why the fiddle player hates playing in C...

Because he/she isn't a very good fiddle player, perhaps? C is hardly a challenging key, even for folkies - after all, the fingering is exactly the same as G, only one string over...
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Rob2Hook on April 03, 2010, 10:26:30 PM
Because he/she isn't a very good fiddle player, perhaps? C is hardly a challenging key, even for folkies - after all, the fingering is exactly the same as G, only one string over...

Yes, but only if you accept the lower tone - suitable for a waltz, but jigs sound dead down there.

Rob.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on April 03, 2010, 10:47:47 PM
Yes, it's either too low or too high in pitch, though strangely enough, "D" - only a tone higher - sounds alright on the fiddle!
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Stiamh on April 04, 2010, 01:10:00 AM
Because he/she isn't a very good fiddle player, perhaps? C is hardly a challenging key, even for folkies - after all, the fingering is exactly the same as G, only one string over...

Yes, but only if you accept the lower tone - suitable for a waltz, but jigs sound dead down there.

Hmm, I did consider the blandness argument before posting my comment, but discounted it. I rather like the mellowness of C. Some hackneyed and very bright-sounding reels in D like the Maid Behind the Bar sound rather refreshing in C on the fiddle, IMO.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on April 04, 2010, 08:09:43 AM
Because he/she isn't a very good fiddle player, perhaps? C is hardly a challenging key, even for folkies - after all, the fingering is exactly the same as G, only one string over...

Yes, but only if you accept the lower tone - suitable for a waltz, but jigs sound dead down there.

Hmm, I did consider the blandness argument before posting my comment, but discounted it. I rather like the mellowness of C. Some hackneyed and very bright-sounding reels in D like the Maid Behind the Bar sound rather refreshing in C on the fiddle, IMO.

I completely agree with Steve Jones - C is a wonderful key to play in.

Rob - if you think jigs sound 'dead' in C you haven't heard the right players or the right instruments. Many of the old East Anglian musicians played in C and we still have a good following of playing in C in that region today. Again - listen to John K or Brian Peters playing their anglo concertina in C or F and then tell me if they sound dead.

The trouble is that thanks to Peter Kennedy's efforts in the 1950s (a mixed blessing IMO) we have become so flooded out by D/G melodeons that other keys like C, F or Bb rarely get a look in, and the monoculture D/G 'disease' has since spread like the grey squirrel (to mix my metaphors).

Dig out some of the collections of old (and not so old) tunes. The Joshua Gibbons Lincolnshire collection comes to mind, and of course our very own 'Before the Night Was Out' East Anglian tunes. Many of them are in C, they work brilliantly in C, and deserve to be played in C.

Let's hear it for playing in C !

OK - I'll go back to bed now.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Erika on April 04, 2010, 10:12:00 AM
Here's another vote for the joys of playing in C!
A group of players here have even got a 'dedicted' C session going so we don't upset the D/G melodeonists. We have a growing repertoire of tunes that sound great - mostly from 'Before The Night Was Out'.

Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Martin Duffy on April 04, 2010, 11:56:05 AM
The trouble is that thanks to Peter Kennedy's efforts in the 1950s (a mixed blessing IMO) we have become so flooded out by D/G melodeons that other keys like C, F or Bb rarely get a look in, and the monoculture D/G 'disease' has since spread like the grey squirrel (to mix my metaphors).

I'm forever having to change tunes out of C that I enjoy playing in C - I personally really like playing Cuckoo's Nest on my fiddle in C & have heard quite a few players record it in this key, and although I can now just about play it in a couple of other keys, it sounds better to my ears in C!!  Perhaps a lot of it is what one is used to hearing.  In classical music you play in lots of keys, with plenty of modulation, so become used to hearing & playing tunes in lots of keys, yet if you're used to playing & hearing music in D/G other keys sound alien?! 
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Rob2Hook on April 04, 2010, 01:15:45 PM
No, no!  I'm not against playing in C.  My four stop is in C (like the most common East Angian boxes) and it goes great with the anglo.  I like playing my C/F Clubs, too.  It's just that the fiddle tends to fade into the background against that kind of competition.

In the ceilidh band, our concertina player is very keen on the combination of anglo and four stop - mostly Scottish tunes, though.  I guess that's the influence of the bothy box.  We got cornered by an ex-pat Aberdeen lady visiting from Australia who hadn't heard the sound since her childhood.

Rob.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on April 04, 2010, 03:14:15 PM
No, no!  I'm not against playing in C. 
Phew!

Quote
My four stop is in C (like the most common East Angian boxes) and it goes great with the anglo.
Yes I like that combination too.  (:)

Quote
I like playing my C/F Clubs, too.  It's just that the fiddle tends to fade into the background against that kind of competition.
I can understand this point of view, but my guess is that the fiddle is more audible than you think; if it wasn't there, you'd notice its absence.

Quote
In the ceilidh band, our concertina player is very keen on the combination of anglo and four stop - mostly Scottish tunes, though.  I guess that's the influence of the bothy box.  We got cornered by an ex-pat Aberdeen lady visiting from Australia who hadn't heard the sound since her childhood.

Risk of some serious thread-drift here, as we move on to discussing playing in keys other than D and G, but never mind, it's definitely a worthwhile topic.

General question for everyone:
Do you get the feeling that in the last couple of years or so, more English melodeon players are experimenting with instruments not in D/G? I do hope this is the start of a trend. There certainly seems to be a steady market in buying up C/F Club boxes and they do make a lovely sound.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Lester on April 04, 2010, 03:35:20 PM
General question for everyone:
Do you get the feeling that in the last couple of years or so, more English melodeon players are experimenting with instruments not in D/G? I do hope this is the start of a trend. There certainly seems to be a steady market in buying up C/F Club boxes and they do make a lovely sound.

To build on the drift, it is not only the keys that are changing, as observed by Steve, but there is a definite drift away from flash Italian melodeons back toward Hohners and vintage one at that. At Witney last year most of the tutors were playing them.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Sandy on April 05, 2010, 12:37:00 PM
General question for everyone:
Do you get the feeling that in the last couple of years or so, more English melodeon players are experimenting with instruments not in D/G? I do hope this is the start of a trend. There certainly seems to be a steady market in buying up C/F Club boxes and they do make a lovely sound.

To build on the drift, it is not only the keys that are changing, as observed by Steve, but there is a definite drift away from flash Italian melodeons back toward Hohners and vintage one at that. At Witney last year most of the tutors were playing them.
I also noted a lot of new one row envy at Mendlesham, myself included.  (:)
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Stiamh on April 05, 2010, 04:19:58 PM
Steve_FR, C is a nice key for the box, no question. Just yesterday I had the pleasure of playing a tone down (on my B/C box C#/D style) for a dance workshop, acoustically, along with a C flute and a tuned-down fiddle. Especially nice since the hall was very echoey.

On the fiddle I'd say that in general, playing tunes in C in standard tuning isn't quite such a buzz. It can be nice enough though and I was suspicious of a fiddle player claiming to hate the key. I think I understand now, from Rob's answer above: as a fiddle player I used to dislike playing with 4-voice boxes, esp. one rows in LMMH, or big wet-tuned red Paolo 2-rows, because they occupy the entire acoustic spectrum and relegate you to irrelevance when played loud. Which is the wrong way balance of power entirely in my view!

Several times in sessions here Québécois fiddlers have told me they _really_ like the sound of my boxes, which are all MM or MMM, and I'm sure the main reason is that they are too used to getting smothered by the 4-voice one rows that are the standard in Qc music.

Sorry for adding to the thread diversion but that's the way of it on these forums!

[Edited to make post visible again - accented characters.]
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Anahata on April 05, 2010, 07:26:38 PM
General question for everyone:
Do you get the feeling that in the last couple of years or so, more English melodeon players are experimenting with instruments not in D/G? I do hope this is the start of a trend. There certainly seems to be a steady market in buying up C/F Club boxes and they do make a lovely sound.

Could be. I've just bought my first C/F Club.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: oggiesnr on April 05, 2010, 09:54:49 PM
My first concertina was a C/G Lachenal and being a simple soul I played in C with the melody on the right hand and chords etc on the left.  Then I discovered that evryone in sessions played in G (or others) so then I'm playng across the rows and sides and the fexibilty of the box was gone.

It's heresy but when I first heard the great Irish concertina players playing all these notes my first thought was "why not just play an English?".  I still feel the same way when I hear a B/C player playing right hand only.

Steve
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: flipper on April 17, 2010, 01:56:51 AM
My instruments in order of learning

recorder
piano
folk guitar (and a bit of classical)
Melodeon D/G
Melodeon B/C

I got a B/C box after moving to a new area and finding the new morris side I had joined had several tunes in C or F or A and found that this covered all eventualitys. The PA player who had instigated these tunes left and they were converted to being more D/G friendly. I have since found that I really don't like to be in a session without both boxes as you never know when someone is going to play something outside the usual D/G range. I have found the experince liberating and no longer worry about converting a tune if in an odd key but play it in the key in which it was written. As the friends I play with all have the capacity to do the same there is no problem and its fun!!!!!! The day I stop learning something new on my boxes is the day I hang them up !!!
Title: Keys (was ... other instuments)
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 17, 2010, 07:17:34 AM
Risk of some serious thread-drift here, as we move on to discussing playing in keys other than D and G, but never mind, it's definitely a worthwhile topic.  General question for everyone:  Do you get the feeling that in the last couple of years or so, more English melodeon players are experimenting with instruments not in D/G? I do hope this is the start of a trend. There certainly seems to be a steady market in buying up C/F Club boxes and they do make a lovely sound.

I ventured onto C/F in the 90's - I have to say mainly for the keys of Dm, Gm and G myxolydian . Sold my second C/F 'to a good home'  just this month but still have the keys 'covered'. 3-rows are useful for that!  

My journey? Well the last decade I've played more and more in C.  It' s somehow soothing to the soul and great for singing against. I like it as a major, as a minor and as a blues key (bit of each there, I suppose). Both my present boxes can get into Gm, to my ear is a quite ethereal key not much used here (yet) but very current in Scandanavia.

Sessions? Guess I'll always need a D/G of some variety ...
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: george garside on April 17, 2010, 10:26:53 AM
I agree about keeping a Dg for sessions ( & I use one for band work due to  lightweight to umph ratio! & that I am the lead instrument!)  however for most other stuff, song accompaniment, playing with a veriety of other instrument players who are not mouldedd to DG and 'cos I like playing tunes in keys other than intended by the maker I prefer the chromasticity of the 3 row.

for what its  worth I strongly recommend as a learning/practicing exercise the playing of 'your' tunes in as many different keys as your instrument is capable of ? why not winster gallop in A flat or F sharp!

 george :||:
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Marje on April 17, 2010, 06:27:36 PM
I played various instruments but none of them well. I can stumble my way around a piano, a recorder, and a guitar but not with any great skill.

But I think any engagement with music teaches you something. Even if you give up an instrument after a year or two's lessons, you'll have discovered something about how notes relate to each other, how harmonies and chords work, or how to play in tune. Music's never lost or wasted, it stays with you, even if only to enhance your appreciation of other people making music.

But for the melodeon, the thing that made instant sense of it to me was that I had also played the mouth organ as a child. When the push/pull system was explained to me, I said, "Oh yes, I see! Right, I'll buy one of those and I'll teach myself how to play it." And I did (some 30 years after last playing the mouth organ). I also find that it helps me to think in terms of tonic sol-fa (do, re mi, etc) because I was taught that at school, but that's a bit of a personal peculiarity.

Did you know the built-in spell check on this site doesn't recognise "melodeon"?
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Bob Ellis on April 18, 2010, 10:45:45 AM
Both my present boxes can get into Gm, to my ear is a quite ethereal key not much used here (yet) but very current in Scandanavia.

I agree about Gm - it is a lovely key in which to play. To my mind, it sounds quite Middle Eastern. The last three tunes I have learnt have all been in Gm.

We even use it for our Morris side, where we play Cuckoo's Nest in Gm.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 18, 2010, 01:53:12 PM
I agree about Gm - it is a lovely key in which to play. To my mind, it sounds quite Middle Eastern. The last three tunes I have learnt have all been in Gm.

You're not fingering Ab as well as a Bb by any chance ....

Quote
We even use it for our Morris side, where we play Cuckoo's Nest in Gm.

.. cuckoos nest in all manner of strange places, mate!  "A flat" seems to make a lot of sense in the circumstances ;)   Chris
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Kautilya on April 18, 2010, 06:12:05 PM
Here's another vote for the joys of playing in C!
A group of players here have even got a 'dedicted' C session going so we don't upset the D/G melodeonists. We have a growing repertoire of tunes that sound great - mostly from 'Before The Night Was Out'.


Ooh!  Where? When?  :||: :||: :|||: :|||:
Maybe it could be combined with a day out to the fair and for some Cea Air, tho obviously avoiding the DodGems; and not too far from the train station....may be an hour and a half from the Big Smoke, door to door.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on April 18, 2010, 10:50:37 PM
Yes. I too would lik eto play my C box with somebody else, i fonly to improve my weak mastery!  :||: in ("C") !!
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: joreema on December 20, 2011, 06:33:52 PM
I started with guitar but stopped to play it for several years. Started to play guitar again when I played with a bagpipe player.
In the meantime I bought a MacCann Duet. I love this instrument and I'm playing it now for 15 years. It's a special friend. So, the melodeon was a big surprise although I knew it before. But I am learning the melodeon now like a fanatic.

I like to play in every key. C is nice, too, but for a ceilidh D is more practical because of the violin and I find the sound is more present. I bought also a Eb/Bb flat box to play with brass and with hurdy gurdy (Cm/Gm).
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on December 20, 2011, 10:49:56 PM
I've said it before and I'll say it again (and again and etc) "For a fiddler C is no more difficult than D, A or G. It's all the same finger pattern!" Now Eb etc is a completely different bucket of crabs (Vide T Pratchett, passim).  :|glug
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Martin J on December 21, 2011, 07:38:34 PM
I was always told better never than late !!     but here goes

Violin - worse than awful, I get the tune but Oh it's so painful (see Theo's comments on tonal quality)
Piano - forced as a child.  Can now play guitar style accompaniment but can achieve no dexterity with tunes etc.
Harmonium - as above but no child traumas
Mouth Organ - Good enough to lead a ceilidh band in the 70's
Guitar - accompaniment, finger pick variety of styles
Singer - audience is the best judge of this offering
Bass Guitar - easy after guitar
Melodeon - told it was like a mouth organ but it hurt when I put it in my mouth.
Bouzouki - beginner
Failed - whistles, recorder and anything else you blow

Favourite melodeon keys Eb/Bb, C/F, G/C
Favourite Melodeon - Castagnari D/G for all sessions and quite a lot of the band repertoire.

All the above achieved with little or no ability to read music. (:)  >:E - keep  :||: and  :|glug

Footnote.  The guitar playing gave the ability to create arrangements without reading stave music
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: pikey on December 21, 2011, 10:39:38 PM
in time order:

voice
glockenspiel
recorder
guitar
cello
tin whistle
anglo concertina

then melodeon!

Followed by:
fiddle
washboard
banjo
chinese shawm
trombone
tuba
bandoneon

and then started all over again....... :-)
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Stiamh on December 21, 2011, 11:29:06 PM
A. Instruments my dear wife has tried to persuade me to take up recently, presumably hoping that this would lead to my playing the box less, or stopping altogether:

- Hammered dulcimer (tried patiently explaining to her that this would quickly become at least equally if not more annoying; she is not convinced)
- Concertina (patiently explained that tinas can be more ear-piercingly strident than accordions; not convinced)
- Anything but accordion... (haven't found a convincing argument to deal with that one)


B. Instruments my wife has tried to persuade me to play more of, hoping that etc. etc. :

- Low whistle (no objection, but no time)
- Flute (as above)

She has recently embarked on a vindictive campaign of serially adopting stray cats, knowing how much I dislike the things. I think she is not going to stop until there is one cat in the house per accordion... perish the thought.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: doktorfolkenstein on December 22, 2011, 03:47:43 AM
I've played everything from harmonica to trombone to bassoon, with some classical training; currently I stick mainly with melodeon, Anglo concertina, tin whistle, kaval, bağlama, and cümbüş.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: jackson10 on December 22, 2011, 11:55:07 AM
Guitar, banjo, mandolin and english concertina. It was the beautiful sound of the Bastari treble concertina reeds that made me interested in free reed instruments, so that led to the melodeon.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Graham Spencer on December 22, 2011, 12:36:39 PM
Guitar, bass and - sorry about this - piano-accordion.  I was railroaded into the latter when my morris side lost all its musicians, and as I was the only one who played anything at all I was presented with a borrowed PA and told "You've got 3 weeks to learn tunes XYZ, 'cos you're playing for a dance-out next month."  Fortunately I soon saw the light (in both senses of the word!) and ditched the 120-bass monster in favour of an Erica.......

Graham
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: jackson10 on December 22, 2011, 02:59:41 PM
It was the beautiful sound of the Bastari treble concertina reeds that made me interested in free reed instruments, so that led to the melodeon.
Actually I think that uses accordion reeds rather than concertina reeds. Never understood quite the difference but there seems to be a different sound.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: pikey on December 22, 2011, 03:03:59 PM
Yes. I too would lik eto play my C box with somebody else, i fonly to improve my weak mastery!  :||: in ("C") !!

Problem solved Chris - I've got a one row in , and two big clubs in C/F.

Just say when, and we'll confuse and confound the D/G players by striking up inster 5allop in C  ! 
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Theo on December 22, 2011, 04:10:34 PM
inster 5allop
 

Oo i new tune?  I don't think I've ever heard  inster 5allop  :o >:(
 
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: KLR on December 22, 2011, 04:32:11 PM
C on the fiddle takes a bit of practice.  What I've found is there's tricky tunes in any key on that instrument; in the flat keys you have to watch your intonation, is all. 

Fiddle
Flute/fife/piccolo (wooden)
Boehm flute
Tenor banjo
Irish pipes (own 3 sets, favor Bb)
Guitar
"Keyboards"

Am learning the C#/D box.  Also recently picked up a Giulette "free bass" PA, where the bass can be set so the buttons sound individual notes.  It's the C griff chromatic button accordion layout, in essence.  Takes lots of work to remember what chord is formed by what shape, where you go to ascend the scale, etc.  I play jazz standards on this - "cocktail accordion" I guess you'd call it.  Although I mostly drink scotch...

Watch this video (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kocX-YO3ezQ&list=FL-9vCZmDWDSv6RkqhQZfv4A&index=9&feature=plpp_video) to get an idea of what these things can do.  This is a Titano, which used a system different than mine - this is the "quint" system, where the bass and counter-bass of the Stradella are echoed in higher octaves by the rest of the buttons. 
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: pikey on December 22, 2011, 04:41:27 PM
inster 5allop
 

Oo i new tune?  I don't think I've ever heard  inster 5allop  :o >:(
 
;D  Happy Christmas Theo!  It's a 5/4 variant of a well known tune from 5erbyshire!
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Theo on December 22, 2011, 04:45:09 PM
C on the fiddle takes a bit of practice. 

Understatement of the year!
Anything on the fiddle takes a bit of practice.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: ladydetemps on December 22, 2011, 04:47:50 PM
C on the fiddle takes a bit of practice.  

Understatement of the year!
Anything on the fiddle takes a bit of practice.
Even just holding the silly thing takes practice.

Sorry...mine got packed away for a month and now its punishing me by sounding like a cat in a mangle again.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: KLR on December 22, 2011, 05:41:37 PM
Even just holding the silly thing takes practice.

Indeed you can't spend enough money on chin/shoulder rests.  It's essential to get things set up correctly for one's anatomy.  Imagine trying to play an accordion with, what, an asymmetrical shape?   But you can spend a few bucks to make it less so.  And I mean a few.  Accordion straps seem to sell for about twice as much as the typical chin/shoulder rest. 

Most violins sound like cigar boxes, unfortunately, and always will.  I spent a few $$$$ on a nice sounding one and haven't unpacked any of the cheapies since, they're just dead or nasty sounding in comparison.  The good one would only be rated "intermediate" by your classical people, too. 
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on December 22, 2011, 08:32:08 PM
Mais c'est un doddle (jouant en "C"), un morceau de gateau! I haven't used a chin rest for some twenty years now, though I wouldn't advise anyone to copy me. I've never used a shoulder rest, or seen the need to (pardon placing of preposition).

Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on December 22, 2011, 08:35:52 PM
inster 5allop will be learned on "C" box!  :||:
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on December 23, 2011, 12:40:46 AM
Sorry...mine got packed away for a month ....
Have you moved house?
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on December 23, 2011, 12:45:05 AM
inster 5allop will be learned on "C" box!  :||:
I think it ought to be Tune of the Month (in all its variations and manifestations)!  ;)

Steve
(who lives close to the 5erbyshire border and the Eek 5istrict Irrational Ark)
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: ladydetemps on December 23, 2011, 09:18:27 AM
Sorry...mine got packed away for a month ....
Have you moved house?
Nope. My sister decided to decorate which involves her dumping everything out of her room in my room.  >:(
I'm living in what looks like steptoe & sons house.


Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Pete Dunk on December 25, 2011, 12:01:59 AM
inster 5allop will be learned on "C" box!  :||:
I think it ought to be Tune of the Month (in all its variations and manifestations)!  ;)

Steve
(who lives close to the 5erbyshire border and the Eek 5istrict Irrational Ark)

Issing m'self laffin!
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Eric Barker on December 25, 2011, 06:22:03 AM
Before melodeon I played guitar, mountain dulcimer, irish bouzouki, tenor banjo, tin whistle and English Concertina.  Along with the Melodeon I have picked up the Finnish Kantele and the ukulele.  I have dropped the banjo and bouzouki and only dabble on guitar, dulcimer and whistle.  Late at night the Kantele and ukulele reign.  During the day, melodeon is king.  Eric
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Prestidigitator on December 25, 2011, 11:29:21 AM
Like many others here, I've had a go, with varying degrees of success and lengths of time, on an eclectic range of instruments starting with violin (RSM grades at age 8 on), via brass and woodwind, to fretted instruments. I'm not sure whether my efforts on any of them could be dignified as "playing".

I started playing melodeon in my teens, let it drop for a long while and then took it up again, and now concentrate on that.

The only thing that I would like to persevere with in future is, dare I say it, the Anglo concertina. I'll have to take care that MAD doesn't become CAD if I do.

Seasons greetings to all from Sunny Suffolk.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: malcolmbebb on December 25, 2011, 11:37:48 AM

The only thing that I would like to persevere with in future is, dare I say it, the Anglo concertina. I'll have to take care that MAD doesn't become CAD if I do.


You will indeed - they are closely related.

Malcolm
who had a bit of a play with electric keyboards, whistley things and was snared by Anglo concertina before expanding into melodeon. Still can't play any properly but enjoying trying.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Pete of Ebor on December 25, 2011, 05:09:09 PM
Yes. I played guitar at primary school from the age of 7, and was rather good - or so my teacher told my parents... When I eventually went to Grammar School (yes, they still had them in the 70s) we all had to take/endure a compulsory Instrumental music class. I really wanted to play classical guitar but was told I couldn't as it's not an orchestral instrument.  ???
I then spent (wasted?) 2 years trying to be taught the violin, but to no avail. Couldn't (and still can't) scrape anything out of it.

... but the worst part of it - I found out years later that the head of the music dept. was an accomplished classical guitarist  >:(
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Howard Jones on December 26, 2011, 01:36:46 PM
I do sometimes wonder if the purpose of school music departments is to put people off music.  My music teacher was similarly prejudiced against guitar.  He recognised I had some musical aptitude ,and throughout my school career wrote in my end of term reports "Should learn an instrument".  During this time I was teaching myself guitar and starting to figure out anglo concertina.  I was not interested in either the instruments or the music that he could offer.

So far as he was concerned, "music" meant only classical.  And yet the way he taught it did nothing to inspire me to take an interest in classical music.  We once spent a entire term "studying" Beethoven's 5th but it wasn't until the final lesson that he actually played us the bloody thing.  It took another teacher, an amateur musician, to open my ears to classical music.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Graham Spencer on December 26, 2011, 02:22:47 PM
I do sometimes wonder if the purpose of school music departments is to put people off music.  My music teacher was similarly prejudiced against guitar.  He recognised I had some musical aptitude ,and throughout my school career wrote in my end of term reports "Should learn an instrument".  During this time I was teaching myself guitar and starting to figure out anglo concertina.  I was not interested in either the instruments or the music that he could offer.

So far as he was concerned, "music" meant only classical.  And yet the way he taught it did nothing to inspire me to take an interest in classical music.  We once spent a entire term "studying" Beethoven's 5th but it wasn't until the final lesson that he actually played us the bloody thing.  It took another teacher, an amateur musician, to open my ears to classical music.

Not all of them are that bad; I count myself very lucky that my school music teacher was very open-minded and encouraging whatever way our musical bent (if we happened to have one) lay.  He was a part-time member of the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra, with whom he played keyboard instruments such as the celesta when required. We all, of course had to learn the recorder and to read music (for which I am eternally grateful) and there was ample opportunity to take up another instrument.  Being the late 50s/early 60s, it's not hard to imagine where most of our teenage musical tastes lay, but he didn't ever try to belittle pop music. He exposed to us to a wide variety of styles of music, and by the time we got to the 6th Form he organised regular social evenings out at all kinds of musical events - symphony concerts & chamber recitals of course, but also jazz, folk and even a few "experimental" gigs. A few of us were learning guitar among ourselves, and he did all he could to help and encourage us. I attribute my wide taste in music today to his influence, and I will always be grateful that I went to that school (a very traditional boys' grammar school) at the time when he was running the music department.

Graham
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Bob Ellis on December 26, 2011, 03:21:02 PM
I was a boy soprano soloist with the cathedral choir - an angelic voice in an anything but angelic receptacle.  >:E

My music teacher would not let me learn any instrument: every music lesson I had a personal singing tutor. This continued even after my voice broke until, at the age of 13 or 14, I became the singer with a local rock & roll band. My music teacher found out about it and gave me an ultimatum - I must leave the rock & roll band or he would stop my singing lessons. As almost any teenager would have done, I chose rock & roll. Not only did he stop my singing lessons, he threw me out of the music class altogether and I had to do extra Latin instead! So don't get me started about music teachers...
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Ollie on December 26, 2011, 04:05:57 PM
I feared that when I started A level music, I would be forced to endure another 2 years of piano lessons (with a great teacher, I might add, I just didn't enjoy it). However, due to having an incredibly open-minded and enlightened head of department, I was allowed to do the performance section of the course on melodeon. Times have changed, thank goodness.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Rob2Hook on December 26, 2011, 05:28:44 PM
My abiding memories of my music teacher include the time he took us few reprobates aside to ask for ideas how he could keep his out of tune piano when the replacement arrived so he could put drawing pins in the hammers to make a "honkey-tonk".  When we came to sit the "O" Level, before the fateful turning over of the papers, he searched my pockets for a light for his cigar!  Oh yes, he allowed us to use the practice rooms at lunchtine to rehearse for the folk club, too.

Rob.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Rog on December 27, 2011, 11:34:52 AM
Lots of voice in my yoof, which is how I learned to read music, piano (RSM grade 5), 6 and 12 string guitar, bass guitar, dabbled with a large piano accordian which led me to the diatonic melodeon. Am now addicted to playing melodeon and piano. Spend far too much time on both instruments, in particular the piano which is like a giant magnet, drawing me to it.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on January 01, 2012, 07:27:29 PM
Started on sax and woodwinds.  Played whistle and wooden flute to a medium high level in Irish sessions in Minnesota.  Currently play boxes, tenor guitar, and piano.

Everything has helped.  My wife tells me that when I get wrapped in the piano for a few weeks (working out a piece or something), my box playing is much better when I come back to it.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Randal Scott on January 03, 2012, 12:12:53 AM
Me too...sax and ww at age 8, guitar at 11, classical guitar at 15, drums at 15, bluegrass banjo at 16, pedal steel and fiddle at 28, upright bass and hammered dulcimer at 32, mandolins, clawhammer and tenor banjo, and concertinas at 42, melodeons a few years ago...a little piano in there, a little oud, saz, some ukulele...

Still do it all except for pedal steel, piano, oud and ukes...oh and I gave up studying flamenco and classical guitar--always my primary instrument--a couple of years ago...which has allowed me more time for folk music..
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 03, 2012, 08:57:00 AM
Sax eh?  Well here's one new recruit to the brigada melodeonista,  playing 'previous instrument' to accompany Dolly May a few New Years back.

                                 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VilzE5Tb7HI
Clues 

   1.  It precedes 'sax', alphabetically, and by just one letter
   2.  Joel's on the right (though not politically, of course)!  :|glug
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Christo Tracey on January 04, 2012, 04:19:29 PM
Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
(and what were they?)

Yep, used to play harmonicas and blues harps.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: OldJack on January 14, 2012, 06:51:31 AM
I have been trying, off and on, to play the 30 button Anglo concertina. I can do somethings but the chords defeat me. So, last month I picked up a cheap Cajun box in C thinking that would get me past the block. Well, I like my cheap melodeon and am wondering when it's time to upgrade whether to go for a BC or a CC#. I've looked at the keyboard layouts but I'm not enough of a musician to note the advantages or disadvantages. I'd like to collect some comments.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Payul on January 14, 2012, 10:47:01 AM
Nice to read everybody,s story.... (:)

Played flamenco guitar for 25 years, mostly solo, ( paco Peña stuff) sometimes with a trio. ( Gypsy king stuff)

In my Youth the mouth harp, chromatically, I was fascinated as a boy with the old harmonica trio's from the 50ties,
Like The Hotcha trio, or the harmonicats.

So, when I heard the melodeon lately, it sounded like you have two mouthharps with a bellow in between.
I was looking for an extra instrument to play, so I was sold..... :|||:
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: mattsmee on January 14, 2012, 10:55:00 AM
We have quite a diverse group here.

Well, I picked up the melodeon when I was 12 or 13 years old. Before that I play recorder in primary school from the age of 5 or 6. I then picked up the baritone horn when I was 8-10 (can't remember) which swiftly changed into play euphonium. I also made an attempt at the harmonica before the melodeon.
Now I am 22 years old and I play a multitude of instruments ranging from a good to excellent standard. They include: melodeon, bass guitar, guitar (acoustic and electric), keyboard, bodhran, organ, bouzouki, cuatro and probably some others. I don't know how I have room for all of them, luckily I don't own an organ.
All this led to me graduating in 2011 with a 2.1 in BSc (hons) Music, Commercial Composition and Technology
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 26, 2012, 09:47:12 AM

All the
choice
you'd
ever
need
here  ;)
  (http://chrisryall.net/img/instr200.png) (http://chrisryall.net/img/instruments.png)
Click me
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Tom on January 26, 2012, 10:28:19 AM
I'm a jobbing drummer and world Perc. teacher/facilitator.
Over the years I'd tried many folk melody instruments and not got on with any of them- I had pretty much resigned myself that I would never find a melody instrument I could enjoy playing.
Then...
I overheard a grade A 'miserable Git' melodeon player boring some poor woman to death about the virtues of the melodeon, in particular how the notes were placed to make it easier to play the tunes. I thought "well, if that MOG can get excited about it then maybe it's worth a punt. And I'm loving it.

An added bonus for me is recapturing what it's like to learn an instrument  from scratch. It's been a great many years! It's also really helping the teaching I do on drums and percussion, especially understanding the frustration of something not going right. I don't get that practicing drums because it's my job and I've learnt to practice several hours if needs be but with melodeon I can always say "bugger this! It's supposed to be a fun hobby" and then you stop practicing for a few days and thus make no noticeable improvement that week.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: myhuckleberryfriend on January 26, 2012, 11:42:38 AM
Love the flow chart.

I played the piano at school and found it incredibly boring and yawned my way through practice and lessons. Forty years later I picked up a mouthorgan  which led me to the melodeon. Now glad I learnt to read dots at school as it has helped my playing no end.

but I do love the flow chart.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Ray Langton on January 26, 2012, 11:54:30 AM
Started on electric guitar wanting to be a rock star like a million other young people. Saw a guy on Sidmouth seafront sit down, open a box and start playing a melodeon. I thought -he didn't even stop to tune it and he didn't have to cart around a heavy amp and all those cables-I'll give that a try! Was bought my first melodeon that Christmas-a new cheap German one row which was not easy to play, but I was hooked.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Strigulino on January 26, 2012, 12:00:48 PM
Loved music at school but hated theory, so didn't do any musical qualifications apart from grade 3 flute I think it was.  But my average week was choir practice Monday, recorder group Tuesday, orchestra Wednesday, madrigal group Thursday and hockey on Friday.

Yes, my school had a madrigal group.  Though Philomela lost her love, fresh note she warbleth yet again!

Then one evening a week I played the flute in a youth music group.  We'd do all sorts of stuff, current hits, old country songs, about 100 guitarists, a few drummers, a little group of flutes, whatever people wanted to play.  I think they're still going.  I had a bit of a knack for being given a tape of a tune and being to work out the notes and a harmony, so that's where I got my first taste of arranging.  I could read music reasonably well but slowly, so we tended to just get a typewritten sheet of the words and I'd write the note letters in biro above the words.  It worked for us.

Became allergic to the flute.  I kid you not.  The nickel plate made my lips swell up and go red.  But this was just as I was doing my A-levels so I was pretty busy anyway.

Since school I've been in a gospel choir (not religious actually, but love the singing).  Also been in a choir for Handel's Messiah, and for the last two or three years I have sung carols on Christmas Eve at my local hospital, and at their carol concert.  

Dabbled in a few instruments since the whole flute allergy incident.  Started with the saxophone as the fingering was similar but it had a reed and plastic instead of metal.  Fun to play, but the fact that it was transposed into a different key completely threw me.  Suddenly notes that I had hammered into my brain were G, were no longer G.  I still have the sax, but don't play it.

I have a keyboard that I can find notes, major and minor chords on, which is helpful for finding tunes and harmonies.  I also have quite a collection of different ocarinas, and a nice ukelele which is fun to play but makes my fingers hurt after a while.  I'm not into string instruments enough to get through that pain barrier I'm afraid.

The melodeon came about because I missed having an instrument to play, and I really wanted one that didn't involve trying to sight read, was in the treble clef for when I did have to sight read, didn't go off into the silly realms of high and low and the bass clef like pianos do, and that was portable.  Saw someone playing one at the British Esperanto conference a few years ago and thought "that looks fun" and saw someone playing one again on my honeymoon in Ireland and that clinched it.  Bought one a few weeks after we got back, been practicing hard since.

In retrospect it's the perfect instrument, for reasons given above.  I only really have to worry about two keys (four if you include the relative minors) and a limited range of notes.  I can read the music enough to get the tune and then go off playing by ear.  It's an instrument with chord and bass backing built in so I can make a pretty good noise solo, or I could sing along if I wanted (flute can't do that).  Portable, doesn't require plugging in or batteries.  Unusual, and therefore interesting.  
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Martin J on January 26, 2012, 01:11:26 PM

All the
choice
you'd
ever
need
here  ;)
  (http://chrisryall.net/img/instr200.png) (http://chrisryall.net/img/instruments.png)
Click me
Wow, I'm a rich professional who enjoys life and drinks beer which apparently with a certain amount of prejudice to other races and musical persuasions make me a melodeon player.  Great  ;D  :|||:
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: ladydetemps on January 26, 2012, 01:15:56 PM

All the
choice
you'd
ever
need
here  ;)
  (http://chrisryall.net/img/instr200.png) (http://chrisryall.net/img/instruments.png)
Click me
What's a bassoon? Isn't it a type of monkey? :p
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Ollie on January 26, 2012, 01:48:24 PM

All the
choice
you'd
ever
need
here  ;)
  (http://chrisryall.net/img/instr200.png) (http://chrisryall.net/img/instruments.png)
Click me
According to that, I should be an opera singer...  ::)
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Ollie on January 26, 2012, 01:53:58 PM

All the
choice
you'd
ever
need
here  ;)
  (http://chrisryall.net/img/instr200.png) (http://chrisryall.net/img/instruments.png)
Click me
What's a bassoon? Isn't it a type of monkey? :p

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CZ1Nz3UOOas
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Owen Woods on January 26, 2012, 02:49:48 PM
So we are all people who want to be professional musicians, who like enjoying life, who like beer, who don't want to play classical or jazz but are not German.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Lester on January 26, 2012, 03:21:51 PM
So we are all people who want to be professional musicians, who like enjoying life, who like beer, who don't want to play classical or jazz but are not German.

Yep  ;D
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: ladydetemps on January 26, 2012, 03:23:25 PM
So we are all people who want to be professional musicians, who like enjoying life, who like beer, who don't want to play classical or jazz but are not German.
That's flawed. I don't like beer. Don't want to be a professional musician.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Strigulino on January 26, 2012, 03:24:33 PM
I have seen a similar chart for choosing a medial specialty.  It's scarily accurate, in my experience.

http://www.usmletomd.com/tips4match/uploaded_images/choosing-a-specialty-788196.jpg
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Lester on January 26, 2012, 03:37:35 PM
So we are all people who want to be professional musicians, who like enjoying life, who like beer, who don't want to play classical or jazz but are not German.
That's flawed. I don't like beer. Don't want to be a professional musician.

I will be over to seize your melodeons shortly.  :o
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Andy Simpson on January 26, 2012, 04:41:43 PM
Hmm, Ich will zu ein profimusiker, Ich liebe leben und bier, klassische musik und jazz sind nicht nach meine geschmack...aber es einen fehler...
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: diatosoldo on January 26, 2012, 06:03:54 PM

All the
choice
you'd
ever
need
here  ;)
  (http://chrisryall.net/img/instr200.png) (http://chrisryall.net/img/instruments.png)
Click me
ah that's funny :))
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Strigulino on January 26, 2012, 06:50:34 PM
Hmm, Ich will zu ein profimusiker, Ich liebe leben und bier, klassische musik und jazz sind nicht nach meine geschmack...aber es einen fehler...

Ha ha.... mi devis uzi rettradukilon sed nun mi komprenas la ŝercon!
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 27, 2012, 07:48:25 AM
That's flawed. I don't like beer. Don't want to be a professional musician.

No one is perfect , m'dear  :|glug

I have seen a similar chart for choosing a medial specialtiy.  It's scarily accurate, in my experience. http://www.usmletomd.com/tips4match/uploaded_images/choosing-a-specialty-788196.jpg

OMG  that is so, so scarily accurate :o   -   'Doc 3-Row' (radiologist)  :|glug
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Sandy on January 27, 2012, 09:01:06 AM
Very good !!...  looks like my daughter will be a 'Drumming Dermatologist'  :D

Sandy
 (:)
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Strigulino on January 27, 2012, 10:26:38 AM
Heh I work in Radiology now myself. They only come out of their nice dark little offices for food, and to hide if they think I want something. ;)
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Marje on January 27, 2012, 12:03:03 PM
I enjoyed the flow chart but it needs a bit of tweaking for straight women. If I don't actually want to get some girls or be a professional musician (which I don't), it looks like I'm restricted to drums or bassoon. Then again, even men have to want to be professional before they're on the path to melodeon, which scarcely corresponds to the folk world I know.

Maybe we need to  create a Melnet version of this, with more folk instruments and an option of several types of melodeon? It could also included alternatives such as piano accordion, recorder, bodhran, concertina, pipes, spoons, etc, to which people not worthy of the melodeon could be directed.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: malcolmbebb on January 27, 2012, 12:07:29 PM


Maybe we need to  create a Melnet version of this, with more folk instruments and an option of several types of melodeon? It could also included alternatives such as piano accordion, recorder, bodhran, concertina, pipes, spoons, etc, to which people not worthy of the melodeon could be directed.

Hmmm - tread very carefully...
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: pikey on January 27, 2012, 01:27:55 PM
Cello playing Psychiatrist. Mm....... ;D
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 27, 2012, 01:33:00 PM
Very good !!...  looks like my daughter will be a 'Drumming Dermatologist'  :D Sandy  (:)  

Hope you've other chilldren to your name. Dermatologists work in groups of three (it ensures a majority diagnosis)  ;)

I enjoyed the flow chart but it needs a bit of tweaking for straight women.

Don't think it's meant to be taken that seriously ... and one could always tweak the women  >:E
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Theo on January 27, 2012, 02:27:45 PM
I might be stating the obvious here but I think the chart was intended to be a joke!
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Marje on January 27, 2012, 03:21:25 PM
I think I had managed to work out that it was a joke - I wasn't looking on it as a serious guide to lifestyle choices. It would just be a better joke if it was applicable to women as well as men, and could be funnier that way. That's all I meant.
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on January 27, 2012, 07:31:26 PM
Daughter no1 wants to do Obs & Gyn (aka lady bits doctor), so I'm completely confused on both charts.

This thread is beginning to divert towards I'm Sorry I Haven't A Clue - late arrivals at the medical school music club!

Andy




Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: juker on January 31, 2012, 06:20:19 PM
Some great new stories here - there sure is a lot of music out there.
I love the chart too Chris!
Title: Re: Before you took up the melodeon did you play another instrument(s)?
Post by: Graham Spencer on January 31, 2012, 08:00:12 PM
Daughter no1 wants to do Obs & Gyn (aka lady bits doctor), so I'm completely confused on both charts.

This thread is beginning to divert towards I'm Sorry I Haven't A Clue - late arrivals at the medical school music club!

Andy

As in Dr Mel O'Deon administering his dire tonic........?
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal